fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement

  
 
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.5 #1New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Do we have a block diagram for the 50/3.5 yet? 150 grams means the TI would never stay home. Seeing what they managed with the 5/3 Heliar, the 8/6 of this one, and its glass types are of interest. The Heliar has 10 blades and shares the same AOV equal to 51mm.

A good video, it highlights the clever internal flange for the 50/3.5 (2:40). I'd worry about dust ingress if it collapsed, that is a lengthy surface to keep clean.

The Type I near-body focus ring might suit sone users better than the Type II setup. The closer MFD Type II appears to extend further (4:05), and requires greater finger reach.
Feb 21, 2024 at 10:22 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.5 #2New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Fred Miranda wrote:
Thank you for sharing these videos, Juha! They've answered most of our questions. From what I gathered from the auto-translation, Cosina decided to keep the 50/3.5 Type I extended because collapsing it wouldn't really add any extra functionality, except for making it more compact when not in use.

However, if they had made it collapsible, there would always be a risk of small vibrations and airflow, potentially allowing dust to get inside the lens. It seems like the decision was made to preserve the aesthetics of the past and avoid these potential issues. Personally, I prefer the slimmer Type II
...Show more →

Leica has the collapsable 90mm macro M lens. LLL has the collapsable 35mm 8-element M lens. Is it the APO-Lanthar designation that made Cosina nervous about perfect optical alignment and positioning when extended and locked? If so, why that design at all? Does it allow for us to hang a nice pine-scented air freshener from it and not have it fall off the end of the lens? Someone please think of something creative and useful for this narrow gap At least the user will never mistake the focusing ring for the aperture ring or the other way around.

I'll bet Cosina didn't decide to add the detent at 0.7m until after the 50 2.2 was designed and tooled up. Or the detent is added expense that didn't align with the 50 2.2's price.

About the haptic feedback (detent) at 0.7m, I have opinions (shocking, I know):

I'm actually bummed about the detent on the other lenses. Firstly, they are not as helpful in practice as one might think they would be, at least as designed on the 35 Lux FLE CF lens I had. The detent causes focusing issues right on either side of 0.7m since the focus wants to snap into the 0.7m detent. If the detent was light enough not to do that, it wouldn't be strong enough to notice when passing 0.7m. With the positive detent of the 35 Lux (which some criticize for not being strong enough), critical focus near 0.7m became irritating for me, so I was left with setting it to 0.7m and focusing by moving my camera/myself back and forth to align the rangefinder patch – or I would give up and instead choose another shooting distance.

Secondly, the indicator that the rangefinder decouples is literally staring me in the eye – the rangefinder focusing patch stops moving. That's the detent. I just slowly move focus back the other way until I see the patch move slightly and I immediately stop moving the focus ring – then I can sway forward and back a tiny bit to focus. I have to do that anyway with a detent when focusing near 0.7m for the reasons described above.

Thirdly, most M lenses are rangefinder-coupled to slightly below 0.7m, and the detent interferes with that. Hopefully Cosina put their notch at the exact decoupling spot and not at 0.7m.

I wish we had a happy middle ground – perhaps something that could engage and disengage the detent the same way some lenses allow the aperture ring to be de-clicked.
Feb 21, 2024 at 10:24 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.5 #3New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
All their APO-Lanthar web pages now show MTF charts, maybe this one will too. Comparisons with the existing A-L VM 50mm lens will surely be made, for the slower apertures in any case. Slow lenses are often truly great, with a much-reduced aberration overhead narrowing the spectrum of required design corrections.

Fun fact: the variants of this new 50/3.5 lens are among the lightest full-frame APOs available, perhaps ever. The 150 gram version is half the weight of the lightest Leica M APO - the 300 gram Leica APO Summicron-M 1:2/50 mm ASPH. They are on a mission in VM, the 90/2.8 APO is only 250 grams. The 35/50 APOs in the VM range were reduced to around the Leica equivalents of approx 300 grams.

Slow APOs are an easier task and should have been done many years ago, to complete slow lenses' existing natural advantage in colour correction. We may see quite a few more APOs from now on, since Cosina has clearly made APO designs a strong (we can say central with regard to EVF cameras) element of their lens release program.

Edited on Feb 22, 2024 at 12:04 AM · View previous versions
Feb 21, 2024 at 11:02 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #4New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
highdesertmesa wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteThank you for sharing these videos, Juha! They've answered most of our questions. From what I gathered from the auto-translation, Cosina decided to keep the 50/3.5 Type I extended because collapsing it wouldn't really add any extra functionality, except for making it more compact when not in use.

However, if they had made it collapsible, there would always be a risk of small vibrations and airflow, potentially allowing dust to get inside the lens. It seems like the decision was made to preserve the aesthetics of the past and avoid these potential issues. Personally, I prefer the slimmer Type II for the insane 0.35m MFD, even though it means the filters would rotate with focusing, like polarizers.

The CV 50/2.2 appears to be simple and elegant. According to the video, its compact screw-in hood doesn't interfere with the 50mm framelines, which is great for RF shooters.

It's great to hear that they're listening to feedback and adding a tactile feel when the focusing ring goes beyond 0.7m for the 50/3.5. However, it's puzzling why they haven't implemented this feature for the 50/2.2. I think it would be beneficial for them to incorporate this to all their future lenses.
Leica has the collapsable 90mm macro M lens. LLL has the collapsable 35mm 8-element M lens. Is it the APO-Lanthar designation that made Cosina nervous about perfect optical alignment and positioning when extended and locked? If so, why that design at all? Does it allow for us to hang a nice pine-scented air freshener from it and not have it fall off the end of the lens? Someone please think of something creative and useful for this narrow gap At least the user will never mistake the focusing ring for the aperture ring or the other way around.

I'll
...Show more →

I have a lens, the Laowa 85mm f/5.6 APO Macro M-mount, where I find the 0.7m detent to be just right. It offers a nice tactile sensation without preventing the ring from turning. For me, it provides the perfect feedback for knowing when to stop focusing. However, as you pointed out, most lenses focus beyond 0.7m, and the Voigtlander lenses I own even go down to 0.6m, making this feature more annoying than helpful. An alternative is to visually see when the rangefinder disengages when focusing close, which also works well.
Feb 21, 2024 at 11:14 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #5New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
philip_pj wrote:
Do we have a block diagram for the 50/3.5 yet? 150 grams means the TI would never stay home. Seeing what they managed with the 5/3 Heliar, the 8/6 of this one, and its glass types are of interest. The Heliar has 10 blades and shares the same AOV equal to 51mm.

A good video, it highlights the clever internal flange for the 50/3.5 (2:40). I'd worry about dust ingress if it collapsed, that is a lengthy surface to keep clean.

The Type I near-body focus ring might suit sone users better than the Type II setup. The closer MFD Type II
...Show more →

The focus throw appears similar between Type I and II for focus distances until close range, but the Type II rotates much further to reach 0.35m.
One observation is that the Type II includes meters and feet distance markings, while the Type I only has meters.

The purpose of the metal pole for the Type II style is still unclear to me. Usually such poles are used for an infinity lock, but it seems it might just be an aesthetic component for the new lens.
Feb 21, 2024 at 11:42 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.5 #6New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Fred Miranda wrote:
The purpose of the metal pole for the Type II style is still unclear to me. Usually such poles are used for an infinity lock, but it seems it might just be an aesthetic component for the new lens.

Whether designed with infinity lock, or not, the metal post typically prevents the head of these simple-helix lenses from unscrewing off the mount. There should be a focus tab on the reverse side of the barrel but all product images I found are from the front side only. At nearest focus, the tab hits the post and stops rotating. The post can be unscrewed to allow lens servicing.
Feb 21, 2024 at 11:59 PM
sselhtrim
Offline
Details
p.5 #7New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Wonder if the time is ripe for them to produce a new moderate speed 21mm, with less field curvature...
Feb 22, 2024 at 12:08 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.5 #8New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Fred Miranda wrote:
philip_pj wroteDo we have a block diagram for the 50/3.5 yet? 150 grams means the TI would never stay home. Seeing what they managed with the 5/3 Heliar, the 8/6 of this one, and its glass types are of interest. The Heliar has 10 blades and shares the same AOV equal to 51mm.

A good video, it highlights the clever internal flange for the 50/3.5 (2:40). I'd worry about dust ingress if it collapsed, that is a lengthy surface to keep clean.

The Type I near-body focus ring might suit sone users better than the Type II setup. The closer MFD Type II appears to extend further (4:05), and requires greater finger reach.
The focus throw appears similar between Type I and II for focus distances until close range, but the Type II rotates much further to reach 0.35m.
One observation is that the Type II includes meters and feet distance markings, while the Type I only has meters.

The purpose of the metal pole for the Type II style is still unclear to me. Usually such poles are used for an infinity lock, but it seems it might just be an aesthetic component for the new lens.


I think they said on the product introduction video that the pole on Type II is there to make it easier to grab onto in order to rotate the lens when taking it off or putting it on the camera as the lens is so narrow and there may be nothing else to grab hold of. The English auto-translation entirely skipped that part. They called the pole "yubigakari" 指係 which translates to finger handle.

I think the 40/2.8 designed for Sony to be used with CV VM-E close focus adapter has a similar pole design for same purpose.

Edited on Feb 22, 2024 at 01:11 AM · View previous versions
Feb 22, 2024 at 12:51 AM
jaygould
Offline
Details
p.5 #9New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
I wish we'd see some more lenses for E mount instead. These two + the new 28mm would be great.
Feb 22, 2024 at 12:54 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.5 #10New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
rico wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteThe purpose of the metal pole for the Type II style is still unclear to me. Usually such poles are used for an infinity lock, but it seems it might just be an aesthetic component for the new lens.
Whether designed with infinity lock, or not, the metal post typically prevents the head of these simple-helix lenses from unscrewing off the mount. There should be a focus tab on the reverse side of the barrel but all product images I found are from the front side only. At nearest focus, the tab hits the post and stops rotating. The post can be unscrewed to allow lens servicing.


There is no focus tab on the Type II (nor Type I) lens actually. The product introduction video shows the lens full rotation of the focus helicoid from around 4:00 to 4:09.
Feb 22, 2024 at 01:22 AM
fjablo
Online
Details
p.5 #11New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
The rotating aperture ring of the type ii 50/3.5 would drive me absolutely nuts..

Quirky ergonomics in true Cosina fashion
Feb 22, 2024 at 01:27 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.5 #12New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
philip_pj wrote:
Do we have a block diagram for the 50/3.5 yet? 150 grams means the TI would never stay home. Seeing what they managed with the 5/3 Heliar, the 8/6 of this one, and its glass types are of interest. The Heliar has 10 blades and shares the same AOV equal to 51mm.

A good video, it highlights the clever internal flange for the 50/3.5 (2:40). I'd worry about dust ingress if it collapsed, that is a lengthy surface to keep clean.

The Type I near-body focus ring might suit sone users better than the Type II setup. The closer MFD Type II
...Show more →

I haven't seen any block diagram for the new 50/3.5 yet. The 75/1.5 mirrorless lens introduction videos showed the block diagram probably because it's same as 75/1.5 VM but for the new 50/3.5 and 50/2.2 there is no such data shown yet. Probably have to wait for official release announcement for that (which would normally come about 1 month prior to actual launch date).
Feb 22, 2024 at 01:42 AM
hanay78
Offline
Details
p.5 #13New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
But the real contender maybe is the heliar 50/3.5? I mean if one likes, or do not mind, the front element turning like type II, then the heliar should be the real contender...

From what I have shown I hope I will be able to get type I when it reaches the market. Lets hope it likes Sony sensor

Fred Miranda wrote:
rscheffler wrote
Fred Miranda wroteThank you for sharing these videos, Juha! They've answered most of our questions. From what I gathered from the auto-translation, Cosina decided to keep the 50/3.5 Type I extended because collapsing it wouldn't really add any extra functionality, except for making it more compact when not in use.

However, if they had made it collapsible, there would always be a risk of small vibrations and airflow, potentially allowing dust to get inside the lens. It seems like the decision was made to preserve the aesthetics of the past and avoid these potential issues. Personally, I prefer the slimmer Type II for the insane 0.35m MFD, even though it means the filters would rotate with focusing, like polarizers.
I don't quite buy the apparent reasoning behind not making it collapsible. The whole point of a collapsible design, its sole functional reason, is to be more compact when not in use. And this slow 50/3.5 is quite long for a 50mm design, therefore it would really benefit from a collapsible design. Based on the design of the Leica 90/4 Macro, the whole optical assembly is inside the tube that collapses - there is no internal movement of elements to facilitate this capability, therefore there wouldn't be structural changes that would increase the opportunity for dust ingress.

Whatever the case, if I was to get this lens, my preference would be type 1 simply for the non-rotating aperture and filter rings and the raised red dot. I also think the design looks quite nice, particularly in panda, just that collapsibility would have made it that much more practical.

Looking forward to seeing how these new 50s stack up!
Cosina likely anticipated that there would be questions about this and addressed it in the video. Personally, I would have preferred if the Type I featured collapsibility. I'm very curious about their performance and will be comparing them to the Voigtlander 50/2 APO-Lanthar.


Feb 22, 2024 at 02:48 AM
ISO1600
Online
Details
p.5 #14New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
Is it safe to assume the quick artsy skit at the end of the 50/2.2 video was shot with the lens? If so, I do like the look from it!
Feb 22, 2024 at 04:08 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.5 #15New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
ISO1600 wrote:
Is it safe to assume the quick artsy skit at the end of the 50/2.2 video was shot with the lens? If so, I do like the look from it!


No, they reuse the same intro and outro sequences (from a pool of a few options) with their product introduction videos again and again and those must have been produced a couple of years ago.
Feb 22, 2024 at 04:18 AM
ISO1600
Online
Details
p.5 #16New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
dang!
Feb 22, 2024 at 04:26 AM
CookieDough14
Offline
Details
p.5 #17New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
sselhtrim wrote:
Wonder if the time is ripe for them to produce a new moderate speed 21mm, with less field curvature...


Holy shit yes. The venerable ZM 21mm f2.8 is the only non Leica representative in this space and if Cosina can release either a 21mm f2.8 at half the size or a ZM 21mm f2 at the same size. Those would be instant wins.
Feb 22, 2024 at 04:41 AM
mboy
Offline
Details
p.5 #18New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
So can someone tell me why Cosina showing Zeiss products on their website? Does Cosina have a partnership or rights to manufacture Zeiss lenses?
Feb 22, 2024 at 06:36 AM
DrThomasUttich
Online
Details
p.5 #19New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
@mboy all current Zeiss branded M-lenses are produced by Cosina – at least the the Zeiss C Biogon T* 2.8/35 ZM on my shelf 😊

Edited on Feb 22, 2024 at 06:46 AM · View previous versions
Feb 22, 2024 at 06:46 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.5 #20New Cosina Voigtländer 50/3.5 APO & 50/2.2 VM announcement
mboy wrote:
So can someone tell me why Cosina showing Zeiss products on their website? Does Cosina have a partnership or rights to manufacture Zeiss lenses?


Cosina is the manufacturer of Zeiss Otus, Milvus, Classic and ZM line lenses and they are also the distributor of those lines in Japan market.
Feb 22, 2024 at 06:46 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister