grmedhat1 wrote:
If those sample pictures is what the fuss is about...what's all the fuss about? Is this a camera designed for geeks where only specs give you bragging rights and actual performance gains have to be measured by emotion rather than practical benefit?
Seems so. It has lots of bling-bling for the gear collector and a lot of so-what stuff for the serious photographer. How does adding a "must have" feature such as a shaking sensor add to Canon's claim of better reliability?
Just because the features don't mean much to you doesn't mean they are only meaningful to cash laden amateurs looking for bling. We do pro work (less these days, as I am back in school), and I could benefit from every added feature except the 10FPS. How can you possibly say that a reasonable attempt to resolve the dust problem is not of practical benefit? Dust is the enemy of film and digital photography, and we should welcome innovative solutions to the problem. Clearly the system works, considering Canon has it on their Rebel, and that camera's reliability is acceptable. What gives you cause to believe that Canon can't implement it reliably on an EOS-1 camera?
Adding the complexity of more moving parts doesn't prove the claim. Only the test of time will prove whether or not it makes the camera more reliable. If the self cleaning sensor works so well how come the software that comes with it has "Dust Delete Data" functions?
Does the inclusion of one dust solution require Canon to exclude other means of dealing with dust? It is entirely possible that software dust removal is designed to supplement, rather than supplant hardware efforts to do the same.
I don't care what brand is stamped on the frame, clearly this a piece of equipment designed for cash laden point-and-shooters. I wouldn't be surprised if it came with window decals to stick on a pimped 4x4 as well. If this is what Nikon and the photography industry in general is supposed to be aiming at to stay in the game it doesn't look good for serious photographers and photography.
On what basis do you state this repeated claim? I find it completely absurd that you would equate useful innovation in camera technology with decline of photography as business and craft. As a once pro-shooter, I see plenty to like here. How are dust removal, live preview, weather sealing, lighter weight, and other usability and functionality bringing about the death of "serious ... photography?"
I'm interested to read your answer.
Arka C.