p.6 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
There has been plenty of great responses and discussion here. Ironically the only ones not worth reading are the ones complaining about the question. There has been no issues with fan boys or insults. I think people were hoping for more drama. It's an imperfect question with no real answer, only opinions and experiences which is what I was hoping for and is what members provided.
gdanmitchell wroteAlphaPhotography wroteSome people take these questions too seriously. It's just a discussion of the three systems lenses.“ Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?” is not “just a discussion of the three systems.”The question is literally which one is best.
A discussion of the sort you now claim to be desiring might be titled something like: “Favorite Lenses on Your System?”
Anyone who has been around photography discussions for a while knows exactly where the “which brand is best?” discussion lead. The question is entirely unresolvable. The thinking is highly subjective and context based. And it feeds the fanboy beast.
Perhaps you’d like to start a new discussion thread with a title that reflects your interest in hearing from people about their favorite lenses… and not arguing about “the BEST” brand?
For once, I totally agree with Dan. Your attitude now does not reflect the question you asked.
p.6 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
What Sony and Canon lenses do you use and which are you favorites? Have you used any overlapping focal lengths and which did you stick with?
IndyFab wroteRustyRus wrote100% Leica-
I'll raise you 110% >>> Hasselblad especailly for landscape
_______________________________________________________
I use Canon & Sony as they both do what I want & need. However, thats not to say I would not shoot Nikon, they too are an excellent system.
Point being, pick a system that best fits your wants & needs.
Dont discount Tamron, Sigma, Zeiss, and Voigtlander lenses. .
____________________________________________________________
Landscape / Cityscape / Wildlife / for me its not about favorite lens, its about what I need for the capture, as I chose what I felt rendered very well for the task at hand, after doing my do deligence..
p.6 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Having used all three setups (hobbies at best for my photos). Always found Sony to produce better images with less time editing for my workload. Especially Sony's GM lens lineup. Canon's L series glass fantastic but super expensive and heavy. There new L 1.4 glass is more video centered and the 35mm L 1.4 (RF) needs heavy correction to look right. Nikon I think has the best quality for the money.
If I was rating things from a person mainly shooting family photos, travel and some light video it would go. This is only in terms of mirrorless lenses. Mainly only rating as prime lens. Have not used a zoom lens in decades. Honestly thought I think they all make quality lenses at this point. More what style lens you like that work your for your needs best.
Sony - Excellent consistent images from the GM master line.
Nikon - Excellent option for high quality cheaper lenses. Loved there 1.8 S line and now there new 1.4 Z line.
Canon - Top tier L 1.2 line. Have not been super impressed with 1.4 RF L line. There cheaper 1.8 STM line did not work for me. Way too slow focusing for moving targets (kids). Another plus for Canon is I get a work discount with them which also includes the refurbished options.
Some of my favorite lenses below that I have used.
Sony 35mm 1.4 GM
Sony 135mm 1.8
Batis 85mm 1.8
Nikon Z 1.8 (35mm, 50mm, 85mm). All bought refurbished from Nikon for fairly cheap. Have not tried there budget 1.4 line or 1.2 glass.
Canon 135mm 1.8 is. Love that this lens has IS. Very fun to use.
Somewhat RF 35mm 1.4L Once i learned how to fast edit all the image correction that needs done.
p.6 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Well said - the last two posts started are telling.
johnvanr wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteThere has been plenty of great responses and discussion here. Ironically the only ones not worth reading are the ones complaining about the question. There has been no issues with fan boys or insults. I think people were hoping for more drama. It's an imperfect question with no real answer, only opinions and experiences which is what I was hoping for and is what members provided.
gdanmitchell wroteAlphaPhotography wroteSome people take these questions too seriously. It's just a discussion of the three systems lenses.“ Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?” is not “just a discussion of the three systems.”The question is literally which one is best.
A discussion of the sort you now claim to be desiring might be titled something like: “Favorite Lenses on Your System?”
Anyone who has been around photography discussions for a while knows exactly where the “which brand is best?” discussion lead. The question is entirely unresolvable. The thinking is highly subjective and context based. And it feeds the fanboy beast.
Perhaps you’d like to start a new discussion thread with a title that reflects your interest in hearing from people about their favorite lenses… and not arguing about “the BEST” brand?For once, I totally agree with Dan. Your attitude now does not reflect the question you asked.
p.6 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Someone is going to have to explain to me how the 35/1.4 RF VCM needs heavy corrections. 3-4% distortion isn't that high, really, and the resolution is very high according to opticallimits and it may be the best 35/1.4 out there imo
I guess it's the popular thing to say maybe that's the opinion of many Youtubers so I did myself a favor and didn't check YouTube
Going to Sony due to -3-4% distortion and getting one of their zooms having ~9% distortion doesn't sound like you're getting ahead on distortion.
p.6 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
It’s a fun question to address. When I first switched to mirrorless (after shooting Canon DSLR for many years), I was divorcing Canon and I compared just a couple of lens and body combinations between Sony and Nikon expecting to to prefer Sony because they’d been at mirrorless longer. I actually took a detour to Fuji GFX, but that’s another story and I’m a Nikon shooter now after returning to full frame system.
Primary deciding factor was I ended up liking Nikon zooms best (14-24/2.8 and 70-200/2.8). Subsequently was very pleasantly surprised with the 24-120/4 and blown away by the optical qualities of the Plena 135, and 105 Macro.
The 100-400 is also very good. What separates that zoom and the 800 PF from other manufacturers offers is their handling characteristics. I honestly have no idea if they’re sharper than what Canon or Sony offer, but they’re plenty sharp. I’m pretty certain they were designed to promote stealthy and comfortable field craft. The zoom is rear weighted and very balanced to handhold at all focal lengths, and the 800 mm is amazingly handholdable for that focal length while only giving up a 1/3 stop versus a conventional 800/5.6 monster. In combination those two lenses work well, with one providing amazing reach and the other enabling very close focus for subjects the reach isn’t needed or would be an impediment.
The 3 lens zoom kit I have covers 14 to 400mm with excellent IQ across the range, and nice close focusing distances with excellent corners. They are so close to having a bagful of primes and u can capture almost anything in nature with them. If Sony or Canon make theirs better all I can say is WOW! That is impressive! But I don’t care because I have what I need. And if I ever decide I need a fast supertelephoto with a built in 1.4x TC, there’s couple of very expensive Z’s waiting.
Now if Nikon would only issue that fast 35mm that Sony already does so well… which brings up a whole other can of worms. I think the best 35mm (and 90mm) lenses I’ve owned were L mount Leica Summicron APO. I owned those with a Panasonic S1R just because they had such unique diffraction limited design (meaning they were sharpest wide open at f/2) and were otherwise optical engineering marvels with such incredible color, pop, and dimensional rendering. But I actually didn’t love shooting those fixed focal lengths and sold that system after owning it for a year - great to date but not marriage material. I brought my Nikon lenses home to meet mom so to speak. And the Plena is in the same league as those Summicrons - not a diffraction limited design but otherwise an optical marvel.
p.6 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
IndyFab wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteWhat Sony and Canon lenses do you use and which are you favorites? Have you used any overlapping focal lengths and which did you stick with?
IndyFab wroteRustyRus wrote100% Leica-
I'll raise you 110% >>> Hasselblad especailly for landscape
_______________________________________________________
I use Canon & Sony as they both do what I want & need. However, thats not to say I would not shoot Nikon, they too are an excellent system.
Point being, pick a system that best fits your wants & needs.
Dont discount Tamron, Sigma, Zeiss, and Voigtlander lenses. .____________________________________________________________
Landscape / Cityscape / Wildlife / for me its not about favorite lens, its about what I need for the capture, as I chose what I felt rendered very well for the task at hand, after doing my do deligence..
