j4nu wrote:
Yes, these examples are something I visualize when I hear "3d pop".
I guess the other category is "dimensionality", which matches some of the photos posted here in my eyes.
Your photo fits into the former IMHO, though I believe there's a thin line between the amount of transition/blur that makes or brakes such shots in terms of "3d pop" (i.e. too abrubt / no transition makes the effect lesser, not stronger) ...
I like the discussion in the video where he explains Mystique explains that the subject in some way should be connected to the rest of the image. Images where something sharp looks like it was pasted onto the background aren't that interesting (to me). maybe i don't agree everything he says though.
Yes, the old yellow flower shot is about blur but also leading line between much blur and "sharp"part.
Yes, "dimensionality" or perhaps an image with volume (not only area) doesn't need a lot of blur at all. In the video the mystique guy shows one such image (red flowers and two ladies) but the background is still blurred to some extent. The image by tsdevine on page 3 post 16 is an example of an image with volume, or depth, but not an image with pop. That's the way I understand the lingo here.
It would be difficult for the industry to make a 180 degree turn. They maneuver like a cruise ship once the course is set. Their big profit centres are ultra fast lenses that only really see use wide open - their raison d'etre.
This of course induces the painted-on look, compounded by the flat face look. It's almost as bad when you see industry leaders producing a flat bokeh field in the background, which tends to mimic a green screen look. So they are maximising separation at both longitudinal extremes of the imagery.
What to do? Firstly, realize that a fair proportion of their users want to head in a different direction than the one chosen by the cultural establishment. Not all, by nay means, many love what they see.
It would require fine attention to naturalistic focus fade regimes, greater tonality in colour and brightness (contrast control) in images of people, the right amount of detail in shadows and highlights, film-like roll-off in highlights (shoulder), and great attention to spherical aberration correction (for bokeh ball softness and low contrast bokeh). Less panic over CA correction that only shows at 100%, and perfectly round balls in corners.
A recognition that vignette mimics what they sky often does in nature, as well as the art classics - Mona Lisa, The Night Watch, Girl with the Pearl Earring, etc. Intelligent flare design. A neutral colour palette, to permit users to have more options in post processing.
These all require subtle understanding and a shifting of priorities. I don't think they are up for it. Subtlety is not their strong suit.
And they are doing very nicely with their current direction, so the need is not there for edge cases like us. The bright hope is DZO, whose recent Simera lenses are cine derivatives with many of the above characteristics designed into them. It is taking an outsider to see what can be done, now that Zeiss is gone. The industry is run by optical engineering and marketing types, not artistic people and their fellow travellers.
philip_pj wrote:
It would be difficult for the industry to make a 180 degree turn. They maneuver like a cruise ship once the course is set. Their big profit centres are ultra fast lenses that only really see use wide open - their raison d'etre.
Could you provide a brief list of lenses that fit the design philosophy you are looking for?
philip_pj wrote:
It would be difficult for the industry to make a 180 degree turn. They maneuver like a cruise ship once the course is set. Their big profit centres are ultra fast lenses that only really see use wide open - their raison d'etre.
This of course induces the painted-on look, compounded by the flat face look. It's almost as bad when you see industry leaders producing a flat bokeh field in the background, which tends to mimic a green screen look. So they are maximising separation at both longitudinal extremes of the imagery.
What to do? Firstly, realize that a fair proportion of their users want to head in a different direction than the one chosen by the cultural establishment. Not all, by nay means, many love what they see.
It would require fine attention to naturalistic focus fade regimes, greater tonality in colour and brightness (contrast control) in images of people, the right amount of detail in shadows and highlights, film-like roll-off in highlights (shoulder), and great attention to spherical aberration correction (for bokeh ball softness and low contrast bokeh). Less panic over CA correction that only shows at 100%, and perfectly round balls in corners.
A recognition that vignette mimics what they sky often does in nature, as well as the art classics - Mona Lisa, The Night Watch, Girl with the Pearl Earring, etc. Intelligent flare design. A neutral colour palette, to permit users to have more options in post processing.
These all require subtle understanding and a shifting of priorities. I don't think they are up for it. Subtlety is not their strong suit.
And they are doing very nicely with their current direction, so the need is not there for edge cases like us. The bright hope is DZO, whose recent Simera lenses are cine derivatives with many of the above characteristics designed into them. It is taking an outsider to see what can be done, now that Zeiss is gone. The industry is run by optical engineering and marketing types, not artistic people and their fellow travellers....Show more →
Yet, many (most) fine photographers today are producing exemplary and beautiful work with this gear that you think is so inadequate.
Like many here, I like to think we can see something good in many of the pantheon of past, present and near future lenses, and I have have nowhere near as much knowledge as many members, probably including your good self.
I believe one needs lenses that solve problems in what you shoot. Sadly, it might mean you need a few at your main focal lengths. I'm not trying to hedge, but I'm better at what I don't like than what is ideal. Most of the ones I love the look of are too big and heavy, also. I don't believe in disparaging anyone's work but instead focus on the lenses' performance.
Many wide angles are pretty great. Some I like: CV 15/4.5, Zeiss 21/2.8, Leica 21/3.4 and 24/3.8, CY 28/2, CY 35/1.4, ZF 35/2. Many 50s fit my criteria : Otus 55/1.4, Simera 50/1.4, Nikon's 58/1.4, Sony's 55/1.8, CV Heliar 50/3.5 and new 50/3.5 APO, CY 35-70/3.4, plenty more, mostly from 20C. Short teles are hard, we have so few but for me: CV 75/2.5, 75/1.5, Loxia 85/2.4, CY 85/2.8, ZF 100/2, CY 100/3.5, Nikon 105/2.5, Leica R 90/2, Leica R 100/2.8, Leica R 80/1.4, Otus 100/1.4 (IMO the best lens of the last two decades), the longer Leica SL primes. They are nearly all 'edge case' lenses or 'brushed aside into history' lenses.
But these would be for intimate portraits, landscapes and Himalaya environments. And the caveat is that tastes change over your career, and so does your shooting style. I'm now very fussy about portraits.
Have you noticed that many modern fast lenses produce images that appear to be highly front lit? Maybe they all use flash. Not to be a critic of any photographer, but look at these pages as examples of f1.2 lenses:
An example of a challenging portrait. 'The Voigtlander Heliar 50mm f/3.5 is known for its unique, soft focus character. Embrace this by using it to create dreamy, ethereal portraits. 'It produces a unique, film-like aesthetic.' (shot on a 42mp a7rII)
..
crop to show shaping, skin treatment, color tone and highlight handling
philip_pj wrote:
An example of a challenging portrait. 'The Voigtlander Heliar 50mm f/3.5 is known for its unique, soft focus character. Embrace this by using it to create dreamy, ethereal portraits. 'It produces a unique, film-like aesthetic.' (shot on a 42mp a7rII)
[images]
crop to show shaping, skin treatment, color tone and highlight handling
Eh... I don't know what to say really...
The girl is very cute. If i look at the image again my heart will probably melt. Putting that aside:
A challenging portrait...
For the most of the time I like and appreciate your posts. I have mentioned that earlier and I do it again. Sometimes however I don't get everything and it's not because English isn't my first language.
I have been taking (mostly mediocre) images for decades and besides of images I also like technical stuff. That doesn't help in this case: I have no idea about what film-like aesthetic, shaping, skin treatment, color tone and highlight handling means.
Well, partly I understand: there will be differences due to lens flare (--> contrast) "Shaping" is probably not about distortion here. As much as I like my Voigtländer lenses I have never thought about shaping, skin treatment, color tone and highlight handling. Maybe you can explain a little? Using another 50mm lens would have caused what?
(And why not move away from the harsh sun and use any normal lens?)
philip_pj wrote:
An example of a challenging portrait. 'The Voigtlander Heliar 50mm f/3.5 is known for its unique, soft focus character. Embrace this by using it to create dreamy, ethereal portraits. 'It produces a unique, film-like aesthetic.' (shot on a 42mp a7rII)
There’s nothing wrong with that photograph. It is nice. But there’s nothing exceptional about it either. It is a lovely, competent photograph of n appealing subject, and it uses light well. but it is no more lovely than or different from what would be produced with a wide variety of lenses and camera systems.
No, I do not believe that all lenses are “the same.” But I’m convinced that most of the stuff about some lens being superb for, say, portraits in ways that place it far beyond what could be done with supposedly “lesser” lenses is mostly about confirmation bias— seeing what we already believed to be true.
I suppose one could say about me that “you just don’t have the sensitivity to see it.” And I perhaps cannot persuade you otherwise, though I’m confident that you would be wrong. But I’m at least as sensitive to these things as most photographers and fare more sensitive to them than the average viewer. And I’m just not seeing anything that says “this was made with an exceptional, unparalleled lens.”
Sorry for being blunt, but this might be a useful Emperor’s New Clothes moment for some people.
philip_pj wrote:
If you have some time, I suggest you look at either or both of these articles from a veteran cinematographer at Arri, it is well worth anyone's while to do this:
We really sound like a bunch of wine (exotic glas) connoisseurs musing about an exceptional fragrance (trait or drawing) of a unique wine (lens) and what needs to be done to achieve such a product.
It's a necessary development, control of language is a hidden key to understanding. Before we have a description, the concept does not officially exist. The Arri guy did a great service to his readers.
I worked in the wine industry for several years and witnessed numerous blind tastings. They can fool the best judges, even winemakers.
philip_pj wrote:
If you have some time, I suggest you look at either or both of these articles from a veteran cinematographer at Arri, it is well worth anyone's while to do this:
It is notable that cat's eye bokeh is a feature of the expensive ARRI Signature Prime lenses. Also, the number of elements and types of glass are not mentioned anywhere in their technical specifications (or I couldn't find it).
philip_pj wrote:
[...]
Aesthetic is a description of a certain style
[...
]Heliars (to me) ARE normal lenses, like Sonnars and Sonnar derivatives. If a lens fails in Australian light (we all develop squints, like Clint Eastwood), it will fail in the Himalaya - this shot was in Kagbeni, upper Nepal, 3500m. Quite a number of lenses do fail and images cannot be rescued, such as the C-Sonnar I tried, it just had too much macro contrast. People love it and good, but it won't work for me.
Thank you for elaborating. I understand what you mean better now. I don't agree about everything but there are may factors making us think along different paths I believe.
Film-like is often low contrast due to high internal flare. The post processing style when you let the darkest parts of the image stay at dark grey rather than close to black.
(The other thing that's film-like to me is the way film behaves with high-lights, the shoulder rather than burning out the world.)
Putting film-like and aesthetic next to each other makes less sense to me. The common Zeiss high microcontrast and, often, bad bokeh isn't limited to film.
Shaping... that is very much a product of how the photographer uses the tool rather than ta feature of the tool. Stop your fast lens down and let the subject be a part of the image, not something pasted onto a blurred background. There is no wonder cine people avoids the bold, big, up in the face style when shooting - such images are a pain when looking at them in the cinema. In commercials perhaps but not when it counts
Here we have a parallel when it comes to actors: those with a background from the theater world are often having a problem toning their facial expressions down. At a theater bold gestures are necessary, on the big screen they are often too much.
Anyway, I think "shaping" is much more about the photographers skill than a lens feature.
About strongly lit faces... that's a certain style coming from both the moment the image is captured and from post processing. It seems as the current common wisdom says images should never be "underexposed". More light! But I don't believe it is a lens feature to magically produce a searchlight - you are surely right right about commercial and corporate images here. The the pros spread their wisdom.
Casablanca, Ingrid Bergman, rounded sharpness, the full image rather than eye-lashes. Yes please.
I will read up about the Arri signature lenses and also compare it to the philosophy behind the Leitz Cine lenses of which I, secretely, wish I owned one or two of their Summilux-C lenses. I know, it doesn't make sense... but at least one of them at some point? (The full frame Leitz Prime series I'm not familiar with at all.)
I'm also not familiar with shooting in Australia or at 3500 meters above the sea. But macro contrast... Sometimes people refer resolution at 10 lp/mm as macro contrast but I suppose that is not what you are thinking about here?
I have a near full set of Zeiss lenses for my Hasselblad 503cx, 7 different ones. I also have a triplet of Zeiss Mulvis lenses for my F-mount Nikons. I also have several Leica Summiluxes, as well as several L-series primes for my Canon EOS. On top of that I now have a couple of Sony GM lenses, Mamiya TLR Sekors, Mamya 645 Sekors, two Rolleiflex cameras with both Xenotar and Planar lenses. Plus various Voigtlanders and Fuji X-mount primes. About 40 total.
I have never seen 3D pop in my life.
I didn't notice it in the posted video. The dude just talks about it but doesn't show it. If 3D pop existed, the Internet would have been filled with simple proof: the same scene shown with/without 3D pop, left/right comparison. Instead, I only see stories. 3D pop is similar to that light at the end of the tunnel that people see as they experience clinical death. The internet full of stories about that light, but not a single image of it. My hope is that instead of that tunnel light I get to finally get to see 3D pop in my last moments.
I see some pop in the picture of the girl. But, it most likely is due to the subject separation as opposed to any special characteristics of the lens used. Again, i said "pop" and not "3D pop". If 3D pop was obvious, it would be easy to point it out. Since it's not so obvious to the point of questioning its existence, I have to ask why it's of any interest, much less importance.
I did my own test using one of the favored 3D pop lenses, the 55mm f/1.8 Sony Zeiss vs the kit zoom, 28-70mm Sony. Side by side they look the same. Sorry. No pop in the images I took, 3D or otherwise.