p.9 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Funny how it's very often the people that "don't care who or what is the best" actually delivering "the BEST" photographs..
Meanwhile, those that cannot help themselves and constantly switch systems for fear of missing out on the "best possible performance".. they are somehow stuck in a deep trench, unable to progress any further and getting better at photography..
(not pointing any fingers here, just voicing my impression)
As far as I can tell, none of the current mirrorless lens offerings are optically inferior to any of the film era lenses..
Yet, there's people still using these "old" lenses creating much "better" works than many who use the most modern cameras and lenses available on the market..
Jan 11, 2025 at 09:58 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.9 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Look at the 35 1.4 VCM Opticallimits test resolution. -3.86% distortion doesn't seem to be a problem. If <4% gives you problems I don't think you're going to like any of the latest systems
p.9 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote:
Mike seriously, what is this crusade? You are desperate to paint the 34/1.4 VCM as having normal distortion and your method is to compare it to extreme zoom designs. Like do you honestly even believe the argument you’re making?
The 20-70 has high distortion. It’s also the only 20-70 zoom in existence for full frame. Same with the Canon 24-105/2.8, which also has crazy extreme distortion.
But a 35/1.4 is not an extreme zoom lens. So comparing distortion characteristics between a 35 and an extreme zoom design is just ludicrous. Why on earth does it matter to you? The 35 VCM has very high distortion for a 35mm full frame prime. So much so that in looking through designs I have yet to find another one that has higher.
Arguing against this is simply ridiculous. And I don’t understand why you care. It doesn’t mean the lens is terrible. It just means that it has high distortion. The E mount Sigma 85/1.4 has very high pincushion distortion for an 85mm lens..and it’s still a fantastic lens. ...Show more →
The irony is I'm a Canon RF shooter and I recently picked up the RF 24mm f1.4 VCM in light of it's heavy distortion and software corrections. But I'm not going to pretend that this new line of lenses heavy reliance on correction is normal for this class of primes or something to be ignored. It is what it is. I don't love it when compared to previous L lenses and to the competition but I'm hopeful that the results will still be great.
All these systems excel at different lenses. I don't see the point in pretending there isn't some bad eggs or flawed or strange designs here and there, regardless of how much they affect each individual's photography or use case. Some people don't care about sharp corners, others may need perfection and low coma. I wish Canon could have made a design more similar to Sony's 35mm f1.4 GM, just with less focus breathing, but I'm glad they finally at least offer a smaller lighter fast 35mm that doesn't have sucky autofocus (35mm f1.8 STM).
I guess this is a good example of the fan boyism others were worried about. There are SO many amazing lenses from Canon to bring up and defend for their merits, but for him to die on the hill of some of their strangest design choices is so bizarre.
p.9 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
You pretty much know,on a thread like this, reading the op, you are going to get ridiculous claims about Canon. Anything Canon does gets turned into a negative, including not particularly high distortion vs competitors due to lens corrections everyone's doing. But if you think <4% is too much and go Sony (even though EF 35/1.4 II has less distortion) then buy 16-35/4 or 20-70, you're at 9%, explain how that's getting ahead
And the redneck-y sounding welding things to a 600/4 bit is a real joy. And yes nikon probably could have made their Z 600/4 in F mount for D850 etc DSLR users like Canon did. They had enough room to put a TC in, seems unlikely they put elements behind it....Show more →
I'm not sure why this is the hill you're choosing to die on. As someone above said a $1500 35mm f1.4 prime and an $1100 20-70mm f4 zoom are not comparable. The 20-70mm f4 is also the only design of its kind.
I'm a Canon RF shooter and there are plenty of incredible lenses to defend from them.
Just off the top of my head lenses I own that I love:
-RF 85mm f1.2
-RF 28-70mm f2
-RF 100-500mm
-RF 70-200mm f2 (compact gen 1 version, no other manufacturer offers one as small)
-RF 15-35mm f2.8
-RF 100mm f2.8 macro
Lenses I don't own but look to be exceptional with little compromise:
-RF 100-300mm f2.8
-RF 50mm f1.2
Lenses I owned previously and think suck from Canon (slow noisy AF):
-RF 35mm f1.8 STM
-RF 16mm f2.8 STM
Lenses that are obviously strange or cost cutting design choices:
-RF 400mm and 600mm primes using rehashed 2018 EF designs
-RF VCM line with heavy reliance on software correction with a non-declickable aperture ring, presumably to keep size and weight identical across the line for video shooters
And to downplay the usefulness of Nikon's built-in TC's just seems insane to me. It's one of the main reasons I'm interested in the system. I'm sick of fumbling with TC's in the field and don't get me started on Canon's TC limited implementation with the 100-500mm and the inability to use one on the original RF 70-200mm f2.8. It's so frustrating.
p.9 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
mbphoto_2.8 wrote:
Funny how it's very often the people that "don't care who or what is the best" actually delivering "the BEST" photographs..
Meanwhile, those that cannot help themselves and constantly switch systems for fear of missing out on the "best possible performance".. they are somehow stuck in a deep trench, unable to progress any further and getting better at photography..
(not pointing any fingers here, just voicing my impression)
As far as I can tell, none of the current mirrorless lens offerings are optically inferior to any of the film era lenses..
Yet, there's people still using these "old" lenses creating much "better" works than many who use the most modern cameras and lenses available on the market.....Show more →
I wish some of these folks that argue over this achingly boring minutia would also post photos. If so much of this equipment doesn't meet their standards they must be putting out some absolutely amazing work. Shame we seldom get to see it.
Gary
Jan 11, 2025 at 11:43 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.9 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote: AmbientMike wroteYou pretty much know,on a thread like this, reading the op, you are going to get ridiculous claims about Canon. Anything Canon does gets turned into a negative, including not particularly high distortion vs competitors due to lens corrections everyone's doing. But if you think <4% is too much and go Sony (even though EF 35/1.4 II has less distortion) then buy 16-35/4 or 20-70, you're at 9%, explain how that's getting ahead
And the redneck-y sounding welding things to a 600/4 bit is a real joy. And yes nikon probably could have made their Z 600/4 in F mount for D850 etc DSLR users like Canon did. They had enough room to put a TC in, seems unlikely they put elements behind it.I'm not sure why this is the hill you're choosing to die on. As someone above said a $1500 35mm f1.4 prime and an $1100 20-70mm f4 zoom are not comparable. The 20-70mm f4 is also the only design of its kind.
I'm a Canon RF shooter and there are plenty of incredible lenses to defend from them.
Just off the top of my head lenses I own that I love:
-RF 85mm f1.2
-RF 28-70mm f2
-RF 100-500mm
-RF 70-200mm f2 (compact gen 1 version, no other manufacturer offers one as small)
-RF 15-35mm f2.8
-RF 100mm f2.8 macro
Lenses I don't own but look to be exceptional with little compromise:
-RF 100-300mm f2.8
-RF 50mm f1.2
Lenses I owned previously and think suck from Canon (slow noisy AF):
-RF 35mm f1.8 STM
-RF 16mm f2.8 STM
Lenses that are obviously strange or cost cutting design choices:
-RF 400mm and 600mm primes using rehashed 2018 EF designs
-RF VCM line with heavy reliance on software correction with a non-declickable aperture ring, presumably to keep size and weight identical across the line for video shooters
And to downplay the usefulness of Nikon's built-in TC's just seems insane to me. It's one of the main reasons I'm interested in the system. I'm sick of fumbling with TC's in the field and don't get me started on Canon's TC limited implementation with the 100-500mm and the inability to use one on the original RF 70-200mm f2.8. It's so frustrating. ...Show more →
You are going to use either 20-70 or 35/1.4 to shoot photos and potentially have to correct distortion on either. Of course it is directly comparable. You're basically dying on the hill of needing extreme software correction, but that's not the case for distortion at <4%, but 9% of 20-70 is extreme
Just because Nikon didn't make an F mount latest 600/4 doesn't make the Canon Rf "rehashed, " and I doubt any semi recent supertele needs an optical upgrade. But if 2018 concerns you, Sony 400/2.8 came out then, Nikon 600/4 came out in 2020 or something , almost a whopping 5 years old if you think it's a problem. Leica made lenses in both m39 & M mounts right after M came out, why wouldn't they
I've used tc's a ton, built in could be handy, never used one though and haven't died yet. I Cringe seeing people use tc's on 70-200_2.8's, guess it works though. I'd need tc at the long end, the complaint about not being able to use them on 100-500 on the short end has some merit , but mostly gets irritating
p.9 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I sadly can't add anything to this discussion because I've only used the Nikkors. Which doesn't mean reading this wasn't exceptionally interesting. However Chris Niccols just got on the same boat and compared the Trinity lenses from Nikon, Canon and Sony:
p.9 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I'm pumped to watch this. This is exactly the kind of comparison I love to see. Chris and Jordan are my favorite youtubers.
GrieSoss wrote:
I sadly can't add anything to this discussion because I've only used the Nikkors. Which doesn't mean reading this wasn't exceptionally interesting. However Chris Niccols just got on the same boat and compared the Trinity lenses from Nikon, Canon and Sony:
p.9 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
You pretty much know,on a thread like this, reading the op, you are going to get ridiculous claims about Canon. Anything Canon does gets turned into a negative, including not particularly high distortion vs competitors due to lens corrections everyone's doing. But if you think <4% is too much and go Sony (even though EF 35/1.4 II has less distortion) then buy 16-35/4 or 20-70, you're at 9%, explain how that's getting ahead
And the redneck-y sounding welding things to a 600/4 bit is a real joy. And yes nikon probably could have made their Z 600/4 in F mount for D850 etc DSLR users like Canon did. They had enough room to put a TC in, seems unlikely they put elements behind it....Show more →
Nah not redneck. More like Frankenstein. EF 400 + 2x TC + RF adapter = our “new” RF 800mm. There is one benefit for the user with that approach, shorter mfd.
p.9 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Buckeye2604 wrote: AmbientMike wroteYou pretty much know,on a thread like this, reading the op, you are going to get ridiculous claims about Canon. Anything Canon does gets turned into a negative, including not particularly high distortion vs competitors due to lens corrections everyone's doing. But if you think <4% is too much and go Sony (even though EF 35/1.4 II has less distortion) then buy 16-35/4 or 20-70, you're at 9%, explain how that's getting ahead
And the redneck-y sounding welding things to a 600/4 bit is a real joy. And yes nikon probably could have made their Z 600/4 in F mount for D850 etc DSLR users like Canon did. They had enough room to put a TC in, seems unlikely they put elements behind it.Nah not redneck. More like Frankenstein. EF 400 + 2x TC + RF adapter = our “new” RF 800mm. There is one benefit for the user with that approach, shorter mfd.
If you look at the optical diagram, and know how to read one, it is pretty obvious they didn't just attach a 2x III. But if you can find a better 1200, use it, I guess? But maybe you enjoy welding
Jan 12, 2025 at 10:58 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.9 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
rscheffler wrote: AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.
This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.
IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I just happened to get on here right after it got posted. You pretty much knew it would devolve into mostly-ignorant anti Canon crap at some point. I do think my comment (and others) helped keep it on track, this thread lasting to page 9, well, I certainly didn't expect that
p.9 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I've used all three systems, and for the life of me I don't see much daylight between any of them. Sure, each has its relative strengths....like Nikon with its innovative set of long primes....but basically, just like with the camera bodies, they are all shades of fantastic across the board. I am shooting Nikon these days mostly because I shoot a lot of wildlife and was able to snag a reasonably priced 600tc, but the prior few years I was shooting Canon and had only good experience there as well. If you can't take great images with the hardware these three currently offer, the issue would tend to be behind the camera, not with the camera....
p.9 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
cohenfive wrote:
If you can't take great images with the hardware these three currently offer, the issue would tend to be behind the camera, not with the camera....
p.9 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
DanielJStein wrote:
I might be the weird one on the chat here and I look at lenses mainly for how well they do for astrophotography. Having been on all 3 systems at one point, I can say that I think Nikon Z S line lenses are the best. Sony comes in at a close 2nd, but Canon is still kind of eh in this field.
For me, I am looking at how well longitudinal CA (loCA), coma, and astigmatism impact star shapes, especially as you get close to the corners. The previous F mount Nikon lenses were actually pretty bad at this, and the Sony GM's were pretty decent. However with the Z series, Nikon has stepped up the game. The Z 50 1.8 S may be the best 50 I have used for astro for example. The 35 is not as good as the 50, but still better than the Sony 35 1.4 GM. The 24's are neck and neck, although my friend has a 24 1.4 GM for his Sony and I do not think it is as good. Meanwhile another one of my friends has that exact same lens and his copy is much better....Show more →
This is exactly the same scenario for me. For most of the stuff I shoot all three systems are fine. I have two very good photographer friends and one shoots Sony and the other Nikon. When we are shooting landscape, seascape, etc. it is hard to discern the difference in systems. Where things get interesting is in astro. I still adapt the excellent Sigma Art 14mm f1.8 and it does fine for Canon. The others use modern lenses from each line (G Master and ZF mount) and their images are much cleaner and crisp in the corners.
I would argue Canon has never had a good astro entrant and has never prioritized astrophotography outside of their RA conversion cameras. Sad, as there are a lot of us out there and I am sure we would snap up a good UWA fast lens is Canon produced it. As technology has allowed more and more nighttime photography it is interesting that Canon has never leaned in that direction.
p.9 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Have you used the Sony 14mm f1.8? How does it compare to the Sigma 14mm f1.8 and/or Sigma 14mm f1.4 for astro?
Hathaway wrote: DanielJStein wroteI might be the weird one on the chat here and I look at lenses mainly for how well they do for astrophotography. Having been on all 3 systems at one point, I can say that I think Nikon Z S line lenses are the best. Sony comes in at a close 2nd, but Canon is still kind of eh in this field.
For me, I am looking at how well longitudinal CA (loCA), coma, and astigmatism impact star shapes, especially as you get close to the corners. The previous F mount Nikon lenses were actually pretty bad at this, and the Sony GM's were pretty decent. However with the Z series, Nikon has stepped up the game. The Z 50 1.8 S may be the best 50 I have used for astro for example. The 35 is not as good as the 50, but still better than the Sony 35 1.4 GM. The 24's are neck and neck, although my friend has a 24 1.4 GM for his Sony and I do not think it is as good. Meanwhile another one of my friends has that exact same lens and his copy is much better.This is exactly the same scenario for me. For most of the stuff I shoot all three systems are fine. I have two very good photographer friends and one shoots Sony and the other Nikon. When we are shooting landscape, seascape, etc. it is hard to discern the difference in systems. Where things get interesting is in astro. I still adapt the excellent Sigma Art 14mm f1.8 and it does fine for Canon. The others use modern lenses from each line (G Master and ZF mount) and their images are much cleaner and crisp in the corners.
I would argue Canon has never had a good astro entrant and has never prioritized astrophotography outside of their RA conversion cameras. Sad, as there are a lot of us out there and I am sure we would snap up a good UWA fast lens is Canon produced it. As technology has allowed more and more nighttime photography it is interesting that Canon has never leaned in that direction. ...Show more →
p.9 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Has anyone compared the Canon RF 85mm f1.2 and Nikon Z 85mm f1.2? (And/or the new Sony 85mm f1.4 GM II)
I'd also be curious to see how the 50mm f1.2/f1.4 offerings compare even though I'm not currently much of a 50mm shooter. I owned the Sony Zeiss 55mm f1.8 way back but have since moved more towards 35mm + 85mm or zooms.
The Sony 85mm f1.4 GMII seems like it would be an excellent travel combo when paired with one of their smaller bodies.
p.9 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Have you used the Sony 14mm f1.8? How does it compare to the Sigma 14mm f1.8 and/or Sigma 14mm f1.4 for astro?
I haven’t personally but my buddy that shoots Sony does and likes it and the images are quite good. We shoot a fair bit of astro together and his images are clean in the corners. Not that Sony has fixed the star eater SW issue his images are coming out quite nice. Better and cleaner than my Sigma on R5 images.
p.9 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The star eater is still an issue?!? I remember that from YEARS ago. I think they weighed slightly into my decision to move to Canon because it was annoying for the little astro I did at the time.
Hathaway wrote: AlphaPhotography wrote:
Have you used the Sony 14mm f1.8? How does it compare to the Sigma 14mm f1.8 and/or Sigma 14mm f1.4 for astro?
I haven’t personally but my buddy that shoots Sony does and likes it and the images are quite good. We shoot a fair bit of astro together and his images are clean in the corners. Not that Sony has fixed the star eater SW issue his images are coming out quite nice. Better and cleaner than my Sigma on R5 images.