p.28 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I don't even know how this is an argument.
Canon have ZERO 3rd party glass, do you need it or not.
Nikon have like 30+ 3rd party glass(and it's obviously gonna grow), do you need it or not.
Sony obviously got even more.
In general for consumer it's ALWAYS better to have a choice, more choice, period.
p.28 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: AmbientMike wroteI could say the same to you, you already told us Canon's not allowing this stuff. If a 24-70/2.8 having IS, numerous 70-200/2.8's and 35/1.4's, lightweight 100-400, 30+ years of EF available using what is probably the best adapter our there, huge amount supertele options, in addition to, yes, numerous 3rd party EF options somehow aren't enough for you, and you have to keep harping on this recent 3rd party stuff well, i dont know what tell you,So, for the record, you're saying that there's no reason for me to want to put a 35-150 / 2-2.8 or 35 / 1.2 on my R5? Or that no one should have an interest in, say, a Sigma 28-105 / 2.8 for half the price of Canon's 24-105 / 2.8 IS? Or, more to the point, that no one shooting Canon should have any interest in *any* of the following lenses:
Earlier quoteAnd Canon pretty clearly isn't just doing this for $$$ like you claimPlease spell out what the reason is, then. Seriously -- explain why Canon is *actively* blocking third party manufacturers from selling RF mount lenses.
How many more times do you want me to explain it, so you can finally figure it out?
The 35-150 looks interesting, very fast, I used to use 35-135 Tamron on film. It has no IS though, for one thing, and no wide angle.
If you just want 3rd party to the exclusion on everything else, putting blinders on to reasons other companies might exclude 3rd party, kerp going, I guess. Doesn't appeal to me though
p.28 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: takowasa wroteAmbientMike wroteI could say the same to you, you already told us Canon's not allowing this stuff. If a 24-70/2.8 having IS, numerous 70-200/2.8's and 35/1.4's, lightweight 100-400, 30+ years of EF available using what is probably the best adapter our there, huge amount supertele options, in addition to, yes, numerous 3rd party EF options somehow aren't enough for you, and you have to keep harping on this recent 3rd party stuff well, i dont know what tell you,So, for the record, you're saying that there's no reason for me to want to put a 35-150 / 2-2.8 or 35 / 1.2 on my R5? Or that no one should have an interest in, say, a Sigma 28-105 / 2.8 for half the price of Canon's 24-105 / 2.8 IS? Or, more to the point, that no one shooting Canon should have any interest in *any* of the following lenses:
Earlier quoteAnd Canon pretty clearly isn't just doing this for $$$ like you claimPlease spell out what the reason is, then. Seriously -- explain why Canon is *actively* blocking third party manufacturers from selling RF mount lenses.How many more times do you want me to explain it, so you can finally figure it out?
Once would be great. Unless you can link and quote to *anything* you wrote that was even remotely an answer to this question which I've posed to you multiple times.
The 35-150 looks interesting, very fast, I used to use 35-135 Tamron on film. It has no IS though, for one thing, and no wide angle.
If you just want 3rd party to the exclusion on everything else, putting blinders on to reasons other companies might exclude 3rd party, kerp going, I guess. Doesn't appeal to me though
You didn't even remotely answer my question. No one asked what your opinion of the 35-150 / 2-2.8 was. The question was why it is a good thing that *I* can't buy one for my R5. I also asked about the Viltrox 35 / 1.2. I also asked why someone shouldn't want to use a Sigma 28-150 / 2.8 for half the price of the Canon 24-105 / 2.8 IS (yes, I know the Canon has IS and goes to 24mm, but let's not ignore the "half the price" part of the equation).
Additionally, you didn't answer the question as to why Canon *actively* prevents third party from making RF mount lenses if it is for *any* reason other than their belief that this policy makes them more money. So, again, if you would be so kind, answer the question since, no, you haven't answered my questions even once.
Lastly, who said or implied anyone wanted to shoot third party to the exclusion of anything else? Do you honestly believe that making such an inane comment helps your case? I happen to really like my Canon lenses and my Canon R5. After all, if I didn't, I'd sell it all and switch.
In short, the overall question is why is it a good thing that Canon shooters can't *also* use RF mount third party lenses on their Canon cameras? The rest of the questions were simply specific examples of the more general question (along with addressing your bizarre statement that *anyone* was talking about shooting third party exclusively on RF mount).
If you could answer even once, it would be greatly appreciated.
Jun 06, 2025 at 12:36 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.28 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The 35/1.4 VCM is optimized for video, and looks like it might be the top stills option, as well. It's much lighter, minimal focus breathing, etc, the distortion people freaked out over really isn't bad at all in the days of computational imaging and besides EF 35/1.4 II has extremely low distortion.
So there's no reason to go to another brand that restricts me from using the best fast 35mm out there. Any adapter for other brands isn't going to be as good as the EF-RF people complain about.
You insist on limiting my lens options and not allowing me to use the best, 35/1.4 VCM, unless I use an adapter (if one even exists for rf to other brands.)
p.28 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
The 35/1.4 VCM is optimized for video, and looks like it might be the top stills option, as well. It's much lighter, minimal focus breathing, etc, the distortion people freaked out over really isn't bad at all in the days of computational imaging and besides EF 35/1.4 II has extremely low distortion.
So there's no reason to go to another brand that restricts me from using the best fast 35mm out there. Any adapter for other brands isn't going to be as good as the EF-RF people complain about.
You insist on limiting my lens options and not allowing me to use the best, 35/1.4 VCM, unless I use an adapter (if one even exists for rf to other brands.)...Show more →
I don't know who you were replying to (if anyone at all) with this post, but it has no relevance, whatsoever, about what's being discussed. No one -- NO ONE -- is telling you not to choose the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM over other options. Not a single person has said or implied it, so please stop with this false flag argument.
The question (I've lost count how many times it's been asked) is why it is a good thing that Canon does not allow third party to make lenses in RF mount (technically, not allow AF lenses for FF in RF mount)? No one -- NO ONE -- is saying you have to buy these lenses. But why is it a good thing that no one else can put these lenses on their Canon cameras? Please answer this simple question.
After you've answered that question, there's one more question for you: if Canon *actively* prevents third party from making RF lenses, then aside from Canon doing this because they feel it makes Canon more money, what is the reason? This question has also been asked multiple times with no answer.
p.28 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: AmbientMike wroteThe 35/1.4 VCM is optimized for video, and looks like it might be the top stills option, as well. It's much lighter, minimal focus breathing, etc, the distortion people freaked out over really isn't bad at all in the days of computational imaging and besides EF 35/1.4 II has extremely low distortion.
So there's no reason to go to another brand that restricts me from using the best fast 35mm out there. Any adapter for other brands isn't going to be as good as the EF-RF people complain about.
You insist on limiting my lens options and not allowing me to use the best, 35/1.4 VCM, unless I use an adapter (if one even exists for rf to other brands.)I don't know who you were replying to (if anyone at all) with this post, but it has no relevance, whatsoever, about what's being discussed. No one -- NO ONE -- is telling you not to choose the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM over other options. Not a single person has said or implied it, so please stop with this false flag argument.
The question (I've lost count how many times it's been asked) is why it is a good thing that Canon does not allow third party to make lenses in RF mount (technically, not allow AF lenses for FF in RF mount)? No one -- NO ONE -- is saying you have to buy these lenses. But why is it a good thing that no one else can put these lenses on their Canon cameras? Please answer this simple question.
After you've answered that question, there's one more question for you: if Canon *actively* prevents third party from making RF lenses, then aside from Canon doing this because they feel it makes Canon more money, what is the reason? This question has also been asked multiple times with no answer....Show more →
It is all about money.
For every single camera and lens manufacturer.
So, there is no difference between Canon, Nikon, Sony, Sigma, Tamron, …
Of course there are different strategies to make the most money. Some work, some not.
Every customer has a different answer to these strategies = gives the hard earned money to the manufacturer with the best package for his use cases.
It has little relevance what other forum members answer.
p.28 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote:
After you've answered that question, there's one more question for you: if Canon *actively* prevents third party from making RF lenses, then aside from Canon doing this because they feel it makes Canon more money, what is the reason? This question has also been asked multiple times with no answer.
Companies often protect intellectual property actively. If not many will steal or abuse your company rights.
The fact that Sony decided to open their lens mounts years ago to the 3rd parties doesn't mean they won't actively go after other companies that infringe on their IP. If some unauthorized company started making E mount FF camera bodies with globular shutters, do you think they will idly stand by?
Maybe somebody should change the title of the thread to who makes the best camera system.
p.28 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
tomba8tomba wrote:
It is all about money.
For every single camera and lens manufacturer.
So, there is no difference between Canon, Nikon, Sony, Sigma, Tamron, …
Of course there are different strategies to make the most money. Some work, some not.
Every customer has a different answer to these strategies = gives the hard earned money to the manufacturer with the best package for his use cases.
It has little relevance what other forum members answer.
---------------------------------------------
EB-1 wrote:
Companies often protect intellectual property actively. If not many will steal or abuse your company rights.
The fact that Sony decided to open their lens mounts years ago to the 3rd parties doesn't mean they won't actively go after other companies that infringe on their IP. If some unauthorized company started making E mount FF camera bodies with globular shutters, do you think they will idly stand by?
Maybe somebody should change the title of the thread to who makes the best camera system.
EBH
I am in complete agreement with both replies above. What I am disagreeing with is that blocking access to third party lenses is good for the consumer and that the reasons for blocking third party lenses has to do with anything but the company's perception that it is more profitable.
As I said in a post a ways back, Canon likely feels preventing third partly manufacturers making RF mount lenses results in greater profit for Canon because Canon is currently #1, whereas Nikon and Sony, not being #1, feel that being more open to third party results in greater profits (Sony more so than Nikon, obviously).
However, I do question whether Canon's strategy is good in the longer term. That is, do the increased profit from blocking third party lenses outweigh the loss of customers to other systems and new customers choosing other systems for a greater availability of lenses? Because for every customer Canon loses to another system, they lose any and all purchases that person may have made.
To be clear, I am not saying Canon's strategy is not more profitable. I'm just saying that it's not obvious to me why it is more profitable. That is, I understand how it might be more profitable, but also understand how it might not be. In any case, any Canon user who has an interest in a third party lens is absolutely hurt by this strategy, which is a bummer.
Jun 06, 2025 at 02:54 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.28 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
If a company came up to Canon, and says hey, our lens is about $1k, it's probably going to cost you OEM sales, and, BTW, how about we just reverse engineer the mount, so you get nothing? Great deal for Canon, isn't it?
But of course the problem saying it's about money, as I've said repeatedly, is that Nikon seems to be having the same issues with Sigma Canon is. But one guy is having a hard time realizing I already answered his question so I'll say it again
Jun 06, 2025 at 04:50 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.28 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: AmbientMike wroteThe 35/1.4 VCM is optimized for video, and looks like it might be the top stills option, as well. It's much lighter, minimal focus breathing, etc, the distortion people freaked out over really isn't bad at all in the days of computational imaging and besides EF 35/1.4 II has extremely low distortion.
So there's no reason to go to another brand that restricts me from using the best fast 35mm out there. Any adapter for other brands isn't going to be as good as the EF-RF people complain about.
You insist on limiting my lens options and not allowing me to use the best, 35/1.4 VCM, unless I use an adapter (if one even exists for rf to other brands.)I don't know who you were replying to (if anyone at all) with this post, but it has no relevance, whatsoever, about what's being discussed. No one -- NO ONE -- is telling you not to choose the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM over other options. Not a single person has said or implied it, so please stop with this false flag argument.
The question (I've lost count how many times it's been asked) is why it is a good thing that Canon does not allow third party to make lenses in RF mount (technically, not allow AF lenses for FF in RF mount)? No one -- NO ONE -- is saying you have to buy these lenses. But why is it a good thing that no one else can put these lenses on their Canon cameras? Please answer this simple question.
After you've answered that question, there's one more question for you: if Canon *actively* prevents third party from making RF lenses, then aside from Canon doing this because they feel it makes Canon more money, what is the reason? This question has also been asked multiple times with no answer....Show more →
I used roughly the same argument for 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there, as you used on your lens and its "irrelevant" & " false flag." But if you want to use a less expensive, inferior lens, go ahead
p.28 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: takowasa wroteAmbientMike wroteThe 35/1.4 VCM is optimized for video, and looks like it might be the top stills option, as well. It's much lighter, minimal focus breathing, etc, the distortion people freaked out over really isn't bad at all in the days of computational imaging and besides EF 35/1.4 II has extremely low distortion.
So there's no reason to go to another brand that restricts me from using the best fast 35mm out there. Any adapter for other brands isn't going to be as good as the EF-RF people complain about.
You insist on limiting my lens options and not allowing me to use the best, 35/1.4 VCM, unless I use an adapter (if one even exists for rf to other brands.)I don't know who you were replying to (if anyone at all) with this post, but it has no relevance, whatsoever, about what's being discussed. No one -- NO ONE -- is telling you not to choose the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM over other options. Not a single person has said or implied it, so please stop with this false flag argument.
The question (I've lost count how many times it's been asked) is why it is a good thing that Canon does not allow third party to make lenses in RF mount (technically, not allow AF lenses for FF in RF mount)? No one -- NO ONE -- is saying you have to buy these lenses. But why is it a good thing that no one else can put these lenses on their Canon cameras? Please answer this simple question.
After you've answered that question, there's one more question for you: if Canon *actively* prevents third party from making RF lenses, then aside from Canon doing this because they feel it makes Canon more money, what is the reason? This question has also been asked multiple times with no answer.I used roughly the same argument for 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there, as you used on your lens and its "irrelevant" & " false flag." But if you want to use a less expensive, inferior lens, go ahead
I'm happy to hear you believe that the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM is the best 35mm lens out there. But no one asked. Moving right along, maybe it's my fault that you're not answering my questions. Let me rephase them so that the only acceptable answers are "Yes", "No", or "I don't know". I'll give my answer in parentheses after each question.
Question 1:
Do people who own Canon cameras benefit from Canon actively blocking third party lenses being used on RF mount? (No)
Question 2:
Does Canon feel that their strategy of blocking third parties from making RF mount lenses increases their profits? (Yes)
Question 3:
Did anyone say that Canon should not charge third parties a license fee to make lenses for the RF mount? (No)
Question 4:
Did anyone say that they you, personally, should use third party lenses? (No)
If your answers to the above four questions are the same as mine, then great! After all, that's all I was talking about. If not, then we can discuss why our opinions differ. But what I'm not going to do is debate with you which lenses you think are best (although that is the title of this thread!). If you feel, for example, that the Canon RF 35 / 1.4L VCM is the best 35mm lens out there, that's great. But what I want to know is why you feel that I am wrong for wanting to be able to use a Viltrox 35 / 1.2 on my R5 (or a Tamron 35-150 / 2-2.8), and why you think it's good that Canon prevents me from doing so. Thus, the four yes/no questions above. So, again, if you would be so kind, please answer. Then we can move forward!
p.28 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
... 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there...
It’s not remotely close to being the best 35mm f/1.4 (or faster) out there. The Canon EF 35mm f/1.4 II, Sony GM 35mm f/1.4 and Sigma 35mm f/1.2 for EF are all better. Of those, two can be mounted to RF via the Canon EF–RF adapter—but then the cameras will not apply lens corrections to them in video—and one cannot be mounted at all.
It’s the best 35mm f/1.4 available on Canon RF for shooting video corrected for vignetting and barrel distortion at 35mm and f/1.4, by virtue of being the only one.
p.28 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
melcat wrote: AmbientMike wrote... 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there...It’s not remotely close to being the best 35mm f/1.4 (or faster) out there. The Canon EF 35mm f/1.4 II, Sony GM 35mm f/1.4 and Sigma 35mm f/1.2 for EF are all better. Of those, two can be mounted to RF via the Canon EF–RF adapter—but then the cameras will not apply lens corrections to them in video—and one cannot be mounted at all.
It’s the best 35mm f/1.4 available on Canon RF for shooting video corrected for vignetting and barrel distortion at 35mm and f/1.4, by virtue of being the only one.
"Best" is subjective. It's easy to see how someone would think the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM was the best. For example, I bought a new RF 50 / 1.4L VCM for the same price I could have bought a 9+ used RF 50 / 1.2L. With regards to optics and aperture, the latter is clearly the better lens. However, the former is "good enough" in that regard (it's actually really, really good), but the operation (size, weight, AF speed) made it the better choice for me.
Jun 06, 2025 at 08:07 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.28 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: AmbientMike wrotetakowasa wroteAmbientMike wroteThe 35/1.4 VCM is optimized for video, and looks like it might be the top stills option, as well. It's much lighter, minimal focus breathing, etc, the distortion people freaked out over really isn't bad at all in the days of computational imaging and besides EF 35/1.4 II has extremely low distortion.
So there's no reason to go to another brand that restricts me from using the best fast 35mm out there. Any adapter for other brands isn't going to be as good as the EF-RF people complain about.
You insist on limiting my lens options and not allowing me to use the best, 35/1.4 VCM, unless I use an adapter (if one even exists for rf to other brands.)I don't know who you were replying to (if anyone at all) with this post, but it has no relevance, whatsoever, about what's being discussed. No one -- NO ONE -- is telling you not to choose the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM over other options. Not a single person has said or implied it, so please stop with this false flag argument.
The question (I've lost count how many times it's been asked) is why it is a good thing that Canon does not allow third party to make lenses in RF mount (technically, not allow AF lenses for FF in RF mount)? No one -- NO ONE -- is saying you have to buy these lenses. But why is it a good thing that no one else can put these lenses on their Canon cameras? Please answer this simple question.
After you've answered that question, there's one more question for you: if Canon *actively* prevents third party from making RF lenses, then aside from Canon doing this because they feel it makes Canon more money, what is the reason? This question has also been asked multiple times with no answer.I used roughly the same argument for 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there, as you used on your lens and its "irrelevant" & " false flag." But if you want to use a less expensive, inferior lens, go aheadI'm happy to hear you believe that the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM is the best 35mm lens out there. But no one asked. Moving right along, maybe it's my fault that you're not answering my questions. Let me rephase them so that the only acceptable answers are "Yes", "No", or "I don't know". I'll give my answer in parentheses after each question.
Question 1:
Do people who own Canon cameras benefit from Canon actively blocking third party lenses being used on RF mount? (No)
Question 2:
Does Canon feel that their strategy of blocking third parties from making RF mount lenses increases their profits? (Yes)
Question 3:
Did anyone say that Canon should not charge third parties a license fee to make lenses for the RF mount? (No)
Question 4:
Did anyone say that they you, personally, should use third party lenses? (No)
If your answers to the above four questions are the same as mine, then great! After all, that's all I was talking about. If not, then we can discuss why our opinions differ. But what I'm not going to do is debate with you which lenses you think are best (although that is the title of this thread!). If you feel, for example, that the Canon RF 35 / 1.4L VCM is the best 35mm lens out there, that's great. But what I want to know is why you feel that I am wrong for wanting to be able to use a Viltrox 35 / 1.2 on my R5 (or a Tamron 35-150 / 2-2.8), and why you think it's good that Canon prevents me from doing so. Thus, the four yes/no questions above. So, again, if you would be so kind, please answer. Then we can move forward!...Show more →
If you want to whine, moan and complain all day long, like you have been, about your favorite lens not being available in Canon, I doubt many people want to listen to you. But go ahead.
Jun 06, 2025 at 10:49 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.28 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
melcat wrote: AmbientMike wrote... 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there...It’s not remotely close to being the best 35mm f/1.4 (or faster) out there. The Canon EF 35mm f/1.4 II, Sony GM 35mm f/1.4 and Sigma 35mm f/1.2 for EF are all better. Of those, two can be mounted to RF via the Canon EF–RF adapter—but then the cameras will not apply lens corrections to them in video—and one cannot be mounted at all.
It’s the best 35mm f/1.4 available on Canon RF for shooting video corrected for vignetting and barrel distortion at 35mm and f/1.4, by virtue of being the only one.
According to the opticallimits test, 35/1.4 VCM probably is the best. Looked better than the 35/1.4 II, and the Sony apparently isn't as good for video. If you don't like distortion corrections, they are hard to avoid lately
p.28 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
According to the opticallimits test, 35/1.4 VCM probably is the best.
You’re cherrypicking Klaus’s results here. He mentions the outlining, cat’s eyes, onion rings and fringing in the bokeh, which were my objections to the lens. But he also talks about focus shift and a built-in profile which doesn’t fully correct the vignetting, which I hadn’t known about.
I’m curious: do you have this lens? If so, can you tell us whether it fully corrects vignetting in video? (I’m not picky, I’d be using a lit set at low ISO and the noise increase wouldn’t be a problem.) How about that rattle? Does it bother you?
Klaus measured the vignetting at 3.5 stops, versus 2.4 stops for the original EF 35mm f/1.4 and 3 stops for the Mk II.
p.28 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Yes, it is getting difficult because "best" depends on the properties of interest. AF speed, IS, MTF corner to corner are important to me; videos, size/weight or the borkahs not so much.
p.28 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: melcat wroteAmbientMike wrote... 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there...It’s not remotely close to being the best 35mm f/1.4 (or faster) out there. The Canon EF 35mm f/1.4 II, Sony GM 35mm f/1.4 and Sigma 35mm f/1.2 for EF are all better. Of those, two can be mounted to RF via the Canon EF–RF adapter—but then the cameras will not apply lens corrections to them in video—and one cannot be mounted at all.
It’s the best 35mm f/1.4 available on Canon RF for shooting video corrected for vignetting and barrel distortion at 35mm and f/1.4, by virtue of being the only one."Best" is subjective. It's easy to see how someone would think the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM was the best. For example, I bought a new RF 50 / 1.4L VCM for the same price I could have bought a 9+ used RF 50 / 1.2L. With regards to optics and aperture, the latter is clearly the better lens. However, the former is "good enough" in that regard (it's actually really, really good), but the operation (size, weight, AF speed) made it the better choice for me.
Your arguments in favour of the RF 50 / 1.4L VCM also apply to the other VCM lenses.
All the Nikon and Sony users will surely cry in the Nikon and Sony forums that the Canon VCM lenses are not available for their bayonets