Canon R5 - 100-500 + TC - Trifecta of Canon Zooms which can also be used on Sony - Zeiss & Voigtlander Primes.
I loved my Sony 200-600mm and still miss it sometimes. But when I was in the process of comparing Sony (A9II) and Canon (R5) the 100-500mm was another lens that swayed me. It was probably partially the fact that the A9II had lower resolution and the higher res fast readout options (A1) weren't out yet, but the files coming out of the 100-500mm paired with the R5II were beautiful and tack sharp. As they should be for $2700. The most glaring difference was with "macro" shots. I remember focusing on a jumping spider on a sign nearby. The Canon R5 eye-AF actually tracked it and had excellent reproduction and sharpness. The Sony struggled to recognize or track it at all and even the shots I was able to get in focus were soft. It was much worse at those close working distances than the 100-500mm which I love to use often.
p.6 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
jjjwolf7722 wrote:
Having used all three setups (hobbies at best for my photos). Always found Sony to produce better images with less time editing for my workload. Especially Sony's GM lens lineup. Canon's L series glass fantastic but super expensive and heavy. There new L 1.4 glass is more video centered and the 35mm L 1.4 (RF) needs heavy correction to look right. Nikon I think has the best quality for the money.
If I was rating things from a person mainly shooting family photos, travel and some light video it would go. This is only in terms of mirrorless lenses. Mainly only rating as prime lens. Have not used a zoom lens in decades. Honestly thought I think they all make quality lenses at this point. More what style lens you like that work your for your needs best.
Sony - Excellent consistent images from the GM master line.
Nikon - Excellent option for high quality cheaper lenses. Loved there 1.8 S line and now there new 1.4 Z line.
Canon - Top tier L 1.2 line. Have not been super impressed with 1.4 RF L line. There cheaper 1.8 STM line did not work for me. Way too slow focusing for moving targets (kids). Another plus for Canon is I get a work discount with them which also includes the refurbished options.
Some of my favorite lenses below that I have used.
Sony 35mm 1.4 GM
Sony 135mm 1.8
Batis 85mm 1.8
Nikon Z 1.8 (35mm, 50mm, 85mm). All bought refurbished from Nikon for fairly cheap. Have not tried there budget 1.4 line or 1.2 glass.
Canon 135mm 1.8 is. Love that this lens has IS. Very fun to use.
Somewhat RF 35mm 1.4L Once i learned how to fast edit all the image correction that needs done. ...Show more →
I agree with all that. The Sony 135mm f1.8 is one of the best lenses I've ever used. Nearly flawless. The Nikon Z f1.8 S line does seem to get rave reviews. I just don't get that excited about f1.8 lenses and they're very long, making them a bit more conspicuous and harder to travel with, fit in bags or coat pockets, etc. One of the first lenses I ever used was a Canon 40mm f2.8 STM pancake which I still own. It was compact, light, cheap, and had good character. I wish more companies would focus on making lenses like that. I'm willing to make some sacrifices for size and weight. Sony's 35mm f1.4 GM is the perfect example of this. It's still an f1.4 but doesn't have many compromises between focus breathing which can be corrected in camera. I've actually thought about getting one over the Nikon 35mm f1.8 S or Nikon 35mm f1.4. All three are about the same size but based on what I've seen the Sony performs better.
The Canon 135mm f1.8 is intriguing since I haven't had a 135mm in years since the 135mm GM (and Sigma 135mm before that). But there is also the Nikon 135mm Plena which appears to be a special lens, albeit very heavy and large. I hope I can compare those two in the near future.
I agree with not being impressed with Canon's new f1.4 line but I'm only going off what I'm seeing from an optical design, build, etc. I just got the RF 24mm f1.4 in the mail and I'm hoping it's better than I'm expecting. All the mixed feedback online about the 35mm f1.4 is in the back of my mind but I'm forcing myself to give the (VCM) line a chance to see for myself. I do like the rendering on the 35mm from what I've seen. But again I think the 35mm GM may be slightly better based on examples I've seen.
p.6 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
I loved my Sony 200-600mm and still miss it sometimes. But when I was in the process of comparing Sony (A9II) and Canon (R5) the 100-500mm was another lens that swayed me. It was probably partially the fact that the A9II had lower resolution and the higher res fast readout options (A1) weren't out yet, but the files coming out of the 100-500mm paired with the R5II were beautiful and tack sharp. As they should be for $2700. The most glaring difference was with "macro" shots. I remember focusing on a jumping spider on a sign nearby. The Canon R5 eye-AF actually tracked it and had excellent reproduction and sharpness. The Sony struggled to recognize or track it at all and even the shots I was able to get in focus were soft. It was much worse at those close working distances than the 100-500mm which I love to use often. ...Show more →
I sometimes use my Sony 200-600 and Canon 100-500 together. They are different enough. I don't use the 200-600 on a low-res body as it would defeat the purpose of gaining some pixels per duck.
p.6 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
woodstork wrote:
It’s a fun question to address. When I first switched to mirrorless (after shooting Canon DSLR for many years), I was divorcing Canon and I compared just a couple of lens and body combinations between Sony and Nikon expecting to to prefer Sony because they’d been at mirrorless longer. I actually took a detour to Fuji GFX, but that’s another story and I’m a Nikon shooter now after returning to full frame system.
Primary deciding factor was I ended up liking Nikon zooms best (14-24/2.8 and 70-200/2.8). Subsequently was very pleasantly surprised with the 24-120/4 and blown away by the optical qualities of the Plena 135, and 105 Macro.
The 100-400 is also very good. What separates that zoom and the 800 PF from other manufacturers offers is their handling characteristics. I honestly have no idea if they’re sharper than what Canon or Sony offer, but they’re plenty sharp. I’m pretty certain they were designed to promote stealthy and comfortable field craft. The zoom is rear weighted and very balanced to handhold at all focal lengths, and the 800 mm is amazingly handholdable for that focal length while only giving up a 1/3 stop versus a conventional 800/5.6 monster. In combination those two lenses work well, with one providing amazing reach and the other enabling very close focus for subjects the reach isn’t needed or would be an impediment.
The 3 lens zoom kit I have covers 14 to 400mm with excellent IQ across the range, and nice close focusing distances with excellent corners. They are so close to having a bagful of primes and u can capture almost anything in nature with them. If Sony or Canon make theirs better all I can say is WOW! That is impressive! But I don’t care because I have what I need. And if I ever decide I need a fast supertelephoto with a built in 1.4x TC, there’s couple of very expensive Z’s waiting.
Now if Nikon would only issue that fast 35mm that Sony already does so well… which brings up a whole other can of worms. I think the best 35mm (and 90mm) lenses I’ve owned were L mount Leica Summicron APO. I owned those with a Panasonic S1R just because they had such unique diffraction limited design (meaning they were sharpest wide open at f/2) and were otherwise optical engineering marvels with such incredible color, pop, and dimensional rendering. But I actually didn’t love shooting those fixed focal lengths and sold that system after owning it for a year - great to date but not marriage material. I brought my Nikon lenses home to meet mom so to speak. And the Plena is in the same league as those Summicrons - not a diffraction limited design but otherwise an optical marvel. ...Show more →
I've heard a lot about the Nikon 24-120mm f4. It's on my radar for a versatile zoom along with the Tamron 35-150mm f2-2.8. I'm just not sure how I feel about f4 after getting so used to f2 and f2.8 zooms over the years. I currently use the RF 28-70mm and RF 15-35mm f2.8.
That's interesting to hear about the handling of the Nikon 100-400mm and 800mm. It's something I hadn't thought about or weighed too heavily when considering lenses, partially because it's hard to know without testing them. But I do hate the throw on the RF 200-800mm so handling is something I need to weigh more heavily. Enjoying using the lenses is half the battle.
I also wish Nikon would sell a 35mm f1.4 that competes with the GM, or even a 35mm f1.2 although it'd be ridiculously big and heavy based on their other designs. And the Plena is on my list of lenses I'd like to try. I keep hearing so many great things about it and the rendering looks special with it's round specular highlights. 135mm is a difficult focal length to use (for me) but when you have the working room it's very rewarding for those half and full body shots with lots of compression.
p.6 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Someone is going to have to explain to me how the 35/1.4 RF VCM needs heavy corrections. 3-4% distortion isn't that high, really, and the resolution is very high according to opticallimits and it may be the best 35/1.4 out there imo
I guess it's the popular thing to say maybe that's the opinion of many Youtubers so I did myself a favor and didn't check YouTube
Going to Sony due to -3-4% distortion and getting one of their zooms having ~9% distortion doesn't sound like you're getting ahead on distortion.
I'm not sure what the exact amount of distortion and vignetting is but it's pretty bad. Just look at the uncorrected example images reviewers have posted. The Sony 35mm GM f1.4 appears to perform much better in this regard.
I wish I could find a site that has measured both lenses for comparison. Optical Limits has a review of the VCM but not the GM. Lenstip has a review of the GM but not the VCM.
p.6 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
I've heard a lot about the Nikon 24-120mm f4. It's on my radar for a versatile zoom along with the Tamron 35-150mm f2-2.8. I'm just not sure how I feel about f4 after getting so used to f2 and f2.8 zooms over the years. I currently use the RF 28-70mm and RF 15-35mm f2.8.
That's interesting to hear about the handling of the Nikon 100-400mm and 800mm.
I also wish Nikon would sell a 35mm f1.4 that competes with the GM, or even a 35mm f1.2 although it'd be ridiculously big and heavy based on their other designs. And the Plena is on my list of lenses I'd like to try. I keep hearing so many great things about it and the rendering looks special with it's round specular highlights. 135mm is a difficult focal length to use (for me) but when you have the working room it's very rewarding for those half and full body shots with lots of compression....Show more →
Nikon’s choices regarding handling vs optical characteristics are varied, and they offer tremendous overlap in a lot of focal lengths aiming to give us choices to fit our work flow and optical requirements. It seems to me their design philosophy starts with use cases and they build the lens around a conceptual model for use.
For example, I have two Z lenses that cover 24mm and they each have very different use cases and they perform optically similarly at similar apertures, same could be said for 105mm where I have 4 choices, or 135mm when I have 3. Which lens I grab depends on whether I’m shooting for isolation vs depth, how close I want to get to subject, whether I need a versatile focal length range or if a prime is it, how light I want to travel, and whether I’m shooting on land, from a aircraft, or underwater. Nikon’s lenses are indeed high performers optically, but I really vibe with their system for use case choices in their design. Each lens has its subject matter and workflow emphasis.
The Plena is heavy and bulky, but it pairs well with the Z9 and I don’t really feel out of whack using it. It is weird on the Z7. But it wasn’t designed to be a haptic delight - it was designed to be Nikon’s best autofocus optic with overall strength wide open to f/16. It is probably designed with a huge image circle to assure its wonderful edge to edge sharpness and those round bokeh balls to the corners - hence bulky because it’s effectively a medium format lens. This is the ‘details matter to the corners and/or I wish to pleasingly obliterate the background and isolate my subject in wonderful detail lens.’ It is a lot of fun to shoot. I use it for creative subject isolation wide open, and for incredible detailed focus stacked and panostitching landscapes that enlarge very big and withstand nose-to-the-print scrutiny (at f/5.6 to f11). I’ve seen Sony users put their 135 to similar use and the Plena at least matches that. I did test the Sony on a A7Riii and adapted to a Z7. It performed better on the native body with a bit more microcontrast. It was not a buy for me to adapt to Z. I haven’t tested the Plena vs Sony side by side, but the Plena seems to be the better render overall to my taste. Both are very sharp.
The 24-120/4 is less of an optical marvel but renders so well. You give up a stop of light (versus my 14-24/2.8) but you pick up such range and close focusing ability that really isolates subjects you can get close to. I haven’t tested it but credible reviews indicate the 24-70 /2.8 is just a bit better than the 24-120, but not worlds better. When I can only carry one lens and have no idea what I want to shoot this is it. Covers most cameo portrait scenarios, landscape, almost macro, good for panostitching, and even a bit of wildlife if it’s approachable. This is the ‘National Geographic lens’. It’s also my grab it on the way to the beach lens. I’ve shot with it from the air and in a water housing that has a zoom gear and speciality flat port for accommodating its telescoping zoom. Versatility and portability. My wife is often fighting me to use this lens when we travel. It could turn into the ‘Divorce’ lens if I’m not careful.
I agree Nikon falls short on 24mm and 35mm fast primes. They haven’t issued either yet and the 1.8s in those lengths are not their best optical offers. Not bad by any means, but not industry leaders. I suspect the fast primes will be heavy and bulky with incredible coma and edge performance. And perhaps excellent close focus distance. Will be interesting to see if they go for 1.2. I will likely buy whichever of those two make the best Astro/landscape lens and bias toward one if it is superior than the other in the corners. The 20/1.8 is already excellent for that use case but I like a bit less ultra wide look and bit more toward normal. So, at this point I’d be renting class-leading Sony 24 GM or 35 GM if I wanted to shoot a very fast prime. I did test the 35 GM and it performs a bit better on the native body than adapted to Z, but outperformed the z 35/1.8 on the z cam. So I’m waiting patiently for Nikon to catch up with their S-line super fast lens like I did with the Plena.
p.6 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote: jjjwolf7722 wroteHaving used all three setups (hobbies at best for my photos). Always found Sony to produce better images with less time editing for my workload. Especially Sony's GM lens lineup. Canon's L series glass fantastic but super expensive and heavy. There new L 1.4 glass is more video centered and the 35mm L 1.4 (RF) needs heavy correction to look right. Nikon I think has the best quality for the money.
If I was rating things from a person mainly shooting family photos, travel and some light video it would go. This is only in terms of mirrorless lenses. Mainly only rating as prime lens. Have not used a zoom lens in decades. Honestly thought I think they all make quality lenses at this point. More what style lens you like that work your for your needs best.
Sony - Excellent consistent images from the GM master line.
Nikon - Excellent option for high quality cheaper lenses. Loved there 1.8 S line and now there new 1.4 Z line.
Canon - Top tier L 1.2 line. Have not been super impressed with 1.4 RF L line. There cheaper 1.8 STM line did not work for me. Way too slow focusing for moving targets (kids). Another plus for Canon is I get a work discount with them which also includes the refurbished options.
Some of my favorite lenses below that I have used.
Sony 35mm 1.4 GM
Sony 135mm 1.8
Batis 85mm 1.8
Nikon Z 1.8 (35mm, 50mm, 85mm). All bought refurbished from Nikon for fairly cheap. Have not tried there budget 1.4 line or 1.2 glass.
Canon 135mm 1.8 is. Love that this lens has IS. Very fun to use.
Somewhat RF 35mm 1.4L Once i learned how to fast edit all the image correction that needs done.But there is also the Nikon 135mm Plena which appears to be a special lens, albeit very heavy and large. I hope I can compare those two in the near future.
The difference is like 10mm and 45g. If Plena is very large and heavy, then they all are. The new Viltrox Lab 135mm is the abnormally heavy lens.
p.6 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
All make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.
p.6 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
You are right. I didn't realize they were that similar.
Buckeye2604 wrote: AlphaPhotography wrotejjjwolf7722 wroteHaving used all three setups (hobbies at best for my photos). Always found Sony to produce better images with less time editing for my workload. Especially Sony's GM lens lineup. Canon's L series glass fantastic but super expensive and heavy. There new L 1.4 glass is more video centered and the 35mm L 1.4 (RF) needs heavy correction to look right. Nikon I think has the best quality for the money.
If I was rating things from a person mainly shooting family photos, travel and some light video it would go. This is only in terms of mirrorless lenses. Mainly only rating as prime lens. Have not used a zoom lens in decades. Honestly thought I think they all make quality lenses at this point. More what style lens you like that work your for your needs best.
Sony - Excellent consistent images from the GM master line.
Nikon - Excellent option for high quality cheaper lenses. Loved there 1.8 S line and now there new 1.4 Z line.
Canon - Top tier L 1.2 line. Have not been super impressed with 1.4 RF L line. There cheaper 1.8 STM line did not work for me. Way too slow focusing for moving targets (kids). Another plus for Canon is I get a work discount with them which also includes the refurbished options.
Some of my favorite lenses below that I have used.
Sony 35mm 1.4 GM
Sony 135mm 1.8
Batis 85mm 1.8
Nikon Z 1.8 (35mm, 50mm, 85mm). All bought refurbished from Nikon for fairly cheap. Have not tried there budget 1.4 line or 1.2 glass.
Canon 135mm 1.8 is. Love that this lens has IS. Very fun to use.
Somewhat RF 35mm 1.4L Once i learned how to fast edit all the image correction that needs done.But there is also the Nikon 135mm Plena which appears to be a special lens, albeit very heavy and large. I hope I can compare those two in the near future.The difference is like 10mm and 45g. If Plena is very large and heavy, then they all are. The new Viltrox Lab 135mm is the abnormally heavy lens.
p.6 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wrote:
All make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.
Jan 09, 2025 at 10:22 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.6 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote: AmbientMike wroteSomeone is going to have to explain to me how the 35/1.4 RF VCM needs heavy corrections. 3-4% distortion isn't that high, really, and the resolution is very high according to opticallimits and it may be the best 35/1.4 out there imo
I guess it's the popular thing to say maybe that's the opinion of many Youtubers so I did myself a favor and didn't check YouTube
Going to Sony due to -3-4% distortion and getting one of their zooms having ~9% distortion doesn't sound like you're getting ahead on distortion.I'm not sure what the exact amount of distortion and vignetting is but it's pretty bad. Just look at the uncorrected example images reviewers have posted. The Sony 35mm GM f1.4 appears to perform much better in this regard.
I wish I could find a site that has measured both lenses for comparison. Optical Limits has a review of the VCM but not the GM. Lenstip has a review of the GM but not the VCM.
No, it is not bad.
I don't know why people keep saying it is, unless they're just getting it off some goofy YouTube video or sites, it is in the 3-4% range. While I don't have the 35/1.4, I believe one of the lenses I've been using has about the same amount of distortion. Certainly better than the ~9% on some Sony zooms, 3-4% definitely nothing new
If I shoot Raw I click a check box in DPP to get rid of the distortion if needed. Even the Rebel SL2 had distortion corrections in body for jpegs I'd guess recent bodies have that. Not hard.
Jan 09, 2025 at 12:17 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.6 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
I'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
...Show more →David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.
The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.
p.6 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.
It is light but Canon just slapped the RFmount on the EF glass and shipped them to have options. I'd be very surprised if they're not that far out from 400 and 600mm lenses designed specifically for the RF mount.
There also is a substantial difference in size from the Nikon 600 and the Canon. The Nikon is shorter than the bare EF 600 III and has a built in 1.4TC. to boot. NIkon hit home runs with both of those TC lenses. You don't realize the difference until they're on cameras, side by side. Add the hoods and its grossly different.