fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

  
 
huddy
Offline
Details
p.11 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Which brand's optical design choices do you prefer?

huddy wroteEach of the Big 3 make the best lenses. We are so spoiled now with optics that could only be dreamed of 25 years ago. There are variations in optical design choices of course but I actually view this as a plus. Photographers have more niches served and if we take the time to learn our craft, shooting needs/styles, artistic preferences, I would say there has never been an easier time to find a great lens+mount to fit any need.

Maybe best of all, we can more easily adapt old lenses from yesteryear and also have many great 3rd party makers hitting performance targets that also used to be impossible.


No strong preference for me. I'm doing this for fun and I don't have the means to try all of the different systems. I came into photography with a prior visual arts background and spent a lot of early time learning about composition/light. My exploration of lenses (on Nikon F mount where I started) was based entirely on determining what perspectives I liked for shooting and engaging with my subjects (family) and ensuring the apertures were fast enough to get sufficient shutter speed in low light conditions in a time when I couldn't afford VR lenses and IBIS didn't exist.

At this point, I'm sticking with Nikon because:
1. I've been using lenses and making lovely prints for my family with lenses that are up to 50 years in age. None of the modern equipment is technologically different in a meaningful way between manufacturers for me.
2. I don't have the financial means to shoot 2-3 systems side by side.
3. I wouldn't want to spend the time doing #2 anyway since system #1 already works so well.

Some of the Sony GM lenses look great. One of my friends who shoots Canon has the modern 85/1.2. His work is fantastic and the lens is terrific. I'm just not the person who is shooting in a niche that needs/wants to eke out the very most round/smooth bokeh, or discuss the finer points of which of an A1 vs Z9 vs R1 plus a specific supertelephoto for a specific bird species is what I need to achieve the results I want!

Edited on Jan 13, 2025 at 09:32 AM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2025 at 09:30 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


AlphaPhotography wrote:
The A9 was and is a very specialized camera. When it released there was nothing close to matching its blackout-free EVF and speed. High dynamic range was never a big priority. Same with the A9III and its global shutter.

AmbientMike wrote
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.


Yes if you consider other things besides DR Canon DSLRS are excellent cameras. But to say "dump your DSLR it's no good" at the time the A9 is being marketed with few complaints about DR is pretty ridiculous
Jan 13, 2025 at 09:32 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


duncangr wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
What do you mean by "far superior DR" of the R1 ?


I looked at Bill claff, R1 is 3/4 to 1 stop better, i thought it was higher.

Like the R3. That camera beats the A9III by almost 2 full stops on Bill Claff's tests!!!
Jan 13, 2025 at 09:34 AM
duncangr
Offline
Details
p.11 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
duncangr wrote
AmbientMike wrote
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
What do you mean by "far superior DR" of the R1 ?
I looked at Bill claff, R1 is 3/4 to 1 stop better, i thought it was higher.

Like the R3. That camera beats the A9III by almost 2 full stops on Bill Claff's tests!!!


This is "far superior" ??

Where exactly is it 3/4 to 1 stop better ?

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_R1-Sony_A9iii.jpg
Jan 13, 2025 at 09:54 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
duncangr wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
duncangr wrote
AmbientMike wrote
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
What do you mean by "far superior DR" of the R1 ?
I looked at Bill claff, R1 is 3/4 to 1 stop better, i thought it was higher.

Like the R3. That camera beats the A9III by almost 2 full stops on Bill Claff's tests!!!
This is "far superior" ??

Where exactly is it 3/4 to 1 stop better ?

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_R1-Sony_A9iii.jpg


If you read my post you'll see R1 wasn't as high as I thought, better than A9III though, that camera's DR is almost identical to 5DsR . R3 blows a9III away global sensor doesn't help DR, makes it more like older Canon DSLR'S

People post these graphs, and dont get how similar the graph for the low DR camera they dumped looks to the high DR camera

It is pretty clearly at around iso 100 (though 50 is close,) the max DR on the R1, a9III max PDR is iso 250 (though 125 close.) He lists the max PDR in the table below the graphs, too. Also, looking at the site (not sure about the graph you posted though?) a9III has NR (down pointing triangles) people complain about that the R1 doesn't have!!!




Edited on Jan 13, 2025 at 10:23 AM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2025 at 10:09 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.11 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
In most ways, modern mirrorless cameras excel beyond the capabilities of our older DSLRs. Yet DSLRs are still fine picture-making tools and are far from obsolete — for some kinds of photography more than others perhaps.

If you have a DSLR and like what it does for you, there’s little reason to switch to mirrorless. If you are at the point where your DSLR is starting to seem a bit long in the tooth, then there’s a very good chance that replacing it with a mirrorless camera will be a fine idea.

I use both mirrorless and DSLR systems at the current time.

Of course, all of this nitpicking over which thing has the slightly better specs in some way has about as much relationship to photography as debates about the shininess of automotive paint have to driving…
Jan 13, 2025 at 10:21 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


duncangr wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
duncangr wrote
AmbientMike wrote
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
What do you mean by "far superior DR" of the R1 ?
I looked at Bill claff, R1 is 3/4 to 1 stop better, i thought it was higher.

Like the R3. That camera beats the A9III by almost 2 full stops on Bill Claff's tests!!!
This is "far superior" ??

Where exactly is it 3/4 to 1 stop better ?

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_R1-Sony_A9iii.jpg


I'm not seeing any triangles on the R1 graph on Bill Claff's site. Those denote NR, which the a9III apparently has.

Not sure how you got those on there in the graph you posted. Am I missing something here?
Jan 13, 2025 at 10:32 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.11 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Indeed, the poor DR of the R1 compared to the R3 may simply be the result of Canon having stopped to apply in camera noise reduction to boost their DR number. Or... they are doing it in a more subtle way that isn't as easy to uncover for Bill Claff/as effective in terms of DR numbers improvement.

Assuming they actually stopped doing it, I personally see this as a positive thing. We see things the way they are instead of an artificially embellished version of reality. I wonder how those who defended Canon for applying in camera NR to their raw files since the R6/R5/R3 feel about that?

I certainly wasn't happy to see Sony follow suit with the a9III, but considering how much focus they have put on DR these past years, I understand the temptation not to loose on DR vs competitors. It's the wrong move though, NR on desktop will always be far better than NR in camera.
Jan 14, 2025 at 12:39 AM
Maxxus46
Offline
Details
p.11 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
If talking telephotos lenses, Nikon wins. Easily Best selection of any full frame system
Jan 14, 2025 at 11:00 AM
Rod.smith7
Offline
Details
p.11 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
It seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.

Jan 14, 2025 at 11:11 AM
duncangr
Offline
Details
p.11 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
duncangr wrote
AmbientMike wrote
duncangr wrote
AmbientMike wrote
rscheffler wroteMike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
What do you mean by "far superior DR" of the R1 ?
I looked at Bill claff, R1 is 3/4 to 1 stop better, i thought it was higher.

Like the R3. That camera beats the A9III by almost 2 full stops on Bill Claff's tests!!!
This is "far superior" ??

Where exactly is it 3/4 to 1 stop better ?

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_R1-Sony_A9iii.jpg
I'm not seeing any triangles on the R1 graph on Bill Claff's site. Those denote NR, which the a9III apparently has.

Not sure how you got those on there in the graph you posted. Am I missing something here?


Here is a screen shot take of his original post - apparently he subsequently changed the threshold so the R1 now falls just outside the triangle level.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_r1.png

The only valid way to compare is to visually compare images after post processing. Any other comparison is academic and of little practical use.
Jan 14, 2025 at 03:26 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.11 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
bernardl wrote:
We see things the way they are instead of an artificially embellished version of reality.


If you project light through a lens of some arbitrary focal length, set to some particular aperture that affects such things as DOF, and you capture data about the relative intensity of red, blue, and green light as digital values, and you then use various formulas to convert those values to an image that is displayed on a screen (applying various compensatory curves in the camera, during the conversion, and on the screen)…

… you are not seeing “reality.” It is an artificial stand-in for reality, at best. No photograph is a perfectly objective record of the subject.

And essentially all cameras are applying noise reduction in order to expand the dynamic range and more.

Also, no modern high-end digital camera has “poor” DR.
Jan 14, 2025 at 05:16 PM
dmcphoto
Offline
Details
p.11 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
In terms of IQ I don't think it makes much difference which brand of cameras and lenses you use. OTOH, if you need a very light and compact setup one brand could be "best". Likewise if you want a lens that only one manufacturer produces.

A great equalizer is processing software. Some of the AI sharpeners, for instance, do not sharpen the existing fine details. Instead the AI uses them and their context to determine how they should look and replaces them with pixels created by the AI, not by your lens. To some extent (not completely) this takes your lens out of the equation.

In 2018 I captured a photo of a bird under atrocious conditions with camera settings that were not very appropriate. I slightly missed focus, and the bird moved its head a little during the exposure. The photo was garbage. Because it was my only image of this particular bird I tried pretty hard to salvage it in PS, but it was hopeless. I recently tried the latest version of an expensive (IMO) AI image processing application and the result was mind blowing. The bird now has head feathers where there was just a noisy blur with almost no hint of feathers. The blurred and slightly oval eyes that were a result of it turning it's head during the 1/40 sec exposure were round and sharp with details around the edges. It looks like would have if I did everything correctly. Given this, I have to assume that properly captured images from a very sharp lens and a less sharp version from a different maker would be equally sharp after going through this application.

I'm not addressing any ethical or authorship concerns here, and I'm not sure if the use of these programs is "good", but they certainly work. That said, they work better for some things than others, and tend to make a mess of distant talus slopes on mountains, for instance. But they will only get better.
Jan 14, 2025 at 05:59 PM
Nikkorman
Offline
Details
p.11 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The classic Olympus OM Zuiko lenses were excellent. Oly should have either made a full frame that can use those lenses or made them for CanoNikoSony.

Classic lenses made by Olympus, Pentax, Nikon, Canon, and others really stand the test of time. I am not sure if newer lenses will last as long. However, each of the today's manufacturers make good glass.
Jan 14, 2025 at 06:13 PM
jackalooope
Offline
Details
p.11 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I had the chance to try the mighty Zeiss Otus 55mm f/1.4, and it was truly impressive. The sharpness and beautiful rendering are exceptional. Aside from its large size, I can't think of any drawbacks. Too sad Zeiss does not make these lenses anymore.
Jan 14, 2025 at 08:17 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.11 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
jackalooope wrote:
I had the chance to try the mighty Zeiss Otus 55mm f/1.4, and it was truly impressive. The sharpness and beautiful rendering are exceptional. Aside from its large size, I can't think of any drawbacks. Too sad Zeiss does not make these lenses anymore.


It's amazing as long as you don't check the look of bokeh balls...

Cheers,
Bernard
Jan 14, 2025 at 11:30 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.11 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
gdanmitchell wrote:
bernardl wroteWe see things the way they are instead of an artificially embellished version of reality.
If you project light through a lens of some arbitrary focal length, set to some particular aperture that affects such things as DOF, and you capture data about the relative intensity of red, blue, and green light as digital values, and you then use various formulas to convert those values to an image that is displayed on a screen (applying various compensatory curves in the camera, during the conversion, and on the screen)…

… you are not seeing “reality.” It is an artificial stand-in for reality, at best. No photograph is a perfectly objective record of the subject.

And essentially all cameras
...Show more →

Agreed but this is not what I meant. I meant that I prefer to see the real quality of the sensor in terms of DR, not artificially boosted numbers.

For 2 main reasons:
- It helps me decide what camera to pick
- I will get better shadow noise reduction on the desktop than Canon can do in camera

We already had this discussion a few months ago. There is really no valid reason to apply NR to raw files. The only case would be if the camera were able to capture some information that would enable better noise reduction that can be done elsewhere, such as dark frame reduction, but this isn't what we are talking about here.

We see with the R1 that when (less) NR is applied in camera there are still significant DR differences. So no, not all sensors are equal.

Cheers,
Bernard

Jan 14, 2025 at 11:32 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.11 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Rod.smith7 wrote:
It seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.



Or you can just use the SOny E lenses on natively branded bodies including 61MP.

EBH
Jan 15, 2025 at 12:05 AM
jackalooope
Offline
Details
p.11 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Forgot to mention the infamous onion rings.

bernardl wrote:
jackalooope wroteI had the chance to try the mighty Zeiss Otus 55mm f/1.4, and it was truly impressive. The sharpness and beautiful rendering are exceptional. Aside from its large size, I can't think of any drawbacks. Too sad Zeiss does not make these lenses anymore.
It's amazing as long as you don't check the look of bokeh balls...

Cheers,
Bernard

Jan 15, 2025 at 01:01 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.11 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
jackalooope wrote:
Forgot to mention the infamous onion rings.

bernardl wrote
jackalooope wroteI had the chance to try the mighty Zeiss Otus 55mm f/1.4, and it was truly impressive. The sharpness and beautiful rendering are exceptional. Aside from its large size, I can't think of any drawbacks. Too sad Zeiss does not make these lenses anymore.
It's amazing as long as you don't check the look of bokeh balls...

Cheers,
Bernard


That made me sell my 3 Otus (28, 55 and 85), just kept the 100mm f1.4 that solved the issue.

Cheers,
Bernard

Jan 15, 2025 at 02:57 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister