fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Canon r1 official announcement.

  
 
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.13 #1Canon r1 official announcement.
It occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
May 27, 2024 at 11:12 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #2Canon r1 official announcement.
alundeb wrote:
It occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.


One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.
May 27, 2024 at 11:19 AM
Uarctos
Offline
Details
p.13 #3Canon r1 official announcement.
R3 could be a one off camera and the R1 will probably take its place and then some.
I would love to see the new R5II becoming bigger, I find the 5D4's size to be perfect.
May 27, 2024 at 11:22 AM
robert_in_ca
Offline
Details
p.13 #4Canon r1 official announcement.
molson wrote:
alundeb wroteIt occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.


That is true and it's certainly a big step in the right direction. However QPAF isn't exclusive to Canon and it will only be a matter of time before others do it.
May 27, 2024 at 11:32 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #5Canon r1 official announcement.
robert_in_ca wrote:
molson wrote
alundeb wroteIt occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.
That is true and it's certainly a big step in the right direction. However QPAF isn't exclusive to Canon and it will only be a matter of time before others do it.



Yes - Olympus /OM Systems has had it for a few years now.

May 27, 2024 at 12:03 PM
JaimitoFrog
Offline
Details
p.13 #6Canon r1 official announcement.
Who uses Olympus these days? Surprised it is still in business.

molson wrote:
robert_in_ca wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteIt occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.
That is true and it's certainly a big step in the right direction. However QPAF isn't exclusive to Canon and it will only be a matter of time before others do it.
Yes - Olympus /OM Systems has had it for a few years now.


May 27, 2024 at 12:08 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.13 #7Canon r1 official announcement.
molson wrote:
alundeb wroteIt occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.


Which means the R1 is really a 96MP camera so that should quiet the critics....or not...
May 27, 2024 at 12:18 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.13 #8Canon r1 official announcement.
robert_in_ca wrote:
arbitrage wrote
EvilZardoz wroteI'm curious as to what the future looks like for the R3; will we see this swallowed up by the R1 and R5? The R3 looks like a good place to put a global shutter.
Probably would never happen but I'd love to see R5II internals in an R3 sized body...call it R3S or R3II. I still find the R3 to be the perfect size for an integrated grip camera. 1DX and R1 are bigger than they need to be for me. Z9 is overly heavy.

Global shutter could be something for the R3II. Otherwise I don't see what an R3II would be? Just doesn't seem necessary if the R1 is 24-30MP.
Having owned the R3 for a good period of time before moving over to the Z9 - I still find the R3 to have better ergonomics and feel better in hand (lower weight) than the Z9. I wonder if the R3 was more of a gap stop until the R1 could be further developed. I am not sure why Canon has been taken so long to release their flagship camera, especially when you consider the RF mount was launched at the end of 2018.


They probably didn't want to piss off all the sports/agencies that spent $6500 on the 1DXIII in 2020 so they put out the R3 saying it wasn't the flagship and now they are on the regular 4 year cycle for the R1 to replace the 1DXIII.
May 27, 2024 at 12:21 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #9Canon r1 official announcement.
JaimitoFrog wrote:
Who uses Olympus these days? Surprised it is still in business.



If they weren't still around, who could Sony, Nikon, et al copy ideas from?
May 27, 2024 at 12:56 PM
randomguy
Offline
Details
p.13 #10Canon r1 official announcement.
molson wrote:
alundeb wroteIt occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.


Yep it will be an absolutely huge advantage to the horizontal bar code shooters out there who can't figure out that they can rotate the camera.
May 27, 2024 at 02:18 PM
Imagemaster
Online
Details
p.13 #11Canon r1 official announcement.
JaimitoFrog wrote:
Who uses Olympus these days? Surprised it is still in business.


How about because some photographers find the gear to be better quality and they get as good or better results than many than shoot FF with the big three.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1858825/
May 27, 2024 at 02:23 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #12Canon r1 official announcement.
randomguy wrote:
molson wrote
alundeb wroteIt occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.
Yep it will be an absolutely huge advantage to the horizontal bar code shooters out there who can't figure out that they can rotate the camera.


The problem with Nikon cameras becomes apparent when you do rotate the camera, and suddenly it can't focus... but I'm curious - why do you photograph bar codes?
May 27, 2024 at 02:51 PM
armd
Offline
Details
p.13 #13Canon r1 official announcement.
middlerockies wrote:
When was the last time the Canon rumor mill was so confident about a spec like MP count, this close to launch, on such an important camera, and it coming out wrong? Genuinely curious as I don't usually follow the rumor sites. Seems like everyone is more than certain it's 24MP from what I've been reading, and you have to believe people who have the camera or know someone who has the camera--they're all talking with each other but under NDA/embargo. Doesn't seem likely that it would be wrong with so much confidence this close to launch.


It's very difficult to say but if the latest spec rumors hold true, it's impossible to see this as anything more than a rebadged R3mkII. Likewise, it is too soon to speculate whether Canon's release with be the goat or a dead goat.
May 27, 2024 at 04:30 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.13 #14Canon r1 official announcement.


RoamingScott wrote:
Tony5787 wroteGood to see that they’re keeping pace with a 3yr old camera, making me really happy to have invested so much money into this system that just keeps offering me what I don’t want.

snapsy wrote
arbitrage wroteCR confirmed on their own forums that the 30% increase in read speed is a VIDEO spec. He hasn't seen a trustworthy source of what the stills read speed is. Maybe it is 30% also but for now the 30% faster than the R3 is only for VIDEO
FYI, the current rumor of 24MP @ 14-bit with a 2ms (1/500) readout speed comes to 19.55 GB/s of sensor data, which is nearly identical to the data rate of the Z8/Z9 of 19.6 GB/s`of 45MP @ 1/268. That makes it more believable IMO.
This is an honest question. At what point did you look at the RF system as a whole and decide that it was the best system on the market to invest in?

The whole thing has been a headscratcher from the beginning for me. Everything about RF has been a non-starter.

And now we can ask...how many more times must an RF shooter be punched in the gut before they bail to greener pastures, and boy, are the other pastures greener!


How's the Z9 working out For you? You realize it's roughly 2x the weight of the R5?

Those pastures don't seem so green g8ven you are concurrently figuring out how to deal with the weight. News flash: medium format has mostly been heavy, nothing absurd about GFX system being heavy. Unbelievable you'd post anti Canon crap like this in the middle of the other thread, maybe pick up an R5 + 24-105 to solve your issues

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1859593/
May 27, 2024 at 10:27 PM
randomguy
Offline
Details
p.13 #15Canon r1 official announcement.
molson wrote:
randomguy wrote
molson wrote
alundeb wroteIt occurs to me that QPAF must be really important for Canon to make work with the R1. If the real world benefits are as high as Canon ambitions, it will be a faboluously accurate focusing camera.
One big advantage is that the quad pixel AF is sensitive to both horizontal and vertical lines.

The system Nikon uses is only sensitive to vertical lines, so having QPAF would be a huge advantage to Canon.
Yep it will be an absolutely huge advantage to the horizontal bar code shooters out there who can't figure out that they can rotate the camera.
The problem with Nikon cameras becomes apparent when you do rotate the camera, and suddenly it can't focus... but I'm curious - why do you photograph bar codes?


I don't, that was kind of the point...
May 27, 2024 at 11:21 PM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.13 #16Canon r1 official announcement.
middlerockies wrote:
When was the last time the Canon rumor mill was so confident about a spec like MP count, this close to launch, on such an important camera, and it coming out wrong? Genuinely curious as I don't usually follow the rumor sites. Seems like everyone is more than certain it's 24MP from what I've been reading, and you have to believe people who have the camera or know someone who has the camera--they're all talking with each other but under NDA/embargo. Doesn't seem likely that it would be wrong with so much confidence this close to launch.


Not from what I've been reading. (24mp).
But who cares?
Speculating on the likely hood of a bunch of guessing being accurate, why?

There was a massive amount of speculating on the Canon 1DS4.
As it turns out, 1DS, 1DS2, 1DS3 was as far as the 'S' line went.
Canon changed the pattern and the 1D4 was a single model for the 1 Series and this continued for 1DX, 1DXII and 1DXIII.
1DXIII 20mp was a surprise. The favoured guess was significantly more.

Sony A1 was also a surprise. Nobody predicted 50mp at 30 fps.

It did make the Nikon Z9/Z8 predictable though.

So to answer "When was the last time the Canon rumor mill was so confident about a spec like MP count, this close to launch, on such an important camera, and it coming out wrong?" : 1DXIII.
May 28, 2024 at 03:30 AM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.13 #17Canon r1 official announcement.
JaimitoFrog wrote:
Who uses Olympus these days? Surprised it is still in business.


Well, we could go to the Olympus forum section and provide an incomplete answer to your question, but I think most understand it was a figure of speech, not a literal question.
However, once you started typing the second sentence, didn't you see the flaw in your logic?

They are still in business! Who uses Olympus these days? A lot more than you think.

So to re word your post with an injection of logic:
I'm surprised they are still in business as I didn't think there are enough users to keep them in business. Obviously, I was wrong.

