This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.
Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Canon innovated with a <7lb 600/4 making it available in both Rf and EF mounts, 2 years or so earlier. Somehow nikon is superior since its >7lb 600/4 only available in Z mount and it came out later? Makes pretty much no sense
If you have problems <4% distortion you're not likely to be happy using anything today. All the major brands do computational imaging. If you avoid it on 35/1.4 (EF 35/1.4 II is even less distortion vs other brands) you can easily get more distortion on other lenses if you're not careful, the Canon is probably the best out there, <4% is correctable afaik
You should probably buy DSLR lenses, not many (any?) of those required the amount of digital correction seen lately on mirrorless lenses (isn't technology great?) BTW Sony didn't have a single fast supertele until 2018, the same year Canon's 600/4 came out. Of course, Canon and Nikon had 400/2.8 and 400/3.5 in the 1980's
p.8 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Canon innovated with a <7lb 600/4 making it available in both Rf and EF mounts, 2 years or so earlier. Somehow nikon is superior since its >7lb 600/4 only available in Z mount and it came out later? Makes pretty much no sense
If you have problems <4% distortion you're not likely to be happy using anything today. All the major brands do computational imaging. If you avoid it on 35/1.4 (EF 35/1.4 II is even less distortion vs other brands) you can easily get more distortion on other lenses if you're not careful, the Canon is probably the best out there, <4% is correctable afaik
You should probably buy DSLR lenses, not many (any?) of those required the amount of digital correction seen lately on mirrorless lenses (isn't technology great?) BTW Sony didn't have a single fast supertele until 2018, the same year Canon's 600/4 came out. Of course, Canon and Nikon had 400/2.8 and 400/3.5 in the 1980's...Show more →
Sony FE 600mm f/4: 3040g (6.70lb)
Sony FE 1.4X TC: 167g (0.37lb)
Nikon Z 600m f/4 TC: 3260g (7.19lb)
They're all essentially the same weight. If you always use your 600mm lens bare and handhold it, then sure, you save 0.4-0.5lb with the Canon and Sony lenses. But most people use these lenses with TCs at least some of the time and most use them on a tripod at least some of the time. And when you add a TC the Canon is the heaviest. Plus, you lose the ability to instantly engage and disengage the TC. So yes, the Nikon is superior and the weight difference is negligible when you start getting into this class of lens. If you really want to nit pick, then the Canon lens isn't the lightest either with or without a TC.
I'm not sure why you keep talking about the Canon version being available for EF mount as being a great thing. Mirrorless is the future and both Canon and Nikon are phasing out their DSLRs. Buying a DSLR lens these days is a dead end. Adding mount converters to large lenses like this isn't great to start with, and is even worse when you start adding a DSLR mount TC into the mix. Instead, Nikon and Sony focused on making their mirrorless versions better. Sony by making theirs the lightest available. Nikon by making theirs much lighter than their DSLR version and by including a TC.
Jan 10, 2025 at 10:51 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Wezre wrote: AmbientMike wroteCanon innovated with a <7lb 600/4 making it available in both Rf and EF mounts, 2 years or so earlier. Somehow nikon is superior since its >7lb 600/4 only available in Z mount and it came out later? Makes pretty much no sense
If you have problems <4% distortion you're not likely to be happy using anything today. All the major brands do computational imaging. If you avoid it on 35/1.4 (EF 35/1.4 II is even less distortion vs other brands) you can easily get more distortion on other lenses if you're not careful, the Canon is probably the best out there, <4% is correctable afaik
You should probably buy DSLR lenses, not many (any?) of those required the amount of digital correction seen lately on mirrorless lenses (isn't technology great?) BTW Sony didn't have a single fast supertele until 2018, the same year Canon's 600/4 came out. Of course, Canon and Nikon had 400/2.8 and 400/3.5 in the 1980'sCanon RF 600mm f/4: 3090g (6.81lb)
Canon RF 1.4X TC: 224g (0.49lb)
Sony FE 600mm f/4: 3040g (6.70lb)
Sony FE 1.4X TC: 167g (0.37lb)
Nikon Z 600m f/4 TC: 3260g (7.19lb)
They're all essentially the same weight. If you always use your 600mm lens bare and handhold it, then sure, you save 0.4-0.5lb with the Canon and Sony lenses. But most people use these lenses with TCs at least some of the time and most use them on a tripod at least some of the time. And when you add a TC the Canon is the heaviest. Plus, you lose the ability to instantly engage and disengage the TC. So yes, the Nikon is superior and the weight difference is negligible when you start getting into this class of lens. If you really want to nit pick, then the Canon lens isn't the lightest either with or without a TC.
I'm not sure why you keep talking about the Canon version being available for EF mount as being a great thing. Mirrorless is the future and both Canon and Nikon are phasing out their DSLRs. Buying a DSLR lens these days is a dead end. Adding mount converters to large lenses like this isn't great to start with, and is even worse when you start adding a DSLR mount TC into the mix. Instead, Nikon and Sony focused on making their mirrorless versions better. Sony by making theirs the lightest available. Nikon by making theirs much lighter than their DSLR version and by including a TC....Show more →
It's an advantage to be able to use your light 600/4 on a D850 or 5D4 or your latest mirrorless using an adapter, especially if you are making the transition. I have no idea why you wouldn't want the option.
Jan 10, 2025 at 12:06 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I used to own, for one, a Nikkor 24/2.8 af (probably pre-D.) They may have just put the AIS in an af mount to use in af cameras. Not everything gets a complete redesign, for that matter is 24/2.8 AIS even different optically from AI
Jan 10, 2025 at 12:10 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote:
Of course, those Canon superteles are still fantastic lenses, but the 800 and 1200 are strange misses to me, as it seems like a wonderful opportunity to create a 400/2.8+2xTC and 600/4+2xTC, giving both lenses in one. At that point, I don't think any Canon shooter would care that they were repurposed EF designs.
But I guess that does make it so they can't charge $7000 for a specialized 2x TC you can't remove.
In any case, I do expect Canon will release some very nice updated supertelephotos over the coming year or two.
If you don't like the Canon 1200/8, you can buy the competitors except there aren't any. The critiques of the lens tend to sound a bit anti intellectual "what in tarnation, they just slapped a darn 2x on there, and welded it right on!" Of course that's not actually quite the case, people might think they sound intelligent saying that, but they don't, really
p.8 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Ultimately, each lens program of the three major manufacturers includes some extraordinary, class-leading lenses in addition to ordinary lenses and in every program there are lenses that you would very much like to see from your own manufacturer.
At least the Sony E-mount can also be adapted with Nikon Z.
Nikon's strength in the Z system is certainly the telephoto range, the only thing missing is a comparable solution to the Sony 300/2.8, or a Z 100/120-300/2.8 VR S variant.
Otherwise, with lenses such as the Z 85/1.2 S, Z MC 105/2.8 VR S, Z 135/1.8 S Plena, Z 400/2.8 TC VR S, Z 400/4.5 VR S, Z 100-400/4.5-5.6 VR S, Z 600/4 TC VR S, Z 600/6.3 PF VR S, Z 180.600/5.6-6.3 VR, Z 800/6.3 PF VR S, (Z 28-400), Nikon is outstandingly well positioned.
For me, this is clearly the best in class in this segment overall.
Sony now has a fantastic variety of standard zooms, plus innovations such as the 20-70/4, 24-50/2.8, 28-70/2, including the various other options in the segment.
In the primes @ 50mm and below I also see them clearly ahead.
The Z 50/1.2 S and of course the Noct are optically exceptional lenses, but in terms of weight and dimensions, especially for an f/1.2, they are absoutly over the top.
Similarly with the 70-200/2.8 solutions, where the Nikon leaves little to be desired optically, but is somewhat out of balance in terms of weight/dimensions.
I think Sony is better positioned here, even with the high-quality primes from 35mm and below.
The 300/2.8 is another highlight.
I still own various Canon FD lenses like the 85/1.2 L, or the 20-35/3.5 L, but with the Bayonet switch from FD to EF and five-digit sums in FD lenses, the company has been on ignore ever since.
However, with a few exceptions, such as the Plena, my favorites are high-quality manual focus lenses such as the Cosina/Voigtländer lenses.
I'm old-fashioned in that respect, I love the feel, the character of a precision mechanical tool, the indestructibility of these lenses, the classic aperture ring, when they also perform as optically outstandingly as the Apo Lanthare, for example.
There are many other lens manufacturers, some with outstanding legacy, many already mentioned, such as Zeiss, Leica, Cosina, Schneider-Kreuznach, Rodenstock, but ultimately also many other manufacturers such as Fuji, Pentax, Olympus, or older things like some medium format Mamiya Sekor lenses.
In the end, it's all about variety and the right tool can sometimes be vintage and/or manual focus.
There are so many old gems from different decades and MILC is the open sesame for so many mounts.
The last thing I would strive for would be lenses from just one manufacturer, especially as the switch from fast, modern MILC AF optics to some MF pearls or Vintage gems can also change the mind set, which can sometimes be very productive.
Jan 10, 2025 at 06:22 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
It's a bit incongruous to see people on one hand, clamoring for a lens redesign and on the other, clamoring to be able to attach ~7 elements to their lenses , and having that built in.
Granted I'm a big proponent of tc's, but they're also a bit clunky.
BTW 20-70 Sony is one of the ones having ~9% distortion. If you are trying to get less distortion buying 35/1.4 Sony, and then buy 20-70, you are not exactly coming out ahead on distortion compared to the 35/1.4 VCM. I doubt the recent 24-50's from any manufacturer are a great choice to avoid computational imaging including distortion corrections
p.8 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
All great points. I'm glad you brought up the Sony 20-70mm f4 and 24-50mm f2.8 as their unique lenses for the system.
Vento wrote:
Ultimately, each lens program of the three major manufacturers includes some extraordinary, class-leading lenses in addition to ordinary lenses and in every program there are lenses that you would very much like to see from your own manufacturer.
At least the Sony E-mount can also be adapted with Nikon Z.
Nikon's strength in the Z system is certainly the telephoto range, the only thing missing is a comparable solution to the Sony 300/2.8, or a Z 100/120-300/2.8 VR S variant.
Otherwise, with lenses such as the Z 85/1.2 S, Z MC 105/2.8 VR S, Z 135/1.8 S Plena, Z 400/2.8 TC VR S, Z 400/4.5 VR S, Z 100-400/4.5-5.6 VR S, Z 600/4 TC VR S, Z 600/6.3 PF VR S, Z 180.600/5.6-6.3 VR, Z 800/6.3 PF VR S, (Z 28-400), Nikon is outstandingly well positioned.
For me, this is clearly the best in class in this segment overall.
Sony now has a fantastic variety of standard zooms, plus innovations such as the 20-70/4, 24-50/2.8, 28-70/2, including the various other options in the segment.
In the primes @ 50mm and below I also see them clearly ahead.
The Z 50/1.2 S and of course the Noct are optically exceptional lenses, but in terms of weight and dimensions, especially for an f/1.2, they are absoutly over the top.
Similarly with the 70-200/2.8 solutions, where the Nikon leaves little to be desired optically, but is somewhat out of balance in terms of weight/dimensions.
I think Sony is better positioned here, even with the high-quality primes from 35mm and below.
The 300/2.8 is another highlight.
I still own various Canon FD lenses like the 85/1.2 L, or the 20-35/3.5 L, but with the Bayonet switch from FD to EF and five-digit sums in FD lenses, the company has been on ignore ever since.
However, with a few exceptions, such as the Plena, my favorites are high-quality manual focus lenses such as the Cosina/Voigtländer lenses.
I'm old-fashioned in that respect, I love the feel, the character of a precision mechanical tool, the indestructibility of these lenses, the classic aperture ring, when they also perform as optically outstandingly as the Apo Lanthare, for example.
There are many other lens manufacturers, some with outstanding legacy, many already mentioned, such as Zeiss, Leica, Cosina, Schneider-Kreuznach, Rodenstock, but ultimately also many other manufacturers such as Fuji, Pentax, Olympus, or older things like some medium format Mamiya Sekor lenses.
In the end, it's all about variety and the right tool can sometimes be vintage and/or manual focus.
There are so many old gems from different decades and MILC is the open sesame for so many mounts.
The last thing I would strive for would be lenses from just one manufacturer, especially as the switch from fast, modern MILC AF optics to some MF pearls or Vintage gems can also change the mind set, which can sometimes be very productive....Show more →
p.8 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
It's a bit incongruous to see people on one hand, clamoring for a lens redesign and on the other, clamoring to be able to attach ~7 elements to their lenses , and having that built in.
Granted I'm a big proponent of tc's, but they're also a bit clunky.
BTW 20-70 Sony is one of the ones having ~9% distortion. If you are trying to get less distortion buying 35/1.4 Sony, and then buy 20-70, you are not exactly coming out ahead on distortion compared to the 35/1.4 VCM. I doubt the recent 24-50's from any manufacturer are a great choice to avoid computational imaging including distortion corrections ...Show more →
It's a bit incongruous to see people on one hand, complaining about 7 elements antiquated design that can actually be engaged or disengaged while adding litle weigh and price but improve on functionality so much but totally blind to empty space just to accomodate unneccesarily long flange distance of old mount on a newer more modern mount design. On top of that also applause the nerve for a company to
weld antiquated elements permanently to a lens with no ability to engage or disengage it at a cost of $6000-7000 more
and call that unique and something to brag about.
p.8 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Teleconverters being clunky is exactly why having them built-in is such a big deal. No more swapping in the field, getting fingerprints or dust on the elements, or risking rain damage. No more missed shots fumbling with a TC. You flip a switch and it's as if you swapped in a longer prime with very little affect on IQ. Based on the samples I've seen having the converter built-in also seems to allow them to dial in tolerances and get better image quality but I'm not sure if that's the case, only that the results are excellent. Nikon offering built-in TC's on their 400 and 600 primes is a big reason I'm currently testing out the system alongside by Canon R5II setup. If Nikon's bodies can match or exceed Canon's for wildlife then the big primes may be the deciding factor. With that said, I'm hopeful to see Canon bring true native RF designs (based around the shorter flange distance) in the near future. I'm also very excited for the potential 200-500mm f4 and I hope they implement built-in TC's into their designs again.
The Sony 20-70mm f4 may have a lot of distortion but it's a very unique wide zoom range where one would expect some compromises. The Canon RF 35mm f1.4 having as much distortion as it does seems like a bizarre choice, especially for those who own or have used the EF 35mm f1.4 II. It's obvious they made some compromises to keep all three VCM primes the same size, filters, etc and to shave some weight. Same with their new RF 24-105mm f2.8 and RF 70-200mm f2.8. I'm not totally opposed to these decisions, especially since I'm doing more video. I'm just a little annoyed that it seems like Sony was able to do it "better" with their older 35mm GM lens. Other than focus breathing I think the Sony outperforms the Canon in most areas based on the tests I've seen. I previously owned the Sony 24mm f1.4 GM and loved it. I just picked up the RF 24mm f1.4 VCM and I hope to love it just as much, even with extensive software corrections.
AmbientMike wrote:
It's a bit incongruous to see people on one hand, clamoring for a lens redesign and on the other, clamoring to be able to attach ~7 elements to their lenses , and having that built in.
Granted I'm a big proponent of tc's, but they're also a bit clunky.
BTW 20-70 Sony is one of the ones having ~9% distortion. If you are trying to get less distortion buying 35/1.4 Sony, and then buy 20-70, you are not exactly coming out ahead on distortion compared to the 35/1.4 VCM. I doubt the recent 24-50's from any manufacturer are a great choice to avoid computational imaging including distortion corrections ...Show more →
Jan 10, 2025 at 07:46 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
suteetat wrote: AmbientMike wroteIt's a bit incongruous to see people on one hand, clamoring for a lens redesign and on the other, clamoring to be able to attach ~7 elements to their lenses , and having that built in.
Granted I'm a big proponent of tc's, but they're also a bit clunky.
BTW 20-70 Sony is one of the ones having ~9% distortion. If you are trying to get less distortion buying 35/1.4 Sony, and then buy 20-70, you are not exactly coming out ahead on distortion compared to the 35/1.4 VCM. I doubt the recent 24-50's from any manufacturer are a great choice to avoid computational imaging including distortion correctionsIt's a bit incongruous to see people on one hand, complaining about 7 elements antiquated design that can actually be engaged or disengaged while adding litle weigh and price but improve on functionality so much but totally blind to empty space just to accomodate unneccesarily long flange distance of old mount on a newer more modern mount design. On top of that also applause the nerve for a company to
weld antiquated elements permanently to a lens with no ability to engage or disengage it at a cost of $6000-7000 more
and call that unique and something to brag about.
"Dern tootin' they just slapped a 2x on the back,. Welded it right on there! Why, my cousin can put one on there, a lot less than $7k!!"
Not a very sophisticated opinion, and they definitely didn't just weld a 2x on there, thats pretty obvious. The 600/4 + tc isn't cheap, either, or likely to be as good at 1200/8
Jan 11, 2025 at 08:27 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Teleconverters being clunky is exactly why having them built-in is such a big deal. No more swapping in the field, getting fingerprints or dust on the elements, or risking rain damage. No more missed shots fumbling with a TC. You flip a switch and it's as if you swapped in a longer prime with very little affect on IQ. Based on the samples I've seen having the converter built-in also seems to allow them to dial in tolerances and get better image quality but I'm not sure if that's the case, only that the results are excellent. Nikon offering built-in TC's on their 400 and 600 primes is a big reason I'm currently testing out the system alongside by Canon R5II setup. If Nikon's bodies can match or exceed Canon's for wildlife then the big primes may be the deciding factor. With that said, I'm hopeful to see Canon bring true native RF designs (based around the shorter flange distance) in the near future. I'm also very excited for the potential 200-500mm f4 and I hope they implement built-in TC's into their designs again.
The Sony 20-70mm f4 may have a lot of distortion but it's a very unique wide zoom range where one would expect some compromises. The Canon RF 35mm f1.4 having as much distortion as it does seems like a bizarre choice, especially for those who own or have used the EF 35mm f1.4 II. It's obvious they made some compromises to keep all three VCM primes the same size, filters, etc and to shave some weight. Same with their new RF 24-105mm f2.8 and RF 70-200mm f2.8. I'm not totally opposed to these decisions, especially since I'm doing more video. I'm just a little annoyed that it seems like Sony was able to do it "better" with their older 35mm GM lens. Other than focus breathing I think the Sony outperforms the Canon in most areas based on the tests I've seen. I previously owned the Sony 24mm f1.4 GM and loved it. I just picked up the RF 24mm f1.4 VCM and I hope to love it just as much, even with extensive software corrections.
...Show more →AmbientMike wroteIt's a bit incongruous to see people on one hand, clamoring for a lens redesign and on the other, clamoring to be able to attach ~7 elements to their lenses , and having that built in.
Granted I'm a big proponent of tc's, but they're also a bit clunky.
BTW 20-70 Sony is one of the ones having ~9% distortion. If you are trying to get less distortion buying 35/1.4 Sony, and then buy 20-70, you are not exactly coming out ahead on distortion compared to the 35/1.4 VCM. I doubt the recent 24-50's from any manufacturer are a great choice to avoid computational imaging including distortion corrections
So the 9% distortion 20-70 is unique, and the Canon 35/1.4 vcm having much less distortion is bizarre? Oh come on. The opticallimits test of the vcm looks extremely sharp maybe even moreso than EF35/1.4 II which has less distortion than the sony.
p.8 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Mike seriously, what is this crusade? You are desperate to paint the 34/1.4 VCM as having normal distortion and your method is to compare it to extreme zoom designs. Like do you honestly even believe the argument you’re making?
The 20-70 has high distortion. It’s also the only 20-70 zoom in existence for full frame. Same with the Canon 24-105/2.8, which also has crazy extreme distortion.
But a 35/1.4 is not an extreme zoom lens. So comparing distortion characteristics between a 35 and an extreme zoom design is just ludicrous. Why on earth does it matter to you? The 35 VCM has very high distortion for a 35mm full frame prime. So much so that in looking through designs I have yet to find another one that has higher.
Arguing against this is simply ridiculous. And I don’t understand why you care. It doesn’t mean the lens is terrible. It just means that it has high distortion. The E mount Sigma 85/1.4 has very high pincushion distortion for an 85mm lens..and it’s still a fantastic lens.
p.8 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
gdanmitchell wrote:
And we’re off and running… ;-)
;-) ;-) ;-)
Jan 11, 2025 at 09:40 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.8 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
You pretty much know,on a thread like this, reading the op, you are going to get ridiculous claims about Canon. Anything Canon does gets turned into a negative, including not particularly high distortion vs competitors due to lens corrections everyone's doing. But if you think <4% is too much and go Sony (even though EF 35/1.4 II has less distortion) then buy 16-35/4 or 20-70, you're at 9%, explain how that's getting ahead
And the redneck-y sounding welding things to a 600/4 bit is a real joy. And yes nikon probably could have made their Z 600/4 in F mount for D850 etc DSLR users like Canon did. They had enough room to put a TC in, seems unlikely they put elements behind it.