fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

  
 
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.29 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
tomba8tomba wrote:
takowasa wrote
melcat wrote
AmbientMike wrote... 35/1.4 VCM, which may be the best 35/1.4 out there...
It’s not remotely close to being the best 35mm f/1.4 (or faster) out there. The Canon EF 35mm f/1.4 II, Sony GM 35mm f/1.4 and Sigma 35mm f/1.2 for EF are all better. Of those, two can be mounted to RF via the Canon EF–RF adapter—but then the cameras will not apply lens corrections to them in video—and one cannot be mounted at all.

It’s the best 35mm f/1.4 available on Canon RF for shooting video corrected for vignetting and barrel distortion at 35mm and f/1.4, by virtue of being the only one.
"Best" is subjective. It's easy to see how someone would think the RF 35 / 1.4L VCM was the best. For example, I bought a new RF 50 / 1.4L VCM for the same price I could have bought a 9+ used RF 50 / 1.2L. With regards to optics and aperture, the latter is clearly the better lens. However, the former is "good enough" in that regard (it's actually really, really good), but the operation (size, weight, AF speed) made it the better choice for me.
Your arguments in favour of the RF 50 / 1.4L VCM also apply to the other VCM lenses.


Absolutely!

All the Nikon and Sony users will surely cry in the Nikon and Sony forums that the Canon VCM lenses are not available for their bayonets

I'm sure there are Nikon and Sony users who would love to use some of the RF lenses, if Canon made them for their mount and vice-versa. That would be an interesting scenario, to be honest! Imagine Canon's VCM primes being available for E mount and Sony's 50-150 / 2 being available for RF mount. : )

However, Canon not making lenses for Nikon and Sony mounts is an entirely different issue than Canon *completely* blocking *all* third parties that want to make lenses for RF mount (for FF lenses with AF, that is).
Jun 07, 2025 at 04:29 PM
abnorm77
Offline
Details
p.29 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I always thought that Canon cameras and lenses have a certain look that I love. Never thought about switching.
Jun 08, 2025 at 07:23 PM
icantbebigwill
Offline
Details
p.29 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I'll throw out my very unqualified opinion.

I've shot all 3 systems and I think you can't really go wrong either way.

Strictly speaking of native mirrorless glass:

I think the RF mount has the highest barrier to entry for top tier glass, and it was my biggest frustration with the system. The 100-500 is begging for a stacked crop body for an incredibly light and capable wildlife kit, however I do wish it had a shorter throw.

E mount has the lowest barrier to entry with fantastic third party glass that gives you 90% of GM glass for a fraction of the cost, of course with Sony imposed limitations. I wish there more "affordable" long primes like the Sigma 500mm.

Z mount has the nice 1.8 S line lenses with the 50mm 1.8 only really being eclipsed by the 1.2 glass of competitors for 3-4x the cost. The Tamron rebranded lenses are also a nice "budget" option. The PF glass is amazing for the price, and you can't really find alternatives to these in RF or E.

If money was no object I think all 3 would serve you well and it's down to camera body preferences at that point.
Jun 09, 2025 at 08:23 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.29 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
melcat wrote:
AmbientMike wroteAccording to the opticallimits test, 35/1.4 VCM probably is the best.
You’re cherrypicking Klaus’s results here. He mentions the outlining, cat’s eyes, onion rings and fringing in the bokeh, which were my objections to the lens. But he also talks about focus shift and a built-in profile which doesn’t fully correct the vignetting, which I hadn’t known about.

I’m curious: do you have this lens? If so, can you tell us whether it fully corrects vignetting in video? (I’m not picky, I’d be using a lit set at low ISO and the noise increase wouldn’t be a problem.) How about that rattle? Does it bother you?

Klaus measured the vignetting at 3.5 stops,
...Show more →

You are very negative on this lens, have you used it? Bought or rented?

Here's his quote on onion rings: "Out-of-focus highlights are quite nicely rendered for a moderately wide prime lens. The inner zone of the discs is relatively clean, with just a hint of onion rings produced by the aspherical elements. There’s only a tiny bit of an outlining effect at the edges of the discs." Another quote on bokeh: "The quality of bokeh is good for such a lens." So if anyone is cherry picking, it seems to be you, personally I tend to find people complaining about a rattle more bothersome than a rattle, myself, and he gives it a 9 mechanically

I've certainly used lenses to get vignetting at max aperture. Reducing it 2.4 stops sounds pretty good to me, correcting it completely sounds like it might look at bit odd actually. And, lest we forget or let it get glossed over, the resolution figures are excellent (!!!) and the distortion not really too bad, on the level of 16-35's we've had for years
Jun 09, 2025 at 12:20 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.29 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Bokeh and its associated features (transitions, degree of blur, shapes of specular highlights, linearity with distance) are very personal and controversial. Instead of 'The quality of bokeh is good', reviewers should be encouraged to offer a description, not a personal rating.

'The quality of the sky is good today', doesn't tell you much, does it? Bokeh typically occupies 75% of most fast lenses's wide images. He could do much better than a card setup no one will ever use. Get a model, stand her in a busy park.

I took a look. It's pretty standard issue 2025, typical in that it globs out very fast with little finesse, and the only distance cues are the coarse machined rings. Looks like someone drew two lines on the flat left side surface - from in-focus to out-of-focus in a few millimeters!

It then offers a wall of blur. This is the kind of bokeh we associate with poor depth representation due to the ultra rapid transitions. And bokeh styles also carry over to smaller aperture images. And we see that here also, that's why he used a lot of leading lines and near-far compositions in his sample images, to try and pump some life into the image depth. Hopefully, it's a cheaper lens, given the lack of options.




Jun 09, 2025 at 07:43 PM
melcat
Offline
Details
p.29 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
I've certainly used lenses to get vignetting at max aperture. Reducing it 2.4 stops sounds pretty good to me, correcting it completely sounds like it might look at bit odd actually.


Amazing. You like vignetting so I shouldn’t want a lens with less of it, or even be able to have it completely corrected in software or on camera.

I routinely bulk-correct vignetting of all images, and very rarely use it for artistic effect. When I do I usually crop to 4:5, which means first correcting the vignette with the profile, then cropping, and then adding post-vignetting according to the new aspect ratio. That’s why, after all, the separate post-vignetting tool exists in Capture One.

You are very negative on this lens, have you used it? Bought or rented?

I handled it in a shop a while ago, before knowing much about it, and was immediately surprised by the 67mm filter thread. Then I looked at the tiny front element inside that and came to a (correct) conclusion about cat’s eye bokeh. Then I noticed the rattle, which, I’m afraid, is enough to rule it out for any situation in which I’d be carrying it around all day.

The VCM lenses are excellent for a certain kind of usage, which doesn’t happen to be mine.
Jun 10, 2025 at 01:50 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister