fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

  
 
Rod.smith7
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


EB-1 wrote:
Rod.smith7 wroteIt seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.
Or you can just use the SOny E lenses on natively branded bodies including 61MP.

EBH


Well, yes, one obviously could but then you’re running two systems or would be shooting Sony exclusively with zero access to Nikon lenses…and, don’t forget that Nikon will be releasing the Z7iii with -60MP as confirmed through a conversation I had with one of their top top executives just yesterday, but keep that on the down low.
Jan 15, 2025 at 09:03 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

duncangr wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
duncangr wrote
AmbientMike wrote
duncangr wrote
AmbientMike wroteI know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
What do you mean by "far superior DR" of the R1 ?
I looked at Bill claff, R1 is 3/4 to 1 stop better, i thought it was higher.

Like the R3. That camera beats the A9III by almost 2 full stops on Bill Claff's tests!!!
This is "far superior" ??

Where exactly is it 3/4 to 1 stop better ?

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_R1-Sony_A9iii.jpg
I'm not seeing any triangles on the R1 graph on Bill Claff's site. Those denote NR, which the a9III apparently has.

Not sure how you got those on there in the graph you posted. Am I missing something here?
Here is a screen shot take of his original post - apparently he subsequently changed the threshold so the R1 now falls just outside the triangle level.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_r1.png

The only valid way to compare is to visually compare images after post processing. Any other comparison is academic and of little practical use.


The a9III had to use NR to get to 5DSR level DR!

I'd say the almost 2 stop DR advantage of the R3 over A9III is pretty huge.

R1 has more DR than A9III + NR. One can't really criticize the supposed NR issue on the R5,R5II, R3 etc


Jan 15, 2025 at 11:39 AM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.12 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I think the dynamic range arguments aren't really much to talk about when talking about cameras that are almost exclusively marketed for sports and action shooting, because low ISO shooting is very low priority on those cameras. As such, I think the maximum dynamic range on the R1, R3 and A9 III don't really matter too much. What matters is the DR at higher ISOs, since these are almost always shot between ISO 400 and 6400. In this range, the R1, R3 and A9 3 are all within about a half a stop of each other from 400-1600 and almost identical above 1600.

In all-rounders, such as the R5 II, Z8/Z9 and Sony A1 II, the max DR becomes more important, but even here, all of the companies are within 1/3 stop of each other, which is absolutely nothing.

People who are generally going to be using their cameras for landscape and outdoor low ISO shooting aren't generally going to grab an R3 or A9 III for these tasks. They can do them, but that's not why people buy them. People buy the A9 III for the global shutter. That's it. If the don't need the global shutter, then an A7 IV is going to be a better buy, and if they want high resolution, an A1 II. Canon shooters are only generally buying the R1 and R3 for sports and maybe wildlife shooting (though even the latter may have people lean to the R5 II for more pixels per duck).
Jan 15, 2025 at 11:48 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Sony is selling $6k cameras that took NR to get to 5DSR DR levels

It's just so absolutely ridiculous what has happened.

We were told, ad nauseum, dump your DSLR'S, a major reason being, they don't have the DR. Little or no discussion on the merits of the DSLR'S, or if you even use low iso's. Now it's 100 excuses telling us, basically, to go buy poor DR camera, not a problem, even though it has far less DR than R5, R3, etc supposedly having a problem since NR applied

Jan 15, 2025 at 01:07 PM
Wezre
Offline
Details
p.12 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Sony is selling $6k cameras that took NR to get to 5DSR DR levels

It's just so absolutely ridiculous what has happened.

We were told, ad nauseum, dump your DSLR'S, a major reason being, they don't have the DR. Little or no discussion on the merits of the DSLR'S, or if you even use low iso's. Now it's 100 excuses telling us, basically, to go buy poor DR camera, not a problem, even though it has far less DR than R5, R3, etc supposedly having a problem since NR applied



I've never seen improved DR stated as a main selling point of mirrorless cameras. Is an added benefit of some newer sensors that have been introduced since DSLRs stopped being developed? I guess? But advancements in DR have been relatively minor compared to the many other significant advancements in mirrorless cameras. BSI sensors were a bigger advancement and were becoming more common as the transition to mirrorless was happening. Major selling points I've seen over the years are more accurate AF, improved tracking across the entire frame, faster continuous shooting, real time exposure preview, blackout free continuous shooting, pixel shift, and IBIS, to name a few.
Jan 15, 2025 at 01:29 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Sony is selling $6k cameras that took NR to get to 5DSR DR levels

It's just so absolutely ridiculous what has happened.

We were told, ad nauseum, dump your DSLR'S, a major reason being, they don't have the DR. Little or no discussion on the merits of the DSLR'S, or if you even use low iso's. Now it's 100 excuses telling us, basically, to go buy poor DR camera, not a problem, even though it has far less DR than R5, R3, etc supposedly having a problem since NR applied



Mike you seem to be a master of these straw man arguments. No one said dump DSLRs due to dynamic range. In the Canon world, there may have been some discussion because Canon sensors had historically low dynamic range until the 5D IV, which Canon also re-used in the original R...and so they have essentially identical image quality. And then they made another jump with the R6 and R5...so many people jumped to mirrorless due to the newer sensors. The R6 II and R5 II (and R8) also all have these high DR sensors. But no one believes the presence of a mirror has anything to do with dynamic range...they are just newer cameras. The benefits of mirrorless are many, but generally in other ways.

Nikon, definitely no such argument was made, as the Nikon DSLRs are had very high DR sensors, many of which were repurposed in the mirrorless line (such as the Z7/Z7 II sharing a sensor with the D850).

It just so happens that the mirrorless cameras are newer in everyone's lineup, so if there's a newer sensor, it's going to likely be better in several ways.

Then you conflate the need for high dynamic range in landscape / studio / general purpose type applications, shot at low ISO, which is important for cameras such as the R6, R5, Z6, Z7, A7, A7R series cameras. And the 'all rounders' like the A1 line, the R5 II, the Z8, etc....of which readout speed AND dynamic range are both important.

But the A9/R1/R3 line are designed for action photography almost entirely...that's 100% the target market. And those cameras aren't shot at base ISO very often. And so base ISO DR is of far less importance than AF accuracy, sensor readout speed, etc. Complaining about the A9 III costing $6000 is like complaining that the TS-E 24mm f/3.5L is insanely priced since the RF 24mm f/1.8 is two full stops faster and only $550. The TS-E does something very specialized. Same with the A9 III. There is no other global shutter full frame sports camera, and for those who need that, they are willing to pay the $$ and sacrifice some other things for the specialized stuff. Anyone who buys an A9 III and DOESN'T need the global shutter is wasting their money...same with someone who shells out for a tilt shift and leaves it locked at 0 the entire time they own it.

I'm curious if you are knowingly making these bad faith arguments, or whether you simply can't understand nuance in any way, because you like to bludgeon discussions with these sweeping generalizations.

Edited on Jan 15, 2025 at 02:33 PM · View previous versions
Jan 15, 2025 at 01:56 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Rod.smith7 wrote:
It seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.

EB-1 wrote:
Or you can just use the SOny E lenses on natively branded bodies including 61MP.

EBH

Rod.smith7 wrote:
Well, yes, one obviously could but then you’re running two systems or would be shooting Sony exclusively with zero access to Nikon lenses…and, don’t forget that Nikon will be releasing the Z7iii with -60MP as confirmed through a conversation I had with one of their top top executives just yesterday, but keep that on the down low.


I was making a general comment, not having very good experiences with camera, adapter, and lens from three different suppliers. I have no idea about a Z7 III. Is it just the same old (2010s) Sony sensor or does Nikon have a supplier of more advanced sensors?

EBH
Jan 15, 2025 at 01:56 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
EB-1 wrote:
Rod.smith7 wroteIt seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.
EB-1 wroteOr you can just use the SOny E lenses on natively branded bodies including 61MP.

EBH
Rod.smith7 wroteWell, yes, one obviously could but then you’re running two systems or would be shooting Sony exclusively with zero access to Nikon lenses…and, don’t forget that Nikon will be releasing the Z7iii with -60MP as confirmed through a conversation I had with one of their top top executives just yesterday, but keep that on the down low.
I was making a general comment, not having very good experiences with camera, adapter, and lens from three different suppliers. I have no idea about a Z7 III. Is it just the same old (2010s) Sony sensor or does Nikon have a supplier of more advanced sensors?

EBH


I have no knowledge of the Z7 III specs, but if they're going 60MP, My guess is it'll be essentially the same Sony based sensor used in the A7R IV and V, but with Nikon processing. There's not a lot of sensor development with regards to pure image quality as of late...sort of reaching a point of diminishing returns there. Honestly, if they re-used the Z7 II sensor I'd be just fine, because while that camera had some deficiencies compared to more modern bodies in terms of autofocus, screen and EVF, the sensor was absolutely phenomenal as long as you didn't need high-speed readout. Absolutely ZERO complaints on that front. I would honestly swap my Z8 for a Z7III if they just put the Z7 II sensor in a Z6 III body (except with the Z8's multi-axis tilt screen) with the new EVF, new AF algorithms and so on.
Jan 15, 2025 at 01:59 PM
duncangr
Offline
Details
p.12 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Sony is selling $6k cameras that took NR to get to 5DSR DR levels

It's just so absolutely ridiculous what has happened.

We were told, ad nauseum, dump your DSLR'S, a major reason being, they don't have the DR. Little or no discussion on the merits of the DSLR'S, or if you even use low iso's. Now it's 100 excuses telling us, basically, to go buy poor DR camera, not a problem, even though it has far less DR than R5, R3, etc supposedly having a problem since NR applied



Well according to ptp, which apparently is your reference for DR performance, there appears to be some DR improvement with some mirrorless cameras. ymmv.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon5DSR.png

Personally I don't find the PTP charts reflect reality accurately but I can understand the desire for some objective measure of things like DR.

However I have to admit the PTP charts are useful for objectively demonstrating how poorly the R1 performs and how well the A7r5 performs.
Jan 15, 2025 at 03:01 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.12 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote:
EB-1 wrote
Rod.smith7 wroteIt seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.
EB-1 wroteOr you can just use the SOny E lenses on natively branded bodies including 61MP.

EBH
Rod.smith7 wroteWell, yes, one obviously could but then you’re running two systems or would be shooting Sony exclusively with zero access to Nikon lenses…and, don’t forget that Nikon will be releasing the Z7iii with -60MP as confirmed through a conversation I had with one of their top top executives just yesterday, but keep that on the down low.
I was making a general comment, not having very good experiences with camera, adapter, and lens from three different suppliers. I have no idea about a Z7 III. Is it just the same old (2010s) Sony sensor or does Nikon have a supplier of more advanced sensors?

EBH
I have no knowledge of the Z7 III specs, but if they're going 60MP, My guess is it'll be essentially the same Sony based sensor used in the A7R IV and V, but with Nikon processing. There's not a lot of sensor development with regards to pure image quality as of late...sort of reaching a point of diminishing returns there. Honestly, if they re-used the Z7 II sensor I'd be just fine, because while that camera had some deficiencies compared to more modern bodies in terms of autofocus, screen and EVF, the sensor was absolutely phenomenal as long as you
...Show more →

Considering the legacy and ambition of Nikon it seems very likely that the Z7III will come with a 80+ mp sensor with a deepened focus on color quality and Expeed 8.

Odds are it’s going to be manufactured by Sony.

As far as the a9III goes anybody stressing low ISO DR as a critical issue of that camera is completely missing the point of that camera. This coming from a former owner who has promoted DR as absolutely essential for 20 years. But… I am still disappointed Sony decided to apply NR to their raw files. I would have preferred worse DR numbers without NR.

Cheers,
Bernard
Jan 15, 2025 at 04:46 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.12 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I'd hope that anyone that was researching an A9 would know why they needed it. It has always been very specialized sports/action focused line. Anyone who needed the speed and blackout free shooting experience benefitted from dumping their DSLR. Dynamic range certainly wasn't a factor as it was poor/average in both Canon DSLR's and the A9. But readout speed, AF tracking, and burst rates were far superior to anything on the market at the time.

AmbientMike wrote:
AlphaPhotography wroteThe A9 was and is a very specialized camera. When it released there was nothing close to matching its blackout-free EVF and speed. High dynamic range was never a big priority. Same with the A9III and its global shutter.

AmbientMike wrote
rscheffler wrote
AmbientMike wroteBoy, do I not see this thread going well.....
rscheffler wroteFrom post #2 of this thread:
Self-fulfilling prophecy/prediction?
AmbientMike wroteIf you'd counter some of these ridiculous claims maybe I wouldn't have to. But just complain about me, like I'm the problem.
Mike, I'm not complaining about you specifically. Just pointing out the irony that you predicted this happening, yet you still got sucked into it.

This thread did seem to hold out longer than I expected before devolving.

IME there is little point in participating once discussions devolve. It doesn't change minds and there are other things I'd rather do.
I know what you're saying, but I do think it matters. A big part of the mirrorless takeover was the nonsense on forums (and probably YouTube, sites, etc) about Canon DSLR'S lacking DR.

Of course at the same time this went on, Sony was trying to sell the original A9 that didn't really have the DR either And now the famous YouTuber barely mentions the far superior DR of the R1 and prefers the A9III & the Z6III which is a full stop behind the D750 on Bill Claff. I guess I was supposed to care before, but not now, those Canon DSLR'S apparently got better recently

I do think it is important to take this stuff on.
Yes if you consider other things besides DR Canon DSLRS are excellent cameras. But to say "dump your DSLR it's no good" at the time the A9 is being marketed with few complaints about DR is pretty ridiculous

Jan 15, 2025 at 09:52 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
That seems like a strange move for them. Do you think it is the rehashed Sony A7RIV/V sensor? I'd imagine at that resolution and price point the readout speed might be pretty slow. But maybe they'll do another partial stacked sensor.

Rod.smith7 wrote:
EB-1 wrote
Rod.smith7 wroteIt seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.
Or you can just use the SOny E lenses on natively branded bodies including 61MP.

EBH
Well, yes, one obviously could but then you’re running two systems or would be shooting Sony exclusively with zero access to Nikon lenses…and, don’t forget that Nikon will be releasing the Z7iii with -60MP as confirmed through a conversation I had with one of their top top executives just yesterday, but keep that on the down low.

Jan 15, 2025 at 09:58 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.12 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I agree. The A9 line has always prioritized speed over ultimate IQ, DR, resolution, etc. And the global shutter puts it in a league of its own for those that need it. It's difficult to fairly compare it to cameras in other segments.

Jman13 wrote:
I think the dynamic range arguments aren't really much to talk about when talking about cameras that are almost exclusively marketed for sports and action shooting, because low ISO shooting is very low priority on those cameras. As such, I think the maximum dynamic range on the R1, R3 and A9 III don't really matter too much. What matters is the DR at higher ISOs, since these are almost always shot between ISO 400 and 6400. In this range, the R1, R3 and A9 3 are all within about a half a stop of each other from 400-1600 and almost
...Show more →
Jan 15, 2025 at 10:01 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.12 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I'm beginning to think he's just trolling with how little sense these arguments make.

Jman13 wrote:
AmbientMike wroteSony is selling $6k cameras that took NR to get to 5DSR DR levels

It's just so absolutely ridiculous what has happened.

We were told, ad nauseum, dump your DSLR'S, a major reason being, they don't have the DR. Little or no discussion on the merits of the DSLR'S, or if you even use low iso's. Now it's 100 excuses telling us, basically, to go buy poor DR camera, not a problem, even though it has far less DR than R5, R3, etc supposedly having a problem since NR applied
Mike you seem to be a master of these straw man arguments. No one said dump DSLRs due to dynamic range. In the Canon world, there may have been some discussion because Canon sensors had historically low dynamic range until the 5D IV, which Canon also re-used in the original R...and so they have essentially identical image quality. And then they made another jump with the R6 and R5...so many people jumped to mirrorless due to the newer sensors. The R6 II and R5 II (and R8) also all have these high DR sensors. But no one believes the presence
...Show more →
Jan 15, 2025 at 10:02 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.12 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I may just be unfamiliar with Nikon's lineup but is the Z7 line their high MP competitor to the Sony A7R line?

bernardl wrote:
Jman13 wrote
EB-1 wrote
Rod.smith7 wroteIt seems that every camera company, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Fuji, etc, are making great lenses lenses today. However, Nikon’s Z mount allowed Nikon to create a fantastic stable of lenses and provide access to all of Sony’s E mount glass, no other mount can do that.
EB-1 wroteOr you can just use the SOny E lenses on natively branded bodies including 61MP.

EBH
Rod.smith7 wroteWell, yes, one obviously could but then you’re running two systems or would be shooting Sony exclusively with zero access to Nikon lenses…and, don’t forget that Nikon will be releasing the Z7iii with -60MP as confirmed through a conversation I had with one of their top top executives just yesterday, but keep that on the down low.
I was making a general comment, not having very good experiences with camera, adapter, and lens from three different suppliers. I have no idea about a Z7 III. Is it just the same old (2010s) Sony sensor or does Nikon have a supplier of more advanced sensors?

EBH
I have no knowledge of the Z7 III specs, but if they're going 60MP, My guess is it'll be essentially the same Sony based sensor used in the A7R IV and V, but with Nikon processing. There's not a lot of sensor development with regards to pure image quality as of late...sort of reaching a point of diminishing returns there. Honestly, if they re-used the Z7 II sensor I'd be just fine, because while that camera had some deficiencies compared to more modern bodies in terms of autofocus, screen and EVF, the sensor was absolutely phenomenal as long as you didn't need high-speed readout. Absolutely ZERO complaints on that front. I would honestly swap my Z8 for a Z7III if they just put the Z7 II sensor in a Z6 III body (except with the Z8's multi-axis tilt screen) with the new EVF, new AF algorithms and so on.
Considering the legacy and ambition of Nikon it seems very likely that the Z7III will come with a 80+ mp sensor with a deepened focus on color quality and Expeed 8.

Odds are it’s going to be manufactured by Sony.

As far as the a9III goes anybody stressing low ISO DR as a critical issue of that camera is completely missing the point of that camera. This coming from a former owner who has promoted DR as absolutely essential for 20 years. But… I am still disappointed Sony decided to apply NR to their raw files. I would have preferred worse
...Show more →
Jan 15, 2025 at 10:06 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote:
AmbientMike wroteSony is selling $6k cameras that took NR to get to 5DSR DR levels

It's just so absolutely ridiculous what has happened.

We were told, ad nauseum, dump your DSLR'S, a major reason being, they don't have the DR. Little or no discussion on the merits of the DSLR'S, or if you even use low iso's. Now it's 100 excuses telling us, basically, to go buy poor DR camera, not a problem, even though it has far less DR than R5, R3, etc supposedly having a problem since NR applied
Mike you seem to be a master of these straw man arguments. No one said dump DSLRs due to dynamic range. In the Canon world, there may have been some discussion because Canon sensors had historically low dynamic range until the 5D IV, which Canon also re-used in the original R...and so they have essentially identical image quality. And then they made another jump with the R6 and R5...so many people jumped to mirrorless due to the newer sensors. The R6 II and R5 II (and R8) also all have these high DR sensors. But no one believes the presence
...Show more →

The A9III took the NR that people complain about on Canon cameras like the R5II to get to 5DsR-level DR.

You can accuse me of this, that, and the other and blather endlessly on a tangent trying to make Sony cameras look good all day long. But that is still the case

If you never saw people saying to dump your canon DSLR'S over DR , I don't know what rock you were hiding under
Jan 15, 2025 at 10:29 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.12 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Again, you take bits and pieces of what’s said, and construct an argument completely of your own making without putting together the whole.

I even address your point about Canon DSLRs, but that was never about DSLRs vs mirrorless. It was about a sensor at the time that was underperforming compared to its peers, and comparing it to those that were more advanced. It just so happened in Canon’s case that coincided with the move to mirrorless.

And you can pretend that every piece of equipment has the same usage needs but that doesn’t make it true. I am not a Sony shooter any more, but it doesn’t take a person with self interest to see the A9 III is a different beast, and pretending that ANYONE buys that camera to shoot primarily landscapes is simply folly. If one doesn’t have a need for what a global shutter can do, they have no business buying an A9 III. It is specialist equipment and literally the only camera of its type on the market.

You have single handedly derailed this thread with ridiculous jumps in logic and making stands on arguments that are just so obtuse it’s almost comical if it weren’t so frustrating.
Jan 15, 2025 at 11:22 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The objective reality is:
- the 5DR was a landscape camera and it’s DR was it’s most important characteristic but it was 2+ stops behind the leading Nikons,
- the a9III is a sports camera and base ISo DR is completely irrelevant. What matters is speed and it totally obliterates the R1 in that sector.

The common aspect in these 2 stories being that Canon remains unable to compete on what matters and the gap is quite frankly astonishing.

Cheers,
Bernard
Jan 16, 2025 at 08:49 AM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
bernardl wrote:
The common aspect in these 2 stories being that Canon remains unable to compete on what matters and the gap is quite frankly astonishing.

Cheers,
Bernard


Canon competes and even wins on what matters to Canon. Market share, sales, and profits. That gap does in fact remain astonishing.
Jan 16, 2025 at 10:08 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.12 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
I may just be unfamiliar with Nikon's lineup but is the Z7 line their high MP competitor to the Sony A7R line?



When the OG Z7 was introduced it certainly was, clearly targeting the A7RII (the A7RIII was introduced shortly before the Z7). Likewise the Z6 targeted the A7II (and to this day plays in the same core space the A7 and R6 series bodies do)

Nikon didn't MP-bump the Z7II while the A7R got that with the A7RIV, but a lot of folks expect the Z7III to get a major MP bump since Nikon is now over-supplied with 45MP options (Z7II, Z8 & Z9 in the current line) and doesn't bring much to the 45MP lineup aside from small size (relative the Z8 & Z9).

How it plays out this year will really show whether or not the Z7 is the high-MP body, or something else now that Nikon has a set of higher-end Z bodies which they lacked when both Z7 bodies were introduced.
Jan 16, 2025 at 11:01 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister