fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

  
 
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.26 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
'- The Chinese market is a lot more important for Nikon than for Canon, Canon has a terrible press in China due to the closing of the RF mount to Chinese manufacturers'

Well, they certainly deserve whatever opprobrium is coming their way from doing so. Two of the Thypoch Simeras are sold in RF (and Z) mount, the 28/1.4 and the 35/1.4. We hope DZO (parent company) also release in Z-mount the other two gems in the Simera line: the 50/1.4 and the 75/1.4. But having said that, DZO is not your average Chinese lens manufacturer.

https://thypoch.com/
https://dzofilm.com/

I see miniscule interest among Canonistas for any manual focus lens! What the Japanese all need to worry about is a longer established outfit - Viltrox. These and other Shenzhen makers (e.g. DJI) have developed some breakthrough optical innovations of late. Stand by for these fast lane outfits. ;-)
May 27, 2025 at 07:51 PM
comotionfilms
Offline
Details
p.26 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
comotionfilms wrotePeople aren’t complaining about “Canon having no lenses” but mentioning that the consumer has much more 3rd party choices with the other mounts. Most of us want choices and options, but If you are happy with canon lenses, or have special needs where certain specific 1st party lenses are essential, then this doesn’t apply. Canon has a ton of older 90s lenses that you can still adapt, but you do miss out on a lot of the recent innovations in the 3rd party market. These new lenses excite some of us, but are of no interest to others, especially those who don’t realize how far the 3rd party market has changed over the last 3-5 years. Canon, Nikon and Sony all make wonderful bodies, so the main difference for many of us is lens selection, though as mentioned, not everyone feels the need to try new and different lens options so just shoot what you like.

AmbientMike wroteI guess I'll look to recommend Canon lenses on the Sony board more, because Canon often has better solutions

Canon is in better shape on 70-200/4's imo, having the older ones, and i just got done recommending one on the Sony board. I have used 10+ different of these extremely useful lenses of this type going back to film. The 70-200/4 L non IS probably beats adapting the "beercan," and the Canon adapter probably beats the EF-E mount adapter.

Canon had the excellent 70-200/2.8 IS II in 2012 or something, before A7 even existed, Sony apparently didnt have a good one til 2021. I've also looked at 30+ year old 80-200/2.8 magic drain pipe recently, Sony doesn't have older to adapt, and Nikon that age isn't going to af, given their never ending lens compatability problems, even on 80's film bodies. You're in better shape on 150/180 macros on Canon I'd bet, and I've looked at older 300/2.8's, yes they can be adapted to Sony, but it's kinda dumb to complain abour Canon having no lenses then have to adapt EF
I looked up the Viltrox 35/1.2, 2 lbs , $1k, basically Rokinon has 35/1.2 in EF, not sure if its the same optics, granted it's mf, in addition to the numerous 1.4 EF options. I'd probably be better off with the Rf 28-70/2.8 and could shoot in lower light utilizing IBIS+IS, if it gives 3 stops or more, in addition to more dof for landscape

People complained about the Samyang Rf 85/1.4 getting banned, and rightfully so, but the af EF version is still available. And I just don't see adding a 3oz adapter to a good sized lens
...Show more →

Comments like this make me realize that Mike is out of touch with the ALT lens market and misses the point of 3rd party lenses. For me, cost isn’t the main driver of lens purchases, though some Chinese lenses are so cheap that I buy them purely out of curiosity. Mike keeps wanting to define “best” as in best lens for everyone, which is weird. Open lens mount means there are more options, which appeals to people like me who…well, like options. There are days when I want to shoot with “worse” lenses because I like the way they flare, or the way they render weird bokeh or the way they swirl, or the way they bloom, or whatever makes them different… Mike looks at charts and specs and thinks that means one lens is best and everyone should pick it and shoot and be happy. Fine for Mike, but that’s not me, thank you very much. I own a lot of expensive glass, but I often rotate other lenses into the mix for a change of pace, or a different look. I can’t tell you how often I leave my RF 85 1.2 at home for the “worse” 3rd party Samyang 85 1.4. If you love your first party lenses and older EF lenses, great. I love a lot of those as well, but the new lenses coming out of other parts of Asia are really interesting these days, even if their MTF scores say that they aren’t anything special for you. And more and more, it seems like canon folks are missing out on these new releases. It’s not the end of the world for most people and I’m too invested in Canon right now, but if I was starting over, I personally wouldn’t pick canon again, at least at this time (probably Nikon).

Oh, and comparing a 2.8 lens and a 1.2 lens is just a weird thing to do, even if one has IS. Both will get the shot for you, but the image will probably look very different and they often have different applications. I’m sure I’m in the minority, but frankly IS isn’t a big deal for me and I rarely shoot at shutter speeds where it’s a concern, unless I’m going for a specific look. We all have different styles and preferences, which is why I like having different lens options, but that’s just me.

May 27, 2025 at 08:41 PM
Vento
Offline
Details
p.26 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
How out of touch he is, is evident in his deliberate disparagement of the Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB, equating it with the Rokinon 35/1.2 in EF.

Maybe he should check out Optical Limits' reviews of the LAB series, especially since he highlighted the source in a previous post regarding the Canon 35/1.4 L VCM.
The Viltrox LAB lenses far outperform various Canon RF lenses reviewed by optical limits..

https://opticallimits.com/nikon/nikon-z/viltrox-af-135mm-f-1-8-z-review/

"The test in Nikon Z mount didn't reveal anything fundamentally new compared to what we have seen in Sony E-mount already, but this was to be expected, of course. The Viltrox AF 135mm f/1.8 LAB Z remains an outstanding lens at a comparatively affordable price point. It is exceeding sharp in the image center straight from f/1.8 and the quality in the outer image field is more than just impressive. And it only gets better from there. Image distortions are low in RAW files and absent in corrected images. Lateral and axial CAs are basically negligible. The bokeh is also very smooth where it counts, and out-of-focus highlights are very clean. The build quality deserves some praise as well. The lens feels very sturdy, and it's also well protected against the elements."

https://opticallimits.com/sony/sony-fe-full-format/viltrox-af-35mm-f-1-2-lab-fe-review/

"Viltrox delivered another impressive lens - this time the ultra-fast Viltrox AF 35mm f/1.2 LAB FE. It's not only fast, but also capable of producing great image quality. It's very sharp at f/1.2 and reaches greatness from f/2. Lateral CAs are low. Axial CAs are noticeable at large aperture settings, although not excessive. The vignetting is typical for such a lens. Images shows a slight pincushion distortions - and our pre-prod sample didn't have a correction profile to eliminate them. The background bokeh is very smooth and out-of-focus highlights are nicely rendered. The build quality is up to professional standards thanks to a weather-sealed all metal housing. The focus control ring is smooth. We wished that Viltrox had used a marked aperture ring instead of "infinite scrolling" but that's a matter of taste. A more precise aperture change per "click" would have been nice, though. The AF is quick and noiseless. Some may find it almost suspicious that we rated many (although not all) Viltrox lenses so highly. However, most of our rating depends on data, and it matches with what we can see in sample images. So, it is once again ... highly recommended!"

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-viltrox-af-35mm-1-2-fe-lab/

"So let’s talk about this Viltrox AF 35mm 1.2 FE LAB. When it was announced I was mainly wondering how it will compare to the Sigma 35mm 1.2 Art DG DN – a lens I have been using since its release and a really strong performer, so not an easy fight to pick. Having used the Sigma extensively, there are three areas where I saw room for improvement: flare resistance could be better, optical vignetting (cat’s eyes) could be lower and it could be a bit smaller and lighter. To my utmost surprise, Viltrox’ engineers managed to achieve all that. But there must have also been some compromises, right? Actually, not really. The Viltrox’ Coma correction is sightly worse (still very good) that is all I could mention here. Personally, I also prefer dedicated aperture rings with actual markings over the programmable control rings of the LAB series lenses, but that isn’t remotely enough to spoil the picture. This is easily Viltrox’ best lens so far and also the best balanced 35mm autofocus lens faster than f/1.4 currently available. I already put my money where my mouth is: my Sigma 35mm 1.2 Art DG DN has been sold and from now on I will be using this Viltrox 35mm 1.2 LAB for all the weddings and reportage work."

https://opticallimits.com/canon/canon-rf/canon-rf-35mm-f-1-4-l-vcm-review/

"The performance of the Canon RF 35mm f/1.4 L VCM is a bit difficult to summarize into a single figure. If image sharpness is what you value the most, this is certainly a lens for you. It's sharp at f/1.4 already and downright superb from f/2 to f/8. It's also resistant to flare, and auto-correction does a good job of correcting vignetting and distortion.The lens does, however, rely heavily on a correction profile to achieve this, which is a bit disappointing for a $1500 USD lens. The correction profile doesn't help with the high axial CAs, and the focus shift is a bit of a concern in manual focus mode, at least. The quality of bokeh is good for such a lens. In terms of build quality, it lives up to its L-designation. Like most other L-class lenses, the outer shell is made of high-quality engineered plastics. The control rings operate smoothly, and there's, of course, some weather sealing. Canon creates a lot of buzz around the new VCM (Voice Coil Motor), and yes, it's super fast and noiseless but that's a baseline expectation for a lens in this price class. However, the VCM does come with a bit of a rattle when you shake the lens (if you are into this). This isn't unusual for this type of AF motor, though. Important for videographers is the very low-focus breathing."

https://opticallimits.com/sony/viltrox-af-16mm-f-1-8-fe-review/#Competition

The Viltrox AF 16mm f/1.8 FE impressed us, to say the least. Ultra-wide lenses are already difficult to design, and high speed on top of this increases the related complexities substantially. Yet, the lens has performed surprisingly well both in our lab as well as during field sessions. The center performance is exceptionally high - most manufacturers manage to do this. However, the Viltrox lens is also capable of providing high-quality results in the outer image field. At f/1.8 and f/2.2, the image corners are already pretty good. At medium aperture settings, the borders/corners are boosted to very good levels - surpassing even the Sony FE 14mm f/1.8 GM here. The field curvature is also very moderate. Lateral CAs are low. Another almost baffling aspect is the near-absence of image distortions in RAW images. The vignetting is high at f/1.8 - more so in RAW images - although that's to be expected in this lens class. Auto-corrected images show a reasonably low light falloff from about f/2.8 onward. Viltrox also made progress with their lens coating - backlight is handled quite well. The build quality of the Viltrox AF 16mm f/1.8 FE is very high, thanks to a dust-proof, all-metal construction with internal focusing. Viltrox kept the weight at a reasonable 550g. The lens also features higher-end goodies such as a dedicated aperture ring with a clickless mode option and custom buttons. Some users will also cheer the return of a distance scale via an LCD display. The STM AF is decently fast and noiseless. Video shooters will also appreciate the lack of focus breathing - once again, without any digital trickery. Many users may still not be aware of Viltrox as a lens manufacturer, but they are becoming a force to be reckoned with. The AF 16mm f/1.8 FE leaves the Laowa 15mm f/2 far behind in the dust. It's a very serious alternative to Sony's own offering. And Viltrox managed this at a much lower price tag. Therefore - Highly Recommended!

As far as I'm concerned, people can stay in their Canon bubble, but I see it as philip_pj has already written, or also opticallimits, Viltrox as a lens manufacturer is becoming a force to be reckoned with.
Impressively, they manage to do this again and again, as optical limits puts it,"once again, without any digital trickery!"
With a 135/1.8, it might not be such a big deal, but it continues, regardless of whether it's a 35/1.2 or even a 16/1.8, whether it's distortion or focus breathing.
Other OEM manufacturers could learn a thing or two from this.



Edited on May 27, 2025 at 09:27 PM · View previous versions
May 27, 2025 at 08:53 PM
numbertwo
Offline
Details
p.26 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The main issue with the cheaper brands is the quality control...
The influencers online always get perfectly centered copies that can perform very well, but the main public maybe not so.
May 27, 2025 at 09:27 PM
comotionfilms
Offline
Details
p.26 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
numbertwo wrote:
The main issue with the cheaper brands is the quality control...
The influencers online always get perfectly centered copies that can perform very well, but the main public maybe not so.


I haven’t had that issue, but if I buy from BH and there’s an issue, I can just swap it out for another.
May 27, 2025 at 10:13 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.26 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
numbertwo wrote:
The main issue with the cheaper brands is the quality control...
The influencers online always get perfectly centered copies that can perform very well, but the main public maybe not so.


That is true, but those things can happen with the big 3 also.

Heck, I even had issues with a 9,000 US$ Phaseone Schneider 120mm f4 macro lens made in Nagano...

But yes, it certainly is more frequent with cheaper glass. Considering the stunning quality of many goods manufactured in China (starting with most Apple products), this has nothing to do with China and everything to do with their price point.

Cheers,
Bernard
May 27, 2025 at 11:36 PM
takowasa
Offline
Details
p.26 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Vento wrote:
How out of touch he is, is evident in his deliberate disparagement of the Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB, equating it with the Rokinon 35/1.2 in EF.

Maybe he should check out Optical Limits' reviews of the LAB series, especially since he highlighted the source in a previous post regarding the Canon 35/1.4 L VCM.
The Viltrox LAB lenses far outperform various Canon RF lenses reviewed by optical limits..

https://opticallimits.com/nikon/nikon-z/viltrox-af-135mm-f-1-8-z-review/

"The test in Nikon Z mount didn't reveal anything fundamentally new compared to what we have seen in Sony E-mount already, but this was to be expected, of course. The Viltrox AF 135mm f/1.8 LAB Z

https://opticallimits.com/sony/sony-fe-full-format/viltrox-af-35mm-f-1-2-lab-fe-review/

"Viltrox delivered another impressive lens - this time the ultra-fast Viltrox AF 35mm f/1.2 LAB FE. It's not only fast, but also capable of producing great image quality. It's very sharp at f/1.2 and reaches greatness from f/2. Lateral CAs are low. Axial CAs are noticeable at large aperture settings, although not excessive. The vignetting is typical for such a lens. Images shows a slight pincushion distortions - and our pre-prod sample didn't have a correction profile to eliminate them. The background bokeh is very smooth and out-of-focus highlights are nicely rendered. The build quality is up to professional standards thanks to a weather-sealed all metal housing. The focus control ring is smooth. We wished that Viltrox had used a marked aperture ring instead of "infinite scrolling" but that's a matter of taste. A more precise aperture change per "click" would have been nice, though. The AF is quick and noiseless. Some may find it almost suspicious that we rated many (although not all) Viltrox lenses so highly. However, most of our rating depends on data, and it matches with what we can see in sample images. So, it is once again ... highly recommended!"

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-viltrox-af-35mm-1-2-fe-lab/

"So let’s talk about this Viltrox AF 35mm 1.2 FE LAB. When it was announced I was mainly wondering how it will compare to the Sigma 35mm 1.2 Art DG DN – a lens I have been using since its release and a really strong performer, so not an easy fight to pick. Having used the Sigma extensively, there are three areas where I saw room for improvement: flare resistance could be better, optical vignetting (cat’s eyes) could be lower and it could be a bit smaller and lighter. To my utmost surprise, Viltrox’ engineers managed to achieve all that. But there must have also been some compromises, right? Actually, not really. The Viltrox’ Coma correction is sightly worse (still very good) that is all I could mention here. Personally, I also prefer dedicated aperture rings with actual markings over the programmable control rings of the LAB series lenses, but that isn’t remotely enough to spoil the picture. This is easily Viltrox’ best lens so far and also the best balanced 35mm autofocus lens faster than f/1.4 currently available. I already put my money where my mouth is: my Sigma 35mm 1.2 Art DG DN has been sold and from now on I will be using this Viltrox 35mm 1.2 LAB for all the weddings and reportage work."

https://opticallimits.com/canon/canon-rf/canon-rf-35mm-f-1-4-l-vcm-review/

"The performance of the Canon RF 35mm f/1.4 L VCM is a bit difficult to summarize into a single figure. If image sharpness is what you value the most, this is certainly a lens for you. It's sharp at f/1.4 already and downright superb from f/2 to f/8. It's also resistant to flare, and auto-correction does a good job of correcting vignetting and distortion.The lens does, however, rely heavily on a correction profile to achieve this, which is a bit disappointing for a $1500 USD lens. The correction profile doesn't help with the high axial CAs, and the focus shift is a bit of a concern in manual focus mode, at least. The quality of bokeh is good for such a lens. In terms of build quality, it lives up to its L-designation. Like most other L-class lenses, the outer shell is made of high-quality engineered plastics. The control rings operate smoothly, and there's, of course, some weather sealing. Canon creates a lot of buzz around the new VCM (Voice Coil Motor), and yes, it's super fast and noiseless but that's a baseline expectation for a lens in this price class. However, the VCM does come with a bit of a rattle when you shake the lens (if you are into this). This isn't unusual for this type of AF motor, though. Important for videographers is the very low-focus breathing."

https://opticallimits.com/sony/viltrox-af-16mm-f-1-8-fe-review/#Competition

The Viltrox AF 16mm f/1.8 FE impressed us, to say the least. Ultra-wide lenses are already difficult to design, and high speed on top of this increases the related complexities substantially. Yet, the lens has performed surprisingly well both in our lab as well as during field sessions. The center performance is exceptionally high - most manufacturers manage to do this. However, the Viltrox lens is also capable of providing high-quality results in the outer image field. At f/1.8 and f/2.2, the image corners are already pretty good. At medium aperture settings, the borders/corners are boosted to very good levels - surpassing even the Sony FE 14mm f/1.8 GM here. The field curvature is also very moderate. Lateral CAs are low. Another almost baffling aspect is the near-absence of image distortions in RAW images. The vignetting is high at f/1.8 - more so in RAW images - although that's to be expected in this lens class. Auto-corrected images show a reasonably low light falloff from about f/2.8 onward. Viltrox also made progress with their lens coating - backlight is handled quite well. The build quality of the Viltrox AF 16mm f/1.8 FE is very high, thanks to a dust-proof, all-metal construction with internal focusing. Viltrox kept the weight at a reasonable 550g. The lens also features higher-end goodies such as a dedicated aperture ring with a clickless mode option and custom buttons. Some users will also cheer the return of a distance scale via an LCD display. The STM AF is decently fast and noiseless. Video shooters will also appreciate the lack of focus breathing - once again, without any digital trickery. Many users may still not be aware of Viltrox as a lens manufacturer, but they are becoming a force to be reckoned with. The AF 16mm f/1.8 FE leaves the Laowa 15mm f/2 far behind in the dust. It's a very serious alternative to Sony's own offering. And Viltrox managed this at a much lower price tag. Therefore - Highly Recommended!

As far as I'm concerned, people can stay in their Canon bubble, but I see it as philip_pj has already written, or also opticallimits, Viltrox as a lens manufacturer is becoming a force to be reckoned with.
Impressively, they manage to do this again and again, as optical limits puts it,"once again, without any digital trickery!"
With a 135/1.8, it might not be such a big deal, but it continues, regardless of whether it's a 35/1.2 or even a 16/1.8, whether it's distortion or focus breathing.
Other OEM manufacturers could learn a thing or two from this.

...Show more →

Any argument against third party lenses as viable options for photographers is beyond ridiculous. That is, how does lack of choice benefit the consumer? But lack of choice can absolutely benefit the manufacturer. It doesn't matter how good or bad third party options are. They are *options*, and options are always good to have.

Right now, Canon is #1, and I'm pretty sure that Canon feels that they make more money by not allowing third party lenses than they would make if they allowed them. If there comes a time that Canon feels otherwise, they will change their policy. However, I am not convinced that Canon does make more money by blocking third party. I'm not saying they don't -- I'm saying I'm not convinced.

If third party manufacturers are making enough compelling options (for whatever reasons, price, quality, focal/aperture ranges, or whatever) that people who shoot Canon want but can't get in RF mount, then Canon loses all the money they would ever give to Canon if they switch systems. In addition, if newcomers choose others over Canon due to Canon's relative lack of lenses compared to others' options, then, again, Canon loses all the money they would have given Canon. The question, then, is how that loss of income compares to all the extra income they gain by all their customers who they are "forcing" to buy OEM who might have otherwise spent their money on third party.

Either way, it's a hypothetical. But since Canon is #1, they feel that their policy of locking RF mount is working to their advantage. However, even if true, that may well be short-sighted, just as American car manufacturers thought their #1 status over imports "justified" decisions that they made which did not benefit the consumer. That is, if Canon's current policy of blocking third party from making RF mount lenses is wrong, then, by the time they free RF mount to third party, it may be too late. Not that Canon will fade away, but their #1 dominance will either shrink significantly or they may find themselves #2 or #3, and they may stay there for the foreseeable future.

It's easy to play armchair quarterback, of course, but all of that is neither here nor there with regards to what's best for the consumer. And what's best for the consumer is choice. But what's best for the consumer does not necessarily align with what's best for the manufacturer. In the end, though, these are First World Problems that we should all be grateful to have. For an increasing number of people, Canon's decision to lock third party out of RF mount is the most trivial of problems to worry about.
May 28, 2025 at 01:06 AM
Vento
Offline
Details
p.26 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
numbertwo wrote:
The main issue with the cheaper brands is the quality control...
The influencers online always get perfectly centered copies that can perform very well, but the main public maybe not so.


Certainly a factor, although this is not an uncommon occurrence even among major manufacturers.
I see the bigger problem in the lack of infrastructure.
Within a 20km/12.5-mile radius, I have three official Nikon dealers here alone.
Viltrox currently doesn't have any such service points.
They're supposed to be accommodating and offer replacements, but that's definitely not comparable and is one of the factors that cost manufacturers a lot of money.

With Canon, Nikon, and Sony, I have a gigantic dealer network and an established infrastructure for repair and support.
Specifically regarding my place of residence, I get a 1-year international Nikon warranty on Z lenses, plus an additional 4-year warranty from Nikon Germany.
So every Z lens comes with a 5-year warranty from Nikon.
This is also a significant advantage compared to Viltrox, where I get a 1-year warranty and will then struggle to find a service/repair point if a defect occurs after the 1-year warranty has expired.

Another important factor is the reverse engineering.
Viltrox doesn't have access to the Z-mount protocols and have reverse engineered Nikon's autofocus communications.
As far as I know, articel of Thom Hogan, they work with some kind of F-mount protocols, tricking the camera into thinking it's using an F-mount lens.
This definitely has a negative impact on AF performance in very demanding scenarios

I've already written about this in the thread where I see disadvantages.

OEMs have a number of advantages, that go beyond the purely optical properties, so I can certainly understand if you're not interested in 3rd-party solutions. OEM lenses are designed specifically for the camera system, ensuring optimal compatibility and performance. Usually with higher grade materials, better coatings and undergo rigorous testing. Support, compatibility, realiability, AF quality/speed/precision, contact points for repairs, spare parts availability, retaining value upon resale, peace of mind.

My main point in my last post: the days of looking down arrogantly on Chinese manufacturers (as it resonates here again and again) like Viltrox are over, at least with lenses like the 135/1.8 LAB, 35/1.2 LAB, or even the 16/1.8.
These lenses are optically on par with comparable products from the major manufacturers, some are even already surpassed.
Considering that Viltrox will be releasing more exotic lenses with the LAB series, then for the price of a Z 35/1.2 S from Nikon, you'll ultimately get a 35/1.2 LAB Z, an 85/1.2 LAB Z, and on top of that, a 135/1.8 LAB Z.
Or to put it another way, I can buy the 35/1.2 LAB three times for that price.
The lack of infrastructure doesn't hurt so much when the lens with very comparable optical performance costs only 1/3 the price.
If it breaks, I'll buy a new one if necessary and still save 1/3 of the comparable OEM lens.

And even if, like me, you go for the OEM lens (Plena instead of Viltrox LAB) and currently avoid Viltrox in the higher price segment, I benefit from the price pressure that this creates over time on the high end Nikon Z S-primes.
Once initial demand is met upon release, it also drives discounts on lenses like the Plena, Z 35/1.2 S, and, in the future, other lenses in the 50/1.2 and 85/1.2 categories.

It will also fill gaps that Nikon hasn't yet addressed, such as the excellent 16mm f/1.8 from Viltrox.
A Viltrox Pro series with 35/50/85 f/1.4 is to follow, which is also welcome, as Nikon's 35/50 f/1.4 offerings are rather mediocre and I have no doubt that Viltrox will deliver a noticeably higher level with the announced f/1.4 Pro series.

Competition, such as that currently being built by Viltrox with its LAB and Pro series, not only stimulates business here, but in the medium term, it also has an eroding effect on the pricing of high-end OEM prime lenses, which until now have largely been unrivaled.
The exception might be Sigma (whose high-quality optics are E- + L-mount exclusive with native mount) in the field of very high-quality AF lenses, but Viltrox is now also playing in this league.
This, in turn, requires manufacturers like Nikon to continually renew their lead, it promotes innovation to justify the premium surcharge for its high-quality and high priced, exotic S-prime lenses, as Viltrox has made rapid progress in the optical capabilities of its latest and highest-quality lenses.
It also encourages reactions and thus product diversity, as Nikon's f/1.4 series is likely a direct response to the ever-expanding AF offerings from Chinese manufacturers in this segment.
To offer something fast but moderately priced apart from the more expensive S-primes
Thus, Nikon customers ultimately benefit indirectly from the competition within the Z mount, even if they remain with OEMs.

May 28, 2025 at 02:53 AM
Hawker man
Offline
Details
p.26 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Several years ago I owned a series of Olympus OM film SLRs, ending with the OM4ti. As well as Olympus Zuiko lenses I had a couple of third party lenses, which worked perfectly with my older Olympus cameras. These were obviously reverse engineered - back in the days when things were simpler, before auto focus, IS etc. I was quite taken aback when NONE of these worked with my new OM4. Olympus had made some minor change or changes to their mount which didn’t affect any of their Zuiko lenses - some several years old by then - but which locked out my third party lenses. I came to the conclusion that, whatever make my camera was, I’d better stick to that manufacturer’s lenses in future.

I now own a Canon R5 and half a dozen RF lenses, mostly L series. Yes, it’d be nice to have access to third party lenses but once burnt, I won’t take the risk. Here in Australia Canon offer a full five year warranty on their lenses if bought from an authorised local distributor and, for me, that’s the clincher.
May 28, 2025 at 11:07 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.26 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
There are 2 types of 3rd party lenses:
- reversed engineered ones
- those using a license of the mount

Theoretical incompatibility risks can only occur with the first type.

Most, if not all, Sony FE mount lenses belong to the second type. For Nikon Z mount at least the Sigma (aPS-C only), Tamron (FF only) and Voigtlander (FF only) also do. Some claim that all Chinese brands lenses do belong to the 1st type.

Btw, even for first type, I haven’t heard of any physical mount change for at least 20 years. The risk is only protocole changes. But Nikon obviously sees 3rd party lenses as an asset serving their customers, not as a threat. So why would they want to trigger an incompatibility now?

Cheers,
Bernard
May 28, 2025 at 12:05 PM
melcat
Offline
Details
p.26 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Hawker man wrote:
I was quite taken aback when NONE of these worked with my new OM4. Olympus had made some minor change or changes to their mount which didn’t affect any of their Zuiko lenses - some several years old by then - but which locked out my third party lenses.


The OM-4 added a microswitch to the mating surface of its bayonet mount, so that it could automatically clear stored spot meter readings when a lens was dismounted. While the microswitch either wasn’t in the swept path of screws on Olympus Zuiko lenses, or the screws were flush enough not to cause a problem, the screws on some third party lenses fouled it. There were stories of lenses breaking the switch, and I suppose if a recessed screw aligned exactly over the switch the camera would think there was no lens and you wouldn’t be able to take a spot meter reading. I filled in the screw recess on at least one of my Tamron Adaptall II adapters with 2 part car body filler and sanded it flat. If I recall correctly, Tamron changed the location of the screw in later production adapters.

May 28, 2025 at 09:42 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.26 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
With third party lenses all three manufacturers (Canon, Nikon, & Sony) provide important limitations.

Canon doesn't seem to license the RF mount to anyone for autofocus lenses. It isn't announced, but their strategy seems to be to allow third parties to make EF mount lenses that can be adapted and this will of course be a clear advantage for their own lenses over third party lenses. They seem to have also made an exception for manual focus lenses as Samyang, Voigtlander and Zeiss now have what appear to be lenses with licensed RF mounts with fully functioning electronic contacts--but obviously without AF.

Nikon allows third parties to license their Z mount, but not many manufacturers have taken them up on this possibility. Tamron builds lenses that get sold as Nikon lenses and makes a few with Tamron labels as well. Voigtlander has licensed the mount and now Zeiss has with the new mirrorless Otus lenses. Sigma seems to have licensed the mount but only for APS-C lenses. So although Nikon seems to allow third parties to license the mount, the deal must not be that enticing as not many manufacturers have taken the challenge to make licensed Z mount lenses.

Sony allows a lot of companies to license the mount, but then handicaps the third party lenses. This is of primary importance for fast action shooting where third party lenses are restricted to 15 fps and third party lenses are also all incompatible with Sony teleconverters, and no third party has built teleconverters yet (I would think Sigma would if they were allowed to do so). So although they license the mount to lots of folks they are still giving their own lenses a leg up.

I don't think any of these strategies is optimal to us as the buyer of lenses. All allow some third party lens options, but all still significantly protect OEM lenses.
May 29, 2025 at 05:48 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.26 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Steve Spencer wrote:
With third party lenses all three manufacturers (Canon, Nikon, & Sony) provide important limitations.

Canon doesn't seem to license the RF mount to anyone for autofocus lenses. It isn't announced, but their strategy seems to be to allow third parties to make EF mount lenses that can be adapted and this will of course be a clear advantage for their own lenses over third party lenses. They seem to have also made an exception for manual focus lenses as Samyang, Voigtlander and Zeiss now have what appear to be lenses with licensed RF mounts with fully functioning electronic contacts--but
...Show more →

In the end using Sony FE mount on Z mount cameras through as adapter, although not perfect either, is one of the best options.

Cheers,
Bernard

May 29, 2025 at 07:36 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.26 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Cliff L. wrote:
melcat wroteA rational company would either open the mount or offer the lenses—and Canon is doing neither.
Trying to follow the whims of a few vocal posters on social media chat sites is not "rational".

A rational company looks at what products they can sell in sufficient volume and at a specific profit margin in order to provide consistent earnings growth, ideally while maintaining or growing market share.

Canon is profitable and has the largest market share, ergo they must be rational.


I don't know about Canon, but I know many cases where that is incorrect.

EBH
May 29, 2025 at 09:47 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.26 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
bernardl wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteWith third party lenses all three manufacturers (Canon, Nikon, & Sony) provide important limitations.

Canon doesn't seem to license the RF mount to anyone for autofocus lenses. It isn't announced, but their strategy seems to be to allow third parties to make EF mount lenses that can be adapted and this will of course be a clear advantage for their own lenses over third party lenses. They seem to have also made an exception for manual focus lenses as Samyang, Voigtlander and Zeiss now have what appear to be lenses with licensed RF mounts with fully functioning electronic contacts--but obviously without AF.

Nikon allows third parties to license their Z mount, but not many manufacturers have taken them up on this possibility. Tamron builds lenses that get sold as Nikon lenses and makes a few with Tamron labels as well. Voigtlander has licensed the mount and now Zeiss has with the new mirrorless Otus lenses. Sigma seems to have licensed the mount but only for APS-C lenses. So although Nikon seems to allow third parties to license the mount, the deal must not be that enticing as not many manufacturers have taken the challenge to make licensed Z mount lenses.

Sony allows a lot of companies to license the mount, but then handicaps the third party lenses. This is of primary importance for fast action shooting where third party lenses are restricted to 15 fps and third party lenses are also all incompatible with Sony teleconverters, and no third party has built teleconverters yet (I would think Sigma would if they were allowed to do so). So although they license the mount to lots of folks they are still giving their own lenses a leg up.

I don't think any of these strategies is optimal to us as the buyer of lenses. All allow some third party lens options, but all still significantly protect OEM lenses.
In the end using Sony FE mount on Z mount cameras through as adapter, although not perfect either, is one of the best options.

Cheers,
Bernard



This strategy can work, but one should keep in mind that E mount to Z camera adapters appear to be reverse engineered and not licensed to use the Z mount. In that way this solution appears to have no benefit over reverse engineered lenses like Viltrox lenses and as Viltrox makes one of the popular E mount to Z camera adapters, we can expect that adapter works just like the Viltrox lenses.
May 30, 2025 at 05:53 AM
Hawker man
Offline
Details
p.26 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Thanks for the explanation, Melcat. That, of course, just proves my point: a manufacturer can readily make some minor adjustment to its mount that doesn’t affect their lenses, but could well affect third party ones. With complex electronic linkages this seems even more possible today.

melcat wrote:
Hawker man wroteI was quite taken aback when NONE of these worked with my new OM4. Olympus had made some minor change or changes to their mount which didn’t affect any of their Zuiko lenses - some several years old by then - but which locked out my third party lenses.
The OM-4 added a microswitch to the mating surface of its bayonet mount, so that it could automatically clear stored spot meter readings when a lens was dismounted. While the microswitch either wasn’t in the swept path of screws on Olympus Zuiko lenses, or the screws were flush enough not to cause a problem, the screws on some third party lenses fouled it. There were stories of lenses breaking the switch, and I suppose if a recessed screw aligned exactly over the switch the camera would think there was no lens and you wouldn’t be able to take a spot
...Show more →
May 30, 2025 at 07:39 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.26 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Steve Spencer wrote:
With third party lenses all three manufacturers (Canon, Nikon, & Sony) provide important limitations.

Canon doesn't seem to license the RF mount to anyone for autofocus lenses. It isn't announced, but their strategy seems to be to allow third parties to make EF mount lenses that can be adapted and this will of course be a clear advantage for their own lenses over third party lenses. They seem to have also made an exception for manual focus lenses as Samyang, Voigtlander and Zeiss now have what appear to be lenses with licensed RF mounts with fully functioning electronic contacts--but
...Show more →

All true for FF, but Canon seems pretty happy to let Sigma pad their optical offerings for their three new crop cameras. I haven't tried it, but, according to the internet, they even allow the full e-shutter frame rates on the r7 and r10 with the Sigma DC lenses. It seems like they're being treated as native OEM, and that's smart. Just like with Sony, if it weren't for Sigma, people would have a lot fewer reasons to take Canon's APSC offerings seriously.
Jun 01, 2025 at 11:11 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.26 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
If you are willing to compromise with DSLR era lenses on your RF mount camera due to the lack of native RF mount options then you might as well adapt Nikon lenses such as the superior 70-200mm f2.8 E FL.

Cheers,
Bernard
Jun 01, 2025 at 04:44 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.26 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The EF -Rf adapter sounds native to me, nice job twisting numerous Canon options across price points into a negative though. Im sure Nikon had a nice 70-200/2.8, as well, I don't consider the 70-200/2.8 IS II to be a compromise,

Sony has much more limited options in the very important 70-200/2.8 space.

But if you consider the excellent 70-200/2.8 IS II an older DSLR lens, preferring the pre 2021 Sony that didn't have such a good reputation or the 70-180 Tamron having no IS to be superior, I dont even know what to tell you.
Jun 01, 2025 at 05:33 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister