I'm curious to hear from people that have specifically shot both the A7RV and any of the 100mp GFX bodies for the purpose of landscape photography.
I'm looking to add a single body to my cabinet for the primary if not sole purpose of landscapes, with the caveat that I hike and shoot, wear the camera on my chest with a Peak Capture Clip, and that weight is a consideration but not the end all be all. I rarely have a tripod on me.
Nikon is simply taking too long to release a small, high resolution body...I have a 100S II preordered, but upon taking delivery of a GF 32-64, immediately second guessed this decision as the weight is just nuts for such a small focal range.
I bought a Sony 20-70/4 and A7R5 and will put them against my Z kit until the release of the GFX to see if the gains are substantial enough for this use case.
Again, only looking for input from folks that have tried these 2 specific kits. Appreciate your thoughts.
Nice to see you embracing more landscape stuff so seriously. I had a A7RV for a while prior to my Z9 and I have to admit, sometimes I wish I'd stayed put. The resolving of that A7RV and it's amazing focus system sure did impress. So what is your motivation to get even higher mp's. Are your prints not large enough or are you cropping big time? The landscapes I took with that A7RV were already so huge to begin with and certainly didn't lack detail.
I had both for 1 year, ended up selling the Fuji and the GFX lenses. The weight, size, non user friendly body (the AF button was so small and weird) and cost of the GFX system did not compensate at all compared to the A7RV with GMs.
In addition, the current offer of Software to edit the pics can fill the minimum gap in the files delivered by both cameras.
The 100S is really “sloppy - slow” on every aspect you compared it with to the 7R5.
dcisive wrote:
Nice to see you embracing more landscape stuff so seriously. I had a A7RV for a while prior to my Z9 and I have to admit, sometimes I wish I'd stayed put. The resolving of that A7RV and it's amazing focus system sure did impress. So what is your motivation to get even higher mp's. Are your prints not large enough or are you cropping big time? The landscapes I took with that A7RV were already so huge to begin with and certainly didn't lack detail.
I doubt I will see a huge difference in autofocus performance between the RV and my Z9. Where I see the biggest difference between Z9 files and my backlog of R4 files is sheer detail...the Sony has it where the Nikon just doesn't.
The R4 has what I always considered a nasty grain pattern even at low ISO, especially compared to the Z9. In testing GFX files, I don't see this noise. The best way I can describe Sony RAW file grain is "gritty".
I do print large. I've made some 60" wide prints off the Z9.
liggy wrote:
I am the world’s lamest landscape photog so please take this with a grain of salt.
Having the 100S, A7RV , 20-70, 32-64 and 35-70 my choice for a hike of any distance would either be the 100S+35-70 or most likely RV+20-70.
I love the 32-64 but it is a chonk. . The 35-70 is much lighter and smaller than the 32-64 and still sharp. Really miss the aperture ring though.
Honestly haven’t used the GFX much since going pretty deep down the Sony rabbit hole.
I typically stop down a bit from wide open and have found that the ibis of the RV is pretty effective and that obviates the need for a tripod.
If it was a once in a lifetime landscape opportunity I’m pretty sure I’d bring the 100S, 23 prime, 32-64 and 100-200 and tripod though. ...Show more →
So here's my dilemma (you've seen me around enough to probably know it already )
I like to travel "light"...the Z9 is cramping that. I like to have a single primary landscape lens. The Z 24-120 is better than anything else on the market for this job.
The Sony 24-105G is an aging optic that I'm unwilling to go back to. I did my time with it for many years, but it's simply not a good enough performer anymore. The 20-70 solves two problems that the 24-105 has: 1) sometimes just not wide enough and 2) pure resolving power.
So...the Sony sensor retains details better than the Z9, and has a great lens likely on par with the 24-120 in terms of resolving. Oops, now I'm losing 50mm of usefulness in the field. Once I start cropping, I'm back at my 45mp file that the Z would have given me.
Enter the 70-200/4 Macro. Much easier to pack than my Z 100-400, though STILL less useful to some degree. A 1.4x helps, but one more thing to pack and carry.
Looking at GFX, 32-64 is almost not wide enough for me. The much more appealing 35-70 is simply NOT wide enough, a total non-starter. By time I try to replicate what the single Z 24-120 gives me, I'm at 3 lenses. Absurd.
Pound for pound, I don't think you can build a more useful kit than an A7R5, 20-70/4, and 70-200/4 Macro + 1.4x.
Mucho Betis wrote:
I had both for 1 year, ended up selling the Fuji and the GFX lenses. The weight, size, non user friendly body (the AF button was so small and weird) and cost of the GFX system did not compensate at all compared to the A7RV with GMs.
In addition, the current offer of Software to edit the pics can fill the minimum gap in the files delivered by both cameras.
The 100S is really “sloppy - slow” on every aspect you compared it with to the 7R5.
Good luck with whatever you choose!
Cheers!
To be fair, I'd be getting the 100S II which is admittedly much faster in operation while having identical IQ. I'm sure the GFX would still lag behind the RV in operational speed, though they have similar burst rates and mechanical shutter abilities.
I agree on modern software doing some heavy lifting...it's what is getting my Z files close to where my Sony files were out of the box.
Accepting that short of carrying *everything* the compromise that suits me personally is the 20-70 as a one lens solution.
For dedicated outings I’d typically tailor the kit to the job at hand. Yep - cropping at 70mm isn’t ideal but if tele is critical I’ll just tote a longer lens in addition to the 20-70.
This is part of the fun though tbh. If you were local you’d be welcome to try my 35-70 but I’d feel the need for the 20-35 or 23 on a landscape oriented outing as you mentioned.
Accepting that short of carrying *everything* the compromise that suits me personally is the 20-70 as a one lens solution.
For dedicated outings I’d typically tailor the kit to the job at hand. Yep - cropping at 70mm isn’t ideal but if tele is critical I’ll just tote a longer lens in addition to the 20-70.
This is part of the fun though tbh. If you were local you’d be welcome to try my 35-70 but I’d feel the need for the 20-35 or 23 on a landscape oriented outing as you mentioned.
As a fun morning activity, I dug through EXIF of my favorite landscape images. Many at 24...28...sooo many at 43 (what?!)...and then it jumped to either 105 if on Sony and 120 if on Z.
That tells me that the 20-70 is the one lens solution for me too...and if I think the vistas will be wide and deep, the tele comes with too. Nice that both share a 72mm size. Appreciate your thoughts.
p.1 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I am small handicapped person, so can't hike too far from my car. I haven't tried A4rV but I had A7rIV and GFX50s for almost 2 yrs. And I picked GFX50s every time except when I needed faster eye AF. Why? first 4:3. I know I can do the same on the Sony which I did, but C1 still doesn't respect in camera crop. Second for me was tilt adapter on EVF. Once you get used to it, hard to go back. Now my GFX100s doesn't take it and I get by. So maybe not that big of a deal. 3rd using GFX for some reason I feel better inside. I don't know why. I used to carry both setups in my car and in the end I will pick GFX and use it a lot more even though GF lenses limited in focal lengths and what not. I had 32-64mm, excellent lens but I did sell it for cheaper 35-70mm which is also excellent. Since I am not a wide angle person I didn't buy 20-35mm. I do have 23mm f4 but rarely use it. And now prices on that are ridiculously low. If you don't need a zoom, then look at that 23mm f4 prime. You can get one for $800-$900. I haven't bought 30mm TSE yet, maybe do some day. I know more weight but I like to do things differently from most folks. I have Canon 24mm, 50mm and 90mm TSE lenses. 3 image stitch with 50mm or the 90mm TSE gives super detailed shots. The new 500mm f5.6 GF is also looking interesting.
p.1 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
bobby350z wrote:
Bigger sensor, bigger lenses.
No kidding, thank you for the insight
This thread is about asking if the juice is worth the squeeze for folks that have squeezed both. You are noted for having squeezed 1.5 since the A7R4 does not count I could not care less about the 50mp GFX, they are nothing special compared to the 61mp sensor to my eye and tests.
p.1 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
I'm curious to hear from people that have specifically shot both the A7RV and any of the 100mp GFX bodies for the purpose of landscape photography.
I'm looking to add a single body to my cabinet for the primary if not sole purpose of landscapes, with the caveat that I hike and shoot, wear the camera on my chest with a Peak Capture Clip, and that weight is a consideration but not the end all be all. I rarely have a tripod on me.
Nikon is simply taking too long to release a small, high resolution body...I have a 100S II preordered, but upon taking delivery of a GF 32-64, immediately second guessed this decision as the weight is just nuts for such a small focal range.
I bought a Sony 20-70/4 and A7R5 and will put them against my Z kit until the release of the GFX to see if the gains are substantial enough for this use case.
Again, only looking for input from folks that have tried these 2 specific kits. Appreciate your thoughts....Show more →
Have you considered just buying a used Nikon z7 ii to complement your z9? From my experience with the Sony a1, there’s some detail loss with stacked sensors if you pixel peep. The 45mp sensor in the z7 ii shouldn’t have those issues and has a proper mechanical shutter.
I haven’t tried the gfx100s but the last Sony body I had has the a7r v and there is nothing bad I can say about the image quality. That with the 12-24/16-35, 24-70, 70-200 version iis should give you all the sharpness you can possibly want.
If you want to enter another rabbit hole, there’s always the Leica m11 as a truly compact landscape kit.
p.1 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
tzhang4284 wrote: RoamingScott wroteI'm curious to hear from people that have specifically shot both the A7RV and any of the 100mp GFX bodies for the purpose of landscape photography.
I'm looking to add a single body to my cabinet for the primary if not sole purpose of landscapes, with the caveat that I hike and shoot, wear the camera on my chest with a Peak Capture Clip, and that weight is a consideration but not the end all be all. I rarely have a tripod on me.
Nikon is simply taking too long to release a small, high resolution body...I have a 100S II preordered, but upon taking delivery of a GF 32-64, immediately second guessed this decision as the weight is just nuts for such a small focal range.
I bought a Sony 20-70/4 and A7R5 and will put them against my Z kit until the release of the GFX to see if the gains are substantial enough for this use case.
Again, only looking for input from folks that have tried these 2 specific kits. Appreciate your thoughts.Have you considered just buying a used Nikon z7 ii to complement your z9? From my experience with the Sony a1, there’s some detail loss with stacked sensors if you pixel peep. The 45mp sensor in the z7 ii shouldn’t have those issues and has a proper mechanical shutter.
I haven’t tried the gfx100s but the last Sony body I had has the a7r v and there is nothing bad I can say about the image quality. That with the 12-24/16-35, 24-70, 70-200 version iis should give you all the sharpness you can possibly want.
If you want to enter another rabbit hole, there’s always the Leica m11! ...Show more →
I started Z with the Z7ii. It's...fine. The EVF kind of stinks, the back screen doesn't tilt vertically, the battery life sucks, it's missing a lot of features from the newer Z models. It's got marginally better IQ and DR than the Z9, but nowhere near the detail of the 61mp sensor.
I tried to enter the M11 hole, but it froze on me.
p.1 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Some 60 inch prints…
The question I’d ask is how many and how many will you seriously be producing going forward? Not everything is better bigger. Not all famous paintings are huge. There are people who make their living selling the usual and often highly impressive, but also perhaps somewhat cliched shots of Grand Canyon, Tetons, Yosemite etc etc. Are you one of those people? If you are then perhaps the extra resolution is a positive factor, if not then I think you have answered your own question with the A7r5 and 20-70mm/70-200.
p.1 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I don’t have the Sony. But cropping the GFX to Fx gets you the 60mp Sony sensor.
How much detail loss did you notice when you cropped your Z7/Z9 to Dx? I can simply say that’s about the same difference I see when I crop my GFX to Fx to give some frame of reference.
Now could I live with 60 going forward? Probably, at least assuming the glass really does keep up with the sensor; my GFX glass does (which actually surprised me). So if the weight was important to me (which it’s not so much in my case), AND there was the range of workable glass available, then the Sony 60 is where I’d probably go. Given what you’ve stated above, it sounds like the correct decision for you 👍🏻
p.1 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Robin Smith wrote:
Some 60 inch prints…
The question I’d ask is how many and how many will you seriously be producing going forward? Not everything is better bigger. Not all famous paintings are huge. There are people who make their living selling the usual and often highly impressive, but also perhaps somewhat cliched shots of Grand Canyon, Tetons, Yosemite etc etc. Are you one of those people? If you are then perhaps the extra resolution is a positive factor, if not then I think you have answered your own question with the A7r5 and 20-70mm/70-200.
I sell my art to well-to-do weekender city folk that are looking to liven up their ridiculously oversized and overpriced lake homes. Erring on the side of quality is always nice, but I've always been happy up to 60" with the 61mp sensor. It's highly unlikely I'd ever go wider than this, nor am I sure where the line of demarcation is for the long side where the GFX 100 is suddenly obviously better in print form. I can cheat with the Nikon files and print on canvas if I need to go big...people like that and suddenly resolution isn't a huge concern any longer.
I at least pride myself on not selling comp stomps...my stuff is pretty unique even if the place isn't.
p.1 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
It probably varies with the hiking you do and your style of shooting but I would find 20mm not wide enough. When I'm above tree line and know there will be huge vistas, I have skipped the middle of the range and just taken a wide and a telephoto to save taking 3 lenses. On my last major trip, I was missing 36-105 in FF eq. and didn't miss it that much.
p.1 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote: bobby350z wroteBigger sensor, bigger lenses.No kidding, thank you for the insight
This thread is about asking if the juice is worth the squeeze for folks that have squeezed both. You are noted for having squeezed 1.5 since the A7R4 does not count I could not care less about the 50mp GFX, they are nothing special compared to the 61mp sensor to my eye and tests.
Hey man 400g diff is not even a beer bottle. Why people complain so much about weight, I never understood. 1 mile is like 20 miles for normal people. I just sucxx it up and carried 1dmk2/500mm f4 along the football field when I used to shoot high school football. Just go pee before the hike, you saved more than the diff in weight of the two lenses. Sorry to be rude.