fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020R5/6 lag/blackout

  
 
Tony5787
Offline
Details
p.3 #1R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
The Sony A9 II was released in 2019.


For all intents and purposes, it’s the same camera as the a9 was. It is surprising that nobody else, even Sony, has adopted a stacked sensor for a MILC besides the a9/a9 II at this point. That seems to be changing with the a7s II successor but I almost wonder if Canon is just waiting to solve rolling shutter issues with the eventual implementation of global shutter.
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:15 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.3 #2R5/6 lag/blackout
Tony5787 wrote:
Zenon Char wroteThe Sony A9 II was released in 2019.
For all intents and purposes, it’s the same camera as the a9 was. It is surprising that nobody else, even Sony, has adopted a stacked sensor for a MILC besides the a9/a9 II at this point. That seems to be changing with the a7s II successor but I almost wonder if Canon is just waiting to solve rolling shutter issues with the eventual implementation of global shutter.


If so why did Sony release the A9 II and why would people pay more for it.
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:17 AM
Tony5787
Offline
Details
p.3 #3R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
Tony5787 wrote
Zenon Char wroteThe Sony A9 II was released in 2019.
For all intents and purposes, it’s the same camera as the a9 was. It is surprising that nobody else, even Sony, has adopted a stacked sensor for a MILC besides the a9/a9 II at this point. That seems to be changing with the a7s II successor but I almost wonder if Canon is just waiting to solve rolling shutter issues with the eventual implementation of global shutter.
If so why did Sony release the A9 II and why would people pay more for it.


It has minor upgrades for working pros like dual UHS-II slots, faster burst speed with the mechanical shutter (which to me is irrelevant with either the a9 or a9 II), gigabit Ethernet, and an upgraded processor which, right now seems to have a minimal effect on AF performance but will probably see more benefits in firmware updates. As far as the sensor tech is concerned though they’re identical.

Also let’s be real, Sony could have released the exact same camera with the different ergonomics and a “II” on it and people are going to buy it just to have the latest and greatest
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:30 AM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.3 #4R5/6 lag/blackout
a9 is what i am talking about. a9II is same.

Zenon Char wrote:
The Sony A9 II was released in 2019.

nandadevieast wroteIts amazing that a camera created 4 years ago is still the camera to beat.

arbitrage wrote
Andrew J wroteAgain, on my M6II and 90d(in mirrorless mode) ZERO blackout as long as I keep the shutter button half pressed. Not that hard really.
I'm not sure if we are talking about the same thing? With shutter half-pressed you aren't taking shots. I'm talking about when actively shooting. But if what you mean is that as long as you take shots and then just release to half way (and not all the way off the shutter) then you don't see blackout then yeah that is how the 1DXIII is and I believe how the R5/R6 are. BUT it is frame insertion...you are seeing the past, not the present (nor future ). EVFs are always somewhat showing the past even when you aren't firing away because there is always some small lag to get the signal processed and into the EVF. This is why a common criticism of EVFs is they are difficult to react to say a bird launching from a perch...you may think you reacted in time but the inherent EVF delay made you miss.

But with frame insertion you are delaying even more than the EVF signal processing delay. To my knowledge only the A9 is showing an actual live feed while shooting without blackout. Cameras in mechanical mode show a live feed while shooting at certain FPS (ie the A7RIV shows a live feed up to H but not H+) but you of course see the natural shutter blackout.

When you are trying to track a swallow, darting and changing direction at random, any type of frame insertion while actively firing will severely hamper your results. It can still be done, I shoot swallows with the A7RIV and at H+ (10FPS) which has mechanical shutter blackout and frame insertion. But the success is many times lower than the A9 in e-shutter.

Anyone interested in how the R5/R6 will look in e-shutter at 20FPS can watch the Fro video where he recorded the direct feed via the Atmos while shooting basketball here:



FWIW, I think whatever they are doing looks pretty darn good and probably fine to track moving subjects with. But I'd have to try it out myself to see. Regardless, being stuck at 20FPS is a big negative for me.

Jul 11, 2020 at 08:41 AM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.3 #5R5/6 lag/blackout
Point was that a9 debuted stacked sensor and no back out ‘real’ finder on an EVF based camera. That is yet to be surpassed. Canon as well as Nikon will eventually catch up there is no doubt. R5 II perhaps will get there.

Tony5787 wrote:
Zenon Char wroteThe Sony A9 II was released in 2019.
For all intents and purposes, it’s the same camera as the a9 was. It is surprising that nobody else, even Sony, has adopted a stacked sensor for a MILC besides the a9/a9 II at this point. That seems to be changing with the a7s II successor but I almost wonder if Canon is just waiting to solve rolling shutter issues with the eventual implementation of global shutter.

Jul 11, 2020 at 08:47 AM
Andrew J
Offline
Details
p.3 #6R5/6 lag/blackout
........you mean is that as long as you take shots and then just release to half way (and not all the way off the shutter) then you don't see blackout then yeah that is how the 1DXIII is and I believe how the R5/R6 are. BUT it is frame insertion...snip
----------------------------------
Yes, that is what I mean. So the problem you have is that I am back in time one or two shots? So what? I am getting all poses that everyone else does. This looks to me like when during a live stream chatters said "Lee, your chat lags 1 second. He said "so what? I am seeing everything you see who cares"? I have the same answer here.
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:57 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.3 #7R5/6 lag/blackout
Yes but he wasn't comparing the 1DXII to a 4 year old camera. He was comparing it to a A9 II which is shown on the top of the video. I don't know much about Sony but they must have made some improvements to justify releasing it. I think it is fair to the readers to say it is a one year old camera. Until the Fro releases the same back to back test with the 1DXIII and the A9 we don't really know what the differences might be.

nandadevieast wrote:
Point was that a9 debuted stacked sensor and no back out ‘real’ finder on an EVF based camera. That is yet to be surpassed. Canon as well as Nikon will eventually catch up there is no doubt. R5 II perhaps will get there.

Tony5787 wrote
Zenon Char wroteThe Sony A9 II was released in 2019.
For all intents and purposes, it’s the same camera as the a9 was. It is surprising that nobody else, even Sony, has adopted a stacked sensor for a MILC besides the a9/a9 II at this point. That seems to be changing with the a7s II successor but I almost wonder if Canon is just waiting to solve rolling shutter issues with the eventual implementation of global shutter.


Jul 11, 2020 at 09:00 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.3 #8R5/6 lag/blackout
Andrew J wrote:
........you mean is that as long as you take shots and then just release to half way (and not all the way off the shutter) then you don't see blackout then yeah that is how the 1DXIII is and I believe how the R5/R6 are. BUT it is frame insertion...snip
----------------------------------
Yes, that is what I mean. So the problem you have is that I am back in time one or two shots? So what? I am getting all poses that everyone else does. This looks to me like when during a live stream chatters said "Lee, your chat lags
...Show more →

That would be the same as using the BFF.
Jul 11, 2020 at 09:01 AM
Tony5787
Offline
Details
p.3 #9R5/6 lag/blackout
Andrew J wrote:
........you mean is that as long as you take shots and then just release to half way (and not all the way off the shutter) then you don't see blackout then yeah that is how the 1DXIII is and I believe how the R5/R6 are. BUT it is frame insertion...snip
----------------------------------
Yes, that is what I mean. So the problem you have is that I am back in time one or two shots? So what? I am getting all poses that everyone else does. This looks to me like when during a live stream chatters said "Lee, your chat lags
...Show more →

That’s true if the subject is traveling in a predictable fashion but if it’s erratic or suddenly changes direction, it could take several frames before you’re able to reliably track it again.
Jul 11, 2020 at 09:48 AM
tiggy
Offline
Details
p.3 #10R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
I only ever go to 20FPS when I really need it. If I was stuck in 20FPS every time I wanted e-shutter (which would be all the time possible) that is a big negative to me. I hope Canon can FW update that to let us have options for lower FPS in e-shutter.


It's simple: you just touch the shutter button gently every other 100ms to get 5 fps, etc.
- RoboTig
Jul 11, 2020 at 11:07 AM
tiggy
Offline
Details
p.3 #11R5/6 lag/blackout
Two comments:

1) The delay caused by frame insertion isn't just a consistent delay. In most implementations, it gets worse over time, so if you have a 4-second-long burst, you might find at the end that the bird isn't in your frame for the latter pictures. It all depends on execution, and we won't really be able to know this about the R5 until someone capable of stressing the camera with close BIF panning lets us know. Interestingly, at 20 fps, this might be worse than at the R's 3 fps.

2) Until very, very recently, I owned both the A9 and A9 II. The II was worth it to me to upgrade primarily because of the doubling of the mechanical shutter fps, and the ergonomic improvements. If you were looking for anything else, you wouldn't really find it. It was really the "A9.1," not the A9 II. My hope was that the vastly increased processing capacity would be employed for some future firmware magic, but that hasn't materialized. For the purposes of discussing the shutter stuff, I don't think there is any improvement in the II, or at least none I noticed. I think it's fair to say that the A9 is remarkable in its unique stacked sensor features that remain on top for an entire camera generation. For those of us seeking such things, it's been an interesting journey, with a few people - like Arbitrage - making it in common.
Jul 11, 2020 at 11:25 AM
bipock
Offline
Details
p.3 #12R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
Not sure it mechanical or electronic. Minute 3:21




To me, I see a one time blackout right at the beginning then it looks really smooth from there. That's a personal opinion though.

Having used the R when it was first released as well as more recently with the updated firmware, it's not the blackout that's bad, it's the lag behind of the action. The R was atrocious for this at first, but firmware updates have made it better. My 1DxIIIs in live view are significantly better. Of course, I would rarely, if ever, use live view for real action.
Jul 11, 2020 at 11:32 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.3 #13R5/6 lag/blackout
bipock wrote:
Zenon Char wroteNot sure it mechanical or electronic. Minute 3:21

To me, I see a one time blackout right at the beginning then it looks really smooth from there. That's a personal opinion though.

Having used the R when it was first released as well as more recently with the updated firmware, it's not the blackout that's bad, it's the lag behind of the action. The R was atrocious for this at first, but firmware updates have made it better. My 1DxIIIs in live view are significantly better. Of course, I would rarely, if ever, use live view for real action.


I was fortunate to get the R just after FW 1.3 came out. I find the AF quite good. Blackout is still pretty bad burst shooting. It has a High Speed Display option that only works on RF lenses but I'm not sure how much difference it made. I only tried once for a short bit but I don't use that lens for those purposes.

The R and RF24-105 will be a prefect point and shoot after I get my R5
Jul 11, 2020 at 11:41 AM
Dpedraza
Offline
Details
p.3 #14R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
Unless he was paid to or is ignoring blackout watch his reaction at minute 6:20. We need to rewatch this.


@16:00 or so the ambassadors mention that shooting you get just see a small white box on the outside of the frame
in the viewfinder
Jul 11, 2020 at 06:27 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.3 #15R5/6 lag/blackout


Dpedraza wrote:
Zenon Char wroteUnless he was paid to or is ignoring blackout watch his reaction at minute 6:20. We need to rewatch this.

@16:00 or so the ambassadors mention that shooting you get just see a small white box on the outside of the frame
in the viewfinder


I’ve seen that. So that is for mechanical shutter, not E?
Jul 11, 2020 at 06:53 PM
Dpedraza
Offline
Details
p.3 #16R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
Dpedraza wrote
Zenon Char wroteUnless he was paid to or is ignoring blackout watch his reaction at minute 6:20. We need to rewatch this.

@16:00 or so the ambassadors mention that shooting you get just see a small white box on the outside of the frame
in the viewfinder
I’ve seen that. So that is for mechanical shutter, not E?


He didn't mention he just said while shooting you just see the white box on the outside of the frame. I guess we'll have to see once non canon ambassadors get to test these. I'm hoping that's with a mechanical shutter. I did my preorder regardless for an R6.
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:01 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.3 #17R5/6 lag/blackout
Dpedraza wrote:
Zenon Char wrote
Dpedraza wrote
Zenon Char wroteUnless he was paid to or is ignoring blackout watch his reaction at minute 6:20. We need to rewatch this.

@16:00 or so the ambassadors mention that shooting you get just see a small white box on the outside of the frame
in the viewfinder
I’ve seen that. So that is for mechanical shutter, not E?
He didn't mention he just said while shooting you just see the white box on the outside of the frame. I guess we'll have to see once non canon ambassadors get to test these. I'm hoping that's with a mechanical shutter. I did my preorder regardless for an R6.


Thanks.I don't plan using the e shutter much. 12 fps is plenty for my needs.
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:29 PM
ShootPDX
Offline
Details
p.3 #18R5/6 lag/blackout
The white box flashing on the outside is the shutter indicator in ES so you know you're shooting.
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:32 PM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.3 #19R5/6 lag/blackout
ShootPDX wrote:
The white box flashing on the outside is the shutter indicator in ES so you know you're shooting.


So there are no videos out showing burst shooting with the mechanical shutter. Should we expect the same results.
Jul 11, 2020 at 08:36 PM
ShootPDX
Offline
Details
p.3 #20R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
ShootPDX wroteThe white box flashing on the outside is the shutter indicator in ES so you know you're shooting.
So there are no videos out showing burst shooting with the mechanical shutter. Should we expect the same results.


I assume the mechanical will have blackout.
Jul 11, 2020 at 09:18 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister