This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.
Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.23 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote: AmbientMike wroteJman13 wroteAmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)Because it’s been pretty much spelled out by people in the industry right around the time Canon forced Samyang to stop selling their brilliant RF 85 1.4. The Samyang situation made it pretty clear what was going on.
Yet Nikon is in the same boat with Sigma. And isn't getting 1st class treatment with Tamron.
p.23 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: Jman13 wroteAmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)
How about the fact that Canon literally shut down production of AF lenses by other companies via legal action (Samyang). Why are you literally incapable of acknowledging anything negative about Canon?
May 21, 2025 at 05:48 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.23 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote: AmbientMike wroteJman13 wroteAmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)How about the fact that Canon literally shut down production of AF lenses by other companies via legal action (Samyang).
Nikon lets 3rd party Chinese go, if its like a lot of things Chinese, its unliscensed. Yet they still aren't in better shape at Sigma, are having issues at Tamron, and the other upstart 3rd party stuff is probably not a big percentage of 3rd party sales.
Yet no one is spewing conspiracy theoris about how tbey did this to make more money, even though I believe they changed more on 18-28 & 70-180 and it might not even be a conspiracy theory to say so. So the whole thing looks pretty stupid, more Canon bashing on FM
p.23 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: comotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wroteJman13 wroteAmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteCome on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)Because it’s been pretty much spelled out by people in the industry right around the time Canon forced Samyang to stop selling their brilliant RF 85 1.4. The Samyang situation made it pretty clear what was going on.Yet Nikon is in the same boat with Sigma. And isn't getting 1st class treatment with Tamron.
We generally know why Nikon and Sigma aren’t doing things. 1) Nikon charges for use of their lens mount for full acceptance. We know this because Tamron lenses on Nikon Z are a little more expensive than they are on Sony. Sonys mount is open and Nikon charges. Sigma likely doesn’t want to have any price difference between mounts, and also it likely makes Tamron more strategic as to which lenses to bring to Z mount.
Also I have heard there is some bad corporate blood between Nikon and Sigma but that is just rumor.
But we also know that Nikon, despite charging mount licensing for Tamron, doesn’t go after other companies that reverse engineered the Z mount. Thus Viltrox and the other makers have been allowed to proceed, something Canon has explicitly shut down.
It’s not Canon bashing. It’s stating facts that you are somehow unwilling to acknowledge. It doesn’t matter the reason Canon doesn’t allow any third party lenses. It matters that they don’t allow third party lenses.
I just don’t understand the rabid apologetic fanboy behavior you exhibit. Literally nothing negative about Canon is either a problem in your mind, or actually Canon’s fault.
I’ve shot with all three of the big players, and while I’m shooting Nikon now I have no issues whatsoever in saying that I wish they were as open with their mount as Sony was (ie, I wish they didn’t charge for licensing). I also wish their eye detect was as good as Canon’s. Shooters should point out where their brand’s stuff falls behind because that’s how everyone improves.
p.23 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: Jman13 wroteAmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wrotePosting this again: The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
After all the gnashing of teeth, Nikon has the same Sigma offerings as Canon, and only a few more Tamron. How many are even buying this stuff on the new names? Are you really going to buy that much of this stuff to change systems?
But I'm detached from reality and facts, no doubt, because I pointed out that maybe a major competitor, Sony, owning a big chunk of Tamron is goofing up Canon & Nikon somehow. And the people saying Canon is just grabbing money don't get challenged, but seriously, how do they know?Come on Mike, you are dying on some weird hills. It’s been explained why overnight, 3rd party became a thing. It’s also been explained that Nikon has around 30 3rd party options to Canon’s ZERO, and they also have access to all of the Sony’s 3rd party options (which makes Nikon the best option, imo). You also seem oddly stuck on sigma and tamron like it’s 2005. If canon was open to 3rd party lenses, they would have them, but they aren’t (at least not yet), so we don’t. Sony has zero say in Canon’s choice to lock down the RF mount. You keep defending canon and it’s just getting weird.Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)
The question I would have is why is the reason important?
As a photographer, my priority is to pick the brand(s) that provides me the widest set of creative options.
For the sake of this example, I don't care the least bit why North Korean people have very little freedom. I know that they don't and I have made the choice to not move to North Korea.
Similarly, I see zero reason to use Canon compared to Sony and Nikon because these 2 brands, whatever their motivation might be, offer me way more creative options without any drawback, in particular Nikon thanks to the possibility to adapt Sony glass with excellent AF. I can buy Sony's super light 300mm f2.8 in one click and get it delivered tomorrow if that lens is mandatory for a given application on Sunday. Or I can use the brilliant Nikon 120-300mm f2.8 if I need more flexibility for a sport event on Monday.
And on average, the time it will take for Nikon/Sony/Sigma/Tamron/Chinese manufacturers to fill a possible hole in their joined line up will be way shorter than it will for Canon. Besides Canon has demonstrated zero ability to lead in image quality, on the contrary, their lenses are very good but nonetheless always a bit behind Sony and Nikon's offerings. In whole honesty, there isn't a single Canon lens I would pick over their Sony/Nikon equivalents. The only unique offering they have is their 24-105mm f2.8 [corrected] and I am not interested in a 1.5 kg standard zoom.
But if you decide that your love for the Canon brand is more important than your freedom I say go ahead and keep shooting yourself in the foot... and be happy about it.
p.23 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
bernardl wrote:
As a photographer, my priority is to pick the brand(s) that provides me the widest set of creative options.
...Besides Canon has demonstrated zero ability to lead in image quality, on the contrary, their lenses are very good but nonetheless always a bit behind Sony and Nikon's offerings.
In my opinion, all brands are so amazingly good nowadays that image quality isn't a primary reason to choose one over the other. I mean, there are reasons to choose A over B, but, for the most part, I don't think differences in IQ between brands really plays a big role here.
In whole honesty, there isn't a single Canon lens I would pick over their Sony/Nikon equivalents. The only unique offering they have is their 24-105mm f1.8 and I am not intesrersted in a 1.5 kg standard zoom.
A 24-105 / 1.8 would really be something! With regards to Canon's "unique" offerings, I think the RF 70-200 / 4L IS and RF 70-200 / 2.8L IS do bring a really unique benefit to the table with their small size. In fact, I just sold my EF 70-200 / 4L IS II, which was an amazing lens, to get the RF 70-200 / 4L IS. Why? I didn't use the EF lens much due to its size -- it wouldn't fit in the same small bag as my camera with my other lenses, so I always had to lug around a small backpack if I intended on using that lens. I am already using the RF version far more than I used the EF version for that reason. Of course, if the RF version were lacking in IQ compared to the EF version, that would be a problem, but it isn't, so it isn't.
But if you decide that your love for the Canon brand is more important than your freedom I say go ahead and keep shooting yourself in the foot... and be happy about it.
To me, it's like people who refuse to buy lenses that rely on software correction despite being better than alternatives that don't require software correction. I understand why they feel the way they do, and don't fault them for not using the lenses that require software correction. However, that's all together different than defending Canon for refusing to allow third party to make lenses for RF mount. In this case, you're not merely choosing not to use third party lenses, you're cheering on Canon for denying others access to third party lenses to use on their Canon cameras. That's bizarre. However, nowadays, bizarre seems to be the new normal with regards to opinions people have on many topics, which, to be honest, is of far more concern than Canon emulating Apple's protectionism.
p.23 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
takowasa wrote: bernardl wroteAs a photographer, my priority is to pick the brand(s) that provides me the widest set of creative options.
...Besides Canon has demonstrated zero ability to lead in image quality, on the contrary, their lenses are very good but nonetheless always a bit behind Sony and Nikon's offerings.In my opinion, all brands are so amazingly good nowadays that image quality isn't a primary reason to choose one over the other. I mean, there are reasons to choose A over B, but, for the most part, I don't think differences in IQ between brands really plays a big role here.
Earlier quoteIn whole honesty, there isn't a single Canon lens I would pick over their Sony/Nikon equivalents. The only unique offering they have is their 24-105mm f1.8 and I am not intesrersted in a 1.5 kg standard zoom.A 24-105 / 1.8 would really be something! With regards to Canon's "unique" offerings, I think the RF 70-200 / 4L IS and RF 70-200 / 2.8L IS do bring a really unique benefit to the table with their small size. In fact, I just sold my EF 70-200 / 4L IS II, which was an amazing lens, to get the RF 70-200 / 4L IS. Why? I didn't use the EF lens much due to its size -- it wouldn't fit in the same small bag as my camera with my other lenses, so I always had to lug around a small backpack if I intended on using that lens. I am already using the RF version far more than I used the EF version for that reason. Of course, if the RF version were lacking in IQ compared to the EF version, that would be a problem, but it isn't, so it isn't.
To me, it's like people who refuse to buy lenses that rely on software correction despite being better than alternatives that don't require software correction. I understand why they feel the way they do, and don't fault them for not using the lenses that require software correction. However, that's all together different than defending Canon for refusing to allow third party to make lenses for RF mount. In this case, you're not merely choosing not to use third party lenses, you're cheering on Canon for denying others access to third party lenses to use on their Canon cameras. That's bizarre. However, nowadays, bizarre seems to be the new normal with regards to opinions people have on many topics, which, to be honest, is of far more concern than Canon emulating Apple's protectionism.
...Show more →Earlier quoteBut if you decide that your love for the Canon brand is more important than your freedom I say go ahead and keep shooting yourself in the foot... and be happy about it.
Yes, agreed with the exceptions of a few gems such as the Plena or 35mm f1.2. Sharpness is a given these days, the differences are much more impacting in terms of look of bokeh IMHO.
There are indeed differences other than pure image quality such as light weight tele lenses or super teles with built-in TCs that are much more impacting. And 3rd party is valuable because of the unique niche offerings (the Tamron 35-150mm, the Sigmas 14mm f1.4 or 300-600mm f4 come to mind) or better price to performance ratios.
Cheers,
Bernard
May 21, 2025 at 07:17 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.23 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Jman13 wrote: AmbientMike wrotecomotionfilms wroteAmbientMike wroteJman13 wroteAmbientMike wroteIts difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try.
The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something, to see that maybe, just maybe, Sony is goofing up Tamron by getting them to charge Canon too much or something, since Sony is apparently the biggest player there. Why can't you see that Sony's stake in Tamron might be causing Canon and Nikon problems? Canon has all kinds of 3rd party lenses in EF, including 150 & 180 macros that you have to get in EF mount , that sony doesnt have unless you go mf, which I'm not really interested in doing.
If you are talking about your lame explanation, that makes little or no sense, as to why 3rd party started to be demanded overnight, then yes, its been explained to me. But it took years for mirrorless to develop and get popular, 3rd party didn't get viable overnight, that makes no sense, and I've used even 80's 3rd party and it's excellent, nothing new. Bought my 180 Tamron used in 2005, excellent lens even todayBecause there is zero evidence for such an accusation. If Sony was preventing Tamron from releasing lenses on Canon, they would also do the same for Nikon, yet Tamron have released lenses on Z mount and also licensed their three f/2.8 trinity zooms to Nikon to be rebadged as Nikon lenses.
And we also know that Canon is preventing all other manufacturers from releasing RF lenses that have autofocus. It isn’t “Canon and Nikon don’t have Tamron lenses.” It’s “Nikon has Tamron lenses, Canon doesn’t, AND Canon doesn’t have any other AF third party glass.”
You have repeatedly argued points in this thread that either are complete speculation without any evidence (The Sony/Tamron conspiracy), or you’re making strawman arguments and asserting them as fact. Or arguing irrelevant points like a dead camera mount has more third party lenses, without realizing that Sony E mount and Nikon Z mount can use Canon EF lenses too.I dont understand other peoples motivation for asserting it's all Canons fault. Talk about a conspiracy theory that you cant prove. How the heck could you possibly know if there are other factors (hint: you don't.)Because it’s been pretty much spelled out by people in the industry right around the time Canon forced Samyang to stop selling their brilliant RF 85 1.4. The Samyang situation made it pretty clear what was going on.Yet Nikon is in the same boat with Sigma. And isn't getting 1st class treatment with Tamron.We generally know why Nikon and Sigma aren’t doing things. 1) Nikon charges for use of their lens mount for full acceptance. We know this because Tamron lenses on Nikon Z are a little more expensive than they are on Sony. Sonys mount is open and Nikon charges. Sigma likely doesn’t want to have any price difference between mounts, and also it likely makes Tamron more strategic as to which lenses to bring to Z mount.
Also I have heard there is some bad corporate blood between Nikon and Sigma but that is just rumor.
But we also know that Nikon, despite charging mount licensing for Tamron, doesn’t go after other companies that reverse engineered the Z mount. Thus Viltrox and the other makers have been allowed to proceed, something Canon has explicitly shut down.
It’s not Canon bashing. It’s stating facts that you are somehow unwilling to acknowledge. It doesn’t matter the reason Canon doesn’t allow any third party lenses. It matters that they don’t allow third party lenses.
I just don’t understand the rabid apologetic fanboy behavior you exhibit. Literally nothing negative about Canon is either a problem in your mind, or actually Canon’s fault.
I’ve shot with all three of the big players, and while I’m shooting Nikon now I have no issues whatsoever in saying that I wish they were as open with their mount as Sony was (ie, I wish they didn’t charge for licensing). I also wish their eye detect was as good as Canon’s. Shooters should point out where their brand’s stuff falls behind because that’s how everyone improves. ...Show more →
You are the one not getting it. If anyone is exhibiting rabid fanboy behavior and unwilling to accept facts, it is you
The whole complaining about Canon not having enough 3rd party starts to fall apart seeing that Nikon has no Sigma lenses, either, so either 1) they are grabbing the money as well or 2) there is some other reason keeping both away from sigma. But we know Nikon is charging $200+ extra on the 70-180, yet you inexplicably ignore that and focus on Canon supposedly being greedy because you can't see the obvious. And Sony probably has a controlling stake in Tamron, probably some bad blood thete between Canon, and who knows what is going on
And you can say look at all these viltrox and TTArisans but probably pretty small part of the market. Before you canonize Sony for going full K mount and leaving their mount open, they needed the lenses, having a new system. There's probably Nothing holy, there.
May 21, 2025 at 11:49 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.23 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Someone mentioned the E mount Tamron 28-75/2.8, let's discuss that. The Tamron is only $200 less than the OEM Canon 28-70/2.8, Sony you're stuck using 3rd party.
If Nikon added to the price like they did on the 70-180, its not going to be any cheaper and, again, still 3rd party vs OEM Canon 28-70/2.8. Not exactly a disservice to Canon customers, is it?
If you want 3rd party, there is the old 28-75/2.8 EF Tamron, a friend has a 24-70/2.8 Sigma EF that's looks like its probably at least good and who knows how many other 3td party options are available in this approximate fl inaddition to the old 28-70/2.8 L, and the 24-70 EF II probably isn't too much more. You might have to go through lens tests to find one of the better ones, probably several 3rd party models available though
p.23 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Someone mentioned the E mount Tamron 28-75/2.8, let's discuss that.
I guess, because you keep ducking answering why it's good that I can't put a Tamron 35-150 / 2-2.8 or Viltrox 35 / 1.2 on my 5D whereas I could put either one on a Sony, Nikon, or Panasonic camera. But, since you're not willing to discuss that...
The Tamron is only $200 less than the OEM Canon 28-70/2.8, Sony you're stuck using 3rd party.
The Canon has IS which the Tamron lacks, so the Canon lens is priced fair. But what's this about Sony shooters being "stuck" using third party? They're not "stuck" at all -- they're *free* to use third party. And they were *free* to put the Tamron 28-75 / 2.8 on their Sony cameras in native E mount since 2021, whereas Canon RF shooters just got the RF 28-70 / 2.8 IS in late 2024.
If Nikon added to the price like they did on the 70-180, its not going to be any cheaper and, again, still 3rd party vs OEM Canon 28-70/2.8. Not exactly a disservice to Canon customers, is it?
Yes, it is a disservice to all who RF shooters who wanted a small, light, and inexpensive (relative to the 24-70 / 2.8L IS) 28-70 / 2.8 IS, and it's simply amazing that you can't fathom that simple point.
If you want 3rd party, there is the old 28-75/2.8 EF Tamron, a friend has a 24-70/2.8 Sigma EF that's looks like its probably at least good and who knows how many other 3td party options are available in this approximate fl inaddition to the old 28-70/2.8 L, and the 24-70 EF II probably isn't too much more. You might have to go through lens tests to find one of the better ones, probably several 3rd party models available though
And even more amazing is you saying to just mount EF lenses to RF mount rather than have native RF mount lenses. OK, where's the EF 35-150 / 2.8 to adapt to my R5? Where's the EF 35 / 1.2 to adapt to my R5? Where's the EF 28-105 / 2.8 to adapt for my R5? Oh wait -- you mean the RF 24-105 / 2.8 IS that costs twice as much? Where's the EF 28-45 / 1.8 to adapt to my R5? Etc., etc., etc..
Look, I shoot Canon and I like what Canon puts out. But Canon neither does me nor anyone else any favors by restricting third party manufacturers for making lenses for RF mount. Now, I know you're not keen on answering questions asked of you, but if you decide to respond, begin by answering the question I've put to you multiple times that you keep refusing to answer: why is it a good thing that I can't get a Tamron 35-150 / 2.8 or Viltrox 35 / 1.2 in RF mount? Or, if you are instead saying that third party is being "mean" to Canon and refusing to make their lenses in RF mount, please explain what third party has to gain by refusing to make RF mount lenses. Or make the [ridiculous] claim that third party are charging Canon to make their lenses in RF mount (seriously?!) and that's why Canon won't allow third party lenses (but you'll have to explain how that jives with Canon using litigation to shut down Samyang from producing RF mount lenses with AF).
p.23 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
The whole complaining about Canon not having enough 3rd party starts to fall apart seeing that Nikon has no Sigma lenses, either, so either 1) they are grabbing the money as well or 2) there is some other reason keeping both away from sigma. But we know Nikon is charging $200+ extra on the 70-180, yet you inexplicably ignore that and focus on Canon supposedly being greedy because you can't see the obvious. And Sony probably has a controlling stake in Tamron, probably some bad blood thete between Canon, and who knows what is going on
And you can say look at all these viltrox and TTArisans but probably pretty small part of the market. Before you canonize Sony for going full K mount and leaving their mount open, they needed the lenses, having a new system. There's probably Nothing holy, there.
p.23 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote: AmbientMike wroteThe whole complaining about Canon not having enough 3rd party starts to fall apart seeing that Nikon has no Sigma lenses, either, so either 1) they are grabbing the money as well or 2) there is some other reason keeping both away from sigma. But we know Nikon is charging $200+ extra on the 70-180, yet you inexplicably ignore that and focus on Canon supposedly being greedy because you can't see the obvious. And Sony probably has a controlling stake in Tamron, probably some bad blood thete between Canon, and who knows what is going on
And you can say look at all these viltrox and TTArisans but probably pretty small part of the market. Before you canonize Sony for going full K mount and leaving their mount open, they needed the lenses, having a new system. There's probably Nothing holy, there.Mike, Nikon has around 30 3rd party AF lenses to Canon’s ZERO. Stop acting like they are the same.
A lot more if you count the 3rd-party lenses re-branded as Nikon...
p.23 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
aCuria wrote: Cliff L. wroteaCuria wroteAs far as I can tell, the EF 35/1.4L is sharper than the RF 35mm f1.4 VCM, and the EF 16-35/2.8L is sharper than the RF 15-35/2.8L.What are you basing this on? I've owned multiple copies of every Canon wide zoom, from the EF 20-35mm f2.8L onwards, and none of them came remotely close to the sharpness of the RF 15-35mm f2.8L. Those lenses were always the weakest segment of Canon's EF lens lineup.I always liked my 16-35L, maybe I had a really good copy. You can see from this sample the 15-35's peripheral seems less sharp than the 16-35L on the wide end.
The 15-35 is also really heavy for a mirrorless lens, its the weight of the 16-35GM II and 16-35 f/4 PZ combined.
I would expect the heavier lens to have less vignetting like the Nikon Plena, but in this case the 15-35 has super high vignetting (4.57ev at 15mm according to optical limits.)
That's what I thought. Perhaps you should actually try using some of these lenses, and then come back to the conversation with some first-hand knowledge.
p.23 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
comotionfilms wrote
Mike, Nikon has around 30 3rd party AF lenses to Canon’s ZERO. Stop acting like they are the same.
Above all, the number is constantly increasing.
Songraw is the next Chinese manufacturer to launch a 50/1.2 and an 85/1.2.
Although you might expect, it's once again without Canon, but instead with E-mount, Z-mount, and L-mount.
I don't think you can complain as a Z mount user at the moment.
Viltrox will soon be adding a 35/1.2 for the Z mount, which means Z-mount user already have two 35/1.2 lenses to choose from, and in the foreseeable future, there will be three different 50/1.2 lenses and three different 85/1.2 lenses.
So there's something for every need and budget.
I'll definitely take a closer look at the Viltrox 35/1.2 when it arrives.
I don't need the full power of the Nikkor Z f/1.2 S lenses @ 2.5-3k lens range at every focal length.
Besides my Plena and my Canon FD 85/1.2 L, I have no need for the 3k-priced Z 85/1.2 S, but I would definitely take a look at a native 3rd-party Z-mount 85/1.2 for $700 with AF.
Viltrox has also announced an f/1.4 Pro series in the focal length range of the LAB series.
Considering the optical level Viltrox has achieved with the LAB series lenses, it's a real disadvantage in the budget-limited range not to have these options because they are blocked by Canon and legally prohibited.
10-group 15-element optical structure
13 aperture blades
Weight about 900 grams
72mm filter interface
Minimum focus distance 0.52m
STM focus motor
Sony E, Nikon Z, and Leica L mount
4,999 RMB (around $700 without tariff)
Expected to go on sale on May 20
p.23 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote: Jman13 wroteDude. No one really cares about the 1980 and 90s AF lenses. If I’m after a quality mirrorless lens without breaking the bank I don’t want to put a large, optically mediocre and noisy AF lens on the camera. And for those that really want to use them Monster has a screw drive adapter.
And frankly the argument falls a bit flat considering we’re really talking about a ten year period. The vast majority of the Canon EF lenses from ‘89-2000 are pretty bad, with a few exceptions.
And yes, people do want the new Chinese stuff. Viltrox is making some incredible glass right now. I have their 16/1.8 Z, and it is an absolutely phenomenal lens. Very sharp from wide open, blistering corner to corner stopped down just a bit, beautiful color and contrast and a very high end build, and it’s very affordable to boot. Their LAB lenses are simply exceptional as well, and even the cheap Air lenses are fantastic. My other Viltrox is a 25/1.7 for APS-C and it’s incredible. Extremely sharp from wide open with a gorgeous out of focus rendering, and it’s under $200.
And again, if I REALLY want Sigma, I can easily adapt the E-mount lenses. Having E mount adaptability is a WAY bigger deal than being able to autofocus old DSLR lenses from the 90s. I owned the Sigma 85/1.4 DN (E mount) and used it on my Z bodies for quite a while and it worked like a native lens. I also adapt the 35/1.4GM because it’s much more compact than the Nikon 35/1.2 but with similar quality. Works like a native lens.
I don’t understand why you are so defensive about your brand. No one is saying that Canon is crap solely because of this situation. Just like I’m not saying Nikon is crap because they don’t have the same lens selection as Sony. I switched away from Sony for a number of reasons but I can easily admit that one of the best things about them was the open mount with ample third party lens availability. It’s a big advantage for that system. Nikon isn’t as good in that department, but it does have the ability to adapt E mount glass very well, so it’s probably the next best there, plus the previously demonstrated better current third party support compared to Canon. Canon clearly has the worst third party support for RF mount. It’s not worth these crazy discussions. It’s simply a fact.Canon is awful, just awful, for 3rd party. So awful, in fact, that if I want an af 150 or 180 macro (180 Tamron my most used 3rd party) I have to buy EF mount. Afaik no one ever made one in Sony.
I just can't seem to get interested in the new cheap Chinese stuff, but if you want to pick a camera brand over it, knock yourself out
Canon made excellent 300/4, 70-200/2.8, 300/2.8, etc years ago that can still be adapted easily. And that is a fact
Sigma's DSLR 150/2.8, 180/3.5, and 180/2.8 and Tam's 180/3.5 are all available in A mount and adapt decently to E, but we can also adapt all of those in EF and successfully adapt the Canon 180L and Nikon AF 200/4 with good AF. E also has the IRIX 150/2.8 (not Chinese, but manual) native and we have Sony's 70-200/4 GII Macro, which gets down to 1:2 throughout the range and, combined with the a6700/rV/a1II/a9III, is an awesome, nicely light, bug tracker. So we've got options.
I have to admit, though, I am a little envious of the RF 100L and it's SA control. That's a fantastic function on a macro lens.
Its difficult to combat the sheer volume of utter nonsense you've managed to put into a single, relatively short post, but I'll try. The weird part is that people are apparently too ignorant, or something...
You've been so full of it to this point I can't comment on your reading skills or if you have any. You already called me delusional, seems a bit late to take the high road imo.
If you think no one cared/cares about third party lenses, then I really don't know what to say. That's about as delusional as it gets, to be honest.
But that was in response to you saying:
The outrage over Canon and 3rd party was pretty stupid, to begin with. Nobody cared about 3rd party , to the point I was trying to figure out how to get up to speed on 3rd party because hardly anyone used it on here. Then, practically overnight, everyone is all butthurt and whining about the 3rd party lenses they didn't even care about, a week before
So when you say "About the only thing people have been generous with on this thread is the insults", well, all I can say is "Doctor, heal yourself."
p.23 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I guess I will have to side with the position that the more open a lens mount is, and the more support that mount gets from the broader industry, the better it is for that mounts users. Especially when it comes to native mount lens support.
Of course that may be not a big thing to a user of even a very restricted mount system who is able to get the lenses he wants/needs.
p.23 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The easy — and accurate — answer is that all of the major companies make excellent lenses that skillful and talented photographers use to make fine photographs. Debating which of them makes The Very Mosrest Best Lenses is a pointless waste of time.
Use Nikon? Pick any of a bunch of tine Nikon lenses. Canon? Lots of great lenses there, too. Sony? Plenty of first class options. Fujifilm? Many wxcellent lenses. Olympus? Good stuff there, too. Etc…
As someone once pointed out, of all of the questions you will need to address as a photographer, the least important is which brand to use.