RoamingScott wrote:
Certain posters have a tendency to post irrelevant detritus based on a small, unrelated sliver of personal experience and can't understand why, year after year, they aren't taken seriously in threads.
middlerockies wrote:
I guess I'm relatively new to the site compared to some of you so I lack the history. But it would be very helpful to have a list of these "contributors" to avoid the sales pitches! I suppose it's like the rest of the internet—you've got to wade through a lot of 💩 to get to the good stuff.
Use the 'Hide Me' button, it works great! I can't even see the posts you guys are referring to (nor is anyone throwing quotes that I can see), but I know who you are talking about. Try it.
Birders want more MP for cropping, and landscapers want more MP for printing. If you talk to photojournalists and sports photographers, they don't want more MP - they want speed and pre-capture to capture decisive moments, and smaller files to avoid filling the buffer and for easier transmitting. Clearly, cameras like the R3 and R1 (and the Sony A9 line) are aimed at the latter group, and no amount of wealthy hobbyist or YouTube wannabe handwringing is going to change that.
middlerockies wrote:
For years you said wait until the R1 comes out; that the R3 was not the flagship. So what does Canon make that's going to compete with the A1 and Z9? Because the R5 ain't it for professionals who are looking for a flagship body.
I never said any such thing. In fact, during those years, I was using an A1, and then a Z9. Now I'm using an R5, because it's actually better than either of those cameras for a lot of the things I use a camera for; the only place where it comes up short is in the social media hype department.
I don't really care if the R1 specs "compete" with the A1 or Z9 - I want Canon to pay more attention to filling out the RF lens line.
What are pros looking for in a flagship body? All-in-one ruggedized body? Can the a1 actually be included because it uses a separate add-on vertical grip? Is the Z9 the only true option if you need/want a high MP 'pro' body? Perhaps this is an indicator of how truly niche the top-end pro market has become. (How many of the Z9 users could not instead use a Z8?)
Some of the R5's shortcomings - heat and battery life - are the reality of it being 4 years old; some of its components are likely even older. Those deficits will be addressed in the Mark II version and it will also be a lot faster. Just the two year gap between the R6 and R6II resulted in significant improvements in these metrics.
As a former life-long 1-series user (since the original EOS-1), at least as far as I'm concerned, I'm happy to have a 'pro' camera with an optional vertical grip. It gives me the choice of a smaller configuration when it's a priority, or add the grip when I need that convenience. I won't complain if Canon improves 5 series durability, weather sealing and improves the add-on grip's ergonomics.
rscheffler wrote:
What are pros looking for in a flagship body? All-in-one ruggedized body? Can the a1 actually be included because it uses a separate add-on vertical grip? Is the Z9 the only true option if you need/want a high MP 'pro' body?
Nikon's generally poor quality control and slow pro service ought to disqualify them, too. The first things I noticed when I picked up an R5 after using the Z8 was how great the ergonomics were, how solid the body felt, and how there was no slop in the RF lens mounts like there was with the Z lenses.
middlerockies wrote:
So now we have this R1 camera that we've all been waiting years for, and it's a disappointing 24MP, after everyone was speculating and discussing earnestly how it's going to be this beast of a camera, perhaps 60-80MP many articles even discussed early on, and since that didn't come to fruition, we now have actual discussions in the R1 threads about them wanting an "R3s" which will be a high-MP version of the R3, in some distant realm many years away. Rinse repeat.
What those people missed, or conveniently ignored, was that the 1 series has always focused more on speed than MP (ignoring the slower 's' variants that were eventually transitioned to the 5D/5Ds line). R1, for better or worse, apparently continues where the 1DX series left off 4 years ago... It seems Canon is being perfectly consistent, if frustratingly so.
As a sometimes sports shooter, yes, I'd like a high performance camera with more than 24MP for additional cropping flexibility. But so far 24MP has not been a deal breaker for my clients (and that with a fourth-tier 'significantly inferior' R6II replacement for the 1DXII). Realistically, R5II, especially if stacked, will be the more logical direction for the majority of Canon users requiring high MP as a 'multi-purpose' camera. Me included. Unfortunately those who truly need flagship build and 50+MP, will likely move to another system, if they haven't already done so.
For me at least, there is more to it than just MP, or dynamic range, weather resistance, etc., etc. CPS, as alluded to by molson above, is one of the intangibles that keeps me in the Canon camp. Sure, grass is greener in some respects in other pastures, but those also have burned out dead areas compared to Canon. There isn't one perfect system for everyone like there isn't one perfect camera bag.
middlerockies wrote:
[They're the only brand who still thinks this way, and every other genre that shoots Canon just has to settle for less.
I personally am not in the market for either 120fps or 50Mpx, but if I was, I would not expect them to coexist in the same camera body.
To me, it just seems that Canon choose to keep its "flagship" camera focused on highest shooting performance, and its more "mainstream" model targeting "do-it-all" territory. I don't think that means settling for less, but maybe you do? In that case, you always have choices.
I personally am with Ron on this one. Having migrated from 1-series DSLRs previously, I rather like now having a "pro enough" grade camera with an optional battery grip, where I have the flexibility to go light when I want to.
Certainly the lack of an integrated grip won't make the R5 II any less professional than various Sony models.
As to the so called, Flagship mentality, if it's so egotistically important to own the "Flagship" model, there's no reason why there can't be "flagships" by category, such as a Sports/action flagship, a Landscape Scenic flagship or even an APS-C flagship, rather than a single crown of the entire lineup.
It seems hard for some to conceive that others could have legitimate priorities other than theirs's.
It would be cute if after all this sturm und drang, Canon announced a surprise "R1s" with an 80 megapixel sensor (and more earthly shooting speed), haha.
This will never happen... but Canon has had 's' models in both the 1 and 5 series in the past.
Or maybe that's what the next R3 will be, since it now feels like it needs a new mission. :-O
Manufactures like to keep their branding simple to understand. Canon has stated time and time again the 1 series bodies are their flagship line that are built to their highest standards—so it’s safe to assume when the R1 launches it will be built like a tank (hopefully without the weight). Same goes for Nikon with the Z9 and Sony with the A1. So if someone wants to own a top of the line flagship camera, it’s not necessarily an ego thing per se, but it just might not really make sense to do so.
Sy Sez wrote:
As to the so called, Flagship mentality, if it's so egotistically important to own the "Flagship" model, there's no reason why there can't be "flagships" by category, such as a Sports/action flagship, a Landscape Scenic flagship or even an APS-C flagship, rather than a single crown of the entire lineup.
It seems hard for some to conceive that others could have legitimate priorities other than theirs's.
There are those that would like to have both a sleek high-performance sports car, and a super heavy duty, 10-ton capacity pickup truck, and they just can't figure out why those ignorant automotive manufactures can't combine them into a single "flagship vehicle.
There is no need to get all upset over how any camera manufacture titles their top of the line camera.
In Canon's case they produce their top of the line bodies targeted toward the sports crowd. So what?
Anyone can purchase it so long as you have deep enough pockets.
As for competing against the other guys "flagships". Well, that's what Canon's second tier bodies (R5 line) are for.
And yep, anyone can purchase those as well.
Simply put. Nothing will be able to touch the level of the R1 for a very long time. Which is why Canon has kept the final specs under very tight wraps.
It all boils down to the AF system a camera brings to market.
What good is the best DR if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the highest FPS if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the largest buffer if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the best weather sealing if your shots aren't in focus.
What good are the fastest card slots if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the best heat dissipation if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the bla bla bla bla ........ if your shots aren't in focus.
The Canon R1 will own this hands down. That's why the people that have actually used the camera said that it's "unreal".
rscheffler wrote:
What are pros looking for in a flagship body? All-in-one ruggedized body? Can the a1 actually be included because it uses a separate add-on vertical grip? Is the Z9 the only true option if you need/want a high MP 'pro' body? Perhaps this is an indicator of how truly niche the top-end pro market has become. (How many of the Z9 users could not instead use a Z8?)
Some of the R5's shortcomings - heat and battery life - are the reality of it being 4 years old; some of its components are likely even older. Those deficits will be addressed in the Mark II version and it will also be a lot faster. Just the two year gap between the R6 and R6II resulted in significant improvements in these metrics.
As a former life-long 1-series user (since the original EOS-1), at least as far as I'm concerned, I'm happy to have a 'pro' camera with an optional vertical grip. It gives me the choice of a smaller configuration when it's a priority, or add the grip when I need that convenience. I won't complain if Canon improves 5 series durability, weather sealing and improves the add-on grip's ergonomics. ...Show more →
Yeah, after knowing there were R1s at the Monaco GP, I kept a close eye on the photogs after the race during the ceremony etc. I saw a lot of them using flippy screens on non-gripped bodies. And these guys were getting jostled around like in a mosh pit trying to get shots of Leclerc's post race celebration.....these pros didn't have to have a rugged 100lb body to shoot professional sports. Some of them probably like the big tanks but a lot of them value other things.
lighthound wrote:
The Canon R1 will own this hands down. That's why the people that have actually used the camera said that it's "unreal".
What people have got past the NDA and spoken about the camera's AF already?
Can you provide a source for that. I haven't read anything about how the AF is....could be amazing...could be too much AI making it a regression for many things.
garyvot wrote: middlerockies wrote[They're the only brand who still thinks this way, and every other genre that shoots Canon just has to settle for less.I personally am not in the market for either 120fps or 50Mpx, but if I was, I would not expect them to coexist in the same camera body.
To me, it just seems that Canon choose to keep its "flagship" camera focused on highest shooting performance, and its more "mainstream" model targeting "do-it-all" territory. I don't think that means settling for less, but maybe you do? In that case, you always have choices.
I personally am with Ron on this one. Having migrated from 1-series DSLRs previously, I rather like now having a "pro enough" grade camera with an optional battery grip, where I have the flexibility to go light when I want to.
Certainly the lack of an integrated grip won't make the R5 II any less professional than various Sony models....Show more →
Well it may not be 50MPs at 120FPS but it looks like by the end of 2024 we will likely have 50MP at 60FPS as that will be pushing similar data to the 24MP at 120FPS in the A9III. Not to mention any CPU improvements over the year and the use of Type 4 CFe-A card.
So for me I maybe don't expect 50 at 120 but I'm expecting (and wanting) 50 at 60 in the A1II.
lighthound wrote:
There is no need to get all upset over how any camera manufacture titles their top of the line camera.
In Canon's case they produce their top of the line bodies targeted toward the sports crowd. So what?
Anyone can purchase it so long as you have deep enough pockets.
As for competing against the other guys "flagships". Well, that's what Canon's second tier bodies (R5 line) are for.
And yep, anyone can purchase those as well.
Simply put. Nothing will be able to touch the level of the R1 for a very long time. Which is why Canon has kept the final specs under very tight wraps.
It all boils down to the AF system a camera brings to market.
What good is the best DR if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the highest FPS if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the largest buffer if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the best weather sealing if your shots aren't in focus.
What good are the fastest card slots if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the best heat dissipation if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the bla bla bla bla ........ if your shots aren't in focus.
The Canon R1 will own this hands down. That's why the people that have actually used the camera said that it's "unreal". ...Show more →
Camera isn't even out yet or and no reviews has been published by reputable reviewers. But already the conclusion is clear, not only is it better than anything out there but it is also better than anything anyone else can make for a very long time!
As always the thing that is "unreal" is the hype whenever a new camera is launched.
randomguy wrote: lighthound wroteThere is no need to get all upset over how any camera manufacture titles their top of the line camera.
In Canon's case they produce their top of the line bodies targeted toward the sports crowd. So what?
Anyone can purchase it so long as you have deep enough pockets.
As for competing against the other guys "flagships". Well, that's what Canon's second tier bodies (R5 line) are for.
And yep, anyone can purchase those as well.
Simply put. Nothing will be able to touch the level of the R1 for a very long time. Which is why Canon has kept the final specs under very tight wraps.
It all boils down to the AF system a camera brings to market.
What good is the best DR if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the highest FPS if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the largest buffer if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the best weather sealing if your shots aren't in focus.
What good are the fastest card slots if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the best heat dissipation if your shots aren't in focus.
What good is the bla bla bla bla ........ if your shots aren't in focus.
The Canon R1 will own this hands down. That's why the people that have actually used the camera said that it's "unreal".Camera isn't even out yet or and no reviews has been published by reputable reviewers. But already the conclusion is clear, not only is it better than anything out there but it is also better than anything anyone else can make for a very long time!
As always the thing that is "unreal" is the hype whenever a new camera is launched.
More accurately, camera isn't even out yet, not even the specs, and people are already saying it's no good.
arbitrage wrote: rscheffler wroteWhat are pros looking for in a flagship body? All-in-one ruggedized body? Can the a1 actually be included because it uses a separate add-on vertical grip? Is the Z9 the only true option if you need/want a high MP 'pro' body? Perhaps this is an indicator of how truly niche the top-end pro market has become. (How many of the Z9 users could not instead use a Z8?)
Some of the R5's shortcomings - heat and battery life - are the reality of it being 4 years old; some of its components are likely even older. Those deficits will be addressed in the Mark II version and it will also be a lot faster. Just the two year gap between the R6 and R6II resulted in significant improvements in these metrics.
As a former life-long 1-series user (since the original EOS-1), at least as far as I'm concerned, I'm happy to have a 'pro' camera with an optional vertical grip. It gives me the choice of a smaller configuration when it's a priority, or add the grip when I need that convenience. I won't complain if Canon improves 5 series durability, weather sealing and improves the add-on grip's ergonomics. Yeah, after knowing there were R1s at the Monaco GP, I kept a close eye on the photogs after the race during the ceremony etc. I saw a lot of them using flippy screens on non-gripped bodies. And these guys were getting jostled around like in a mosh pit trying to get shots of Leclerc's post race celebration.....these pros didn't have to have a rugged 100lb body to shoot professional sports. Some of them probably like the big tanks but a lot of them value other things.
Do you have a non rumor source saying 24mp? Is there anything besides CR? A lot of assumptions being made, I dont think anyone really knows
If you are going to gripe at Dave's positivity, you probably need to be griping at the negativity based on unknown specs