p.3 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Having used all three systems over the past couple of years, I would say Sony makes the best lenses of the three.
Nikon has some nice lenses in their lineup, but in practically every case the equivalent Sony version is slightly better. Nikon also farms a lot of their lens manufacturing out to third parties like Tamron, so without some inside knowledge one can't really say which lenses Nikon actually "makes".
Canon has some great lenses like the RF 100-500L and the RF 100mm macro, but mostly their L-series lenses are what I consider "good but not great". Canon's budget lenses are not terribly inspiring, although the RF 100-400mm f5.6-8 is surprisingly good.
I'll also add that once you've used some good Leica L-mount glass, it will re-calibrate your perception of optical excellence.
p.3 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Was there anything specific about your Sony glass that made you dislike it? I had great overall experiences with their GM lenses so just curious where you felt they lagged behind the competition
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
You start a post with a claim from Ken R on what is perhaps one of the most brilliant lenses Nikon has in their arsenal (the Plena). Now questioning what manufacturer has the best lenses (really?) only to answer like here that you had great experience with Sony lenses.
So, what gives? What is the purpose of your question? You shot with all brands and still need an outside opinion? You cannot judge the results of your own work yourself? You want to buy gear for the sake of buying it?
p.3 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
DanielJStein wrote:
I might be the weird one on the chat here and I look at lenses mainly for how well they do for astrophotography. Having been on all 3 systems at one point, I can say that I think Nikon Z S line lenses are the best. Sony comes in at a close 2nd, but Canon is still kind of eh in this field.
For me, I am looking at how well longitudinal CA (loCA), coma, and astigmatism impact star shapes, especially as you get close to the corners. The previous F mount Nikon lenses were actually pretty bad at this, and the Sony GM's were pretty decent. However with the Z series, Nikon has stepped up the game. The Z 50 1.8 S may be the best 50 I have used for astro for example. The 35 is not as good as the 50, but still better than the Sony 35 1.4 GM. The 24's are neck and neck, although my friend has a 24 1.4 GM for his Sony and I do not think it is as good. Meanwhile another one of my friends has that exact same lens and his copy is much better....Show more →
I haven't used the 50 1.8S for astro, but have used it wide open with city lights and found the coma in the corners to be...not great. It's pretty good across much of the frame but the far corners and even going up the short edge it's not what I would call a great performer. On the other hand, the 20 1.8S is excellent for astro work.
p.3 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
johnvanr wrote:
Beyond that, why does it even matter beyond a certain threshold?
Exactly.
Every one of these lenses is more than "good enough" and capable of producing results beyond the skill levels of 99.9% of users. While you might be able to objectively measure which lens is "best" for certain criteria, it doesn't make much difference beyond bragging rights at the monthly camera club meeting...
p.3 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
It's purely for the sake of discussion and people's experiences across brands. Nothing to read too deeply into. It has been years since I shot Sony but I still love their lineup and compact bodies. I switched to Canon for specific lenses like the 28-70mm f2 which made all the difference in certain shoots over the years from corporate to architecture to events and has been an excellent walk around, albeit heavy. I'm only recently trying Nikon for the first time to see what all the recent hype is about, both with their bodies and lenses like the 135mm Plena, 600mm f4 TC, 600mm f6.3 PF, etc. It also gives me access to lenses like the Tamron 35-150mm f2-2.8. I like to hear what lenses and systems stand out to people over the years as their favorites, even if it's specific for there use. Someone said Nikon is the best for astro after they tried all three systems due to lower coma and LoCA. I don't do much astro currently but it's a genre I've always wanted to do more of. Their insight may play into my role to dive further into Nikon and purchase something like the Nikon 14-24mm f2.8 and carefully research and consider coma performance before going further into either system.
Vinnie_VdB wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteWas there anything specific about your Sony glass that made you dislike it? I had great overall experiences with their GM lenses so just curious where you felt they lagged behind the competition
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.You start a post with a claim from Ken R on what is perhaps one of the most brilliant lenses Nikon has in their arsenal (the Plena). Now questioning what manufacturer has the best lenses (really?) only to answer like here that you had great experience with Sony lenses.
So, what gives? What is the purpose of your question? You shot with all brands and still need an outside opinion? You cannot judge the results of your own work yourself? You want to buy gear for the sake of buying it?
p.3 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Was there anything specific about your Sony glass that made you dislike it? I had great overall experiences with their GM lenses so just curious where you felt they lagged behind the competition
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.
Color, especially with skintones, and build quality on the 70-200 and 24-70 f2.8 GM. Both are workhorse lenses and I had issues with both. Also I usually prefer shooting with a DSLR for studio stuff, and Sony doesn't make one anymore.
p.3 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
For colors and skin tones do you feel it could have been the body's color science? Once of the reasons I left Sony for Canon was the skintones. I often struggled to get them how I wanted even when shooting raw. I felt they were too green/yellow and not as pleasing as what I saw from Canon. I attributed it mainly to the body (A7R4, A9II, and several others)
sungphoto wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteWas there anything specific about your Sony glass that made you dislike it? I had great overall experiences with their GM lenses so just curious where you felt they lagged behind the competition
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.Color, especially with skintones, and build quality on the 70-200 and 24-70 f2.8 GM. Both are workhorse lenses and I had issues with both.
p.3 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I've owned and shot with all three major modern full-frame mirrorless systems, and there's no clear-cut 'X makes better lenses.' I will say that for the most part, I prefer the Nikon and Sony lineups to Canon's lineup, and that was one of the major things that pushed me to swap from Canon to Nikon a year and a half ago...just not enough good lenses in the mid-range, and not too many that really stood out to me, though the RF 50/1.2L and 85/1.2L are absolutely phenomenal. Sony's got some exceptional glass, and I adapt some as well (the 35/1.4GM and Sigma's 85/1.4. also formerly the 50/1.2GM, but I sold that after getting the Nikon 50/1.4. The latter isn't as good, but it is good enough for what I need in a 50 and it's lighter and nearly as fast.)
Right now, I really love Nikon's lens lineup, though there are still some things that aren't as good, as some of the very best lenses are quite large and therefore not too interesting for me. But I love the zooms, with the 24-120/4S, 14-24/2.8S and 100-400S being the best of those types that I've ever used, plus the exceptional 105/2.8 Macro (best macro lens I've used, and I've used a lot), and their very solid mid-range S line primes.
But as many have mentioned, you can get great shots with any modern system, and whether it's Nikon, Canon, Sony, Fujifilm, whatever, plus tons of great third party lenses, it shouldn't matter too much. Not that there aren't preferences.
p.3 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
For colors and skin tones do you feel it could have been the body's color science? Once of the reasons I left Sony for Canon was the skintones. I often struggled to get them how I wanted even when shooting raw. I felt they were too green/yellow and not as pleasing as what I saw from Canon. I attributed it mainly to the body (A7R4, A9II, and several others)
sungphoto wroteAlphaPhotography wroteWas there anything specific about your Sony glass that made you dislike it? I had great overall experiences with their GM lenses so just curious where you felt they lagged behind the competition
sungphoto wroteTie between Canon and Nikon. I prefer Nikon ergonomics and control layout, which is why I consolidated to all Nikon and sold off all of my Canon kit a couple years ago. I was never totally happy with Sony glass and the resale value on them is horrible.Color, especially with skintones, and build quality on the 70-200 and 24-70 f2.8 GM. Both are workhorse lenses and I had issues with both.
Probably, but it has just as much to do with the processing chain ie RAW converter. Generally I find that Nikon is the most neutral when using strobe. In my experience, Sony files tend to show more magenta in the shadows and midtones depending on skintone (something that used to drive me crazy trying to fix), whereas Nikon, Fuji and Canon just look good without much tweaking in Capture One.
p.3 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I am not sure who makes the best, there is high quality in many systems today. That said I have been the happiest in a long time with my lens collection.
All Canon, it has been the best for travel and works for a variety of situations for my needs. Good Job Canon.
p.3 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
You all understand I hope, that questions like this one ("which brand is best, mine or yours?") are just troll fodder and virtually always end up with some kind of angry fanboy battle.
Let's just not go there.
And it really doesn't matter. I've been in exhibits where my prints (from two different brands/systems, and multiple cameras/lenses within each of the two) were hung side-by-side with work done on formats ranging from MFT to miniMF and pretty much every brand you can think of (and a few you can't) and no one cared what brand of lens was used... and no one could even tell.
This is the most pointless kind of discussion topic on camera forums. It will never resolve. There will be no winners. Personal jibes and insults are predictable.
All of today's brands produce outstanding photography equipment, and you could use any of them to produce absolutely top quality work. A decade or two ago few imagined the power of today's gear. There is rarely a rational and objective reason for deciding that one is "the best" compared to the others, and the truth is that most of us base our decisions largely on hopes and dreams and fantasies, not objectives facts.
Sony makes great lenses. Canon makes great lenses. Nikon makes great lenses. Fujifilm makes great lenses, Leica makes great lenses. Voigtlander makes great lenses. The brands I left out make great lenses.
Pick one or a few and get on with making photographs.
p.3 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
krug wrote:
I REALLY don't want to be an old codger party-pooper but this original question is a little like asking "what is the best automobile?" - in both cases the answer has to be heavily dependant on the sub-question "for what purpose are you going to use it ?"
I could make a case for the Range Rover I used for many years for everything OR for the Cobra that I used much more occasionally for a long time purely for fun BUT the honest answer to the question would be one of the clapped out old bangers that got the family around when we had very little money but an urgent need to get to places to work or get kids to school.
And surely in answer to the original question, that wasn't limited to 3 makers, no mention of Zeiss, Leica, even Sigma or Voigtlander is more than a little surprising.
Just my 2 cents worth and absolutely no offence intended to anyone - one of the main delights of this site is that it is a place for everyone - even grumpy old men like me perhaps (- I hope !)....Show more →
Sorry but I have to bite ….
Your mention of Range Rovers is a red rag for me. I utterly detest them. Once the choice of farmers and “The Gentry” now favoured by chavs and drug dealers.
They are #1 for unreliability and #1 for thefts.
I now see RR and automatically assume IDIOT trying to impress 😂.
The new owners of JLR (TATA??) are ruining the once famous marquees, first RR and now - thanks to their latest woke advert….Jaguar.
Sorry for the derail….
Back to topic
I’ll take Planar, Zeiss or Leitz over any modern
brand for sheer optical quality.
p.3 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
There is no "my brand or yours" for me. I have zero brand loyalty. Whichever brand offers the best products or the ones that fit my need the best at any given time are the ones I'll use. I'll likely end up with a Sony setup again in the future for it's compact size. Nikon is intriguing with the RED acquisition and rave reviews about the Z8, their telephoto handheld video stabilization is unmatched from what I've seen but I plan on doing my own testing with that in the coming weeks. It's difficult to test every lens or system so I value feedback from others who have used multiple systems and settled on specific lenses (or bodies). Like if multiple people use the Z 50mm f1.2 after owning the RF 50mm f1.2 and vastly prefer one over the other that will weigh into my decision on which to get next as it's tough to try every lens. In the case or the 135mm Plena it seems like a special lens and I love that they focused on round specular highlights. The last lens I remember to do so was the original Sony 85mm f1.4 GM.
The question could be rephrased as "what are your favorite lenses you've used across all systems and why?" What lenses are memorable, ones you regret selling and buy again, and is there a common brand that you find yourself preferring the output or handling?
gdanmitchell wrote:
You all understand I hope, that questions like this one ("which brand is best, mine or yours?") are just troll fodder and virtually always end up with some kind of angry fanboy battle.
Let's just not go there.
And it really doesn't matter. I've been in exhibits where my prints (from two different brands/systems, and multiple cameras/lenses within each of the two) were hung side-by-side with work done on formats ranging from MFT to miniMF and pretty much every brand you can think of (and a few you can't) and no one cared what brand of lens was used... and no one could even tell.
This is the most pointless kind of discussion topic on camera forums. It will never resolve. There will be no winners. Personal jibes and insults are predictable.
All of today's brands produce outstanding photography equipment, and you could use any of them to produce absolutely top quality work. A decade or two ago few imagined the power of today's gear. There is rarely a rational and objective reason for deciding that one is "the best" compared to the others, and the truth is that most of us base our decisions largely on hopes and dreams and fantasies, not objectives facts.
Sony makes great lenses. Canon makes great lenses. Nikon makes great lenses. Fujifilm makes great lenses, Leica makes great lenses. Voigtlander makes great lenses. The brands I left out make great lenses.
Pick one or a few and get on with making photographs....Show more →
p.3 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Pixelpuffin wrote: krug wroteI REALLY don't want to be an old codger party-pooper but this original question is a little like asking "what is the best automobile?" - in both cases the answer has to be heavily dependant on the sub-question "for what purpose are you going to use it ?"
I could make a case for the Range Rover I used for many years for everything OR for the Cobra that I used much more occasionally for a long time purely for fun BUT the honest answer to the question would be one of the clapped out old bangers that got the family around when we had very little money but an urgent need to get to places to work or get kids to school.
And surely in answer to the original question, that wasn't limited to 3 makers, no mention of Zeiss, Leica, even Sigma or Voigtlander is more than a little surprising.
Just my 2 cents worth and absolutely no offence intended to anyone - one of the main delights of this site is that it is a place for everyone - even grumpy old men like me perhaps (- I hope !).Sorry but I have to bite ….
Your mention of Range Rovers is a red rag for me. I utterly detest them. Once the choice of farmers and “The Gentry” now favoured by chavs and drug dealers.
They are #1 for unreliability and #1 for thefts.
I now see RR and automatically assume IDIOT trying to impress 😂.
The new owners of JLR (TATA??) are ruining the once famous marquees, first RR and now - thanks to their latest woke advert….Jaguar.
Sorry for the derail….
Back to topic
I’ll take Planar, Zeiss or Leitz over any modern
brand for sheer optical quality.