p.15 #2Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote: Sauseschritt wroteMirrorless offers no relevant advantage over DSLR, you just have to get everything new and its super expensive, too.What do you mean by that? Mirrorless lenses, bodies, or both? I could wake up from a drunken slumber and rattle off a half dozen advantages of mirrorless systems.
There is probably a reasonable used market and thus mirrorless is probably much cheaper now than back then, I havent payed attention to the used market in half a decade now, given that I consider my lens selection "complete" for my needs anyway.
I mean I got a 300mm f2.8 lens (AF from the 1990s) for under 1000€, how much more can you ask for ? And yes its slow focus, but I didnt want it for sports anyway.
GroovyGeek wrote:
I can get usable images from my cell phone these days
Well if all you want is "useable" then yeah obviously. Could have used a compact for that since ages. I hear those old Canon compacts had great output ? Before the Sony RX100 revolutionized this area.
p.15 #4Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Matt Granger is a notorious gear breaker. I'm a gear breaker and I haven't had this problem. Literally nothing to see here because it's Matt Granger. He doesn't even have the David Yarrow excuse of "my gear gets sent to NPS because an elephant kicked it." duncangr wrote:
Clearly not Nikon
p.15 #9Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
Best as far as total lens catalogue or just quality?
Sony makes the best trinity zooms for optical quality and weight. Their portrait lenses are second to Nikon in optical quality, but not much, and are lighter and cheaper. For Astro Sony have little competition. Where Sony falters slightly they have all these Sigma and Tamron choices for cheap with some being incredible value. For example Sigma 14-24 2.8, Tamron 35-150
Wildlife lenses goes to Nikon for choices, but also weight with 400 4.5, 600 6.3, 800 6.3 and integrated TC's on the big boys.
For Canon I dont think they have a single lens where Nikon or Sonys version doesnt beat it
p.15 #10Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
ingekj wrote:
Best as far as total lens catalogue or just quality?
Sony makes the best trinity zooms for optical quality and weight. Their portrait lenses are second to Nikon in optical quality, but not much, and are lighter and cheaper. For Astro Sony have little competition. Where Sony falters slightly they have all these Sigma and Tamron choices for cheap with some being incredible value. For example Sigma 14-24 2.8, Tamron 35-150
Wildlife lenses goes to Nikon for choices, but also weight with 400 4.5, 600 6.3, 800 6.3 and integrated TC's on the big boys.
For Canon I dont think they have a single lens where Nikon or Sonys version doesnt beat it ...Show more →
This is a meaningless question. No one will ever come to an agreement that one brand is better than the others —the question is so highly subjective as to be unanswerable. And even it could be answered, the differences are generally insignificant and play out in different ways for different photographers.
The good news is that all three brands make excellent lenses. These lenses are used by talented photographers ot make outstanding photographs. No one can ever tell which brand of lens was used by looking at the photographs.
Of all of the important questions that matter to photographers, “Sony, Nikon, or Canon?” is just about the least important.
p.15 #11Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
JadedWriter wrote:
Matt Granger is a notorious gear breaker. I'm a gear breaker and I haven't had this problem. Literally nothing to see here because it's Matt Granger. He doesn't even have the David Yarrow excuse of "my gear gets sent to NPS because an elephant kicked it." duncangr wroteClearly not Nikon
Could be he just over-torqued the attaching screw on that Promedia replacement tripod foot - which could have overloaded those small attaching screws.
p.15 #13Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
gdanmitchell wrote: ingekj wroteBest as far as total lens catalogue or just quality?
Sony makes the best trinity zooms for optical quality and weight. Their portrait lenses are second to Nikon in optical quality, but not much, and are lighter and cheaper. For Astro Sony have little competition. Where Sony falters slightly they have all these Sigma and Tamron choices for cheap with some being incredible value. For example Sigma 14-24 2.8, Tamron 35-150
Wildlife lenses goes to Nikon for choices, but also weight with 400 4.5, 600 6.3, 800 6.3 and integrated TC's on the big boys.
For Canon I dont think they have a single lens where Nikon or Sonys version doesnt beat itThis is a meaningless question. No one will ever come to an agreement that one brand is better than the others —the question is so highly subjective as to be unanswerable. And even it could be answered, the differences are generally insignificant and play out in different ways for different photographers.
The good news is that all three brands make excellent lenses. These lenses are used by talented photographers ot make outstanding photographs. No one can ever tell which brand of lens was used by looking at the photographs.
Of all of the important questions that matter to photographers, “Sony, Nikon, or Canon?” is just about the least important....Show more →
The point of the thread was to discuss who makes the best lenses. That talented photographers can make good photos with anything is such a boring overdone point, everyone has heard it already. Makes no addition to the discussion.
If no one can tell what brand lens was used in a photo, then the lightest and cheapest would be best? In that case Sigma and Tamron wins.
p.15 #14Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
ingekj wrote:
Best as far as total lens catalogue or just quality?
Sony makes the best trinity zooms for optical quality and weight. Their portrait lenses are second to Nikon in optical quality, but not much, and are lighter and cheaper. For Astro Sony have little competition. Where Sony falters slightly they have all these Sigma and Tamron choices for cheap with some being incredible value. For example Sigma 14-24 2.8, Tamron 35-150
Wildlife lenses goes to Nikon for choices, but also weight with 400 4.5, 600 6.3, 800 6.3 and integrated TC's on the big boys.
For Canon I dont think they have a single lens where Nikon or Sonys version doesnt beat it ...Show more →
To me there is no portrait lens like the Canon RF 85mm f1.2.
p.15 #15Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
This is the dumbest thread! Who really cares. The differences in optical qualities for the same lens by different manufacturers is hardly noticeable, and irrelevant. Now I can say that nikon will probably make the best35mm f/1.2 optically, because no-one else makes it. I am sure though that the other two will soon follow.
p.15 #16Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
AlphaPhotography wrote:
This will obviously be subjective and very opinionated but for those who have shot or currently shoot multiple systems, what company do you feel makes the best lenses? Mainly in terms of IQ but also taking into account things like coatings, autofocus motors, etc. More specifically the mid and upper range lenses.
I previously shot Sony and LOVED many of their GM lenses including the still excellent 135mm f1.8 GM, Sony 24mm f1.4 GM, and Sony 200-600mm. Flare resistance and sharpness were exceptional. Autofocus was always fast and silent. The only issue I saw occasionally was LOCA depending on the lens (like my FE 85mm f1.8 which I still own and have used adapted on my Nikon ZF).
I then moved to Canon (R5 then R5II) which is my main system now. I've heard many times over the years that "RF glass is the best". While I do love many of the lens offerings (15-35mm f2.8, 85mm f1.2, 28-70mm f2, 100-500mm, compact 70-200mm f2.8) I haven't found them to be astronomically better than my Sony glass, and in many cases I've found them to be worse. Specifically autofocus speed/noise, and flaring. The RF 28-70mm f2 and 85mm f1.2 are slow focusing compared to other Canon lenses like the RF 70-200mm f2.8 V1. The focus is also clunky and noisy on those lenses. Flaring resistance I've found inferior to my previous Sony glass, especially the 15-35mm and 85mm f1.2. Recently I saw someone attribute this to "better" coatings on Sony. I do think I prefer the rendering on certain Canon glass like the 28-70mm f2. As sharp as my Sony 135mm f1.8 GM was, it was quite clinical in its rendering. I slightly preferred my older adapted Sigma 135mm f1.8.
I've only just dipped my toes in with Nikon, starting with a ZF + 40mm f2 and 28mm f2.8, and recently a Z8 + 180-600mm + 14-30mm f4. Focus seems reasonably fast but not exceptionally so. My understanding is they use STM motors but clearly they're better than the ones used in Canon's budget lenses. I HATED the Canon RF 35mm f1.8 STM, RF 16mm f2.8, etc. The autofocus motors are noisy and slow. I couldn't even track a slow moving dog with the 35mm.
I recently came across someone speculating the Nikon makes the best lenses because they're an optics company. I've also seen many others speculate the Nikon's z-mount glass is the "best". However it's often biased users of whatever system claiming the company they use is the best, whether is be Canon, Nikon, or Sony. Strangely I see the least "best" claims with Sony which is strange because their GM lenses have been some of my favorites, even ones now 4+ years old. I love their focus on small size without much impact on IQ. Canon seems to have begun attempting something similar with their recent RF hybrid primes, the RF 24mm f1.4 VCM, RF 35mm f1.4, and RF 50mm f1.4. But it appears they've leaned HEAVILY into software corrections which affect overall IQ and have upset many users. I've never seen Canon's mid-high end lenses reviewed so poorly and with such controversy. Across the board most of their L lenses have always received praise, as have Sony's GM and Nikon's S-line lenses. In Dustin Abbott's review of the RF 35mm f1.4 he compared it to the Sony 35mm f1.4 GM and found the Sony better in most ways besides focus breathing. It had worse vignetting, distortion, and is a bit bigger.
Then there's also Tamron, Sigma, and now Viltrox which I have little recent experience with. Their biggest issue is often their compatibility in terms of focus speed and burst shooting (with sony) compared to first party options. But overall their quality seems to match or sometimes exceed the competition.
So what are your thoughts? Who makes the BEST lenses? What specific lenses have you used that stood out to you?
As I continue to test out my new Nikon cameras and lenses I'm taking into account the quality of the rest of the lens line-up as to which system I'll stick with. Canon has some special designs like the 28-70mm f2 (which Sony now offers a "better" version of), the 100-300mm f2.8 (a gamechanger for sports), the 100-500mm has been exceptional for me, and the 10-20mm is on my radar. Nikon has arguably the best wildlife setup which is part of my reason is getting a Z8. The 600mm f4 prime with built-in TC is better than Canon and Sony's offering IMO. The 600mm f6.3 is an awesome lightweight choice. Sony has the best primes and zooms for travel. They're the most compact and still exceptional quality based on the samples I've reviewed....Show more →
If you need AF, Between FE and Canon:
16mm >> FE, Viltrox f/1.8
20mm >> FE, 20mm GM
24mm >> too early to tell, more info needed on the RF VCM
28mm >> The Sigma Art can be adapted to both
35mm >> FE, either Sigma f/1.2 Art or f/1.4 GM
40mm >> The Sigma Art can be adapted to both
50mm >> FE, f/1.2 GM, maybe f/1.4 GM if contrast in 50mm landscapes is your thing
85mm >> there's no perfect 85mm. The RF f/1.2 has slow AF. The FE Sigma DN does not AF fast as well. The EF f/1.4 IS USM has fast AF, but has too much fringing even at f/2.8. The GM mk I is a bit soft and has slow AF. The GM mkII has fast AF, but bokeh isn't great. The RF f/2.0 IS stm is relatively dark and has pretty poor AF (although magnification ratio, ILIS and contrast in back lit situations are great). I'm really hoping there will be an RF VCM very soon that has it all. For IQ the RF f/1.2 might be the best, however, for portability and value for money I think the Sigma DN is better value for money, and IQ is very good, with a huge distortion being a logical design choice at 85mm (not so much at 35mm, Canon).
105mm >> The Sigma Art can be adapted to both
135mm >> probably the RF lens, as it offers in lens stabilization, which the GM does not. That might make a difference at 135mm. I didn't dive in to the "differences" in IQ as I'm not interested so much in a 135mm prime, and most likely both lenses have stellar IQ and stellar AF.
Generally, if you like compact primes, I think the FE mount has the better options. The RF mount has the 28mm pancake, and some lenses have nice magnification factors but other than that I would vote for FE.
I think zooms are harder to compare as there are so many different ranges, aperture (ranges), and performance can be different at different focal lengths. Too complicated. But it makes sense to research which mount offers what you need.
p.15 #17Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
ingekj wrote: gdanmitchell wroteingekj wroteBest as far as total lens catalogue or just quality?
Sony makes the best trinity zooms for optical quality and weight. Their portrait lenses are second to Nikon in optical quality, but not much, and are lighter and cheaper. For Astro Sony have little competition. Where Sony falters slightly they have all these Sigma and Tamron choices for cheap with some being incredible value. For example Sigma 14-24 2.8, Tamron 35-150
Wildlife lenses goes to Nikon for choices, but also weight with 400 4.5, 600 6.3, 800 6.3 and integrated TC's on the big boys.
For Canon I dont think they have a single lens where Nikon or Sonys version doesnt beat itThis is a meaningless question. No one will ever come to an agreement that one brand is better than the others —the question is so highly subjective as to be unanswerable. And even it could be answered, the differences are generally insignificant and play out in different ways for different photographers.
The good news is that all three brands make excellent lenses. These lenses are used by talented photographers ot make outstanding photographs. No one can ever tell which brand of lens was used by looking at the photographs.
Of all of the important questions that matter to photographers, “Sony, Nikon, or Canon?” is just about the least important.The point of the thread was to discuss who makes the best lenses. That talented photographers can make good photos with anything is such a boring overdone point, everyone has heard it already. Makes no addition to the discussion.
If no one can tell what brand lens was used in a photo, then the lightest and cheapest would be best? In that case Sigma and Tamron wins.
My point is precisely about the "point of the thread." It is a nonsensical, meaningless question. There is no answer to it — just meaningless blathering, brand loyalty, seasoned with confirmation bias.
All the major camera companies make excellent lenses, and depending on what brand you use, any of them could be the "best" for you, though if you used one of the other brands, some of its lenses would be best for you.
"That talented photographers can make good photos with anything is such a boring overdone point..." and one that I did not make. My point is that if you cannot tell the difference between photographs made with the excellent lenses from the different brands. There is no difference in the quality of these lenses that has any effect on the quality of photographs.
No one said that "the cheapest" is the best. If you believe that, we can discuss it. I don't, and nothing I have written implies that.
The answer to the thread's question: No one makes "the best lenses." Several companies make outstanding lenses. Get one or more of them and start focusing on making photographs rather than trying to tease out micro-differences among brands.
p.15 #18Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
I would believe it. Matt tends to find a way to break a lot of things and then posts a vid on YouTube about it thinking it's a fault of Nikon build quality. molson wrote: JadedWriter wroteMatt Granger is a notorious gear breaker. I'm a gear breaker and I haven't had this problem. Literally nothing to see here because it's Matt Granger. He doesn't even have the David Yarrow excuse of "my gear gets sent to NPS because an elephant kicked it." duncangr wroteClearly not NikonCould be he just over-torqued the attaching screw on that Promedia replacement tripod foot - which could have overloaded those small attaching screws.
p.15 #19Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
steamtrain wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteThis will obviously be subjective and very opinionated but for those who have shot or currently shoot multiple systems, what company do you feel makes the best lenses? Mainly in terms of IQ but also taking into account things like coatings, autofocus motors, etc. More specifically the mid and upper range lenses.
I previously shot Sony and LOVED many of their GM lenses including the still excellent 135mm f1.8 GM, Sony 24mm f1.4 GM, and Sony 200-600mm. Flare resistance and sharpness were exceptional. Autofocus was always fast and silent. The only issue I saw occasionally was LOCA depending on the lens (like my FE 85mm f1.8 which I still own and have used adapted on my Nikon ZF).
I then moved to Canon (R5 then R5II) which is my main system now. I've heard many times over the years that "RF glass is the best". While I do love many of the lens offerings (15-35mm f2.8, 85mm f1.2, 28-70mm f2, 100-500mm, compact 70-200mm f2.8) I haven't found them to be astronomically better than my Sony glass, and in many cases I've found them to be worse. Specifically autofocus speed/noise, and flaring. The RF 28-70mm f2 and 85mm f1.2 are slow focusing compared to other Canon lenses like the RF 70-200mm f2.8 V1. The focus is also clunky and noisy on those lenses. Flaring resistance I've found inferior to my previous Sony glass, especially the 15-35mm and 85mm f1.2. Recently I saw someone attribute this to "better" coatings on Sony. I do think I prefer the rendering on certain Canon glass like the 28-70mm f2. As sharp as my Sony 135mm f1.8 GM was, it was quite clinical in its rendering. I slightly preferred my older adapted Sigma 135mm f1.8.
I've only just dipped my toes in with Nikon, starting with a ZF + 40mm f2 and 28mm f2.8, and recently a Z8 + 180-600mm + 14-30mm f4. Focus seems reasonably fast but not exceptionally so. My understanding is they use STM motors but clearly they're better than the ones used in Canon's budget lenses. I HATED the Canon RF 35mm f1.8 STM, RF 16mm f2.8, etc. The autofocus motors are noisy and slow. I couldn't even track a slow moving dog with the 35mm.
I recently came across someone speculating the Nikon makes the best lenses because they're an optics company. I've also seen many others speculate the Nikon's z-mount glass is the "best". However it's often biased users of whatever system claiming the company they use is the best, whether is be Canon, Nikon, or Sony. Strangely I see the least "best" claims with Sony which is strange because their GM lenses have been some of my favorites, even ones now 4+ years old. I love their focus on small size without much impact on IQ. Canon seems to have begun attempting something similar with their recent RF hybrid primes, the RF 24mm f1.4 VCM, RF 35mm f1.4, and RF 50mm f1.4. But it appears they've leaned HEAVILY into software corrections which affect overall IQ and have upset many users. I've never seen Canon's mid-high end lenses reviewed so poorly and with such controversy. Across the board most of their L lenses have always received praise, as have Sony's GM and Nikon's S-line lenses. In Dustin Abbott's review of the RF 35mm f1.4 he compared it to the Sony 35mm f1.4 GM and found the Sony better in most ways besides focus breathing. It had worse vignetting, distortion, and is a bit bigger.
Then there's also Tamron, Sigma, and now Viltrox which I have little recent experience with. Their biggest issue is often their compatibility in terms of focus speed and burst shooting (with sony) compared to first party options. But overall their quality seems to match or sometimes exceed the competition.
So what are your thoughts? Who makes the BEST lenses? What specific lenses have you used that stood out to you?
As I continue to test out my new Nikon cameras and lenses I'm taking into account the quality of the rest of the lens line-up as to which system I'll stick with. Canon has some special designs like the 28-70mm f2 (which Sony now offers a "better" version of), the 100-300mm f2.8 (a gamechanger for sports), the 100-500mm has been exceptional for me, and the 10-20mm is on my radar. Nikon has arguably the best wildlife setup which is part of my reason is getting a Z8. The 600mm f4 prime with built-in TC is better than Canon and Sony's offering IMO. The 600mm f6.3 is an awesome lightweight choice. Sony has the best primes and zooms for travel. They're the most compact and still exceptional quality based on the samples I've reviewed.If you need AF, Between FE and Canon:
16mm >> FE, Viltrox f/1.8
20mm >> FE, 20mm GM
24mm >> too early to tell, more info needed on the RF VCM
28mm >> The Sigma Art can be adapted to both
35mm >> FE, either Sigma f/1.2 Art or f/1.4 GM
40mm >> The Sigma Art can be adapted to both
50mm >> FE, f/1.2 GM, maybe f/1.4 GM if contrast in 50mm landscapes is your thing
85mm >> there's no perfect 85mm. The RF f/1.2 has slow AF. The FE Sigma DN does not AF fast as well. The EF f/1.4 IS USM has fast AF, but has too much fringing even at f/2.8. The GM mk I is a bit soft and has slow AF. The GM mkII has fast AF, but bokeh isn't great. The RF f/2.0 IS stm is relatively dark and has pretty poor AF (although magnification ratio, ILIS and contrast in back lit situations are great). I'm really hoping there will be an RF VCM very soon that has it all. For IQ the RF f/1.2 might be the best, however, for portability and value for money I think the Sigma DN is better value for money, and IQ is very good, with a huge distortion being a logical design choice at 85mm (not so much at 35mm, Canon).
105mm >> The Sigma Art can be adapted to both
135mm >> probably the RF lens, as it offers in lens stabilization, which the GM does not. That might make a difference at 135mm. I didn't dive in to the "differences" in IQ as I'm not interested so much in a 135mm prime, and most likely both lenses have stellar IQ and stellar AF.
Generally, if you like compact primes, I think the FE mount has the better options. The RF mount has the 28mm pancake, and some lenses have nice magnification factors but other than that I would vote for FE.
I think zooms are harder to compare as there are so many different ranges, aperture (ranges), and performance can be different at different focal lengths. Too complicated. But it makes sense to research which mount offers what you need.
I shoot the most demanding dance rehearsals and my Z8/Z9 focus a bit better on the pupil of the eye of fast paced dancers at f1.2 in mediocre light than the a9III. Both are excellent.
AF was a topic 3 years ago. It’s now fixed.
Only Canon is behind due to slow focusing bright lenses (50mm f1.2, 85mm f1.2, 28-70mm f2.0,…) and a really inferior long lenses line up. There simply are very few reason to start with RF in 2025 for photographers looking for a high end set up.
p.15 #20Who makes the BEST lenses? Canon or Nikon or Sony?
BokehBeauty wrote: ingekj wroteBest as far as total lens catalogue or just quality?
Sony makes the best trinity zooms for optical quality and weight. Their portrait lenses are second to Nikon in optical quality, but not much, and are lighter and cheaper. For Astro Sony have little competition. Where Sony falters slightly they have all these Sigma and Tamron choices for cheap with some being incredible value. For example Sigma 14-24 2.8, Tamron 35-150
Wildlife lenses goes to Nikon for choices, but also weight with 400 4.5, 600 6.3, 800 6.3 and integrated TC's on the big boys.
For Canon I dont think they have a single lens where Nikon or Sonys version doesnt beat itTo me there is no portrait lens like the Canon RF 85mm f1.2.
Which one?