fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

  
 
Sauseschritt
Offline
Details
p.10 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Well, I went Nikon DSLR back in the day (around 2013) when I got into photography simply because great Nikon lenses are more frequent and more affordable.

Also Nikon supported manual focus lenses better and thus would be the superior choice for Zeiss and Voigtländer lenses.

Canon also had excellent lenses like the 85/1.2 and 135/2, but they would always be expensive.

There are a couple other advantages of Nikon where Canon made unfortunate shortcuts. For example I can use a DX lens (AF 10.5mm f2.8 Fisheye) on Nikon just fine with a full frame sensor. Impossible on Canon.

I understand with mirrorless Canon became the superior choice for lenses, but thats all too expensive for me. I also dont get the point. Mirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.
Jan 12, 2025 at 02:25 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.10 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


Sauseschritt wrote:
Mirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.


What do you mean by that? Mirrorless lenses, bodies, or both? I could wake up from a drunken slumber and rattle off a half dozen advantages of mirrorless systems.
Jan 12, 2025 at 02:34 PM
PixiPhotography
Offline
Details
p.10 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

I used to think like he did as well. Idk about him but I was a die hard DSLR fan until I owned the original Z6 and Z7, and as I was getting into video the countless advantages became clear (IBIS, EVF, size, weight, etc).

AlphaPhotography wrote:
Sauseschritt wroteMirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.
What do you mean by that? Mirrorless lenses, bodies, or both? I could wake up from a drunken slumber and rattle off a half dozen advantages of mirrorless systems.

Jan 12, 2025 at 02:58 PM
Vento
Offline
Details
p.10 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Sauseschritt wrote:
Mirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.


A user with my profile would be absolute proof to the contrary.
Mirrorless is the only way I can use my extensive lens collection digitally again without loss and at the same time I have access to the latest and best AF lenses of the MILC era, like my Nikkor Plena, Z 400/4.5 VR S and others.

Lenses like my old Canon FD's, 85/1.2 L, 20-35/3.5 L, 135/2, 200/2.8, all my remaining Mamiya 645 Sekor optics and many others.
Lenses that could only be used in analog mounts for decades, as they were previously only digitally adaptable with massively degrading optical elements.

So the complete opposite for me, high-quality lenses that have been locked out for years/decades via mount changes are suddenly completely lossless adaptable.
Mirrorless has instantly increased my lens collection many times over, as many of my old lenses were unusable with DSLRs.
Mirrorless offers unique possibilities in this area, whether SLR, DSLR, 35mm or 6x4.5, 6x6, 6x7...medium format lenses, my Z bodys swallow everything and that without having to make any optical compromises when adapting.

Mirrorless is therefore a blessing and the long-awaited and liberating open sesame for photographers with a long equipment history and extensive lens collection like me.
Due to the fact that almost everything can be adapted, it is also one of the cheapest ways to put together high-quality optical photographic equipment.

The possibilities with the Z-mount, which even accepts E-mount lenses, are greater than ever before.
With a few exceptions, this is already close to a completely open mount and can be designed to be as cost-effective as possible, depending on requirements, precisely because of the adaptability of almost all imaginable lenses.
Not only are you cut off from further progress with DSLRs, there are also many more limitations in relation to other mounts.
Add to that the many new, high-quality and in some cases significantly improved mirrorless lenses, and I come to a completely opposite conclusion.
Mirrorless, in my case the Z-mount, has enriched my photography like no mount before, right back to the 70s.





Edited on Jan 12, 2025 at 05:38 PM · View previous versions
Jan 12, 2025 at 05:26 PM
suteetat
Offline
Details
p.10 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I love mirrorless technology and like its potential since Sony released the original A7r. At that time, EVF could be a bit better, autofocus was still significantly behind DSLR but I love focus point that cover almost all the frame, no more recomposing with focus lock. No need to calibrate any lenses. Superior manual focus ability. Dot focus confirmation on Nikon is not bad but I much prefer focus peaking and focus magnifier and at the time, the ability for Sony to adapt various lenses and all those legacy manual lenses (with some limitation). I was shooting Nikon DSLR side by side with Sony mirroless for several years, if it was not birds of wildlife, I actually preferred Sony over Nikon mainly for functionality but still love Nikon color more. Then Nikon brought out the Z system which for my personal preference, I prefer over Sony. Once Z9 comes out, there was really not much point in keeping Nikon DSLR anymore.
Recently I was shooting birds next to a friend who was using D500. Did not realize how loud and very disturbing that was. I could see some birds really was bother by the noise and flew off very quickly.

Jan 12, 2025 at 05:36 PM
huddy
Offline
Details
p.10 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Each of the Big 3 make the best lenses. We are so spoiled now with optics that could only be dreamed of 25 years ago. There are variations in optical design choices of course but I actually view this as a plus. Photographers have more niches served and if we take the time to learn our craft, shooting needs/styles, artistic preferences, I would say there has never been an easier time to find a great lens+mount to fit any need.

Maybe best of all, we can more easily adapt old lenses from yesteryear and also have many great 3rd party makers hitting performance targets that also used to be impossible.
Jan 12, 2025 at 06:18 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.10 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
I used to own, for one, a Nikkor 24/2.8 af (probably pre-D.) They may have just put the AIS in an af mount to use in af cameras. Not everything gets a complete redesign, for that matter is 24/2.8 AIS even different optically from AI


The AiS and the two AF versions are all the same I believe. I had the first 24/2.8 AF briefly and replaced it with the AiS since the first AF version was so bad mechanically, such as the skinny and sloppy manual focus ring with short throw and minimal DOF scale. That was the 80s when IQ expectations were not so high and prior to the AF-D lenses.

EBH
Jan 12, 2025 at 06:29 PM
mawz
Online
Details
p.10 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
EB-1 wrote:
AmbientMike wroteI used to own, for one, a Nikkor 24/2.8 af (probably pre-D.) They may have just put the AIS in an af mount to use in af cameras. Not everything gets a complete redesign, for that matter is 24/2.8 AIS even different optically from AI
The AiS and the two AF versions are all the same I believe. I had the first 24/2.8 AF briefly and replaced it with the AiS since the first AF version was so bad mechanically, such as the skinny and sloppy manual focus ring with short throw and minimal DOF scale. That was the 80s when IQ expectations were not so high and prior to the AF-D lenses.

EBH


Nikon only ever had 2 24/2.8 designs, the original 9/7 design (both pre-AI versions) with CRC (first Nikkor with CRC) and the 9/9 design with CRC introduced with the AI generation and which continued through the D version.

Generally the AI/AI-S versions do a bit better because there's more slop in the focus system for the two AF versions, especially the early non-D.
Jan 12, 2025 at 09:49 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.10 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Which brand's optical design choices do you prefer?

huddy wrote:
Each of the Big 3 make the best lenses. We are so spoiled now with optics that could only be dreamed of 25 years ago. There are variations in optical design choices of course but I actually view this as a plus. Photographers have more niches served and if we take the time to learn our craft, shooting needs/styles, artistic preferences, I would say there has never been an easier time to find a great lens+mount to fit any need.

Maybe best of all, we can more easily adapt old lenses from yesteryear and also have many great 3rd party makers
...Show more →
Jan 12, 2025 at 09:59 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.10 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Sauseschritt wrote:
Mirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR,............


Boy, are you in the dark.
Jan 12, 2025 at 10:56 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.10 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Sauseschritt wrote:
I understand with mirrorless Canon became the superior choice for lenses, but thats all too expensive for me. I also dont get the point. Mirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.


Unfortunately there is no choice if you want new products.

EBH
Jan 12, 2025 at 11:09 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

rscheffler wrote:
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.



I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
Jan 13, 2025 at 01:02 AM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.10 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote:
Mike seriously, what is this crusade? You are desperate to paint the 34/1.4 VCM as having normal distortion and your method is to compare it to extreme zoom designs. Like do you honestly even believe the argument you’re making?

The 20-70 has high distortion. It’s also the only 20-70 zoom in existence for full frame. Same with the Canon 24-105/2.8, which also has crazy extreme distortion.

But a 35/1.4 is not an extreme zoom lens. So comparing distortion characteristics between a 35 and an extreme zoom design is just ludicrous. Why on earth does it matter to you? The 35
...Show more →

Well, he has to compare to the35VCM to the 20-70 because comparing to the GM35 just does not fit his narrative.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54263517505_abc4c8f200_o.jpg

Jan 13, 2025 at 01:14 AM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.10 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The A9 was and is a very specialized camera. When it released there was nothing close to matching its blackout-free EVF and speed. High dynamic range was never a big priority. Same with the A9III and its global shutter.

AmbientMike wrote:
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now,
...Show more →
Jan 13, 2025 at 01:26 AM
duncangr
Offline
Details
p.10 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now,
...Show more →

What do you mean by "far superior DR" of the R1 ?
Jan 13, 2025 at 04:30 AM
3catsinky
Offline
Details
p.10 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
shooting both Sony and Niikon. They are all sharp. My Sigma FE 24-70 is razor sharp. My 24-120F4s
razor sharp. they all work. im happy.
Jan 13, 2025 at 04:54 AM
Hathaway
Offline
Details
p.10 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
The star eater is still an issue?!? I remember that from YEARS ago. I think they weighed slightly into my decision to move to Canon because it was annoying for the little astro I did at the time.

Hathaway wrote:
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Have you used the Sony 14mm f1.8? How does it compare to the Sigma 14mm f1.8 and/or Sigma 14mm f1.4 for astro?

Earlier quote

I haven’t personally but my buddy that shoots Sony does and likes it and the images are quite good. We shoot a fair bit of astro together and his images are clean in the corners. Not that Sony has fixed the star eater SW issue his images are coming out quite nice. Better and cleaner than my Sigma on R5 images.


I typoed in my reply and meant now (as opposed to not). I know it was resolved for Sony some time ago but there were lots of internet whining for years after it was fixed. My buddy shoots an A7R4 and it isn’t an issue anymore.
Jan 13, 2025 at 07:59 AM
DanielJStein
Offline
Details
p.10 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Hathaway wrote:
AlphaPhotography wroteThe star eater is still an issue?!? I remember that from YEARS ago. I think they weighed slightly into my decision to move to Canon because it was annoying for the little astro I did at the time.

Have you used the Sony 14mm f1.8? How does it compare to the Sigma 14mm f1.8 and/or Sigma 14mm f1.4 for astro?

I haven’t personally but my buddy that shoots Sony does and likes it and the images are quite good. We shoot a fair bit of astro together and his images are clean in the corners. Not that Sony has fixed the star eater SW issue his images are coming out quite nice. Better and cleaner than my Sigma on R5 images.

I typoed in my reply and meant now (as opposed to not). I know it was resolved for Sony some time ago but there were lots of internet whining for years after it was fixed. My buddy shoots an A7R4 and it isn’t an issue anymore.


The issue is currently fixed with the A7RV, not the A7RIV. My friend has the 4 and I have 2 friends that an A7IV and I still see the issue with their files. Mark Shelly over on Cloudy Nights has more extensive evidence, but just in what I have seen only the A7RV series has it fixed 100%. A step in the right direction for sure, but all Sony has to do is release a firmware update for their other bodies. I know this is off-topic for this lens thread, but just wanted to get the facts straight.


Jan 13, 2025 at 08:15 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.10 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Sauseschritt wrote:
Mirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.

https://media3.giphy.com/media/13l7w7N4Vr1dw4/200w.gif
Jan 13, 2025 at 09:03 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


Sauseschritt wrote:
I understand with mirrorless Canon became the superior choice for lenses, but thats all too expensive for me. I also dont get the point. Mirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.


At the time, Canon + cheap adapter gave me metering on rebel XT which D70 didn't have. A major reason I went Canon and ir made a big difference since I could use various Nikkor mount gear more easily

There is a lot of truth in your statement though it isn't likely to be popular here. No one really discussed if , for instance, landscape photographers got a benefit using 20-30fps or eye af. It was more nonsensical claims that mirrorless is the future but if course Leica m3 isn't the future but still very desirable, for instance
Jan 13, 2025 at 09:28 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell