p.22 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know? ...Show more →
The disappointment isn’t limited to this forum. I see complaints about Canon’s lack of RF Mount third party options all over the the internet. You may not care that there is no RF option to use a Tamron 35-150, or Viltrox 135/35 1.2 or TTArtisan 75mm f/2 (list goes on and on) but plenty of people do find the lack of third party options as an unfortunate con that comes with being in the RF ecosystem. And no, EF lenses do not make up for it.
p.22 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
If you think no one cared/cares about third party lenses, then I really don't know what to say. That's about as delusional as it gets, to be honest. Let's give even the simplest of examples: Tamron has a very nice 28-75 / 2.8 available, and I'm pretty sure that everyone who bought or will buy the Canon RF 28-75 / 2.8 would have had more than a little interest in that lens. Same goes for the Tamron 17-28 / 2.8 and the Canon RF 16-28 / 2.8. Same goes for the Sigma 35 / 1.2 or 50 / 1.2 vs the Canon RF offerings. For a more exotic example, same goes for the Sigma 28-45 / 1.8.
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
Pretty sure that Canon didn't want Tamron's 35-150 / 2-2.8 to be available for RF mount when they sell their 28-70 / 2, especially given that the Tamron is significantly lighter and costs significantly less.
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt...
No doubt. But, that is more the rule than the exception these days, so you're in good company.
...because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?
Sony owns a big chunk of Tamron. And? Tamron makes lenses for everyone but Canon. Sony makes sensors for everyone but Canon. Sony wants to sell product -- is that really so hard to understand? Now, Canon wants to sell product, too. They differ with Sony in that Canon feels the best way to sell product is to "force" everyone to buy only Canon. Canon's strategy, given that they're #1, may be a successful strategy, in exactly the same way that Apple's strategy is a successful strategy. In fact, Canon may well have noticed Apple's success and switched from being an open system to a closed system to emulate Apple's business strategy.
Do I know that? No, I do not. But I do know that Canon is the *only* camera maker with a closed mount (of Canon, Nikon, Sony, and Panasonic), and I also know that the reason for that is that Canon feels they make more money that way whereas the other manufacturers feel that having an open mount makes them more money (perhaps because they're not #1).
May 21, 2025 at 12:29 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.22 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Posting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?
p.22 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Posting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know? ...Show more →
Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.
p.22 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Why would you even start to buy into a brand with so bad optics that you simply must have 3rd party lenses? THAT seems like dying on some weird hills to me!
p.22 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Z250SA wrote:
Why would you even start to buy into a brand with so bad optics that you simply must have 3rd party lenses? THAT seems like dying on some weird hills to me!
You are missing the point of 3rd party lenses, and why they are so popular. Canon, Nikon and Sony all make wonderful 1st party lenses.
p.22 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Cliff L. wrote: aCuria wroteAs far as I can tell, the EF 35/1.4L is sharper than the RF 35mm f1.4 VCM, and the EF 16-35/2.8L is sharper than the RF 15-35/2.8L.What are you basing this on? I've owned multiple copies of every Canon wide zoom, from the EF 20-35mm f2.8L onwards, and none of them came remotely close to the sharpness of the RF 15-35mm f2.8L. Those lenses were always the weakest segment of Canon's EF lens lineup.
I always liked my 16-35L, maybe I had a really good copy. You can see from this sample the 15-35's peripheral seems less sharp than the 16-35L on the wide end.
The 15-35 is also really heavy for a mirrorless lens, its the weight of the 16-35GM II and 16-35 f/4 PZ combined.
I would expect the heavier lens to have less vignetting like the Nikon Plena, but in this case the 15-35 has super high vignetting (4.57ev at 15mm according to optical limits.)
p.22 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Z250SA wrote:
Why would you even start to buy into a brand with so bad optics that you simply must have 3rd party lenses? THAT seems like dying on some weird hills to me!
Do you honestly think that’s the reason? The reason is choice at a different price point and different optics. Tamron makes a 35-150mm f/2-2.8. Nikon doesn’t make such a lens, nor does Canon. Sony makes an even faster version now, but it’s $4,000, enormous, and doesn’t go as wide.
But the biggest reason is price. I may want a Nikon 135 f/1.8 Plena. And it’s probably the best 135mm lens on the market, third or first party. But it’s also very expensive, and I don’t use that focal length enough to justify that cost. Meanwhile Viltrox makes the 135/1.8 LAB which is also exceptional, with 95% of the performance of the Plena, but it only costs $900 compared to the $2,300 Plena.
They also have their 35/1.2 LAB which is also truly outstanding (Sony only for now but is coming to Nikon in the next couple of months). It’s only $1,000, compared to $2,800 for the Nikon 35/1.2. I could literally buy BOTH Viltrox LAB lenses and still spend $400 less than just buying the Plena.
p.22 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Z250SA wrote:
Why would you even start to buy into a brand with so bad optics that you simply must have 3rd party lenses? THAT seems like dying on some weird hills to me!
Some people don't buy the third party lenses due to the first party lenses being bad. They buy them because they are (substantially!) less expensive, or because they offer things that the first party lenses don't (like super-zoom ranges).
I have used Canon (EF - I had a lot of L glass and a couple of Sigma lenses). I have used Nikon - I mostly used Sigma Art lenses. I now use Sony, and I have mostly GM and G lenses.
With Sony you have plenty of choice in lenses, but there are two limitations - third party lenses can't take teleconverters, and can't autofocus faster than 15 frames/second. Given I'm using an A9 III and an A1 II, I've chosen to go with Sony's GM and G lenses, and they are very fine lenses.
For people shooting on a budget, and using bodies like the A7IV or any of the A7C range (even the A7R range), the restriction of frame rate has no impact at all, so they can use third party lenses and save a considerable amount of money.
For people with less constrained budgets, Sony offers some worthwhile options. For example. the latest addition: the 50-150mm f/2 zoom is a delight to use, and is, so far, unique (the Tamron 35-150mm is only f/2 up to 40mm, and drops down to f/2.8 well before it gets to 150mm). Is there another lens offering f/2 at 150mm? With the 28-70mm I have two f/2 zooms covering a very useful range.
Each brand offers some unique lenses, but I'm happy with the options I have when using Sony. I like that third party lenses are plentiful, but I am very happy with the quality of Sony's first party lenses.
May 21, 2025 at 04:23 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.22 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote: AmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird....Show more →
Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even today
p.22 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Tony Ross wrote:
... They buy them because they are (substantially!) less expensive, or because they offer things that the first party lenses don't (like super-zoom ranges).
Or things like absolute superiority in optical performance. I can name four such primes, three of which I own: the Sigma 35 Art, the Rokinon 135/2, the C/V 110, and the Viltrox 50 Air. All of these are breakthrough lenses, or were at time of release and, yes, happen to be 3rd party. That they can be purchased at a reasonable price is secondary.
p.22 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: comotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even today ...Show more →
Because there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.
p.22 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: comotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
It's difficult in the same way that it would be difficult to prove Santa is real.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something...
I'm going to take the high road here.
...to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
Did I read that right?! Did you just say (imply) that Tamron is charging Canon to make lenses for RF mount?! Really? I mean, really? Did you also "justify" Canon not opening RF mount to third party due to all the available third party EF lenses? You're really making it difficult to stay on the high road!
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even today
So you're saying no one needs third party RF lenses. If someone is so hyped up about a third party lens, just use an old EF third party lens? Wow. I mean, just wow.
Anyway, where can I get that third party 35-150 / 2-2.8 or 35 / 1.2 (with AF, of course!) that I can mount on my R5? Or are you telling me that no one needs those lenses, anyway, and that we're "lame" for even thinking to use them, 'cause the only thing anyone needs is what Canon offers in RF mount or is available in EF mount?
And if your next bit of wisdom is, "If you like third party so much, then why don't you just sell your Canon gear and get the hell out!" Well, maybe I like my Canon gear (a lot) and maybe I would also like to use third party lenses on my Canon camera. And, surprise, I'm not the only one. And double surprise, this does not benefit me and many others, but I can certainly understand how it benefits Canon.
p.22 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: AmbientMike wroteLet's keep it real and admit that Canon may have a good reason to not allow 3rd party.As I stated, they do have a good reason: they feel they make more money by keeping RF locked.
Earlier quoteAnd that you really dont know the reasons unless you are privy to the negotiations (which I doubt.)Here's what I do know: Sony allows 3rd party make lenses for their system, and the lenses work great. Nikon allows Tamron and Viltrox make lenses for their system, and the lenses work great.
Earlier quoteWhatever the problems are, Nikon is in much the same boat.Tamron and Viltrox are in their boat. No one is in Canon's boat except Canon (for RF -- they are letting Sigma in to the RF-s boat). So, from where I sit, not "much the same boat" at all. Not even remotely the same boat.
Earlier quoteSame Sigma lenses as Canon, and not many Tamron. It's naive to assume that it could only be Canons fault given their #1 competitor owns a big chunk of TamronIt's not Canon's "fault", it's Canon's *choice* as they feel it makes them more money. And maybe it does. So if there's something I don't know, it's whether Canon's choice does benefit Canon. That is, as I said before, does the additional money they make by "forcing" Canon users to buy only Canon lenses make them more money than the loss of sales from all who switched systems to use lenses Canon didn't offer? That I don't know. To be honest, I don't think Canon knows, either. But they're #1 right now, so they think it's either working or that the difference isn't important.
Here's a quick question: why is it good that I can't put a Tamron 35-150 / 2-2.8 or Viltrox 35 / 1.2 on my Canon R5? I know why it's good for Canon, but why is it good for me?...Show more →
So were you in the room when Canon made this decision to not allow 3rd party? Somehow I doubt it, so how do you know their reasons for doing things that way?
So who is delusional, here?
May 21, 2025 at 05:32 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.22 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote: AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too. ...Show more →
I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)
p.22 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
What does Tamron have to do with all of the other 3rd party options (or lack there of, in regards to Canon)? Sony’s stake in Tamron has zero impact on Samyang and all of the numerous Chinese 3rd party options. Why are you grasping at such weird theories when the obvious one is so… obvious?
p.22 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
So were you in the room when Canon made this decision to not allow 3rd party? Somehow I doubt it, so how do you know their reasons for doing things that way?
I wasn't in the room for a lot of decisions that were made on any number of topics, and I very much know the reasons the decisions were made. Here's a hint in the case of Canon not allowing third party to make lenses for RF mount: it wasn't for the benefit of people who use Canon cameras.
So who is delusional, here?
Do you really want me to say? I'm trying to be polite, but if you want me to spell it out, then just say so. By the way, did you see my question?
takowasa wrote:
Here's a quick question: why is it good that I can't put a Tamron 35-150 / 2-2.8 or Viltrox 35 / 1.2 on my Canon R5? I know why it's good for Canon, but why is it good for me?
I'd be interested in your answer.
May 21, 2025 at 05:39 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.22 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.It's difficult in the same way that it would be difficult to prove Santa is real.
Earlier quoteThe weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something...I'm going to take the high road here.
Earlier quote...to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.Did I read that right?! Did you just say (imply) that Tamron is charging Canon to make lenses for RF mount?! Really? I mean, really? Did you also "justify" Canon not opening RF mount to third party due to all the available third party EF lenses? You're really making it difficult to stay on the high road!
Earlier quoteIf you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todaySo you're saying no one needs third party RF lenses. If someone is so hyped up about a third party lens, just use an old EF third party lens? Wow. I mean, just wow.
Anyway, where can I get that third party 35-150 / 2-2.8 or 35 / 1.2 (with AF, of course!) that I can mount on my R5? Or are you telling me that no one needs those lenses, anyway, and that we're "lame" for even thinking to use them, 'cause the only thing anyone needs is what Canon offers in RF mount or is available in EF mount?
And if your next bit of wisdom is, "If you like third party so much, then why don't you just sell your Canon gear and get the hell out!" Well, maybe I like my Canon gear (a lot) and maybe I would also like to use third party lenses on my Canon camera. And, surprise, I'm not the only one. And double surprise, this does not benefit me and many others, but I can certainly understand how it benefits Canon.
You've been so full of it to this point I can't comment on your reading skills or if you have any. You already called me delusional, seems a bit late to take the high road imo.
p.22 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: Jman13 wroteAmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)
Because it’s been pretty much spelled out by people in the industry right around the time Canon forced Samyang to stop selling their brilliant RF 85 1.4. The Samyang situation made it pretty clear what was going on.
May 21, 2025 at 05:41 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.22 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: AmbientMike wroteSo were you in the room when Canon made this decision to not allow 3rd party? Somehow I doubt it, so how do you know their reasons for doing things that way?I wasn't in the room for a lot of decisions that were made on any number of topics, and I very much know the reasons the decisions were made. Here's a hint in the case of Canon not allowing third party to make lenses for RF mount: it wasn't for the benefit of people who use Canon cameras.
Earlier quoteSo who is delusional, here?Do you really want me to say? I'm trying to be polite, but if you want me to spell it out, then just say so. By the way, did you see my question?
takowasa wroteHere's a quick question: why is it good that I can't put a Tamron 35-150 / 2-2.8 or Viltrox 35 / 1.2 on my Canon R5? I know why it's good for Canon, but why is it good for me?I'd be interested in your answer.
So do you work for Canon? If not how do you know. Because I doubt Canon wants employees talking online, so I am skeptical you're an insider.