fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

  
 
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #1Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

Jman13 wrote:
Mike - are you physically incapable of understanding nuance?

Honestly. Do you legitimately believe that every camera is made for every type of photography and should be judged under the same lens? Should the Fuji GFX 100 II be considered a failure because it can only do 8 frames per second in a burst?

You are so butthurt about people leaving DSLRs for mirrorless that you try to inject these ridiculous arguments into other segments of the industry.

And there is zero nuance in any part of your arguments. You hear one negative thing about something over here...and then think
...Show more →

Why do you think it is ok to hurt insults and talk down to me?

In your long winded posts apparently trying to distract people from correct interpretations of simple graphs

The a9III has the same DR as the Canon DSLR'S considered obsolete largely over lack of DR years ago . Little or no nuance applied then but now that it bears the Sony nameplate nuances become all important. Because if the a9III gets judged on DR like some DSLR'S used to it loses
Jan 17, 2025 at 10:55 AM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
There's obviously very little difference in most modern lenses, broadly speaking. Even Viltrox is making excellent glass now. The devil is often in the details. Everyone's "best" will be different. Some lenses are easier to directly compare than others. Petapixel recently did that with the "holy trio" from Canon/Nikon/Sony that someone linked earlier in this thread. They found some differences but nothing outrageous or worth switching systems over, except in the case of Sony where the significant size and weight savings might be worth considering for some users. But then the bodies have their own pros and cons that would weigh into such a decision.

Everyone is making their own choices on which system to use based on a multitude of factors. I've seen people switch specifically for some unique lenses that aren't available elsewhere, myself included in the case of the RF 28-70mm f2 several years ago which weighed into my decision. I've seen people switch from Sony to Canon or Nikon for f1.2 lenses, to Nikon for the 135mm Plena or their excellent telephoto offerings including the lightweight PF's, to Canon for their RF 100-300mm f2.8, and to Sony for their lighter weight lenses like the 300mm f2.8 GM.

I love hearing people's feedback on why they chose the system/lenses they did and their experience with them coming from other systems. Personally I had a pretty great experience with my Sony GM lenses and a mixed experience with my current Canon RF lenses, mainly in terms of size, weight, AF noise and speed, and flare resistance. The only issue I experienced on Sony was excessive CA. That's not to say I don't love my RF lenses. I do. Some more than others. The rendering of the 28-70mm f2 is excellent but I've always found the AF a bit slow and noisy and it's a brick to carry. Sony's new 28-70mm f2 offering is compelling. I'd love to see a side-by-side since that has been such an important lens for my use over the years. If it's as good as the Canon at a significantly lower weight and smaller size I'd consider picking up a Sony body just for that lens, as I did many years ago for the Canon.

Some others I'd love to see compared are the 85mm f1.2/1.4 lenses from the three brands. I'm relatively happy with my RF 85mm f1.2, but again it's one of the slower, noisier, clunkier autofocusing RF lenses I own. I find myself gravitating to using my RF 70-200mm f2.8 more for this reason, especially for things like photographing dogs. If Nikon or Sony's f1.2/f1.4 85mm lenses are faster focusing I'd consider swapping for one of them. Especially if they render better as a bonus. I'm pretty satisfied with the rendering of my RF 85mm f1.2 but I do feel like it could be a bit better (smoother background). I think Canon using 9 aperture blades instead of 11 left a bit on the table here. Some examples I've seen from the Nikon 85mm f1.2 are stunning, especially when comparing their Flickr galleries side-by-side, but there's obviously too many variables for that to be a fair comparison. Sony's 85mm f1.4 GMII is a bit less interesting to me. I haven't seen any examples blow me away as I did when the original 85 GM released. I feel like they may have lost some of that lenses magic and reformulated it to be more clinical like some of their more recent lenses, but I haven't looked too closely at it either. The size and weight of Sony's bodies + the 85mm f1.4 GMII is very compelling.

johnvanr wrote:
The discussion based on the assumption that Canon’s products are inferior would only make sense if they were inferior to the extent that they don’t deliver what their users seek. Really, this whole discussion about the best lenses is based on the mistaken belief that slight differences in the performance of top lenses are by themselves making a difference to actual photography. If that were the case, Zeiss and Leica would own the market.

Jan 17, 2025 at 11:08 AM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #3Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I'm legitimately as surprised as he is that you're just flat out not understanding (or ignoring) what everyone is saying. Your argument and your comparison doesn't make any sense. Nobody here agrees with it because it doesn't make any sense. It's ridiculous to compare the A9III with the 5DSR, or most other cameras really. I don't think you realize what the A9III is made for or capable of.

AmbientMike wrote:
Jman13 wroteMike - are you physically incapable of understanding nuance?

Honestly. Do you legitimately believe that every camera is made for every type of photography and should be judged under the same lens? Should the Fuji GFX 100 II be considered a failure because it can only do 8 frames per second in a burst?

You are so butthurt about people leaving DSLRs for mirrorless that you try to inject these ridiculous arguments into other segments of the industry.

And there is zero nuance in any part of your arguments. You hear one negative thing about something over here...and then think it can be applied to everything through brute force, disregarding everything else.

Here's a hint to get you on the right path: If the A1 II and A7R V had the same DR as the A9 III, they'd be failures. For good reason too. Gee, I wonder why that could be.
Why do you think it is ok to hurt insults and talk down to me?

In your long winded posts apparently trying to distract people from correct interpretations of simple graphs

The a9III has the same DR as the Canon DSLR'S considered obsolete largely over lack of DR years ago . Little or no nuance applied then but now that it bears the Sony nameplate nuances become all important. Because if the a9III gets judged on DR like some DSLR'S used to it loses

Jan 17, 2025 at 11:18 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?


AlphaPhotography wrote:
I'm legitimately as surprised as he is that you're just flat out not understanding (or ignoring) what everyone is saying. Your argument and your comparison doesn't make any sense. Nobody here agrees with it because it doesn't make any sense. It's ridiculous to compare the A9III with the 5DSR, or most other cameras really. I don't think you realize what the A9III is made for or capable of.

AmbientMike wrote
Jman13 wroteMike - are you physically incapable of understanding nuance?

Honestly. Do you legitimately believe that every camera is made for every type of photography and should be judged under the same lens? Should the Fuji GFX 100 II be considered a failure because it can only do 8 frames per second in a burst?

You are so butthurt about people leaving DSLRs for mirrorless that you try to inject these ridiculous arguments into other segments of the industry.

And there is zero nuance in any part of your arguments. You hear one negative thing about something over here...and then think it can be applied to everything through brute force, disregarding everything else.

Here's a hint to get you on the right path: If the A1 II and A7R V had the same DR as the A9 III, they'd be failures. For good reason too. Gee, I wonder why that could be.
Why do you think it is ok to hurt insults and talk down to me?

In your long winded posts apparently trying to distract people from correct interpretations of simple graphs

The a9III has the same DR as the Canon DSLR'S considered obsolete largely over lack of DR years ago . Little or no nuance applied then but now that it bears the Sony nameplate nuances become all important. Because if the a9III gets judged on DR like some DSLR'S used to it loses


But you're the same one saying the corrections on the 35/1.4 VCM too large at <4% distortion. Then you call the 20-70, which has up to ~9%, "unique."

And the original a9 has lower DR, but it's not a low DR camera, antiquated and to be avoided, it's a "special" camera, according to you.

So you are not making much sense. Of course I'm sure anything having Sony on it is special.
Jan 17, 2025 at 11:34 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #5Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?

gdanmitchell wrote:
Folks, when there’s one person who consistently, obviously, engages in angry bad faith arguments and takes everything as a personal insult…

… it may be best to simply let those posts go and not respond at all.


Good point. I should avoid Jman13's arguments.

Since arguments having a hard time digesting correct interpretations of graph and hurling insults at those interpreting correctly are indeed bad faith
Jan 17, 2025 at 11:36 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #6Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The a9III has roughly the same DR as Canon DSLR'S often regarded obsolete by Sony users over the lack thereof. The A9III reqires NR to get to the same levels of DR as the supposedly antiquated 5DsR.

Yes, there has been a lot of anger directed at me for saying that. And I question if people making arguments (if they even rise to the level of being arguments or are more a distraction) against the factual statement above actually believe their statements.


Edited on Jan 17, 2025 at 12:03 PM · View previous versions
Jan 17, 2025 at 11:59 AM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.14 #7Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
There's obviously very little difference in most modern lenses, broadly speaking. Even Viltrox is making excellent glass now. The devil is often in the details. Everyone's "best" will be different. Some lenses are easier to directly compare than others. Petapixel recently did that with the "holy trio" from Canon/Nikon/Sony that someone linked earlier in this thread. They found some differences but nothing outrageous or worth switching systems over, except in the case of Sony where the significant size and weight savings might be worth considering for some users. But then the bodies have their own pros and cons that would
...Show more →
johnvanr wroteThe discussion based on the assumption that Canon’s products are inferior would only make sense if they were inferior to the extent that they don’t deliver what their users seek. Really, this whole discussion about the best lenses is based on the mistaken belief that slight differences in the performance of top lenses are by themselves making a difference to actual photography. If that were the case, Zeiss and Leica would own the market.


If you take it down to individual lenses, then a comparison starts to make sense, sure.
Jan 17, 2025 at 12:02 PM
1bwana1
Online
Details
p.14 #8Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
The a9III has roughly the same DR as Canon DSLR'S often regarded obsolete by Sony users over the lack thereof. The A9III reqires NR to get to the same levels of DR as the supposedly antiquated 5DsR.

Yes, there has been a lot of anger directed at me for saying that. And I question if people making arguments against the factual statement above actually believe their statements.



If you are Dynamic Range focused in your photography neither the 5DsR nor the the A9III is probably the best choice for you.

If you are speed and other benefits of Global Shutter focused, then the 5DsR is still probably not the best choice for you. But the A9III may be.

Surely you can see the difference in the 5DsR not currently being competitive in any of the primary attributes and use cases compared to today's mirrorless leaders. Still that doesn't eliminate the 5DsR from being a very good choice to make excellent images with. It is all just a matter of use cases and needs.
Jan 17, 2025 at 12:09 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
You're probably right. Like someone else said the mental gymnastics in these ridiculous arguments would be comical if they weren't so frustrating. So far I've learned that built-in TC's are useless antiquated accessories, Canon's RF 600mm f4 released in 2021 with the same optical design as the 2018 EF 600mm f4 was NOT rehashed, the RF 35mm f1.4 VCM is a direct competitor to the Sony 20-70mm f4 (but the Sony sucks because it has higher distortion, whereas the Canon 35mm VCM's distortion is totally fine even though it's worse than every other modern 35mm f1.4 prime, including its 2015 predecessor), and the 24mp 120fps A9III is competing with the 50mp 5fps 5DSR but the A9III is trash because it's DR is barely any better (13 vs 12.4 stops).

🤦‍♂️

gdanmitchell wrote:
Folks, when there’s a person who consistently, obviously, engages in angry bad faith arguments*, twists what others say, argues against positions others never expressed, willfully misconstrues things, and takes everything as a personal insult…

… it may be best to simply let those posts go and not respond to the person at all.

As someone once said, to do otherwise is about as useful as “administering medicine to the dead” — e.g. pointless and ultimately ineffective.

The “hide” feature on FM is your friend. There are several ways you can use it. Of course, you could hide a participant and simply never see their
...Show more →
Jan 17, 2025 at 12:12 PM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.14 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Mike, you're right, I probably got too personal there, and I apologize for that.

However, the reason everyone is frustrated is because your arguments are almost entirely straw-man arguments that don't actually make sense.

The 5DSR was lambasted for it's lower dynamic range for the following reasons: It was primarily marketed as a camera for landscape use and other photography endeavors where low-ISO image quality is of utmost importance. Its competition at the time was the Sony A7R II and the Nikon D810 (and later the D850). In this space, the 5DSR was nearly two stops behind in dynamic range TO ITS DIRECT COMPETITION. Please note that last part, which is of utmost importance. So: Landscape low ISO priority cameras, and the 5DSR was way behind.

Now, the A9 III is not a landscape camera. No one is buying an A9 III to use for landscapes primarily. It is not competing with the Nikon Z7 II, Nikon Z8, Canon R5 II and the Sony A7R V.

It is a sports and action camera. Period. It CAN be used for other photography, but almost everyone shooting with this camera will be using it for sports and action. It can do things no other camera on the market can do right now. It competes more or less directly with the Canon R1 and R3, which are also primarily sports and action cameras. Here, low ISO image quality is NOT of utmost importance. Speed, focus, buffer, rolling shutter, etc, are all more important. In some areas, it is on par with something like the R1 and R3...in some places it's a little behind (low ISO DR), and in others it's way ahead (rolling shutter).

So taking two cameras that have COMPLETELY different goals and target markets and then applying what was a detriment to one market and saying it's bad in another market is what is incorrect on your end.
Jan 17, 2025 at 12:43 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
But don't you see that the A9III has barely any more dynamic range than the 5DSR? Can you not see that Sony makes subpar cameras, period.

/s

Jman13 wrote:
Mike, you're right, I probably got too personal there, and I apologize for that.

However, the reason everyone is frustrated is because your arguments are almost entirely straw-man arguments that don't actually make sense.

The 5DSR was lambasted for it's lower dynamic range for the following reasons: It was primarily marketed as a camera for landscape use and other photography endeavors where low-ISO image quality is of utmost importance. Its competition at the time was the Sony A7R II and the Nikon D810 (and later the D850). In this space, the 5DSR was nearly two stops behind in dynamic range
...Show more →
Jan 17, 2025 at 12:48 PM
Jman13
Online
Details
p.14 #12Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
For the record, I personally would never buy an A9 III, and if someone gave me one I would sell it. Because I do prioritize low ISO shooting and shoot very little action and essentially no sports. The A9 III is NOT the camera for me. At all. (Also I shoot nikon now and haven’t owned a Sony camera in 4 years)
Jan 17, 2025 at 01:11 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.14 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The AF of the Nikon 85mm f1.2 S is not 400mm f2.8 fast but it is suitable for action on the Z8/Z9.

I used it quite a bit for dance rehearsal photography with good results. It’s rendering is very sweet, it only looses vs the Plena in terms of cat eyed bokeh in the corners but the transition from the plane of sharpness is best in class IMHO.
Jan 17, 2025 at 03:59 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.14 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AmbientMike wrote:
Jman13 wroteMike - are you physically incapable of understanding nuance?

Honestly. Do you legitimately believe that every camera is made for every type of photography and should be judged under the same lens? Should the Fuji GFX 100 II be considered a failure because it can only do 8 frames per second in a burst?

You are so butthurt about people leaving DSLRs for mirrorless that you try to inject these ridiculous arguments into other segments of the industry.

And there is zero nuance in any part of your arguments. You hear one negative thing about something over here...and then think it can be applied to everything through brute force, disregarding everything else.

Here's a hint to get you on the right path: If the A1 II and A7R V had the same DR as the A9 III, they'd be failures. For good reason too. Gee, I wonder why that could be.
Why do you think it is ok to hurt insults and talk down to me?

In your long winded posts apparently trying to distract people from correct interpretations of simple graphs

The a9III has the same DR as the Canon DSLR'S considered obsolete largely over lack of DR years ago . Little or no nuance applied then but now that it bears the Sony nameplate nuances become all important. Because if the a9III gets judged on DR like some DSLR'S used to it loses


There are 2 possibilities I can think of:
1. You genuinely are convinced that what you write is not only an opinion but also an accurate description of reality,
2. You are just promoting Canon, your brand of choice and have decided that never admitting you are wrong is a winning strategy.

I am 100% sure that option 2 is the correct one because I don’t want to insult you as a person.

If option 1 were the actual situation then you would be just another one of those people who think that when 2 opinions collide then the reality is always somewhere in btwn and can be decided by a power play. This is one effective definition of populism.

I don’t respect that because I know that the world evolves as a result of actual truth. Most of the time complex and nuanced.

I am sure you have read Nexus from Harari. If not I strongly advise you to read it.

If option 2 is indeed correct. My question would be why? You are obviously not successful in convincing anyone around here among the tiny group of people actually reading this thread. Even Canon users don’t seem to value your arguments. So what exactly are you trying to achieve? Are you under the impression that you “win” as long as you don’t admit that you “loose”? If you are the only judge of the victory then why bother since your win is already secured by your own standards?

Cheers,
Bernard

Edited on Jan 17, 2025 at 04:46 PM · View previous versions
Jan 17, 2025 at 04:16 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
The rendering/transition does look to be beautiful on the Nikon 85mm f1.2. It reminds me of the original Sony 85mm f1.4 GM.

It's fascinating how different "similar" lenses can render. I remember watching Manny Ortiz compare the 85mm f1.4 GM and 85mm f1.8 Batis nearly a decade ago and was shocked by how different they looked.

https://ibb.co/ZVSzC89
https://ibb.co/wrK3fTJ
https://ibb.co/9YcRQCR
https://ibb.co/K9h4BTY



bernardl wrote:
The AF of the Nikon 85mm f1.2 S is not 400mm f2.8 fast but it is suitable for action on the Z8/Z9.

I used it quite a bit for dance rehearsal photography with good results. It’s rendering is very sweet, it only looses vs the Plena in terms of cat eyed bokeh in the corners but the transition from the plane of sharpness is best in class IMHO.

Jan 17, 2025 at 04:27 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
My comment suggesting people utilize the Hide Me feature instead of arguing with, or denigrating, each other got deleted?

Jan 17, 2025 at 04:29 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.14 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Why are people talking about profits and senors technologies of 10 YO cameras? I thought this was a lens thread.

EBH
Jan 17, 2025 at 08:08 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Are you sure you didn't just hide yourself? 😅
RoamingScott wrote:
My comment suggesting people utilize the Hide Me feature instead of arguing with, or denigrating, each other got deleted?


Jan 17, 2025 at 08:11 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Some guy REALLY loves Canon so we have derailed. We'll get back on track though.

Here's a 135mm comparison from Petapixel last year:

https://youtu.be/rhXU2jEisnc?si=TZBATfRDCZV_e0LF

They found the Canon to be the "quirkiest" with softer corners and the worst flare resistance. This matches my experience with other RF lenses where the flare performance leaves a lot to be desired compared to my previous GM lenses (better coatings?). The Plena appears to have no real weaknesses apart from being a bit heavier. I wish they done full body tests for bokeh instead of in the studio and also whether IS in the Canon makes much difference at this FL. Maybe for video it's more stable than the others?

EB-1 wrote:
Why are people talking about profits and senors technologies of 10 YO cameras? I thought this was a lens thread.

EBH

Jan 17, 2025 at 08:17 PM
wind30
Offline
Details
p.14 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
I'm legitimately as surprised as he is that you're just flat out not understanding (or ignoring) what everyone is saying. Your argument and your comparison doesn't make any sense. Nobody here agrees with it because it doesn't make any sense. It's ridiculous to compare the A9III with the 5DSR, or most other cameras really. I don't think you realize what the A9III is made for or capable of.

AmbientMike wrote
Jman13 wroteMike - are you physically incapable of understanding nuance?

Honestly. Do you legitimately believe that every camera is made for every type of photography and should be judged under the same lens? Should the Fuji GFX 100 II be considered a failure because it can only do 8 frames per second in a burst?

You are so butthurt about people leaving DSLRs for mirrorless that you try to inject these ridiculous arguments into other segments of the industry.

And there is zero nuance in any part of your arguments. You hear one negative thing about something over here...and then think it can be applied to everything through brute force, disregarding everything else.

Here's a hint to get you on the right path: If the A1 II and A7R V had the same DR as the A9 III, they'd be failures. For good reason too. Gee, I wonder why that could be.
Why do you think it is ok to hurt insults and talk down to me?

In your long winded posts apparently trying to distract people from correct interpretations of simple graphs

The a9III has the same DR as the Canon DSLR'S considered obsolete largely over lack of DR years ago . Little or no nuance applied then but now that it bears the Sony nameplate nuances become all important. Because if the a9III gets judged on DR like some DSLR'S used to it loses


Same here… just don’t bother and focus on the topic.
Jan 17, 2025 at 08:19 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister