p.27 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
We know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wrote:
Here's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
p.27 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
The EF -Rf adapter sounds native to me, nice job twisting numerous Canon options across price points into a negative though. Im sure Nikon had a nice 70-200/2.8, as well, I don't consider the 70-200/2.8 IS II to be a compromise,
Sony has much more limited options in the very important 70-200/2.8 space.
But if you consider the excellent 70-200/2.8 IS II an older DSLR lens, preferring the pre 2021 Sony that didn't have such a good reputation or the 70-180 Tamron having no IS to be superior, I dont even know what to tell you.
It's only a negative thought it you look at the world through Canon centric eyes. You should be happy to have access to that brilliant Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 E FL.
Cheers,
Bernard
Jun 01, 2025 at 07:38 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.27 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
bernardl wrote: AmbientMike wroteThe EF -Rf adapter sounds native to me, nice job twisting numerous Canon options across price points into a negative though. Im sure Nikon had a nice 70-200/2.8, as well, I don't consider the 70-200/2.8 IS II to be a compromise,
Sony has much more limited options in the very important 70-200/2.8 space.
But if you consider the excellent 70-200/2.8 IS II an older DSLR lens, preferring the pre 2021 Sony that didn't have such a good reputation or the 70-180 Tamron having no IS to be superior, I dont even know what to tell you.It's only a negative thought it you look at the world through Canon centric eyes. You should be happy to have access to that brilliant Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 E FL.
Cheers,
Bernard
You've been pretty anti Canon in the past, it seems to be clouding your judgment
p.27 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Just so y”all don’t get the wrong idea about those of us who happen to use Canon gear…
…the great majority of us recognize that every brand makes excellent lenses and that fine photographers produce wonderful work using any and all of them…
…. and that focusing on making photographs with whatever gear you chose is the main thing.
p.27 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote:
We know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
The excellent thing about Canon is, you can use the excellent older 70-200/2.8 IS II or III, or buy the RF versions if you have the money. Numerous other options available i believe sigma sport in EF is current, nt and old DSLR lens as has been ridiculously inferred, in this important space, as well.
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.
p.27 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: bernardl wroteAmbientMike wroteThe EF -Rf adapter sounds native to me, nice job twisting numerous Canon options across price points into a negative though. Im sure Nikon had a nice 70-200/2.8, as well, I don't consider the 70-200/2.8 IS II to be a compromise,
Sony has much more limited options in the very important 70-200/2.8 space.
But if you consider the excellent 70-200/2.8 IS II an older DSLR lens, preferring the pre 2021 Sony that didn't have such a good reputation or the 70-180 Tamron having no IS to be superior, I dont even know what to tell you.It's only a negative thought it you look at the world through Canon centric eyes. You should be happy to have access to that brilliant Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 E FL.
Cheers,
BernardYou've been pretty anti Canon in the past, it seems to be clouding your judgment
I have heard it speculated that Bernardl is actually some sort of AI driven Nikon defense bot.
I'm not convinced of that, but maybe a hybrid of some sort. LoL!
p.27 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
1bwana1 wrote: AmbientMike wrotebernardl wroteAmbientMike wroteThe EF -Rf adapter sounds native to me, nice job twisting numerous Canon options across price points into a negative though. Im sure Nikon had a nice 70-200/2.8, as well, I don't consider the 70-200/2.8 IS II to be a compromise,
Sony has much more limited options in the very important 70-200/2.8 space.
But if you consider the excellent 70-200/2.8 IS II an older DSLR lens, preferring the pre 2021 Sony that didn't have such a good reputation or the 70-180 Tamron having no IS to be superior, I dont even know what to tell you.It's only a negative thought it you look at the world through Canon centric eyes. You should be happy to have access to that brilliant Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 E FL.
Cheers,
BernardYou've been pretty anti Canon in the past, it seems to be clouding your judgmentI have heard it speculated that Bernard is actually some sort of AI driven Nikon defense bot.
I'm not convinced of that, but maybe a hybrid of some sort. LoL!
I am flattered, I wish I had the smarts of recent LLMs. But I do appreciate the kind words. I do indeed always strive to provide objective answers.
Speaking of which this is what ChatGPT 4o answers when asked about the best DSLR 70-200mm f2.8:
- Nikon 70–200mm f/2.8E FL ED VR is equal or superior to Canon’s EF IS III in all technical respects, including corrected focus breathing. That makes it arguably the best DSLR 70–200mm f/2.8 lens ever released, especially for high-resolution bodies like the D850.
- Canon EF IS III remains the most versatile and video-friendly, with trusted performance in all scenarios and excellent rendering.
- Sony G SSM II is solid, but its A-mount future is obsolete — best replaced with their mirrorless E-mount GM II lens if possible.
So at the risk of disappointing relative to my LLM level reputation, I still don't understand why a Canon user who is brand agnostic, like Mike obviously is, would consider the availability of such a brilliant Nikon lens as a negative.
p.27 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Seriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrote: comotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.
p.27 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
numbertwo wrote:
The main issue with the cheaper brands is the quality control...
The influencers online always get perfectly centered copies that can perform very well, but the main public maybe not so.
It seems not even influencers get perfect copies all the time
p.27 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The fact that Canon and Sony have been unable to come up with a 35mm f1.2 should tell us something about how incredibly difficult it is to design one that can both offer great image quality and be manufactured consistently.
p.27 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote:
Seriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
...Show more →AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.
I'm glad Canon is staying away from the Dollar Store marketing mentality - where people buy lots of crap they don't need just because it's cheap.
p.27 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Cliff L. wrote: comotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.I'm glad Canon is staying away from the Dollar Store marketing mentality - where people buy lots of crap they don't need just because it's cheap.
Or in other words, you think everyone should only buy Canon lenses because third party lenses aren't good enough? And if someone can't afford the Canon lenses, or needs a different lens that Canon doesn't offer, then it's too bad for them? That's a nice warm way to welcome photographers of all types and economic means into the Canon ecosystem.
p.27 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Wezre wrote: Cliff L. wrotecomotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.I'm glad Canon is staying away from the Dollar Store marketing mentality - where people buy lots of crap they don't need just because it's cheap.Or in other words, you think everyone should only buy Canon lenses because third party lenses aren't good enough? And if someone can't afford the Canon lenses, or needs a different lens that Canon doesn't offer, then it's too bad for them? That's a nice warm way to welcome photographers of all types and economic means into the Canon ecosystem.
It's interesting that you think that, but it's certainly not what I said...
p.27 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Cliff L. wrote: Wezre wroteI'm glad Canon is staying away from the Dollar Store marketing mentality - where people buy lots of crap they don't need just because it's cheap.Or in other words, you think everyone should only buy Canon lenses because third party lenses aren't good enough? And if someone can't afford the Canon lenses, or needs a different lens that Canon doesn't offer, then it's too bad for them? That's a nice warm way to welcome photographers of all types and economic means into the Canon ecosystem.
It's interesting that you think that, but it's certainly not what I said...
OK. You said:
I'm glad Canon is staying away from the Dollar Store marketing mentality - where people buy lots of crap they don't need just because it's cheap.
Can you elaborate on what you meant? 'Cause Wezre's interpretation of what you wrote is the same as mine, and I'm pretty sure it's not merely us. So, if you meant something different, can you explain what you meant?
p.27 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Cliff L. wrote: comotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.I'm glad Canon is staying away from the Dollar Store marketing mentality - where people buy lots of crap they don't need just because it's cheap.
Thanks for the reveal! Canon’s tightly closed mount was in fact driven by sustainability concerns and a, perhaps just a tad paternalistic, desire to help us control our uncontrollable urge to acquire cheap junk. I had overlooked this...
So much so for the old belief that freedom of choice is a central dimension of artistic creation. Canon knows better… just trust them everything will be good with their beautiful beautiful cameras and lenses. The other brands are so nasty.
p.27 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote:
Seriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
...Show more →AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.
comotionfilms wrote:
Seriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
...Show more →AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.
At least people don't seem to be making the ridiculous claim there's no inexpensive lenses available any more, 3rd party and OEM, since i pointed out the numerous lens options available to Canon RF users.
I could say the same to you, you already told us Canon's not allowing this stuff. If a 24-70/2.8 having IS, numerous 70-200/2.8's and 35/1.4's, lightweight 100-400, 30+ years of EF available using what is probably the best adapter our there, huge amount supertele options, in addition to, yes, numerous 3rd party EF options somehow aren't enough for you, and you have to keep harping on this recent 3rd party stuff well, i dont know what tell you,
And Canon pretty clearly isn't just doing this for $$$ like you claim, or if they are, so is Nikon, since their Sigma situation is the same. Of course Nikon is tacking on extra to their Tamrons, but for some weird reason isn't accused of being greedy, of all the dumb things. And Sony just needed lenses, to some degree, I doubt these decisions to let lens companies rip off the mount or not are altruistic
p.27 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
I could say the same to you, you already told us Canon's not allowing this stuff. If a 24-70/2.8 having IS, numerous 70-200/2.8's and 35/1.4's, lightweight 100-400, 30+ years of EF available using what is probably the best adapter our there, huge amount supertele options, in addition to, yes, numerous 3rd party EF options somehow aren't enough for you, and you have to keep harping on this recent 3rd party stuff well, i dont know what tell you,
So, for the record, you're saying that there's no reason for me to want to put a 35-150 / 2-2.8 or 35 / 1.2 on my R5? Or that no one should have an interest in, say, a Sigma 28-105 / 2.8 for half the price of Canon's 24-105 / 2.8 IS? Or, more to the point, that no one shooting Canon should have any interest in *any* of the following lenses:
And Canon pretty clearly isn't just doing this for $$$ like you claim
Please spell out what the reason is, then. Seriously -- explain why Canon is *actively* blocking third party manufacturers from selling RF mount lenses.
p.27 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Everyone knows that you can adapt all that old EF glass, but that’s not what people are talking about Mike. There are around 30 AF FF 3rd party lenses for Nikon’s mirrorless mount and zero for canon RF. ZERO. Seriously man, it’s not the same.
AmbientMike wrote: comotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.comotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.At least people don't seem to be making the ridiculous claim there's no inexpensive lenses available any more, 3rd party and OEM, since i pointed out the numerous lens options available to Canon RF users.
I could say the same to you, you already told us Canon's not allowing this stuff. If a 24-70/2.8 having IS, numerous 70-200/2.8's and 35/1.4's, lightweight 100-400, 30+ years of EF available using what is probably the best adapter our there, huge amount supertele options, in addition to, yes, numerous 3rd party EF options somehow aren't enough for you, and you have to keep harping on this recent 3rd party stuff well, i dont know what tell you,
And Canon pretty clearly isn't just doing this for $$$ like you claim, or if they are, so is Nikon, since their Sigma situation is the same. Of course Nikon is tacking on extra to their Tamrons, but for some weird reason isn't accused of being greedy, of all the dumb things. And Sony just needed lenses, to some degree, I doubt these decisions to let lens companies rip off the mount or not are altruistic ...Show more →
p.27 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Actually I did “need” a fast new 85mm and the Samyang was just better than the Canon offering. Strange that you think you know what other photographers need…
Cliff L. wrote: comotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.I'm glad Canon is staying away from the Dollar Store marketing mentality - where people buy lots of crap they don't need just because it's cheap.
Jun 05, 2025 at 09:36 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.27 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote:
Everyone knows that you can adapt all that old EF glass, but that’s not what people are talking about Mike. There are around 30 AF FF 3rd party lenses for Nikon’s mirrorless mount and zero for canon RF. ZERO. Seriously man, it’s not the same.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.comotionfilms wroteSeriously Mike, wtf are you talking about? Yea, some nice canon glass exists that can be adapted to RF. Great, we get it, we’ve discussed it. The point is that none of the NEW AF FF glass being released by third parties are available on RF because canon has locked 3rd party manufacturers out. That’s not the case on Sony and mostly not the case on Nikon. Shoot your 20 year old 70-200 if you want (I have that lens and still use it too), but having access to the new goodness out there as well would be preferred by many a consumer, including me. I like my canon glass just fine, but there’s a lot of other interesting stuff out there that canon has decided that we can’t use. I get why they are doing it ($$$j, but as a consumer I’d definitely avoid canon at this point if I was starting over. Most of the video market has left canon and I think they are starting to lose their buzz in the stills world, with the younger shooters. I’m sure they will be fine, but as a consumer, they have way less appeal now that they have shut out the other lens manufacturers. Is it their right to do so? Sure, just like it’s my right to encourage others to steer clear of Canon since they no longer seem appealing.
AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteWe know that there are plenty of older lenses out there that you can adapt to RF. What people are missing are all of the newer 3rd party lenses that are being released for Sony and Nikon, but not Canon. I get it, it’s not your cup of tea, but that’s what we are asking for. Older glass is great fun too, but that doesn’t replace the exciting new lenses that are coming out right now.
AmbientMike wroteHere's a couple Sigma 70-200/2.8's available in EF mount, also Tamron has a G2 it looks like, if you want 3rd party and none of the 5 or 6 Canon offerings appeal to you. Older less expensive ones available too. I never did get a native lens on m4/3, didn't find the adapter to be that big of a deal even on tiny 24 Zuiko OM, and i really don't get the aversion to a 3 oz adapter especially on a larger lens like a 70-200/2.8
Canon also has the Rf 24-70/2.8 having IS. I'd think that would be important for video, as we'll as stills, idk about nikon but I don't believe the Sony has stabilization. But if youre not willing to consider any Canon advantages and just want the 3rd party stuff whose companies are apparently expecting to get the lens mount free, i suppose Canon doesn't look so good.At least people don't seem to be making the ridiculous claim there's no inexpensive lenses available any more, 3rd party and OEM, since i pointed out the numerous lens options available to Canon RF users.
I could say the same to you, you already told us Canon's not allowing this stuff. If a 24-70/2.8 having IS, numerous 70-200/2.8's and 35/1.4's, lightweight 100-400, 30+ years of EF available using what is probably the best adapter our there, huge amount supertele options, in addition to, yes, numerous 3rd party EF options somehow aren't enough for you, and you have to keep harping on this recent 3rd party stuff well, i dont know what tell you,
And Canon pretty clearly isn't just doing this for $$$ like you claim, or if they are, so is Nikon, since their Sigma situation is the same. Of course Nikon is tacking on extra to their Tamrons, but for some weird reason isn't accused of being greedy, of all the dumb things. And Sony just needed lenses, to some degree, I doubt these decisions to let lens companies rip off the mount or not are altruistic
Thanks for pointing it out, yet again
Different companies have different lenses. I dont think anyone competes with Canon on T/S lenses, either
You seem to think you know what other photographers need. Not really sure what I'd do with a 35/1.2, myself.