"Optically Identical to EF 600mm f/4L IS III USM lens"
The EF 600mm f4/L IS III released in 2018. It is now a seven year old optical design. It is essentially an EF III with a built-in RF adapter. This is why it is longer in length length than both the RF 600mm and the Sony. The Sony 600mm is lighter and over an inch shorter.
AmbientMike wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.
p.7 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
David83 wrote: AmbientMike wroteAlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.It is light but Canon just slapped the RFmount on the EF glass and shipped them to have options. I'd be very surprised if they're not that far out from 400 and 600mm lenses designed specifically for the RF mount.
There also is a substantial difference in size from the Nikon 600 and the Canon. The Nikon is shorter than the bare EF 600 III and has a built in 1.4TC. to boot. NIkon hit home runs with both of those TC lenses. You don't realize the difference until they're on cameras, side by side. Add the hoods and its grossly different.
Well, if they are going to release new native RF mount 400mm f2.8 and 600mm f4 I feel really sorry for the folks who have forked a very large amount of cash for the current lenses thinking they were buying lenses due to remain current for many years. IMHO it would be again a clear display of lack of respect for their customers.
Btw the weight difference between the Nikon and the Canon is tiny and doesn't even account for the presence of the TC.
p.7 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I am sure Sony and Canon will eventually have supertele with built in TC. Did Canon not start the trend with 200-400 over 10 years ago?
Problem is that supertele lens tend to have long shelf life, say at least 10 years.
Sony released 400/2.8 in very limited supply in 2018 so they are dued for a refresh probably in the
next couple of years likely. Canon is in a bit of a bind, their EF mount one was updated after Sony to match Sony's weight and the RF mount one only a few years ago.
Can Canon afford not to make supertele with no built in TC for the next 5-7 years (by then Sony should already have one more than likely) but if they do, they will get some grumpy customers who only bought
new supertele recently as well. Look like Nikon find the right time to introduce supertele twtih built in TC while suffering a few years earlier with heavier supertele than its competitors
Now that I have Z8/Z9 with 400/2.8TC and 800PF, going out to shoot birds have never been more fun and the flexibility are just incredible. One body with 600/4 TC will be fun as well but there are still times when 400/2.8 focal length is very handy and at the moment, I don't see why I would need to look at Sony or Canon at all.
p.7 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I wouldn't trust the people debating: they have too much time on their hands, lmaos.
I shoot Nikon (3x Z9s + S-line) + have second shooters use Canon + Sony and if they're using the higher end gear (R5II, A7V, etc.) with top (RF-F & GM) lenses, it's near indistinguishable sharpness wise. It's the color rendition that gives it away. Maybe there's a difference in sharpness if one uses tools that can measure that, and sometimes you might get a dud lens that isn't as sharp, or a better copy, but overall I don't think any one brand is better enough that everyone just wants to switch to that brand (switching for other color science isn't the same).
p.7 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The biggest thing Nikon is missing is raw precapture. It is a gamechanger for birding. I'm sure they'll add it in the Z9II though.
suteetat wrote:
I am sure Sony and Canon will eventually have supertele with built in TC. Did Canon not start the trend with 200-400 over 10 years ago?
Problem is that supertele lens tend to have long shelf life, say at least 10 years.
Sony released 400/2.8 in very limited supply in 2018 so they are dued for a refresh probably in the
next couple of years likely. Canon is in a bit of a bind, their EF mount one was updated after Sony to match Sony's weight and the RF mount one only a few years ago.
Can Canon afford not to make supertele with no built in TC for the next 5-7 years (by then Sony should already have one more than likely) but if they do, they will get some grumpy customers who only bought
new supertele recently as well. Look like Nikon find the right time to introduce supertele twtih built in TC while suffering a few years earlier with heavier supertele than its competitors
Now that I have Z8/Z9 with 400/2.8TC and 800PF, going out to shoot birds have never been more fun and the flexibility are just incredible. One body with 600/4 TC will be fun as well but there are still times when 400/2.8 focal length is very handy and at the moment, I don't see why I would need to look at Sony or Canon at all. ...Show more →
p.7 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Can you elaborate on your experience with color science with newer bodies from each brand?
MazeRunner wrote:
I wouldn't trust the people debating: they have too much time on their hands, lmaos.
I shoot Nikon (3x Z9s + S-line) + have second shooters use Canon + Sony and if they're using the higher end gear (R5II, A7V, etc.) with top (RF-F & GM) lenses, it's near indistinguishable sharpness wise. It's the color rendition that gives it away. Maybe there's a difference in sharpness if one uses tools that can measure that, and sometimes you might get a dud lens that isn't as sharp, or a better copy, but overall I don't think any one brand is better enough that everyone just wants to switch to that brand (switching for other color science isn't the same)....Show more →
Jan 09, 2025 at 10:25 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.7 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
David83 wrote: AmbientMike wroteAlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.It is light but Canon just slapped the RFmount on the EF glass and shipped them to have options. I'd be very surprised if they're not that far out from 400 and 600mm lenses designed specifically for the RF mount.
There also is a substantial difference in size from the Nikon 600 and the Canon. The Nikon is shorter than the bare EF 600 III and has a built in 1.4TC. to boot. NIkon hit home runs with both of those TC lenses. You don't realize the difference until they're on cameras, side by side. Add the hoods and its grossly different.
It's just the same stupid crap you hear repeatedly on here.
Canon innovated being the first to have one of the current light 600/4's. Nikon took a couple years longer to get one out then slapped a rather antiquated accessory in there adding weight.
If you're going to say Canon slapped an Rf mount on there I suppose you could say nikon just slapped a Z mount on there. Neither makes much sense maybe nobody cares though.
Jan 09, 2025 at 11:10 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.7 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
"Optically Identical to EF 600mm f/4L IS III USM lens"
The EF 600mm f4/L IS III released in 2018. It is now a seven year old optical design. It is essentially an EF III with a built-in RF adapter. This is why it is longer in length length than both the RF 600mm and the Sony. The Sony 600mm is lighter and over an inch shorter.
AmbientMike wroteAlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.
You're never going to get it, are you?
It is not rehashed they had 2 different mounts so they put it on both.
p.7 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The EF 400mm f2.8 IS III came out in September 2018. Three years later in April 2021 they released the RF 400mm f2.8 with the same old 2018 EF optical formula. They did this by adding an RF mount without redesigning the lens (optimizing it for the shorter flange distance which results in a more compact design).
"Optically Identical to EF 600mm f/4L IS III USM lens"
The EF 600mm f4/L IS III released in 2018. It is now a seven year old optical design. It is essentially an EF III with a built-in RF adapter. This is why it is longer in length length than both the RF 600mm and the Sony. The Sony 600mm is lighter and over an inch shorter.
AmbientMike wroteAlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.You're never going to get it, are you?
It is not rehashed they had 2 different mounts so they put it on both.
p.7 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
In response to the OP, I don't think you can limit it to Sony, Canon, Nikon. Surely there will people pushing Zeiss, maybe Leica, and the large format camera lens makers like Schneider and Rodenstock, and others...
p.7 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
The biggest thing Nikon is missing is raw precapture. It is a gamechanger for birding. I'm sure they'll add it in the Z9II though.
suteetat wroteI am sure Sony and Canon will eventually have supertele with built in TC. Did Canon not start the trend with 200-400 over 10 years ago?
Problem is that supertele lens tend to have long shelf life, say at least 10 years.
Sony released 400/2.8 in very limited supply in 2018 so they are dued for a refresh probably in the
next couple of years likely. Canon is in a bit of a bind, their EF mount one was updated after Sony to match Sony's weight and the RF mount one only a few years ago.
Can Canon afford not to make supertele with no built in TC for the next 5-7 years (by then Sony should already have one more than likely) but if they do, they will get some grumpy customers who only bought
new supertele recently as well. Look like Nikon find the right time to introduce supertele twtih built in TC while suffering a few years earlier with heavier supertele than its competitors
Now that I have Z8/Z9 with 400/2.8TC and 800PF, going out to shoot birds have never been more fun and the flexibility are just incredible. One body with 600/4 TC will be fun as well but there are still times when 400/2.8 focal length is very handy and at the moment, I don't see why I would need to look at Sony or Canon at all.
Yes, I hope Z9 ii will have raw precapture. I use jpg precapture sometimes on my Z9 but when I go out to shoot birds, I turn internal TC on and off hundreds if not thousands of times more than I need to use precapture.
It would be nice to have both, of course.
p.7 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteAmbientMike wroteSomeone is going to have to explain to me how the 35/1.4 RF VCM needs heavy corrections. 3-4% distortion isn't that high, really, and the resolution is very high according to opticallimits and it may be the best 35/1.4 out there imo
I guess it's the popular thing to say maybe that's the opinion of many Youtubers so I did myself a favor and didn't check YouTube
Going to Sony due to -3-4% distortion and getting one of their zooms having ~9% distortion doesn't sound like you're getting ahead on distortion.I'm not sure what the exact amount of distortion and vignetting is but it's pretty bad. Just look at the uncorrected example images reviewers have posted. The Sony 35mm GM f1.4 appears to perform much better in this regard.
I wish I could find a site that has measured both lenses for comparison. Optical Limits has a review of the VCM but not the GM. Lenstip has a review of the GM but not the VCM.No, it is not bad.
I don't know why people keep saying it is, unless they're just getting it off some goofy YouTube video or sites, it is in the 3-4% range. While I don't have the 35/1.4, I believe one of the lenses I've been using has about the same amount of distortion. Certainly better than the ~9% on some Sony zooms, 3-4% definitely nothing new
If I shoot Raw I click a check box in DPP to get rid of the distortion if needed. Even the Rebel SL2 had distortion corrections in body for jpegs I'd guess recent bodies have that. Not hard. ...Show more →
Because near 4% on a 35mm prime is terrible. Comparing it to a random zoom lens from another manufacturer (usually budget) is a a disingenuous argument. Canon also has zooms with atrocious distortion (including their $3000 24-105/2.8) that is digitally corrected (and primes like the 16/2.8).
But here are the distortion numbers for the Nikon and Sony 35s:
Nikon 35/1.8S: 1.28%
Nikon 35/1.4: 2.3% (this is their budget lens)
Sony 35/1.4 GM: 0.73%
Sony 35/1.8: 0.39%
So yea, among 35mm primes, having near 4% barrel distortion is very high, especially when you consider it’s the most expensive of all the lenses above. Given the other characteristics the digitally corrected distortion may not matter to you, but it is very high for a 35mm prime.
p.7 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
That's bizarre. The guy a few posts above said built-in TC's are just an antiquated accessory that adds weight. It's actually useful?!?
suteetat wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteThe biggest thing Nikon is missing is raw precapture. It is a gamechanger for birding. I'm sure they'll add it in the Z9II though.
suteetat wroteI am sure Sony and Canon will eventually have supertele with built in TC. Did Canon not start the trend with 200-400 over 10 years ago?
Problem is that supertele lens tend to have long shelf life, say at least 10 years.
Sony released 400/2.8 in very limited supply in 2018 so they are dued for a refresh probably in the
next couple of years likely. Canon is in a bit of a bind, their EF mount one was updated after Sony to match Sony's weight and the RF mount one only a few years ago.
Can Canon afford not to make supertele with no built in TC for the next 5-7 years (by then Sony should already have one more than likely) but if they do, they will get some grumpy customers who only bought
new supertele recently as well. Look like Nikon find the right time to introduce supertele twtih built in TC while suffering a few years earlier with heavier supertele than its competitors
Now that I have Z8/Z9 with 400/2.8TC and 800PF, going out to shoot birds have never been more fun and the flexibility are just incredible. One body with 600/4 TC will be fun as well but there are still times when 400/2.8 focal length is very handy and at the moment, I don't see why I would need to look at Sony or Canon at all.Yes, I hope Z9 ii will have raw precapture. I use jpg precapture sometimes on my Z9 but when I go out to shoot birds, I turn internal TC on and off hundreds if not thousands of times more than I need to use precapture.
It would be nice to have both, of course.
p.7 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
That's true. I just wanted to focus on the big three full-frame options with mainly native glass for this discussion. Zeiss and Leica are much more niche, don't offer long telephotos, usually MF only, etc.
Tony Ross wrote:
In response to the OP, I don't think you can limit it to Sony, Canon, Nikon. Surely there will people pushing Zeiss, maybe Leica, and the large format camera lens makers like Schneider and Rodenstock, and others...
p.7 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
That's bizarre. The guy a few posts above said built-in TC's are just an antiquated accessory that adds weight. It's actually useful?!?
suteetat wroteAlphaPhotography wroteThe biggest thing Nikon is missing is raw precapture. It is a gamechanger for birding. I'm sure they'll add it in the Z9II though.
suteetat wroteI am sure Sony and Canon will eventually have supertele with built in TC. Did Canon not start the trend with 200-400 over 10 years ago?
Problem is that supertele lens tend to have long shelf life, say at least 10 years.
Sony released 400/2.8 in very limited supply in 2018 so they are dued for a refresh probably in the
next couple of years likely. Canon is in a bit of a bind, their EF mount one was updated after Sony to match Sony's weight and the RF mount one only a few years ago.
Can Canon afford not to make supertele with no built in TC for the next 5-7 years (by then Sony should already have one more than likely) but if they do, they will get some grumpy customers who only bought
new supertele recently as well. Look like Nikon find the right time to introduce supertele twtih built in TC while suffering a few years earlier with heavier supertele than its competitors
Now that I have Z8/Z9 with 400/2.8TC and 800PF, going out to shoot birds have never been more fun and the flexibility are just incredible. One body with 600/4 TC will be fun as well but there are still times when 400/2.8 focal length is very handy and at the moment, I don't see why I would need to look at Sony or Canon at all.Yes, I hope Z9 ii will have raw precapture. I use jpg precapture sometimes on my Z9 but when I go out to shoot birds, I turn internal TC on and off hundreds if not thousands of times more than I need to use precapture.
It would be nice to have both, of course.
Built-in TCs will become the best thing ever as soon as Canon's super tele have them.
Raw pre-capture will obviously be on the z9II. Let's not forget that Nikon was the first manufacturer among the big 3 to introduce jpg pre-capture as a firmware update of the Z9. So they understand the value better than anybody else and it is only architectural limitations that has prevented them from delivering it as a firmware update on the Z9.
But yes, the importance of that feature is way exaggerated by those users promoting Canon. It's actually an easy way to identify them. It's been the same approach forever. When only the Z9 had jpg pre-capture the feature was described by those same guys as completely useless.
p.7 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: David83 wroteAmbientMike wroteAlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.It is light but Canon just slapped the RFmount on the EF glass and shipped them to have options. I'd be very surprised if they're not that far out from 400 and 600mm lenses designed specifically for the RF mount.
There also is a substantial difference in size from the Nikon 600 and the Canon. The Nikon is shorter than the bare EF 600 III and has a built in 1.4TC. to boot. NIkon hit home runs with both of those TC lenses. You don't realize the difference until they're on cameras, side by side. Add the hoods and its grossly different.
Canon innovated being the first to have one of the current light 600/4's. Nikon took a couple years longer to get one out then slapped a rather antiquated accessory in there adding weight.
If you're going to say Canon slapped an Rf mount on there I suppose you could say nikon just slapped a Z mount on there. Neither makes much sense maybe nobody cares though.
I'm not following you here at all. Canon took their EF III lenses and machined an EF to RF adapter, made it silver, and bolted it to the lenses for the RF mount. They removed the Focus window and made some software tweaks. They've said so themselves. Was there anything wrong with that approach? No, both are essentially perfect lenses. But they are not designed from the ground up mirrorless lenses. Im sure they did it to buy them time to develop new lenses. Really, only the RF 100-300 falls in that category for canon thus far.
Nikons lenses are 100% designed for the Z mount. They are smaller and the built in TC is an invaluable feature. The weight difference is small and not noticeable. Swinging the two 600s around with the Canon being half a mile longer, especially with the hood on, handling is a very big difference.
p.7 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: David83 wroteAmbientMike wroteAlphaPhotography wroteI'm surprised Sony and Canon haven't attempted to match Nikon's built-in TC offerings. Canon is especially disappointing with their rehashed EF design for the RF 600mm and it's very long compared to Sonys. 300mm GM looks superb but for versatility I love the idea of the RF 100-300mm f2.8 and may pick one up this year.
The new 70-200mm f2.8 looks excellent but I wish someone would modify that design more. I love what Tamron did with the 35-150mm f2-2.8. I've seen it replace a 70-200mm for a lot of people. Of friend of mine keeps his 35-150mm glued to his A1 and almost never uses his Tamron 70-180mm anymore. I'd love to see something like a 24-135mm f2-2.5. And the RF 100-300mm f2.8 is large but I think that would also replace my 70-200mm f2.8 in most instances.
David83 wroteAll make stellar lenses but Nikon is leading in options for long glass. They also make the two best super tele’s ever with the 400 & 600 TC lenses. Sony’s 300Gm is also a modern marvel.
Canons new 70-200 z lens is also just superb optically, build wise and af speed.The Rf 600/4 is industry leading for low weight. Drives me nuts that people complain about it because they put it in both mounts like Leica used to. Not rehashed for crying out loud.It is light but Canon just slapped the RFmount on the EF glass and shipped them to have options. I'd be very surprised if they're not that far out from 400 and 600mm lenses designed specifically for the RF mount.
There also is a substantial difference in size from the Nikon 600 and the Canon. The Nikon is shorter than the bare EF 600 III and has a built in 1.4TC. to boot. NIkon hit home runs with both of those TC lenses. You don't realize the difference until they're on cameras, side by side. Add the hoods and its grossly different.
Canon innovated being the first to have one of the current light 600/4's. Nikon took a couple years longer to get one out then slapped a rather antiquated accessory in there adding weight.
If you're going to say Canon slapped an Rf mount on there I suppose you could say nikon just slapped a Z mount on there. Neither makes much sense maybe nobody cares though.
Ask any Z shooter that has the 400TC or 600TC if they mind the added weight and if they feel like the built-in TC is "antiquated." They will say no to both.
The F-mount 600 f/4E FL and the Z-mount 600 f/4 TC are completely different optical designs. The EF 600mm f/4L III and the RF 600mm f/4L are the exact same optical design, one just has a longer empty tube at the end and a different lens mount.
Not to mention the RF 800mm and RF 1200mm lenses that are just the 400mm and 600mm lenses with permanently attached 2X TCs. That's some great innovation going on at Canon.
p.7 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Of course, those Canon superteles are still fantastic lenses, but the 800 and 1200 are strange misses to me, as it seems like a wonderful opportunity to create a 400/2.8+2xTC and 600/4+2xTC, giving both lenses in one. At that point, I don't think any Canon shooter would care that they were repurposed EF designs.
But I guess that does make it so they can't charge $7000 for a specialized 2x TC you can't remove.
In any case, I do expect Canon will release some very nice updated supertelephotos over the coming year or two.
p.7 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote:
Of course, those Canon superteles are still fantastic lenses, but the 800 and 1200 are strange misses to me, as it seems like a wonderful opportunity to create a 400/2.8+2xTC and 600/4+2xTC, giving both lenses in one. At that point, I don't think any Canon shooter would care that they were repurposed EF designs.
But I guess that does make it so they can't charge $7000 for a specialized 2x TC you can't remove.
In any case, I do expect Canon will release some very nice updated supertelephotos over the coming year or two.
I too think we will see updated versions from both Canon and Sony. Sony was well into mirrorless when they developed theirs, and Canon needed to get lenses to market to keep up. Nikon had a trick up their sleeve and caught the others with their pants down.
I own both Nikon TC lenses and the Canon EF600 F4 III. I had the RF 400 but sold it a year ago. All of them are incredible but the Nikon lenses are beyond amazing. They are each two lenses in one. There's no trade off with the TC's in use.
p.7 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
That's bizarre. The guy a few posts above said built-in TC's are just an antiquated accessory that adds weight. It's actually useful?!?
suteetat wroteAlphaPhotography wroteThe biggest thing Nikon is missing is raw precapture. It is a gamechanger for birding. I'm sure they'll add it in the Z9II though.
suteetat wroteI am sure Sony and Canon will eventually have supertele with built in TC. Did Canon not start the trend with 200-400 over 10 years ago?
Problem is that supertele lens tend to have long shelf life, say at least 10 years.
Sony released 400/2.8 in very limited supply in 2018 so they are dued for a refresh probably in the
next couple of years likely. Canon is in a bit of a bind, their EF mount one was updated after Sony to match Sony's weight and the RF mount one only a few years ago.
Can Canon afford not to make supertele with no built in TC for the next 5-7 years (by then Sony should already have one more than likely) but if they do, they will get some grumpy customers who only bought
new supertele recently as well. Look like Nikon find the right time to introduce supertele twtih built in TC while suffering a few years earlier with heavier supertele than its competitors
Now that I have Z8/Z9 with 400/2.8TC and 800PF, going out to shoot birds have never been more fun and the flexibility are just incredible. One body with 600/4 TC will be fun as well but there are still times when 400/2.8 focal length is very handy and at the moment, I don't see why I would need to look at Sony or Canon at all.Yes, I hope Z9 ii will have raw precapture. I use jpg precapture sometimes on my Z9 but when I go out to shoot birds, I turn internal TC on and off hundreds if not thousands of times more than I need to use precapture.
It would be nice to have both, of course.
Of course internal TC is really useless. Afterall, I can order any animal to move in closer or further on demand and when an animal is misbehaving badly, I have 100% dust proof method of putting on an taking off TC in a heartbeat so
internal TC is just a useless antiquated dead weight crap
No wonder Canon made one over 10 years ago and could not be bother with it anymore.