May 28, 2024 at 03:42 AM
gkinard1952
Offline
Details
p.13 #18Canon r1 official announcement.
middlerockies wrote:
Tony5787 wroteI mean I shot EF for a good 7-8 years before the RF system became a reality, I was already heavily invested before I bought an R5. I’ve owned an a9 and an a9 II and almost jumped ship to Sony both times but couldn’t justify selling everything off for minimal gains. I still don’t consider the a1 to be that much of an upgrade over what I have now with the R3 and R5 and I vastly prefer the R3 over any other body I’ve shot with outside of the resolution.

If the R1 were like 30-36MP and shot 60-120fps that would be the camera I’m looking for. It’s rare that I need that kind of speed but there are a few things like swallows in flight where it would be super useful to have. There’s a particular shot that I’ve been trying to get now for like three years with the R3 and I’ve gotten really close but even at 30fps the position the bird is in between frames is substantially different.

So basically what I’m trying to say is that no manufacturer offers the camera I want but it seemed like Canon might be the first to do it, now it’s hard to say (and if I had to guess the a1 II and the Z9 II will probably be it).

RoamingScott wrote
Tony5787 wroteGood to see that they’re keeping pace with a 3yr old camera, making me really happy to have invested so much money into this system that just keeps offering me what I don’t want.

snapsy wrote
arbitrage wroteCR confirmed on their own forums that the 30% increase in read speed is a VIDEO spec. He hasn't seen a trustworthy source of what the stills read speed is. Maybe it is 30% also but for now the 30% faster than the R3 is only for VIDEO
FYI, the current rumor of 24MP @ 14-bit with a 2ms (1/500) readout speed comes to 19.55 GB/s of sensor data, which is nearly identical to the data rate of the Z8/Z9 of 19.6 GB/s`of 45MP @ 1/268. That makes it more believable IMO.
This is an honest question. At what point did you look at the RF system as a whole and decide that it was the best system on the market to invest in?

The whole thing has been a headscratcher from the beginning for me. Everything about RF has been a non-starter.

And now we can ask...how many more times must an RF shooter be punched in the gut before they bail to greener pastures, and boy, are the other pastures greener!
I’m in a similar position. Invested earlier on with the R5 and some glass. Dabbled with Sony off and on but was really just waiting for both of them—either of them?—to compete with Nikon on the wildlife lens selection. Then the longer I waited the closer we got to this mythical R1 so I’ve been holding out to see what Canon has been working on for eons, delay after delay after delay. Sony and Nikon are both doing jack-of-all-trades with speed and higher MPs, and Canon released the R3, their new sports camera, so the R1 has *got* to be
...Show more →

Problem is people get caught up in the click bait channels like Canon Rumors and all the YouTube channels. They hype up the early spec's for clicks. That holds interest.

You need to look at past trends and the leadership of the company. Nothing is going to change with Canon as long as the current leader is in place. It's been proven time and time again.

I stopped buying anything new from Canon years ago. Only reason I haven't switched is I don't want to spend the money! My last and current hop with the 500/4II, and my age is telling me it is time... Going to have to dust off the cobwebs and open my wallet.. haha. But, I feel very lucky Sony, Nikon and Sigma have the right gear for my needs. uggggg

Then again I am talking as a die hard birder. So, I know nothing of the other types of photography.


Edited on May 28, 2024 at 04:52 AM · View previous versions
May 28, 2024 at 04:14 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.13 #19Canon r1 official announcement.
I don't know what is worst, people complaining about being stuck with a brand that does not do what they want, or people making fun about that.
Hope it works out for everybody, one way or the other.
May 28, 2024 at 04:42 AM
Rudy Pohl
Offline
Details
p.13 #20Canon r1 official announcement.
Would love to have a Nikon or a Sony, but stuck with a Canon?

Cheer up - Listen to "Love the One You're With" by Stephen Stills (Crosby Stills and Nash 1970)

If you're down and confused
And you don't remember who you're talkin' to
Concentration slip away
Because your baby is so far away
Well, there's a rose in a fisted glove
And the eagle flies with the dove
And if you can't be with the one you love, honey
Love the one you're with
Love the one you're with
Love the one you're with
Love the one you're with


Great song by the way, I remember it well. It's lyrics have come to mind and been helpful several times as I've been dealing with having switched to Canon from Nikon only 6 months before the Z8 was announced, after having been a Nikon user since 1978. Bottom line for me is that there is nothing that I want to do with my photography and videography that my R5 can't do and do well. There is no doubt that had I not switched when I did I would be a happy user of the Z8 and the Z 180-600 lens today. But that's not reality for me right now so I'm determined to get the best out of my Canon gear and above all enjoy my hobby. Anyway, works for me... :
May 28, 2024 at 05:09 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister