Choderboy wrote: garyvot wroteRegardless, the R1 is not trying to be a "do everything" camera. It is a special-purpose dedicated sports/action camera intended to offer the highest level of speed and AF performance Canon can offer, like all 1-series models in the last 15-20 years.Well, 15 years, not 20. 20 years ago there was a choice of 1D2 or 1DS2.
Even 1DX, in 2012, was only just behind the max available resolution. (18mp vs 20)
5DS/R in 2015 was the start of the dedicated sports/action body having significantly less than highest available resolution.
So it's a 9 year period the lower resolution sports/action camera has existed.
Sure.
However, I would argue that the original EOS 1D (and all its direct successors) was always targeted first at photojournalists, sports/action, and wildlife photographers, where highest shooting performance and most rugged build quality was paramount. The 1DX series and R1 continue that direct lineage.
The 1DS ("studio") series was offered for a time but was discontinued as Canon decided the 5-series could meet that need for higher resolution in a smaller, more practical camera. So arguably, the 1DS line was the exception and not the rule for Canon's 1-series models.
But Canon doesn't really need me to defend their product strategy. I think people can vote with their wallets.
Yeah, I think the 2 model period was due to the cost of large sensors at the time.
Then the 5 series went through quite a change too.
5D was just resolution in a rebel body.
5D2 was more resolution.
5D3 no more resolution but made it half way to 1 series build and AF.
5D4 came close enough to 1 series build and AF that many traditional 1 Series buyers
decided it was '1 enough' to swap to a 5.
Choderboy wrote:
5D4 came close enough to 1 series build and AF that many traditional 1 Series buyers
decided it was '1 enough' to swap to a 5.
Well, the 5D IV was/is “1 enough” for me to have bought my second 5D IV, just last week.
I bought my first 5D IV, in March 2018, because it seemed to be “7 enough.” My earlier 1D-series had been a 1D2N, bought pre-owned, to complement my 7D, but when I acquired my pair of 7D Mark II cameras, in late 2014, their performance put the 1D2N out to pasture. Low light AF and high ISO capability were my primary requirements, for “performance,” but the flicker detection/sync, and ability to “talk” to the Speedlites through the camera’s menu, quickly became useful, too.
When I could finally afford a true top-tier pro camera, new, however, I bought a Nikon D5. I had just retired, and my wife and I anticipated being free to finally travel, to photograph wildlife and birds. Nikon was HER system, and had been, since she had started using digital SLRs for personal shooting, in 2008 or 2009. (I had not started using SLRs or DSLRs until 2010.) So, in order for our “pro zoom trinity” and long telephoto lenses to be of one brand/system, to save money, and to reduce the overall weight of our combined kits, Nikon won.
Notably, however, I kept using Canon for macro shooting. (Nikon had stopped caring, much, about macro, well before 2010, when I started building my kit, and needed the best equipment for evidentiary/forensic/crime scene photography.)
With B&H recently selling new-old-stock 1DX Mark II cameras for only ~$3K US, I recently, I revisited the idea of acquiring a 1DX-series camera. It “checked all the boxes,” including integral GPS. Our “citizen scientist” photography has evolved to “action macro,” capturing images of insects and wee beasties, in field conditions, while our photography of birds and distant wildlife has diminished. With the “1D premium,” at that moment in time, being only ~$700 US, I very nearly bought the 1DX II. Then, I bought my second 5D IV. As you said, “1 enough.”
Choderboy wrote:
Yeah, I think the 2 model period was due to the cost of large sensors at the time.
Then the 5 series went through quite a change to.
5D was just resolution in a rebel body.
5D2 was more resolution.
5D3 no more resolution but made it half way to 1 series build and AF.
5D4 came close enough to 1 series build and AF that many traditional 1 Series buyers
decided it was '1 enough' to swap to a 5.
The FF sensor was certainly more costly and had lower production yields, but the higher resolution and available processor capabilities also meant the cameras were a lot slower than the non-s versions, further justifying the split product line.
The move to the 5 series was IMO a good decision by Canon because it made higher resolution accessible to a broader range of users who might not require the high speed performance of the non-s 1D models, or want to spend that much money on a more specialized, ruggedized camera. But what the non-s 1D line had over the 's,' 5 series and all other Canon DSLRs was speed. And it just wasn't by a small amount either. While one could argue the 7 series approached that of the 1D, and later the 80 and 90D, in my experience that was more true on paper than in actual use where the non-1D cameras bogged down noticeably in comparison. It's what kept me a 1D user from 2001 until 2022.
With the R5, R6 and later the R7, R6II and R8, a lot of the speed/performance gaps between Canon's 'consumer' level and 1-series have greatly diminished. And IMO all of those mirrorless cameras outperform all previous Canon DSLRs, including the 1-series. High resolution doesn't seem to be the speed bottleneck that it used to be considering the power of processors now.
While an R3 and likely the R1 are nicer cameras to use for sports/action, the mid-tier Canon mirrorless cameras are not that far off and all of them outclass all previous Canon DSLRs for these applications. This makes the R3/R1 that much more niche than the 1-series ever was previously. As a former 1-series user, I think the R1 looks awesome, but the incentive to get one now is much lower because of how good the R5/R5II, R6II, etc., are for my purposes. I don't feel I *need* an R1 now. While it would provide some 'quality of life' improvements when covering some sports, it doesn't seem like it's as big of a difference as it used to be.
Maybe I'll change my mind if I borrow one from CPS and the actual in-use experience is significantly better than the R5II or R6II. I think that's the one thing that's difficult to appreciate right now - how the actual user experience is compared to the on-paper specs. Especially the new AF tracking and recognition capabilities combined with the improved pre-capture function.
Jeff Cable says his hit rate improved from about 40% to 95% in his shooting so far at the Olympics photographing men’s gymnastics. Presumably that improvement is over the R3…
The R1 DR may be significantly improved, which would be big news. Canon is apparently claiming 16 stops, presumably in response to Sony's ridiculous 15 stop claim on the A7r4, they presumably rounded the 14.8 score to the nearest integer
Canon can't go explaining why that is bogus really, but if they manage to beat the A7r4 by anything close to a full stop that is a pretty big deal, especially give Sony's stagnation in DR performance
KINGOFKNGS wrote:
Jeff Cable says his hit rate improved from about 40% to 95% in his shooting so far at the Olympics photographing men’s gymnastics. Presumably that improvement is over the R3…
KINGOFKNGS wrote:
Jeff Cable says his hit rate improved from about 40% to 95% in his shooting so far at the Olympics photographing men’s gymnastics. Presumably that improvement is over the R3…
I don't believe that is vs the R3. He states in the blog you referenced, "In past Olympics, my take rate when photographing gymnastics was maybe 40% in perfect focus.". I think this is his 8th Olympic games and in this quote he's not clear on his timeframe nor which cameras he's comparing it to.
Nevertheless, if you look at an older blog from him regarding the R3 at the previous Olympics, this is what he stated:
"In the last couple of days, I have had many people ask me about the focus speed and eye-control of the Canon R3 and their overall effectiveness. I can tell you that the focus speed of the R3 was top-notch, giving me a very high percentage of "keepers" from each event. When shooting the fast action of the Olympics, it is a tall order to ask for all images to be tack sharp. This new camera did an amazing job of locking focus."
Perhaps! He did say it was a game changer. If I have to be disappointed in 24 megapixels, hopefully I can at least be excited for class leading AF! 😂 I shoot birds almost exclusively and would welcome improvements in tracking small, fast, erratically flying birds. Swallows are hard but photographing passerines is a lot harder, I think, and if the R1 (and R5II) make appreciable gains in that arena over the R3, I’ll be thrilled. The A9iii seems to be doing a pretty nifty job at tracking birds—hopefully the new offerings from Canon one up it. With reports of improved autofocus for sports, it will be interesting to see how much improvement there is for birds.
pulper11 wrote: KINGOFKNGS wroteJeff Cable says his hit rate improved from about 40% to 95% in his shooting so far at the Olympics photographing men’s gymnastics. Presumably that improvement is over the R3…
https://blog.jeffcable.com/2024/07/capturing-photos-of-men-from-usa.html?m=1I don't believe that is vs the R3. He states in the blog you referenced, "In past Olympics, my take rate when photographing gymnastics was maybe 40% in perfect focus.". I think this is his 8th Olympic games and in this quote he's not clear on his timeframe nor which cameras he's comparing it to.
Nevertheless, if you look at an older blog from him regarding the R3 at the previous Olympics, this is what he stated:
"In the last couple of days, I have had many people ask me about the focus speed and eye-control of the Canon R3 and their overall effectiveness. I can tell you that the focus speed of the R3 was top-notch, giving me a very high percentage of "keepers" from each event. When shooting the fast action of the Olympics, it is a tall order to ask for all images to be tack sharp. This new camera did an amazing job of locking focus."
Jeff made a comment in his blog I think last week that the AF in the R1 is a noticeable improvement over the R3. He said he turned the eye focus control off the first day on the R3, but it works really well in R1 and he plans on using it. I do sports, dance and wildlife, I’m looking forward to hearing more of is experiences with it.
Here are pix of the CPS at Paris Olympics, from Jeff Cable's blog.
Lot of R3, R1 and R5II it seems.
Regarding R1:
"It looked like they had about 40 pre-production units and they are loaning them out to people for a 24 hour period, so that they can try it out. I am lucky in that I have two of them for the entire games."
KINGOFKNGS wrote:
Jeff Cable says his hit rate improved from about 40% to 95% in his shooting so far at the Olympics photographing men’s gymnastics. Presumably that improvement is over the R3…
His testimony is better than any opinion about the camera on FM since he gets to actually shoot with it verses just discuss the specifications. It's a good sign for those who want the R1. Hopefully, he uses the R5II and provides feedback on it.
KINGOFKNGS wrote:
Jeff Cable says his hit rate improved from about 40% to 95% in his shooting so far at the Olympics photographing men’s gymnastics. Presumably that improvement is over the R3…
Methodical wrote:
His testimony is better than any opinion about the camera on FM since he gets to actually shoot with it verses just discuss the specifications. It's a good sign for those who want the R1. Hopefully, he uses the R5II and provides feedback on it.
His post about Canon's CPS Olympics set up has a brief comment at the end:
"I can tell you this. I wish I could keep my hands on the Canon R1 and Canon R5 MKII after the Olympics, because I am totally addicted to them now. If you saw the last blog post, with the incredible success I had with the new focus system, you know why. And I used both cameras this morning to photograph Simone Biles and it was incredible once again."
I'm guessing he probably mostly used the R1 but it at least sounds promising that he also used the R5II and remains very enthusiastic.
It sounds like we are getting close to an era when AF won't be much of a discussion topic anymore as it nears perfection. I shoot a variety of things and I'm very happy with the old R5 almost for everything. I understand the few shortcomings that comes along with it and the need for improvement in a few areas, but for the most part I feel I can shoot just about everything with it. Then, I grab the R3 and it feels almost perfect for me as I don't think it misses much of anything. I end up throwing away so many keepers it's ridiculous. So now if the R1/R5II are a huge jump above the R3, we are definitely nearing a level of perfection for most common shooting situations. The days of wondering if your sequence of shots is crisp will be gone, and you'll pretty much know the new AF system nailed everything as long as you had it in the frame.
artsupreme wrote:
It sounds like we are getting close to an era when AF won't be much of a discussion topic anymore as it nears perfection. I shoot a variety of things and I'm very happy with the old R5 almost for everything. I understand the few shortcomings that comes along with it and the need for improvement in a few areas, but for the most part I feel I can shoot just about everything with it. Then, I grab the R3 and it feels almost perfect for me as I don't think it misses much of anything. I end up throwing away so many keepers it's ridiculous. So now if the R1/R5II are a huge jump above the R3, we are definitely nearing a level of perfection for most common shooting situations. The days of wondering if your sequence of shots is crisp will be gone, and you'll pretty much know the new AF system nailed everything as long as you had it in the frame. ...Show more →
I agree. Combine that with usable pre-capture, the likelihood of missing a sudden peak moment is even more remote. It addresses perhaps one of my main criticisms of mirrorless when photographing action - the system's inherent slight delay. It does mean generating a lot more images, but if Canon can refine their focus confirmation/evaluation implementation to also work with RAW files and more than just human faces, may help offset this downside. And if Canon doesn't, it's a feature that will certainly become increasingly common with standard image editing/culling apps.
rscheffler wrote: KINGOFKNGS wroteJeff Cable says his hit rate improved from about 40% to 95% in his shooting so far at the Olympics photographing men’s gymnastics. Presumably that improvement is over the R3…
https://blog.jeffcable.com/2024/07/capturing-photos-of-men-from-usa.html?m=1Methodical wroteHis testimony is better than any opinion about the camera on FM since he gets to actually shoot with it verses just discuss the specifications. It's a good sign for those who want the R1. Hopefully, he uses the R5II and provides feedback on it.His post about Canon's CPS Olympics set up has a brief comment at the end:
"I can tell you this. I wish I could keep my hands on the Canon R1 and Canon R5 MKII after the Olympics, because I am totally addicted to them now. If you saw the last blog post, with the incredible success I had with the new focus system, you know why. And I used both cameras this morning to photograph Simone Biles and it was incredible once again."
I'm guessing he probably mostly used the R1 but it at least sounds promising that he also used the R5II and remains very enthusiastic....Show more →
Jeff’s latest blog posts have this to say about the R1.
While shooting Simone Biles on the uneven bars, “The last part of the rotation was the uneven bars. In the past I have had a hard time photographing this, as the athletes move up, down, forward, backward and it is hard to track them and keep them in focus. But with the new Canon R1, almost every photo was tack sharp. I was VERY happy with my images.”
And this while shooting womans rugby, “ I used the new "Eye control" of the Canon R1 to determine which athlete would be in focus. It is awesome. Whichever person I am looking at through the eye piece, will be the person that gets tracked by the focus system.”
He didn’t like the eye focus in the R3 and turned it off after trying it, this sounds hopeful it might be good enough for wildlife. He mentioned he’s doing a photo tour in Costa Rica after the Olympics, hopefully he will be able to use an R1 and R5ii there and give his impressions on BIF.
Ischgl99 wrote:
While shooting Simone Biles on the uneven bars, “The last part of the rotation was the uneven bars. In the past I have had a hard time photographing this, as the athletes move up, down, forward, backward and it is hard to track them and keep them in focus. But with the new Canon R1, almost every photo was tack sharp. I was VERY happy with my images.”
He had some great images from the Individual All-Around, including Uneven Bars.