p.6 #1New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
hanay78 wrote:
But the real contender maybe is the heliar 50/3.5? I mean if one likes, or do not mind, the front element turning like type II, then the heliar should be the real contender...
From what I have shown I hope I will be able to get type I when it reaches the market. Lets hope it likes Sony sensor
Fred Miranda wroterscheffler wroteFred Miranda wroteThank you for sharing these videos, Juha! They've answered most of our questions. From what I gathered from the auto-translation, Cosina decided to keep the 50/3.5 Type I extended because collapsing it wouldn't really add any extra functionality, except for making it more compact when not in use.
However, if they had made it collapsible, there would always be a risk of small vibrations and airflow, potentially allowing dust to get inside the lens. It seems like the decision was made to preserve the aesthetics of the past and avoid these potential issues. Personally, I prefer the slimmer Type II for the insane 0.35m MFD, even though it means the filters would rotate with focusing, like polarizers.I don't quite buy the apparent reasoning behind not making it collapsible. The whole point of a collapsible design, its sole functional reason, is to be more compact when not in use. And this slow 50/3.5 is quite long for a 50mm design, therefore it would really benefit from a collapsible design. Based on the design of the Leica 90/4 Macro, the whole optical assembly is inside the tube that collapses - there is no internal movement of elements to facilitate this capability, therefore there wouldn't be structural changes that would increase the opportunity for dust ingress.
Whatever the case, if I was to get this lens, my preference would be type 1 simply for the non-rotating aperture and filter rings and the raised red dot. I also think the design looks quite nice, particularly in panda, just that collapsibility would have made it that much more practical.
Looking forward to seeing how these new 50s stack up!Cosina likely anticipated that there would be questions about this and addressed it in the video. Personally, I would have preferred if the Type I featured collapsibility. I'm very curious about their performance and will be comparing them to the Voigtlander 50/2 APO-Lanthar. Indeed. The CV 50/3.5 APO-Lanthar and CV 50/3.5 Heliar are similar in that way!
p.6 #2New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Juha Kannisto wrote: Fred Miranda wrotephilip_pj wroteDo we have a block diagram for the 50/3.5 yet? 150 grams means the TI would never stay home. Seeing what they managed with the 5/3 Heliar, the 8/6 of this one, and its glass types are of interest. The Heliar has 10 blades and shares the same AOV equal to 51mm.
A good video, it highlights the clever internal flange for the 50/3.5 (2:40). I'd worry about dust ingress if it collapsed, that is a lengthy surface to keep clean.
The Type I near-body focus ring might suit sone users better than the Type II setup. The closer MFD Type II appears to extend further (4:05), and requires greater finger reach.The focus throw appears similar between Type I and II for focus distances until close range, but the Type II rotates much further to reach 0.35m.
One observation is that the Type II includes meters and feet distance markings, while the Type I only has meters.
The purpose of the metal pole for the Type II style is still unclear to me. Usually such poles are used for an infinity lock, but it seems it might just be an aesthetic component for the new lens.I think they said on the product introduction video that the pole on Type II is there to make it easier to grab onto in order to rotate the lens when taking it off or putting it on the camera as the lens is so narrow and there may be nothing else to grab hold of. The English auto-translation entirely skipped that part. They called the pole "yubigakari" 指係 which translates to finger handle.
I think the 40/2.8 designed for Sony to be used with CV VM-E close focus adapter has a similar pole design for same purpose.
p.6 #3New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
jaygould wrote:
I wish we'd see some more lenses for E mount instead. These two + the new 28mm would be great.
How about rephrasing that to be 'in addition' rather than instead? M system users and those who like to adapt to various systems are certainly grateful for Cosina's continuing attention to the M mount.
p.6 #5New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
I played a little bit with the new VM lenses at CP+ today but trials on them were limited to the Cosina counter and there was basically nothing to shoot there except some papers.
From the new VMs I liked the look and feel of the two-tone 50/3.5 Type I best and the lens seemed very sharp at closest distances too.
There was a silver version as well of the 50/2.2 Color-Skopar on display at a glass vitrine, I wonder if they are considering to release it in silver as well though only black one was pre-announced...
p.6 #6New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Thank you for the gorgeous photographs!
It looks very nice. Full black and silver/black are the same weight? Sharpness comparable to 50/f2?
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I played a little bit with the new VM lenses at CP+ today but trials on them were limited to the Cosina counter and there was basically nothing to shoot there except some papers.
From the new VMs I liked the look and feel of the two-tone 50/3.5 Type I best and the lens seemed very sharp at closest distances too.
There was a silver version as well of the 50/2.2 Color-Skopar on display at a glass vitrine, I wonder if they are considering to release it in silver as well though only black one was pre-announced...
p.6 #7New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
This silver/black Type I of 50/3.5 is 240g and the full black (matte black paint) version of Type I is lighter at 150g. Both colors of Type II lens are 250g. I tried the black Type II as well but don't have any photos of it on my camera. Handlingwise I preferred Type I. I don't like the rotating focus (where aperture rotates together with focus ring) as much and the focus throw on the Type II lens is really long. If I was to buy one of these 50/3.5 I'd probably go for the two-tone version of Type I if they are priced equally even though it's heavier than the black Type I and even though Type II focuses closer. Could always use a helicoid adapter with Type I to get it to focus closer than 0.45m as well (when using it adapted).
I can't really say much about sharpness compared to 50 f2 since my testing was limited to shooting papers like this at f3.5 at close distance: https://photos.app.goo.gl/VHYD3BajsTZMS3BZ6, but I got the feeling that it was plenty sharp...
hanay78 wrote:
Thank you for the gorgeous photographs!
It looks very nice. Full black and silver/black are the same weight? Sharpness comparable to 50/f2?
Juha Kannisto wroteI played a little bit with the new VM lenses at CP+ today but trials on them were limited to the Cosina counter and there was basically nothing to shoot there except some papers.
From the new VMs I liked the look and feel of the two-tone 50/3.5 Type I best and the lens seemed very sharp at closest distances too.
There was a silver version as well of the 50/2.2 Color-Skopar on display at a glass vitrine, I wonder if they are considering to release it in silver as well though only black one was pre-announced...
p.6 #9New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Juha Kannisto wrote:
This silver/black Type I of 50/3.5 is 240g and the full black (matte black paint) version of Type I is lighter at 150g.
Thanks for sharing pictures of the lenses, Juha. Could you confirm if the panda two-tone version is made of brass, while the black paint version is made of aluminum?
I can't really say much about sharpness compared to 50 f2 since my testing was limited to shooting papers like this at f3.5 at close distance: https://photos.app.goo.gl/VHYD3BajsTZMS3BZ6, but I got the feeling that it was plenty sharp...
For many rangefinder shooters, the CV 50/2 APO may still be the preferred choice. Although it's not as light and compact, measuring 53mm in length and weighing 287g, it's still manageable. There is only a slight intrusion into the 50mm frame lines. The advantage lies in more than a stop faster aperture and more advanced aperture mechanism. This advantage becomes apparent when comparing it to both the Type I (two-tone) and Type II models, which aren't considerably lighter. It will be a tough task for the 50/3.5 to keep up or outperform the 50/2 APO, but I'm curious to compare them.
p.6 #10New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I played a little bit with the new VM lenses at CP+ today but trials on them were limited to the Cosina counter and there was basically nothing to shoot there except some papers.
From the new VMs I liked the look and feel of the two-tone 50/3.5 Type I best and the lens seemed very sharp at closest distances too.
There was a silver version as well of the 50/2.2 Color-Skopar on display at a glass vitrine, I wonder if they are considering to release it in silver as well though only black one was pre-announced...
p.6 #11New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
I think what is interesting about these new lenses is how they fit in with some combinations with already existing 21mm and 28mm CVM lenses to make some really compelling 21/28/50 set of lenses.
For example if you want very light weight lenses it is going to be hard to beat this combo:
21 f/4 Color Skopar: 136g 55mm diameter by 25.4mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2.8 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 143g 52mm diameter X 23.5mm long and 34mm filter
50 f/3.5 APO Lanthar Type 1 Black: 150g 52mm diameter X 45mm long and 34mm filter
Or if you want very small and light with a bit wider aperture it is hard to beat this combo:
21 f/3.5 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 180g 52mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2 Asph Ultron Type 1: 190g 52mm diameter X 36mm long and 39mm filter
50 f/2.2 Color Skopar: 150g 51.4mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
Either of these combos could easily be paired with the 90 f/2.8 APO Skopar for a very small and quite complete kit.
p.6 #12New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Oldwino wrote:
Jeez, that f3.5 APO looks like a parts-bin job...
The new f/3.5 APO reminds me of the versions 1 and 3 of the Classic Heliar 50mm (I still have my version 3) mixed with the collapsable f/2.0 Classic Heliar 50mm (still have it too). Both of those lenses hold a special place in my heart and on my shelf for photographic and sentimental reasons.
p.6 #13New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
The CV 50/2 APO is still the preferred choice for me. I like the collapsible lens for size and weight, but you are giving up about 1.5 stops. It would be nice to see a comparison of them when available.
p.6 #14New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Steve Spencer wrote:
I think what is interesting about these new lenses is how they fit in with some combinations with already existing 21mm and 28mm CVM lenses to make some really compelling 21/28/50 set of lenses.
For example if you want very light weight lenses it is going to be hard to beat this combo:
21 f/4 Color Skopar: 136g 55mm diameter by 25.4mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2.8 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 143g 52mm diameter X 23.5mm long and 34mm filter
50 f/3.5 APO Lanthar Type 1 Black: 150g 52mm diameter X 45mm long and 34mm filter
Or if you want very small and light with a bit wider aperture it is hard to beat this combo:
21 f/3.5 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 180g 52mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2 Asph Ultron Type 1: 190g 52mm diameter X 36mm long and 39mm filter
50 f/2.2 Color Skopar: 150g 51.4mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
Either of these combos could easily be paired with the 90 f/2.8 APO Skopar for a very small and quite complete kit....Show more →
We all want lightweight lenses, but depending on your Leica M body, lenses that are "too light" (less than 150g) often don't achieve the best balance with the body. For instance, when holding the body using a strap, the lens may tilt upward.
I believe an excellent combination for achieving the ultimate lightweight setup would be the CV 28/2.8 Color-Skopar Type II paired with the new CV 50/2.2 Color Skopar lens. If someone prefers 35mm, there's the underrated CV 35/2.5 Color Skopar V2, weighing 134g and standing only 23mm in height. It's a fantastic lens.
p.6 #15New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
That 50mm 3.5 APO could be a nice little lens to pick up. I do a lot of relatively close shooting with my SL2-S and 50mm APO Summicron-SL. I'm usually at 5.6-6.3 being so close, so 3.5 would be no issue. Would love to carry something much smaller and lighter.
p.6 #16New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteI think what is interesting about these new lenses is how they fit in with some combinations with already existing 21mm and 28mm CVM lenses to make some really compelling 21/28/50 set of lenses.
For example if you want very light weight lenses it is going to be hard to beat this combo:
21 f/4 Color Skopar: 136g 55mm diameter by 25.4mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2.8 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 143g 52mm diameter X 23.5mm long and 34mm filter
50 f/3.5 APO Lanthar Type 1 Black: 150g 52mm diameter X 45mm long and 34mm filter
Or if you want very small and light with a bit wider aperture it is hard to beat this combo:
21 f/3.5 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 180g 52mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2 Asph Ultron Type 1: 190g 52mm diameter X 36mm long and 39mm filter
50 f/2.2 Color Skopar: 150g 51.4mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
Either of these combos could easily be paired with the 90 f/2.8 APO Skopar for a very small and quite complete kit.We all want lightweight lenses, but depending on your Leica M body, lenses that are "too light" (less than 150g) often don't achieve the best balance with the body. For instance, when holding the body using a strap, the lens may tilt upward.
I believe an excellent combination for achieving the ultimate lightweight setup would be the CV 28/2.8 Color-Skopar Type II paired with the new CV 50/2.2 Color Skopar lens. If someone prefers 35mm, there's the underrated CV 35/2.5 Color Skopar V2, weighing 134g and standing only 23mm in height. It's a fantastic lens.
I too find all these lenses just a bit too small. For me the issue with all these 34mm and 39mm filter thread lenses is the high vignetting they all have. I would rather CV had built the lenses just a bit bigger with a larger front element and maybe even a little longer if that helped reduce the vignetting and the swirl in the bokeh.
p.6 #17New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wroteI think what is interesting about these new lenses is how they fit in with some combinations with already existing 21mm and 28mm CVM lenses to make some really compelling 21/28/50 set of lenses.
For example if you want very light weight lenses it is going to be hard to beat this combo:
21 f/4 Color Skopar: 136g 55mm diameter by 25.4mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2.8 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 143g 52mm diameter X 23.5mm long and 34mm filter
50 f/3.5 APO Lanthar Type 1 Black: 150g 52mm diameter X 45mm long and 34mm filter
Or if you want very small and light with a bit wider aperture it is hard to beat this combo:
21 f/3.5 Asph Color Skopar Type 1: 180g 52mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
28 f/2 Asph Ultron Type 1: 190g 52mm diameter X 36mm long and 39mm filter
50 f/2.2 Color Skopar: 150g 51.4mm diameter X 30mm long and 39mm filter
Either of these combos could easily be paired with the 90 f/2.8 APO Skopar for a very small and quite complete kit.We all want lightweight lenses, but depending on your Leica M body, lenses that are "too light" (less than 150g) often don't achieve the best balance with the body. For instance, when holding the body using a strap, the lens may tilt upward.
I believe an excellent combination for achieving the ultimate lightweight setup would be the CV 28/2.8 Color-Skopar Type II paired with the new CV 50/2.2 Color Skopar lens. If someone prefers 35mm, there's the underrated CV 35/2.5 Color Skopar V2, weighing 134g and standing only 23mm in height. It's a fantastic lens.I too find all these lenses just a bit too small. For me the issue with all these 34mm and 39mm filter thread lenses is the high vignetting they all have. I would rather CV had built the lenses just a bit bigger with a larger front element and maybe even a little longer if that helped reduce the vignetting and the swirl in the bokeh.
– And the 35/50 f/2 APOs are no vignetting champs to begin with.
I think one way in which Voigtlander has not yet chosen to innovate (using that term loosely) is by coming out with matched sets of lenses for a given purpose, all with the same design language and that share the same filter size. [removed incorrect info about 50 2.2 filter size]
I appreciate Voigtlander's "clean sheet of paper" approach every time they design a lens because it brings unique offerings. But why not also offer a Loxia-like set of lenses? Give us some paired sets of at least three or more lenses per set.
p.6 #19New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Desmolicious wrote:
The 50 2.2 uses a 34mm filter? My OG 50 2.5 uses a 39mm. Why would CV shrink that down to 34? The 50 2.5 already was a very small lens.
p.6 #20New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Desmolicious wrote:
The 50 2.2 uses a 34mm filter? My OG 50 2.5 uses a 39mm. Why would CV shrink that down to 34? The 50 2.5 already was a very small lens.
Fred Miranda wrote: Desmolicious wroteThe 50 2.2 uses a 34mm filter? My OG 50 2.5 uses a 39mm. Why would CV shrink that down to 34? The 50 2.5 already was a very small lens.I think the new 50/2.2 is 39mm.
Oops, my mistake. Also, great news. I’d read something like “they’re all 34mm” not realizing the plural was referencing the four other lenses.