fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Post your R5 Images Here

  
 
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.56 #1Post your R5 Images Here
...few more



















Oct 11, 2020 at 01:42 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.56 #2Post your R5 Images Here
RobAmy wrote:
Nothing scientific here but me and Amy where standing close to one another and shot this Cormorant this morning. I was in crop mode and Amy was full frame. I cropped her's to a similar size and processed both. Her image held up very well. Her's is almost cropped 50%. We had different settings because we did not do this as a test but interesting none the less. In PS full size 24x16 we both agree mine looks a little better. Hers looks a little over sharpened in full size.

Her's is the second image. She was at 1/1000 • f/6.3
...Show more →

Hey Rob...were these both R5 shots or was Amy shooting her 1DXIII? I was confused what we were trying to compare here. I would think crop mode vs crop in post would be identical if these were both R5??
Oct 11, 2020 at 02:10 PM
bobbytan
Offline
Details
p.56 #3Post your R5 Images Here
Sweet set ... especially the first and last one!

arbitrage wrote:
...few more

Oct 11, 2020 at 02:14 PM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.56 #4Post your R5 Images Here
arbitrage wrote:
Why would there be any difference between in camera crop mode vs crop in post??

There is no difference. Just run a simple test at home shooting anything you desire.


I was wondering this too, not sure if Dave misunderstood I did it with different cameras not 2 R5's.

Oct 11, 2020 at 02:20 PM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.56 #5Post your R5 Images Here
arbitrage wrote:
RobAmy wroteNothing scientific here but me and Amy where standing close to one another and shot this Cormorant this morning. I was in crop mode and Amy was full frame. I cropped her's to a similar size and processed both. Her image held up very well. Her's is almost cropped 50%. We had different settings because we did not do this as a test but interesting none the less. In PS full size 24x16 we both agree mine looks a little better. Hers looks a little over sharpened in full size.

Her's is the second image. She was at 1/1000 • f/6.3 • ISO 1250. I was at 1/1600 • f/5.6 • ISO 1250
Hey Rob...were these both R5 shots or was Amy shooting her 1DXIII? I was confused what we were trying to compare here. I would think crop mode vs crop in post would be identical if these were both R5??


Yes 2 different cameras, sorry for the confusion, Amy used the 1dx and I used the R5. I was in crop mode with the R5 and Amy was full frame with the 1dx and cropped in to match. I never seen a difference in the R5 files with crop mode vs cropping.

Oct 11, 2020 at 02:24 PM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.56 #6Post your R5 Images Here
lighthound wrote:
RobAmy wrote
lighthound wrote
RobAmy wrote
lighthound wroteInteresting and thanks for posting these Rob.
I have to say, I see very little difference between the birds at this size but Amy's eye looks a little sharper to me. But look at the difference between the oof BG. Yours is smoother and less blotchy.
Were they both processed the same? Same lenses?
Yes processed the same and same lenses. Different lenses but the same lens both 400mm f2.8 with the 2x. Yes this size is tough but in full size mine does pull away. Her's does look sharper smaller, she had a bit better DOF too at f6.3.
Do you think the BG differences we see is caused from the 5.6 to 6.3? I guess it would being that all else is equal. Same PPD from one to the other so I wouldn't think cropping in post vs camera would cause any difference.
It could be but I noticed when processing the 1dx files I do see blotchy areas when the noise goes up a bit over the R5, more so in the green colors. I think Pius noted that early on with his files too with the 1dx.
As long as we're at it. I just ran across a test I did myself while shooting elk. Hold on a minute or twelve and I'll post up my in camera crop and post FF crop to match. Will be interesting to see if there are any similarities.

eh, I don't think there is much to learn from my images. Not enough up close detail like your birds.
First image is in camera crop mode full size. Second image is FF cropped to match the first image.
No sharpening or NR applied. Just processed and resized in PS the same
...Show more →

Sorry Dave for the confusion, I was using different cameras, not 2 R5's. My mistake for not explaining that better.

Oct 11, 2020 at 02:32 PM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.56 #7Post your R5 Images Here
RobAmy wrote:
lighthound wrote
RobAmy wrote
lighthound wrote
RobAmy wrote
lighthound wroteInteresting and thanks for posting these Rob.
I have to say, I see very little difference between the birds at this size but Amy's eye looks a little sharper to me. But look at the difference between the oof BG. Yours is smoother and less blotchy.
Were they both processed the same? Same lenses?
Yes processed the same and same lenses. Different lenses but the same lens both 400mm f2.8 with the 2x. Yes this size is tough but in full size mine does pull away. Her's does look sharper smaller, she had a bit better DOF too at f6.3.
Do you think the BG differences we see is caused from the 5.6 to 6.3? I guess it would being that all else is equal. Same PPD from one to the other so I wouldn't think cropping in post vs camera would cause any difference.
It could be but I noticed when processing the 1dx files I do see blotchy areas when the noise goes up a bit over the R5, more so in the green colors. I think Pius noted that early on with his files too with the 1dx.
As long as we're at it. I just ran across a test I did myself while shooting elk. Hold on a minute or twelve and I'll post up my in camera crop and post FF crop to match. Will be interesting to see if there are any similarities.

eh, I don't think there is much to learn from my images. Not enough up close detail like your birds.
First image is in camera crop mode full size. Second image is FF cropped to match the first image.
No sharpening or NR applied. Just processed and resized in PS the same 24x16. I didn't apply the Lens profile correction in LR to either of them.
Sorry Dave for the confusion, I was using different cameras, not 2 R5's. My mistake for not explaining that better.



Ha! No need to be sorry, that was my mistake. For some reason I thought you were comparing your R5's and I didn't catch the different bodies in your comment. Carry on.




Canon EOS R5
EF500mm f/4L IS II USM
ƒ/4.0 500mm 1/500 ISO2000



Elk calf by Dave Wenner, on Flickr


Elk calves by Dave Wenner, on Flickr


Elk calves sharing food by Dave Wenner, on Flickr


Elk calf frisky 1 by Dave Wenner, on Flickr
Oct 11, 2020 at 03:08 PM
Littlefield
Offline
Details
p.56 #8Post your R5 Images Here
Oct 11, 2020 at 03:40 PM
mdvaden
Offline
Details
p.56 #9Post your R5 Images Here
lighthound wrote:
Canon EOS R5
EF500mm f/4L IS II USM
ƒ/4.0 500mm 1/500 ISO2000


That lens gives a very nice dreamy look from that distance.

Oct 11, 2020 at 07:38 PM
bwhip62
Offline
Details
Oct 11, 2020 at 08:41 PM
armd
Offline
Details
p.56 #11Post your R5 Images Here
Yes, it's been a quiet and dull day here too. Drove a distance to a wildlife refuge and everything was too far away even at 1000mm. Popped on the 100-400 and took a few portraits when a couple of Ring Billed gulls seemed interested in what I was doing. They wanted in for a bit of fun so I obliged...














Oct 11, 2020 at 08:49 PM
mdvaden
Offline
Details
p.56 #12Post your R5 Images Here
SpeedyB wrote:
Here's one of a plain ol House Finch but was able to approach at MFD with the 600mm IS iii and 1.4x (handheld).
.


Looks good in the blue spruce. What was the background? Rock? Wall of a building? Or just the smoke you were talking about? Good combo of colors though.

Oct 11, 2020 at 09:19 PM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.56 #13Post your R5 Images Here
mdvaden wrote:
lighthound wroteCanon EOS R5
EF500mm f/4L IS II USM
ƒ/4.0 500mm 1/500 ISO2000
That lens gives a very nice dreamy look from that distance.



It's not necessarily the lens that caused that effect. I did shoot wo @ f4 but most of the soft dreamy effect is coming from the FG and was from me getting down low in the grass. I got plenty of strange looks from others that were standing there, but I really liked the results.
Oct 12, 2020 at 08:57 AM
Tom In Arizona
Offline
Details
p.56 #14Post your R5 Images Here
Gambel's Quail...






Oct 12, 2020 at 09:41 AM
Littlefield
Offline
Details
p.56 #16Post your R5 Images Here
Oct 12, 2020 at 03:05 PM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.56 #17Post your R5 Images Here
Canon R5, 600 III + x2 1200mmm

Oct 12, 2020 at 07:48 PM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.56 #18Post your R5 Images Here
arbitrage wrote:
The 400DOII featured in that set was generously loaned to me by Mr. Sullivan for the day. I came away with mixed feelings about the lens' performance. I'm no stranger to the 400DOII but I could not pull off a sharp shot to save my life with the 2xTC on the lens and shooting in APS-C mode. I think the 400DOII/2xTC and high-pixel density is not a good combination. It seems to only do good at short distances. I'm sort of racking my brain to think if that was more than likely the case even when I owned it. I
...Show more →

Your experiences here match my feelings about the 400DOII exactly. If Canon comes with an APS-C version of the R5 in future, I will likely add Canon to the Nikon D500+500PF, but it will not be with the 400DOII again. I will go for the 500/4, so I won't need the 2.0TC for reach. On the 7DII, the 400DOII+2.0TC still looked very good for closer distances, but going out a bit further it crumbled.
Oct 13, 2020 at 05:16 AM
Miko_Skye
Offline
Details
p.56 #19Post your R5 Images Here
A bit more out in my local area, still more testing and getting familiar with the camera.

400mm 2x (800mm) 1/1000th @ f6.3 ISO 3200


400mm 2x (800mm) 1/1250th @ f6.3 ISO 320


400mm 2x (800mm) 1/2500th @ f6.3 ISO 1000


400mm 2x (800mm) 1/4000th @ f6.3 ISO 1600


400mm 2x (800mm) 1/320th @ f6.3 ISO 4000


70mm 1/320th @ f2.8 ISO 2500






Oct 13, 2020 at 07:50 AM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.56 #20Post your R5 Images Here
ChrisMak wrote:
arbitrage wroteThe 400DOII featured in that set was generously loaned to me by Mr. Sullivan for the day. I came away with mixed feelings about the lens' performance. I'm no stranger to the 400DOII but I could not pull off a sharp shot to save my life with the 2xTC on the lens and shooting in APS-C mode. I think the 400DOII/2xTC and high-pixel density is not a good combination. It seems to only do good at short distances. I'm sort of racking my brain to think if that was more than likely the case even when I owned it. I do know it never performed well on my 5DSR trying to "reach" out over water...same thing yesterday.

It has me thinking that I'm more likely to look towards a 400III or wait it out for an RF supertele vs looking for a used 400DOII to buy.

The 400DOII was doing pretty good with the 1.4TC and things got better as subjects were closer (of course every lens does better with that).
Your experiences here match my feelings about the 400DOII exactly. If Canon comes with an APS-C version of the R5 in future, I will likely add Canon to the Nikon D500+500PF, but it will not be with the 400DOII again. I will go for the 500/4, so I won't need the 2.0TC for reach. On the 7DII, the 400DOII+2.0TC still looked very good for closer distances, but going out a bit further it crumbled.


That's been my experience with every lens, closer you are the better the detail regardless 400 DO II or whatever. As for the R5 it has a 1.6 crop mode. Especially with TC's shooting over a long distance...
Oct 13, 2020 at 11:16 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister