fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020R5/6 lag/blackout

  
 
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.9 #1R5/6 lag/blackout


NissanPatrol wrote:
arbitrage wroteI feel I should spin a bit of positivity back into this discussion and play the glass is half full view a little as I've mostly been looking for glass half empty things over the past week....

What we know is the R5/R6 scan speeds are much better than any Canon camera before (except 1DXIII). We also know they are much faster than other competitors like Nikon Z and Sony A7RIV.

I own and shoot with Nikon Z50 and Sony A7RIV with their very slow scan speeds.
Even with those much slower scan speeds, I've successfully used shutter modes both with frame insertion and with mechanical shutter to shoot BIF successfully. I've also "cheated" and used ES to shoot BIF and come away unscathed many times...ie I couldn't find any noticeable distorted wings etc in my larger BIF. Most times it really takes small/fast BIF to start to see the wonky distortion.

Therefore, even if the R5/R6 aren't up to the 1/160 (6ms) scan times of the A9, I think that for the vast majority of shooting, even for a lot of action and BIF, that the camera will be totally useable both in mechanical and ES. I think when I pick up the R5, I will just try and shoot it in ES all the time until I start to notice wonkiness in my images. Of course I will avoid ES for hummingbirds but for the rest like even for ducks IF I will give ES a try and see how often it ruins a shot or not.

I'm now tempting myself to put my pre-order back in....only live once and with this world these days that may not be as long as one would hope for....
You are justifying to yourself spending the money 😄

True you can take real good bif pictures with the z7 and the z50 and sure that the canon r5 can take excellent bif pictures, but the question can the R5 have the same performance of the a9/ii, and can the canon r5 succeed in scoring the same number of keepers with eratic subjects?

That remains to be answered by real world trial.

But I am happy if you buy one 😄 at least I can get a trustworthy real world review


Yes I’m an expert at that
Jul 17, 2020 at 01:03 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.9 #2R5/6 lag/blackout
Don't know if this is real mechanical but I sure hope so.

Jul 17, 2020 at 01:23 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.9 #3R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
NissanPatrol wrote
arbitrage wroteI feel I should spin a bit of positivity back into this discussion and play the glass is half full view a little as I've mostly been looking for glass half empty things over the past week....

What we know is the R5/R6 scan speeds are much better than any Canon camera before (except 1DXIII). We also know they are much faster than other competitors like Nikon Z and Sony A7RIV.

I own and shoot with Nikon Z50 and Sony A7RIV with their very slow scan speeds.
Even with those much slower scan speeds, I've successfully used shutter modes both with frame insertion and with mechanical shutter to shoot BIF successfully. I've also "cheated" and used ES to shoot BIF and come away unscathed many times...ie I couldn't find any noticeable distorted wings etc in my larger BIF. Most times it really takes small/fast BIF to start to see the wonky distortion.

Therefore, even if the R5/R6 aren't up to the 1/160 (6ms) scan times of the A9, I think that for the vast majority of shooting, even for a lot of action and BIF, that the camera will be totally useable both in mechanical and ES. I think when I pick up the R5, I will just try and shoot it in ES all the time until I start to notice wonkiness in my images. Of course I will avoid ES for hummingbirds but for the rest like even for ducks IF I will give ES a try and see how often it ruins a shot or not.

I'm now tempting myself to put my pre-order back in....only live once and with this world these days that may not be as long as one would hope for....
You are justifying to yourself spending the money 😄

True you can take real good bif pictures with the z7 and the z50 and sure that the canon r5 can take excellent bif pictures, but the question can the R5 have the same performance of the a9/ii, and can the canon r5 succeed in scoring the same number of keepers with eratic subjects?

That remains to be answered by real world trial.

But I am happy if you buy one 😄 at least I can get a trustworthy real world review
Yes I’m an expert at that


Me too. This is little like professional wrestling. One gets pummelled for 30 minutes and then has a miraculous recovery and wins the day.
Jul 17, 2020 at 01:33 PM
bobbytan
Offline
Details
p.9 #4R5/6 lag/blackout
Shutter sound of the R5. The mechanical shutter is loud compared to Sony cameras.

Jul 17, 2020 at 02:40 PM
Geoff Hui
Offline
Details
p.9 #5R5/6 lag/blackout
Some action shots from the R6

Jul 17, 2020 at 03:21 PM
bobbytan
Offline
Details
p.9 #6R5/6 lag/blackout
At the 1:50 mark the guys says it's f5.6 at 400mm.

Geoff Hui wrote:
Some action shots from the R6



Jul 17, 2020 at 04:17 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.9 #7R5/6 lag/blackout


Zenon Char wrote:
Don't know if this is real mechanical but I sure hope so.


I couldn’t find anywhere in that video showing the EVF or LCD but I only scrubbed through it real fast on my phone. Everything I saw was either video footage or still images from the shoot. Is there a time stamp you saw the EVF feed at??
Jul 17, 2020 at 04:25 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.9 #8R5/6 lag/blackout


bobbytan wrote:
At the 1:50 mark the guys says it's f5.6 at 400mm.

Geoff Hui wroteSome action shots from the R6


It is if you set the camera to half stops. But either way the camera is likely rounding down at 1/2 stops and up at 1/3 stops. Most likely 400mm is truly around f/6 or so.
Jul 17, 2020 at 04:27 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.9 #9R5/6 lag/blackout
bobbytan wrote:
Shutter sound of the R5. The mechanical shutter is loud compared to Sony cameras.



Good. I want to scare off coyotes, etc and for what I'm about to spend I want people around me to say wow.
Jul 17, 2020 at 04:30 PM
bobbytan
Offline
Details
p.9 #10R5/6 lag/blackout
He didn't say anything about have to change the exposure compensation increments to 1/2 stop. Maybe it's f5.6 with the R6?

arbitrage wrote:
bobbytan wroteAt the 1:50 mark the guys says it's f5.6 at 400mm.

Geoff Hui wroteSome action shots from the R6

It is if you set the camera to half stops. But either way the camera is likely rounding down at 1/2 stops and up at 1/3 stops. Most likely 400mm is truly around f/6 or so.


Jul 17, 2020 at 04:31 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.9 #11R5/6 lag/blackout


bobbytan wrote:
He didn't say anything about have to change the exposure compensation increments to 1/2 stop. Maybe it's f5.6 with the R6?

arbitrage wrote
bobbytan wroteAt the 1:50 mark the guys says it's f5.6 at 400mm.

Geoff Hui wroteSome action shots from the R6

It is if you set the camera to half stops. But either way the camera is likely rounding down at 1/2 stops and up at 1/3 stops. Most likely 400mm is truly around f/6 or so.

Or more likely he is just regurgitating the Canon provided spec sheet as many early sponsored reviews were doing and never really tested like Cameralabs did. Regardless, every zoom in existence is cheating on both focal length and aperture so I can’t see it mattering at all. I don’t see why the R6 would make a difference?
Jul 17, 2020 at 04:42 PM
Jonesy
Offline
Details
p.9 #12R5/6 lag/blackout
Very responsive! I was very impressed with it. Feels much better in the hand and the af and tracking felt great! It made me excited to shoot with it. The joystick was very fast to change the af points also.
Can’t wait to get mine
kezeka wrote:
Jonesy wroteI shot with the R5 today, and to be honest with you I didn't even notice any blackout when shooting 12fps.
How responsive was the shutter? Did it feel delayed or like it lagged at all? Any other thoughts after having held it in hand?

Jul 17, 2020 at 05:05 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.9 #13R5/6 lag/blackout
Jonesy wrote:
Very responsive! I was very impressed with it. Feels much better in the hand and the af and tracking felt great! It made me excited to shoot with it. The joystick was very fast to change the af points also.
Can’t wait to get mine
kezeka wrote
Jonesy wroteI shot with the R5 today, and to be honest with you I didn't even notice any blackout when shooting 12fps.
How responsive was the shutter? Did it feel delayed or like it lagged at all? Any other thoughts after having held it in hand?


Hopefully you can also use the LCD to move the AF point/s around. I didn't miss the joystick with the R. LCD is faster.
Jul 17, 2020 at 05:14 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.9 #14R5/6 lag/blackout


Zenon Char wrote:
Jonesy wroteVery responsive! I was very impressed with it. Feels much better in the hand and the af and tracking felt great! It made me excited to shoot with it. The joystick was very fast to change the af points also.
Can’t wait to get mine
kezeka wrote
Jonesy wroteI shot with the R5 today, and to be honest with you I didn't even notice any blackout when shooting 12fps.
How responsive was the shutter? Did it feel delayed or like it lagged at all? Any other thoughts after having held it in hand?
Hopefully you can also use the LCD to move the AF point/s around. I didn't miss the joystick with the R. LCD is faster.

Yes that is still available as an option if you don’t want to use the joystick. The joystick has options to change how fast it reacts to a given movement which should be pretty slick. Would have loved to see the 1DXIII AF-ON button with sensor but I guess they had to save something for the R1X.
Jul 17, 2020 at 05:27 PM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.9 #15R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
I don't recall seeing this video before even though it was 4 days ago.
At the 10:45 mark you can see his settings are ES, H+ (20FPS) and AI Servo. There is a blackout after the shot. But I think what this is is when you stop a burst you get that "blackout"...actually not really a blackout but just a stutter which I think is the camera coming out of the blackout free slideshow it does while you hold the shutter down and do a burst. Basically the 20FPS ES mode is blackout free with very fast frame insertion and then
...Show more →

Geoff, I had a look at the 10:45 mark and that's not blackout, I figured out how to solve that problem when I was shooting RW blackbirds with my 1dx III in live-view... My biggest concern is how does it perform with EF lenses and distortion with electronic shutter. EF lenses are at the top of my list, should be for every wildlife / sports photographer. Image review is on, think default is 2 sec's... turn off in first menu tab under # 3. You probably have to do that with Sony or the last photo in the burst stays in your EVF... You can leave image review on but you would have to keep the back-button pushed down when you let go the shutter button to continue tracking your subject in real time but if you release both buttons the image will review on the screen for set amount of secs. I don't have the R5 or R6 but I'm almost positive that's the problem.... Those Canon testers need some training.... "joking"

Edited on Jul 18, 2020 at 12:50 AM · View previous versions
Jul 18, 2020 at 12:31 AM
Mike Jacks0n
Offline
Details
p.9 #16R5/6 lag/blackout
Not sure if anyone mentioned it, but in the video linked above at the 3:00 mark he does say, "All you see is a little white box...", in regards to what he sees when using the e-shutter.

Jul 18, 2020 at 12:37 AM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.9 #17R5/6 lag/blackout
Mike Jacks0n wrote:
Not sure if anyone mentioned it, but in the video linked above at the 3:00 mark he does say, "All you see is a little white box...", in regards to what he sees when using the e-shutter.



That's all you see, just the white rectangle blinking in E-shutter mode, same on the 1dx III.
Jul 18, 2020 at 12:44 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.9 #18R5/6 lag/blackout
Pius Sullivan wrote:
arbitrage wroteI don't recall seeing this video before even though it was 4 days ago.
At the 10:45 mark you can see his settings are ES, H+ (20FPS) and AI Servo. There is a blackout after the shot. But I think what this is is when you stop a burst you get that "blackout"...actually not really a blackout but just a stutter which I think is the camera coming out of the blackout free slideshow it does while you hold the shutter down and do a burst. Basically the 20FPS ES mode is blackout free with very fast frame insertion and then when you stop your burst you get that "jump" as it goes back to real time view. At least that is how I see it working.

Caveat: the above is on R6. You can also see earlier in the video a lot of rolling shutter when he tests panning shooting a straight pole.

On a positive note, the bird tracking looks phenomenal!!

Geoff, I had a look at the 10:45 mark and that's not blackout, I figured out how to solve that problem when I was shooting RW blackbirds with my 1dx III in live-view... My biggest concern is how does it perform with EF lenses and distortion with electronic shutter. EF lenses are at the top of my list, should be for every wildlife / sports photographer. Image review is on, think default is 2 sec's... turn off in first menu tab under # 3. You probably have to do that with Sony or the last photo in the burst
...Show more →

Good call...yes that makes sense...I forgot about that as I didn't think anyone would be stupid enough to leave that on....
Jul 18, 2020 at 06:19 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.9 #19R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
Zenon Char wroteDon't know if this is real mechanical but I sure hope so.

I couldn’t find anywhere in that video showing the EVF or LCD but I only scrubbed through it real fast on my phone. Everything I saw was either video footage or still images from the shoot. Is there a time stamp you saw the EVF feed at??


I think you are correct.
Jul 18, 2020 at 06:57 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.9 #20R5/6 lag/blackout
Mike Jacks0n wrote:
Not sure if anyone mentioned it, but in the video linked above at the 3:00 mark he does say, "All you see is a little white box...", in regards to what he sees when using the e-shutter.



There have been several actual videos of the actual LCD showing no blackout and white box using E shutter so at this point I'm convinced. We just need to know if the EVF 120 fps or Smooth setting will do what it says.
Jul 18, 2020 at 07:00 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister