fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*

  
 
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.35 #1Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
gdsf2 wrote:
arbitrage wroteI wanted to revisit something I brought up last week.

Why does Nikon simulate some sort of "click" noise when not in Silent mode whenever you hit Play or Menu?
This is so stupid.
I want to have the fake shutter sound at level 1 but that click gives me nightmares of shooting a DSLR dinosaur with a mirror clacking out of the way into LV or playback.
There doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of that fake click but still retain my shutter noise.

Does anyone have any reasonable explanation for why Nikon is adding this sound?
Is there any setting I'm missing to have that sound off but shutter sound on?
I do. That is IBIS parking. If you turn VR off, it does not make that sound when you push menu or play. So Nikon did not add any sound.


So if Nikon can stop it parking in Silent mode then I wish there would be a way to have it not park but still give me fake shutter. That is my request.

If that is IBIS, then why is it so loud? No other IBIS camera I have is loud like that when it parks.

Is there a way to have VR on the lens but IBIS off in camera? I'd rather have IBIS off all the time if I could. On other systems there isn't a way to decouple them.

Edited on Jan 23, 2022 at 09:03 AM · View previous versions
Jan 23, 2022 at 09:01 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.35 #2Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
arbitrage wrote:
philwaring wrote
arbitrage wrote1000mm and 850mm with the 500PF...
How did the AF feel at 1000mm? Clearly the central sharpness holds up surprisingly well.
In the full sun I was shooting in it was doing fine for these perched birds. However the other day I tried the 1.7x (didn't try the 2x that day) in cloudy/shady backyard conditions and the focus was terrible. I went and grabbed my A1/200-600/1.4TC to see how it compared. Nikon at 850 f/9.5, Sony at 840 f/9. The Sony was much better and stable once tracking. The Nikon sometimes would get focus but then lose it....green square back to red square....hunt, hunt....I'm sure the 2x would be even worse.

Despite these cherry picked shots I posted, I don't think I
...Show more →

Yep, the Z Nikon TC are so much better on the Z cameras. That plus adapted versus native glass, I am not surprised.
Jan 23, 2022 at 09:02 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.35 #3Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
gdsf2 wrote:
arbitrage wrote
philwaring wrote
arbitrage wrote1000mm and 850mm with the 500PF...
How did the AF feel at 1000mm? Clearly the central sharpness holds up surprisingly well.
In the full sun I was shooting in it was doing fine for these perched birds. However the other day I tried the 1.7x (didn't try the 2x that day) in cloudy/shady backyard conditions and the focus was terrible. I went and grabbed my A1/200-600/1.4TC to see how it compared. Nikon at 850 f/9.5, Sony at 840 f/9. The Sony was much better and stable once tracking. The Nikon sometimes would get focus but then lose it....green square back to red square....hunt, hunt....I'm sure the 2x would be even worse.

Despite these cherry picked shots I posted, I don't think I would bother shooting the 1.7 or 2x on the 500PF. There was a lot of inconsistency in the results even with just perched birds. I think I'd stick with the 1.4 and crop more.
Yep, the Z Nikon TC are so much better on the Z cameras. That plus adapted versus native glass, I am not surprised.


That is the realization I'm starting to come around to. I think the long term dream of using all the great F glass has to be put in context of the limitations it will bring for challenging AF situations compared to native Z glass and Z TCs.

I think the Z9 will really shine with the 400S and TCs.
Jan 23, 2022 at 09:05 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.35 #4Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
arbitrage wrote:
gdsf2 wrote
arbitrage wroteI wanted to revisit something I brought up last week.

Why does Nikon simulate some sort of "click" noise when not in Silent mode whenever you hit Play or Menu?
This is so stupid.
I want to have the fake shutter sound at level 1 but that click gives me nightmares of shooting a DSLR dinosaur with a mirror clacking out of the way into LV or playback.
There doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of that fake click but still retain my shutter noise.

Does anyone have any reasonable explanation for why Nikon is adding this sound?
Is there any setting I'm missing to have that sound off but shutter sound on?
I do. That is IBIS parking. If you turn VR off, it does not make that sound when you push menu or play. So Nikon did not add any sound.
So if Nikon can stop it parking in Silent mode then I wish there would be a way to have it not park but still give me fake shutter. That is my request.

If that is IBIS, then why is it so loud? No other IBIS camera I have is loud like that when it parks.


I didn’t build it, I am just telling you what it is. Just shoot silent mode. That is why there is a silent mode. I don’t think Nikon is taking requests here.

Edited on Jan 23, 2022 at 09:11 AM · View previous versions
Jan 23, 2022 at 09:06 AM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.35 #5Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
arbitrage wrote:
gdsf2 wrote
arbitrage wrote
philwaring wrote
arbitrage wrote1000mm and 850mm with the 500PF...
How did the AF feel at 1000mm? Clearly the central sharpness holds up surprisingly well.
In the full sun I was shooting in it was doing fine for these perched birds. However the other day I tried the 1.7x (didn't try the 2x that day) in cloudy/shady backyard conditions and the focus was terrible. I went and grabbed my A1/200-600/1.4TC to see how it compared. Nikon at 850 f/9.5, Sony at 840 f/9. The Sony was much better and stable once tracking. The Nikon sometimes would get focus but then lose it....green square back to red square....hunt, hunt....I'm sure the 2x would be even worse.

Despite these cherry picked shots I posted, I don't think I would bother shooting the 1.7 or 2x on the 500PF. There was a lot of inconsistency in the results even with just perched birds. I think I'd stick with the 1.4 and crop more.
Yep, the Z Nikon TC are so much better on the Z cameras. That plus adapted versus native glass, I am not surprised.
That is the realization I'm starting to come around to. I think the long term dream of using all the great F glass has to be put in context of the limitations it will bring for challenging AF situations compared to native Z glass and Z TCs.

I think the Z9 will really shine with the 400S and TCs.


And I think F glass will be fine in 95% of use cases. The other 5% no.
Jan 23, 2022 at 09:10 AM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.35 #6Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
arbitrage wrote:
Two sequences made in the 120FPS 11MP jpeg mode....fun....

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51838151399_86f1da2e36_o.gifezgif.com-gif-maker by Bird/Wildlife Photos, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51837913543_56882e3d2e_o.gifezgif.com-gif-maker-2 by Bird/Wildlife Photos, on Flickr


This is exciting! It opens up a whole new medium for me.... for wildlife photographers, for us.

One must keep that bird steady and as close to the same spot in the frame as possible. Poor Matt Granger found that out. You did a pretty good job of keeping them there. It is *not* easy, but better if they are flying across the frame.

Questions:

Was this done handheld, or with gimbal or fluid head?

If this is handheld, you did *not* get the extra VR stops with the 500PF did you?

Is the Z9's video AF, the same as its still AF?

Does the new 400 2.8 S have the extra VR that is combined with the Z9's (is it called IBIS or IRIS?)

I wonder if you can get one of those ducks in that lagoon flying straight at you...... and in focus! That's probably too much for the system, but thought I would ask.

Thanks for this news.





Jan 23, 2022 at 09:47 AM
George DeCamp
Online
Details
p.35 #7Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
arbitrage wrote:
gdsf2 wrote
arbitrage wroteI wanted to revisit something I brought up last week.

Why does Nikon simulate some sort of "click" noise when not in Silent mode whenever you hit Play or Menu?
This is so stupid.
I want to have the fake shutter sound at level 1 but that click gives me nightmares of shooting a DSLR dinosaur with a mirror clacking out of the way into LV or playback.
There doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of that fake click but still retain my shutter noise.

Does anyone have any reasonable explanation for why Nikon is adding this sound?
Is there any setting I'm missing to have that sound off but shutter sound on?
I do. That is IBIS parking. If you turn VR off, it does not make that sound when you push menu or play. So Nikon did not add any sound.
So if Nikon can stop it parking in Silent mode then I wish there would be a way to have it not park but still give me fake shutter. That is my request.

If that is IBIS, then why is it so loud? No other IBIS camera I have is loud like that when it parks.

Is there a way to have VR on the lens but IBIS off in camera? I'd rather have IBIS off all the time if I could. On other systems there isn't a way to decouple them.


It's IBIS and only stops that sound when you shut VR off. Don't think it shuts off in silent mode either! That's using 500pf still have to try it with 100-400 but my lens at at LensCoat, sent it to my friend Scott who owns it to make a template for covers.
Jan 23, 2022 at 11:36 AM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.35 #8Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
arbitrage wrote:
That is the realization I'm starting to come around to. I think the long term dream of using all the great F glass has to be put in context of the limitations it will bring for challenging AF situations compared to native Z glass and Z TCs.

I think the Z9 will really shine with the 400S and TCs.


The good news is that 500PF with TCx2 would not AF at all with D850 (and I assume D6 but never tried this combination) but it still work with Z9 for certain scenario
and overall I think I still get better keeper rate with 500PF with Z9 than D6. But the bad news is that Z mount native lens do work even better. 100-400+ TCx2 at F11 can track at least bigger slower bird in flight such as egrets perfectly fine. I have not try anything faster though. I definitely am looking forward to what the 400/2.8s could do.

Edited on Jan 23, 2022 at 02:52 PM · View previous versions
Jan 23, 2022 at 02:50 PM
Rimpson
Offline
Details
p.35 #9Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
Something a little different from me.





3Z a Crowd

Jan 23, 2022 at 02:52 PM
gdsf2
Offline
Details
p.35 #10Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
George DeCamp wrote:
arbitrage wrote
gdsf2 wrote
arbitrage wroteI wanted to revisit something I brought up last week.

Why does Nikon simulate some sort of "click" noise when not in Silent mode whenever you hit Play or Menu?
This is so stupid.
I want to have the fake shutter sound at level 1 but that click gives me nightmares of shooting a DSLR dinosaur with a mirror clacking out of the way into LV or playback.
There doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of that fake click but still retain my shutter noise.

Does anyone have any reasonable explanation for why Nikon is adding this sound?
Is there any setting I'm missing to have that sound off but shutter sound on?
I do. That is IBIS parking. If you turn VR off, it does not make that sound when you push menu or play. So Nikon did not add any sound.
So if Nikon can stop it parking in Silent mode then I wish there would be a way to have it not park but still give me fake shutter. That is my request.

If that is IBIS, then why is it so loud? No other IBIS camera I have is loud like that when it parks.

Is there a way to have VR on the lens but IBIS off in camera? I'd rather have IBIS off all the time if I could. On other systems there isn't a way to decouple them.
It's IBIS and only stops that sound when you shut VR off. Don't think it shuts off in silent mode either! That's using 500pf still have to try it with 100-400 but my lens at at LensCoat, sent it to my friend Scott who owns it to make a template for covers.


It does not park IBIS in silent mode when you press view or menu buttons (or it does but somehow does it silently, which I doubt). This does not depend on lens as far as I can tell.
Jan 23, 2022 at 03:04 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.35 #11Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
gdsf2 wrote:
arbitrage wrote
gdsf2 wrote
arbitrage wroteI wanted to revisit something I brought up last week.

Why does Nikon simulate some sort of "click" noise when not in Silent mode whenever you hit Play or Menu?
This is so stupid.
I want to have the fake shutter sound at level 1 but that click gives me nightmares of shooting a DSLR dinosaur with a mirror clacking out of the way into LV or playback.
There doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of that fake click but still retain my shutter noise.

Does anyone have any reasonable explanation for why Nikon is adding this sound?
Is there any setting I'm missing to have that sound off but shutter sound on?
I do. That is IBIS parking. If you turn VR off, it does not make that sound when you push menu or play. So Nikon did not add any sound.
So if Nikon can stop it parking in Silent mode then I wish there would be a way to have it not park but still give me fake shutter. That is my request.

If that is IBIS, then why is it so loud? No other IBIS camera I have is loud like that when it parks.
I didn’t build it, I am just telling you what it is. Just shoot silent mode. That is why there is a silent mode. I don’t think Nikon is taking requests here.


Thanks for the clarifications around the IBIS. That steered me in the right direction so I know now that if I keep VR off then I can eliminate the sound but keep the fake shutter sound on.

I realize Nikon isn't taking requests from me....I do hope they will listen a little better to their users though as some things would be rather simple to implement and create an even better user experience.
Jan 23, 2022 at 03:40 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.35 #12Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
bs kite wrote:
arbitrage wroteTwo sequences made in the 120FPS 11MP jpeg mode....fun....

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51838151399_86f1da2e36_o.gifezgif.com-gif-maker by Bird/Wildlife Photos, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51837913543_56882e3d2e_o.gifezgif.com-gif-maker-2 by Bird/Wildlife Photos, on Flickr
This is exciting! It opens up a whole new medium for me.... for wildlife photographers, for us.

One must keep that bird steady and as close to the same spot in the frame as possible. Poor Matt Granger found that out. You did a pretty good job of keeping them there. It is *not* easy, but better if they are flying across the frame.

Questions:

Was this done handheld, or with gimbal or fluid head?

If this is handheld, you did *not* get the extra VR stops with the 500PF did you?

Is the Z9's video AF, the same as its still AF?
...Show more →

This is all handheld...the 500PF never sees a tripod unless I'm doing controlled IQ tests in the backyard

I don't think VR would even have been on for these sequences but if it was it would not be getting any special combined stops that the Z lenses may get. I typically switch off VR once at 1/2000 or faster. Sometimes I don't bother to but yesterday I did shut it off for some of the time.

I haven't tried video AF yet. I may experiment with it a little bit shortly.

The new 400/2.8 has 5.5 stops of basic VR. It says it has Synchro VR with the Z9. According to the Z9 brochure, Synchro VR allows a total of 6 stops. But that brochure was written before the 400 so not sure if the 400 bumps that past 6 stops or not??

I got sequences of things flying straight at me. The system has a bit of a tendency to back focus on the ducks but there are still correctly focused shots in each burst.
Jan 23, 2022 at 03:49 PM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.35 #13Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
Very interesting. Handheld standing or handheld sitting?

My 500PF never sees the tripod either. I have a few short clips done with the D850 with the 200-500 clamped to the gunwale of the canoe. That worked ok but they are done with Focus Peaking in manual.

I don't believe I could stand and string together a 120 fps handheld burst that looks as smooth as those two you posted. I thought you were probably sitting, with the camera down and your arms braced on your legs. I think that would be much more stable and smoother.

That 400S looks very exciting for sure. The technology is working toward being able to stand and handhold a smooth panned video. Just gotta keep the subject close to the same spot in the frame as possible. Slow motion helps too.

Will look forward to more of your tests

Jan 23, 2022 at 04:48 PM
Kasper6188
Offline
Details
p.35 #14Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
Chickadee z9 / 100-400

Jan 23, 2022 at 04:52 PM
eorlando
Offline
Details
p.35 #15Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
A few from a gray dismal day in S FL. Taken with a 500mmpf. I can’t wait to get out and shoot with the z9 in better light. CC welcomed and appreciated. Thanks

1.
5430F21A-1756-4340-9F51-6297CB965359 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

2.
AB430E33-10F7-4820-A48E-99FA077CA6F0 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

3.
21433819-15D5-42C7-9FA2-5D7FDCD33F0A by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

4.
72DEE5C8-0FA2-4573-8342-387628F55DE5 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

5.
3D080CF6-A340-49AD-BD20-DB012DEB02A1 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

6.
CE1AC968-DF68-4C7A-A9B6-22D988A35FEC by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

7.
744F27E5-9DC1-4015-BDD2-0523A2AFE487 by Eric Orlando, on Flickr

8.
9CD31EDE-DF21-4543-8CD1-0A355222BE5E by Eric Orlando, on Flickr
Jan 23, 2022 at 05:05 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.35 #16Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
bs kite wrote:
Very interesting. Handheld standing or handheld sitting?

My 500PF never sees the tripod either. I have a few short clips done with the D850 with the 200-500 clamped to the gunwale of the canoe. That worked ok but they are done with Focus Peaking in manual.

I don't believe I could stand and string together a 120 fps handheld burst that looks as smooth as those two you posted. I thought you were probably sitting, with the camera down and your arms braced on your legs. I think that would be much more stable and smoother.

That 400S
...Show more →

I'm usually just squatting when I shoot at this location. Sometimes standing once my legs start to cramp up from the squat. . Those two sequences would have been squatting I think.
Jan 23, 2022 at 05:08 PM
rick2906
Offline
Details
p.35 #17Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
me with my z9 and 600 f4 at -35 degrees not counting humidity My friend took this with his canon R5 and his battery froze!! No hiccup with the z9!!
z9 at -35 degrees by eric laquerre, sur Flickr
Jan 23, 2022 at 05:40 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.35 #18Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
Z09_5637 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_5690 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Z09_5647 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Jan 23, 2022 at 07:44 PM
Thang
Offline
Details
p.35 #19Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
Z9 allows 1.4tc to be used on 800E nicely.










Jan 23, 2022 at 08:38 PM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.35 #20Z9 and Z8 ! : A thread for Z9/Z8 images and *discussion*
arbitrage wrote:
gdsf2 wrote
arbitrage wrote
gdsf2 wrote
arbitrage wroteI wanted to revisit something I brought up last week.

Why does Nikon simulate some sort of "click" noise when not in Silent mode whenever you hit Play or Menu?
This is so stupid.
I want to have the fake shutter sound at level 1 but that click gives me nightmares of shooting a DSLR dinosaur with a mirror clacking out of the way into LV or playback.
There doesn't seem to be a way to get rid of that fake click but still retain my shutter noise.

Does anyone have any reasonable explanation for why Nikon is adding this sound?
Is there any setting I'm missing to have that sound off but shutter sound on?
I do. That is IBIS parking. If you turn VR off, it does not make that sound when you push menu or play. So Nikon did not add any sound.
So if Nikon can stop it parking in Silent mode then I wish there would be a way to have it not park but still give me fake shutter. That is my request.

If that is IBIS, then why is it so loud? No other IBIS camera I have is loud like that when it parks.
I didn’t build it, I am just telling you what it is. Just shoot silent mode. That is why there is a silent mode. I don’t think Nikon is taking requests here.
Thanks for the clarifications around the IBIS. That steered me in the right direction so I know now that if I keep VR off then I can eliminate the sound but keep the fake shutter sound on.

I realize Nikon isn't taking requests from me....I do hope they will listen a little better to their users though as some things would be rather simple to implement and create an even better user experience.


I asked a friend of mine whose works included translating all Nikon manual to Thai and was a beta tester for Z9. He is not sure but he knows about the noise. However, parking IBIS is probably not it as he said that when you go into menu mode, IBIS is parked as well but there is no noise then. I asked him to look into this but it will take sometimes as he played a lot with pre production units but production units have different firmware and menus are a bit different. If I find out anything, I will let you know.

Jan 23, 2022 at 09:06 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister