fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024ED elements , lens design and 3D pop

  
 
Garmadon
Offline

p.1 #1ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
I found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
You can see it here , in minute 22:11 :



Basically , Lenses with less ED elements that also have group complexity of >1.27 will show great pop .

While I dont have any optics education - I can see the pop most of the times.
I checked many lenses that I owned /seen online and it seems quite right .
In this method you can predict the pop in the Loxia line ,most of the Batis line , all non APO Voigtlanders ,85mm GM , 85mm Samyang ,50mm GM ,50mm planar, 35mm distagon, 35mm and 55mm sonnars , the new Thypoch lenses .

What do you guys think?
Nov 06, 2024 at 04:40 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.1 #2ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
I found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
You can see it here , in minute 22:11 :



Basically , Lenses with less ED elements that also have group complexity of >1.27 will show great pop .

While I dont have any optics education - I can see the pop most of the times.
I checked many lenses that I owned /seen online and it seems quite right .
In this method you can predict the pop in the Loxia line ,most of the Batis line , all non APO Voigtlanders ,85mm GM , 85mm Samyang
...Show more →

Wow, that was hard to watch. I don't think it makes much sense. A number of lenses that I think have quite a bit of pop have more than 3 ED/APD elements (and why 3 is ok and 4 isn't?) including the ZEISS Otus 55, 85, and 100 and the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 135 f/2 APO. I could add a bunch more. I don't think his basic claim that ED/APD elements make lenses look flat makes sense or is supported, but hey it is really hard to define "pop," so maybe I just don't get it.
Nov 06, 2024 at 07:04 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.1 #3ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Yes ,it is better at ×2 speed.
He also say that Zeiss and voigtlander use different ed glass that has less impact . For those you can take up to 20% ed.

Some more lenses that passed : Sigma 28-45 f1.8 ,Nikon 40mm f2. Also there is a new one : TTartisan 75mm f2.

Steve Spencer wrote:
Garmadon wroteI found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
You can see it here , in minute 22:11 :



Basically , Lenses with less ED elements that also have group complexity of >1.27 will show great pop .

While I dont have any optics education - I can see the pop most of the times.
I checked many lenses that I owned /seen online and it seems quite right .
In this method you can predict the pop in the Loxia line ,most of the Batis line , all non APO Voigtlanders ,85mm GM , 85mm Samyang ,50mm GM ,50mm planar, 35mm distagon, 35mm and 55mm sonnars , the new Thypoch lenses .

What do you guys think?
Wow, that was hard to watch. I don't think it makes much sense. A number of lenses that I think have quite a bit of pop have more than 3 ED/APD elements including the ZEISS Otus 55, 85, and 100 and the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 135 f/2 APO. I could add a bunch more. I don't think his basic claim that ED/APD elements make lenses look flat makes sense or is supported, but hey it is really hard to define "pop," so maybe I just don't get it.

Nov 06, 2024 at 07:19 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.1 #4ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
Yes ,it is better at ×2 speed.
He also say that Zeiss and voigtlander use different ed glass that has less impact . For those you can take up to 20% ed.

Some more lenses that passed : Sigma 28-45 f1.8 ,Nikon 40mm f2. Also there is a new one : TTartisan 75mm f2.

Steve Spencer wrote
Garmadon wroteI found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
You can see it here , in minute 22:11 :



Basically , Lenses with less ED elements that also have group complexity of >1.27 will show great pop .

While I dont have any optics education - I can see the pop most of the times.
I checked many lenses that I owned /seen online and it seems quite right .
In this method you can predict the pop in the Loxia line ,most of the Batis line , all non APO Voigtlanders ,85mm GM , 85mm Samyang ,50mm GM ,50mm planar, 35mm distagon, 35mm and 55mm sonnars , the new Thypoch lenses .

What do you guys think?
Wow, that was hard to watch. I don't think it makes much sense. A number of lenses that I think have quite a bit of pop have more than 3 ED/APD elements including the ZEISS Otus 55, 85, and 100 and the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 135 f/2 APO. I could add a bunch more. I don't think his basic claim that ED/APD elements make lenses look flat makes sense or is supported, but hey it is really hard to define "pop," so maybe I just don't get it.


Another lens that is usually nominated as one of the lenses with the most 3D pop is the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 21 f/2.8. It has 5 ED/APD elements. A pretty strong counter example to the claims in this video.
Nov 06, 2024 at 07:22 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.1 #5ED elements , lens design and 3D pop

Also the Otus 28mm , but maybe those are not ED elements (extra dispersion)?
Zeiss describe them as "special glass with anomalous partial dispersion".
Maybe the partial has somthing to do with it ? or is it just marketing?
Steve Spencer wrote:
Garmadon wroteYes ,it is better at ×2 speed.
He also say that Zeiss and voigtlander use different ed glass that has less impact . For those you can take up to 20% ed.

Some more lenses that passed : Sigma 28-45 f1.8 ,Nikon 40mm f2. Also there is a new one : TTartisan 75mm f2.

Steve Spencer wrote
Garmadon wroteI found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
You can see it here , in minute 22:11 :



Basically , Lenses with less ED elements that also have group complexity of >1.27 will show great pop .

While I dont have any optics education - I can see the pop most of the times.
I checked many lenses that I owned /seen online and it seems quite right .
In this method you can predict the pop in the Loxia line ,most of the Batis line , all non APO Voigtlanders ,85mm GM , 85mm Samyang ,50mm GM ,50mm planar, 35mm distagon, 35mm and 55mm sonnars , the new Thypoch lenses .

What do you guys think?
Wow, that was hard to watch. I don't think it makes much sense. A number of lenses that I think have quite a bit of pop have more than 3 ED/APD elements including the ZEISS Otus 55, 85, and 100 and the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 135 f/2 APO. I could add a bunch more. I don't think his basic claim that ED/APD elements make lenses look flat makes sense or is supported, but hey it is really hard to define "pop," so maybe I just don't get it.
Another lens that is usually nominated as one of the lenses with the most 3D pop is the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 21 f/2.8. It has 5 ED/APD elements. A pretty strong counter example to the claims in this video.

Nov 06, 2024 at 08:13 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.1 #6ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
Also the Otus 28mm , but maybe those are not ED elements (extra dispersion)?
Zeiss describe them as "special glass with anomalous partial dispersion".
Maybe the partial has somthing to do with it ? or is it just marketing?
Steve Spencer wrote
Garmadon wroteYes ,it is better at ×2 speed.
He also say that Zeiss and voigtlander use different ed glass that has less impact . For those you can take up to 20% ed.

Some more lenses that passed : Sigma 28-45 f1.8 ,Nikon 40mm f2. Also there is a new one : TTartisan 75mm f2.

Steve Spencer wrote
Garmadon wroteI found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
You can see it here , in minute 22:11 :



Basically , Lenses with less ED elements that also have group complexity of >1.27 will show great pop .

While I dont have any optics education - I can see the pop most of the times.
I checked many lenses that I owned /seen online and it seems quite right .
In this method you can predict the pop in the Loxia line ,most of the Batis line , all non APO Voigtlanders ,85mm GM , 85mm Samyang ,50mm GM ,50mm planar, 35mm distagon, 35mm and 55mm sonnars , the new Thypoch lenses .

What do you guys think?
Wow, that was hard to watch. I don't think it makes much sense. A number of lenses that I think have quite a bit of pop have more than 3 ED/APD elements including the ZEISS Otus 55, 85, and 100 and the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 135 f/2 APO. I could add a bunch more. I don't think his basic claim that ED/APD elements make lenses look flat makes sense or is supported, but hey it is really hard to define "pop," so maybe I just don't get it.
Another lens that is usually nominated as one of the lenses with the most 3D pop is the Zeiss ZE/ZF/Milvus 21 f/2.8. It has 5 ED/APD elements. A pretty strong counter example to the claims in this video.


ED and APD elements are just different naming for the same general class of glass. Zeiss, Leica, and Cosina (who makes Voigtlander) generally call this glass APD; Nikon, Canon, and Sony generally call this glass ED.
Nov 06, 2024 at 08:25 AM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.1 #7ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
I don't know enough about optics to prove it, but I have theory lenses with more 3D pop are less corrected and those aberrations, such as field curvature give some of that pop effect.

For example, the sigma 45mm f2.8 is known for having smooth bokeh but has fringing. I have heard some people say the bokeh would not be as smooth if they corrected the design for fringing.
Nov 06, 2024 at 04:59 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.1 #8ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
DWOfPaul wrote:
I don't know enough about optics to prove it, but I have theory lenses with more 3D pop are less corrected and those aberrations, such as field curvature give some of that pop effect.

For example, the sigma 45mm f2.8 is known for having smooth bokeh but has fringing. I have heard some people say the bokeh would not be as smooth if they corrected the design for fringing.


I think it depends on the aberration. Under corrected spherical aberrations certainly can make the bokeh softer. That is what I believe gives the Sigma 45 f/2.8 its signature bokeh, but fringing I think isn't that related. Under corrected spherical aberrations can also mask fringing, but fringing itself I don't think makes the bokeh softer or harsher.

I think what generally happens is that when a lens tries to reduce aberrations it tends to go for all of them reduced chromatic aberrations, reduced spherical aberrations, reduced field curvature, etc., and that very corrected look doesn't lend itself to rendering that some people like.

I think 3D pop, however, is very complex. Perceptual psychologists have studied 3D perception in 2D objects for over 100 years. There are many factors involved and it isn't simple, but I don't think control of fringing is one of the factors that matters much if at all, and this hypothesis in the video posted by the OP is really about whether controlling fringing reduces 3D pop and I doubt that it does, but really that is just speculation on my part.
Nov 07, 2024 at 06:43 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.1 #9ED elements , lens design and 3D pop

As Steve said, the 45 is known for undercorrected SA. I don't think it's bad for CA.

https://www.lenstip.com/578.5-Lens_review-Sigma_C_45_mm_f_2.8_DG_DN_Chromatic_and_spherical_aberration.html
Nov 07, 2024 at 06:48 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.1 #10ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Steve Spencer wrote:
DWOfPaul wroteI don't know enough about optics to prove it, but I have theory lenses with more 3D pop are less corrected and those aberrations, such as field curvature give some of that pop effect.

For example, the sigma 45mm f2.8 is known for having smooth bokeh but has fringing. I have heard some people say the bokeh would not be as smooth if they corrected the design for fringing.
I think it depends on the aberration. Under corrected spherical aberrations certainly can make the bokeh softer. That is what I believe gives the Sigma 45 f/2.8 its signature bokeh, but fringing I think isn't that related. Under corrected spherical aberrations can also mask fringing, but fringing itself I don't think makes the bokeh softer or harsher.

I think what generally happens is that when a lens tries to reduce aberrations it tends to go for all of them reduced chromatic aberrations, reduced spherical aberrations, reduced field curvature, etc., and that very corrected look doesn't lend itself to rendering
...Show more →

I dont think there is a connection between 3d pop and Bokeh , I think the 3D 'feel' can be achieved even when the whole frame is in focus.
Nov 07, 2024 at 08:11 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.1 #11ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
I found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
You can see it here , in minute 22:11 :



Basically , Lenses with less ED elements that also have group complexity of >1.27 will show great pop .

While I dont have any optics education - I can see the pop most of the times.
I checked many lenses that I owned /seen online and it seems quite right .
In this method you can predict the pop in the Loxia line ,most of the Batis line , all non APO Voigtlanders ,85mm GM , 85mm Samyang
...Show more →

I think… that “3D pop” is an undefinable, mutable term that people use to describe something that isn’t objectively there in a lens. It is more likely the result of what and how one photographs.

I don’t like the term at all, at least when people attempt to use it to describe something objective. But what I think we’re talking about is a kind of clarity and separation in photographs. But the biggest actors there are things like lighting, color and luminosity relationships, how one uses DOF, composition, and other decisions that photographers make — not something intrinsic in lenses.
Nov 07, 2024 at 08:16 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.1 #12ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
DWOfPaul wroteI don't know enough about optics to prove it, but I have theory lenses with more 3D pop are less corrected and those aberrations, such as field curvature give some of that pop effect.

For example, the sigma 45mm f2.8 is known for having smooth bokeh but has fringing. I have heard some people say the bokeh would not be as smooth if they corrected the design for fringing.
I think it depends on the aberration. Under corrected spherical aberrations certainly can make the bokeh softer. That is what I believe gives the Sigma 45 f/2.8 its signature bokeh, but fringing I think isn't that related. Under corrected spherical aberrations can also mask fringing, but fringing itself I don't think makes the bokeh softer or harsher.

I think what generally happens is that when a lens tries to reduce aberrations it tends to go for all of them reduced chromatic aberrations, reduced spherical aberrations, reduced field curvature, etc., and that very corrected look doesn't lend itself to rendering that some people like.

I think 3D pop, however, is very complex. Perceptual psychologists have studied 3D perception in 2D objects for over 100 years. There are many factors involved and it isn't simple, but I don't think control of fringing is one of the factors that matters much if at all, and this hypothesis in the video posted by the OP is really about whether controlling fringing reduces 3D pop and I doubt that it does, but really that is just speculation on my part.
I dont think there is a connection between 3d pop and Bokeh , I think the 3D 'feel' can be achieved even when the whole frame is in focus.


As I alluded to above, perceptual psychologists have studies 3D perception of 2D objects for over 100 years. I think it is an interesting and complex topic. To summarize, there are many factors involved in whether people report seeing 3D dimensionality in a 2D object. Some of those factors (and in fact most) have nothing to do with blur in the image, but that doesn't mean that blur plays no role. I think all the things Dan mentioned are likely to play a role. If you hold all those things constant, however, do some lenses lead to people seeing more 3D perception in an image than other lenses? I don't know, but it wouldn't surprise me if that were true, but even if it is true the lens would just be one factor among many affecting 3D perception. If your goal was creating 3D perception, which I don't think it hardly ever is for me, the lens would just be one thing among many that you would have to consider and I doubt it would be that important of a factor.
Nov 07, 2024 at 09:12 AM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.1 #13ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
@Steve Spencer @tsdevine Thanks for the correction. I am trying to learn more about optics and what trades off with what.
Nov 07, 2024 at 10:21 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.1 #14ED elements , lens design and 3D pop

No worries, I'm on that same journey. It stuck in my mind that I learned this about the Sigma 45 from Fred.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1608234/26#15069334

DWOfPaul wrote:
@Steve Spencer@ @tsdevine@ Thanks for the correction. I am trying to learn more about optics and what trades off with what.


Nov 07, 2024 at 11:20 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.1 #15ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
I just like that look it makes me stare at the photo.
I guess my goql here is to better understand what creates that 'depth' in a photo . I used to think sharpness is what I see , but I dont think it is.
Please note that I mostley reffer to photos with deep dof , check the photos here ,especially the forst one by Jim Harris.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1788363/0

Someone said it is the 'low element look' ,then I found this video.

Steve Spencer wrote:
Garmadon wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
DWOfPaul wroteI don't know enough about optics to prove it, but I have theory lenses with more 3D pop are less corrected and those aberrations, such as field curvature give some of that pop effect.

For example, the sigma 45mm f2.8 is known for having smooth bokeh but has fringing. I have heard some people say the bokeh would not be as smooth if they corrected the design for fringing.
I think it depends on the aberration. Under corrected spherical aberrations certainly can make the bokeh softer. That is what I believe gives the Sigma 45 f/2.8 its signature bokeh, but fringing I think isn't that related. Under corrected spherical aberrations can also mask fringing, but fringing itself I don't think makes the bokeh softer or harsher.

I think what generally happens is that when a lens tries to reduce aberrations it tends to go for all of them reduced chromatic aberrations, reduced spherical aberrations, reduced field curvature, etc., and that very corrected look doesn't lend itself to rendering that some people like.

I think 3D pop, however, is very complex. Perceptual psychologists have studied 3D perception in 2D objects for over 100 years. There are many factors involved and it isn't simple, but I don't think control of fringing is one of the factors that matters much if at all, and this hypothesis in the video posted by the OP is really about whether controlling fringing reduces 3D pop and I doubt that it does, but really that is just speculation on my part.
I dont think there is a connection between 3d pop and Bokeh , I think the 3D 'feel' can be achieved even when the whole frame is in focus.
As I alluded to above, perceptual psychologists have studies 3D perception of 2D objects for over 100 years. I think it is an interesting and complex topic. To summarize, there are many factors involved in whether people report seeing 3D dimensionality in a 2D object. Some of those factors (and in fact most) have nothing to do with blur in the image, but that doesn't mean that blur plays no role. I think all the things Dan mentioned are likely to play a role. If you hold all those things constant, however, do some lenses lead to people seeing
...Show more →
Nov 07, 2024 at 11:31 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.1 #16ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
After some decades of photography, with a bunch of brands and a whole lot of lenses, while I know that all lenses are not the same, I've seen images that some might say exhibit so-called "3D pop" from just about every camera and lens you can imagine.

While I'm sure that there are better and less-good lenses, I haven't seen anything that convinces me that this thing referred to as "pop" comes from lenses.

You can see it on photographs made with smart phones sometimes!

What is it that gives a photograph some combination of "dimensionality" and a subject that seems to sharply stand out from other elements? It is not one thing, but a collection of them, and they can be applied in a huge variety of ways.

A subject can "pop" due to how it is lit relative to other elements in the scene. Color variations (luminosity and color balance) among elements can do it. (Imagine a warmly lit subject against a darker and more cooly lit background.) The angle of the light and resulting shading can do it, too — shadows, handled well, can overcome a sense of "flatness" I'm images. I think that focus can be an element, with the classic being to soften non-central elements though careful use of DOF and/or things like lens movements. Putting a well-lit subject in front of a background that is less brightly lit can help. Even things like vignetting (from the lens or added in post) can more strongly draw our attention to a central subject.

And don’t discount what happens in post processing either. If you aren’t post processing (either in the traditional ways with film or in the digital darkroom) you aren’t getting everything out of the image that you could. Simple things that almost all of us do can help: Increase contrast a bit. Work with curves, especially masked curves. Consider increasing “vibrance” and/or saturation, and possibly shifting the image’s overall color balance. Use the clarity control. Apply a bit of vignetting. And keep in mind that there are two ways to get something in the image to “pop.” One is to introduce these variables to your main subject. (Again, masks are powerful.) Another is to diminish them in non-subject areas: reduce their brightness a bit, decrease saturation, use a cooler color balance, try negative clarity to diffuse things a bit.

Edited on Nov 07, 2024 at 05:58 PM · View previous versions
Nov 07, 2024 at 12:47 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.1 #17ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
I just like that look it makes me stare at the photo.
I guess my goql here is to better understand what creates that 'depth' in a photo . I used to think sharpness is what I see , but I dont think it is.
Please note that I mostley reffer to photos with deep dof , check the photos here ,especially the forst one by Jim Harris.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1788363/0

Someone said it is the 'low element look' ,then I found this video.

Steve Spencer wrote
Garmadon wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
DWOfPaul wroteI don't know enough about optics to prove it, but I have theory lenses with more 3D pop are less corrected and those aberrations, such as field curvature give some of that pop effect.

For example, the sigma 45mm f2.8 is known for having smooth bokeh but has fringing. I have heard some people say the bokeh would not be as smooth if they corrected the design for fringing.
I think it depends on the aberration. Under corrected spherical aberrations certainly can make the bokeh softer. That is what I believe gives the Sigma 45 f/2.8 its signature bokeh, but fringing I think isn't that related. Under corrected spherical aberrations can also mask fringing, but fringing itself I don't think makes the bokeh softer or harsher.

I think what generally happens is that when a lens tries to reduce aberrations it tends to go for all of them reduced chromatic aberrations, reduced spherical aberrations, reduced field curvature, etc., and that very corrected look doesn't lend itself to rendering that some people like.

I think 3D pop, however, is very complex. Perceptual psychologists have studied 3D perception in 2D objects for over 100 years. There are many factors involved and it isn't simple, but I don't think control of fringing is one of the factors that matters much if at all, and this hypothesis in the video posted by the OP is really about whether controlling fringing reduces 3D pop and I doubt that it does, but really that is just speculation on my part.
I dont think there is a connection between 3d pop and Bokeh , I think the 3D 'feel' can be achieved even when the whole frame is in focus.
As I alluded to above, perceptual psychologists have studies 3D perception of 2D objects for over 100 years. I think it is an interesting and complex topic. To summarize, there are many factors involved in whether people report seeing 3D dimensionality in a 2D object. Some of those factors (and in fact most) have nothing to do with blur in the image, but that doesn't mean that blur plays no role. I think all the things Dan mentioned are likely to play a role. If you hold all those things constant, however, do some lenses lead to people seeing more 3D perception in an image than other lenses? I don't know, but it wouldn't surprise me if that were true, but even if it is true the lens would just be one factor among many affecting 3D perception. If your goal was creating 3D perception, which I don't think it hardly ever is for me, the lens would just be one thing among many that you would have to consider and I doubt it would be that important of a factor.


I really like that shot by Jim, but my own view is that it is the composition that creates the look you are describing way more than the lens. If you want to begin to study what perceptual psychologists describe about this phenomena you can begin by looking up a texture gradient and then think about how that can be used in composition. My own take is whether Jim did that intentionally or not that is what he took advantage of in that photo and it works really well.
Nov 07, 2024 at 12:59 PM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.1 #18ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
While I know some of the usual tricks -I dont really see any of them here. No leading lines ,normal perspective ,0 blur ,no red subject...
Maybe the shadow part in the middle make it look distant? and maybe he applies some clarity to the greens...

Do you see anything else?

Steve Spencer wrote:
Garmadon wroteI just like that look it makes me stare at the photo.
I guess my goql here is to better understand what creates that 'depth' in a photo . I used to think sharpness is what I see , but I dont think it is.
Please note that I mostley reffer to photos with deep dof , check the photos here ,especially the forst one by Jim Harris.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1788363/0

Someone said it is the 'low element look' ,then I found this video.

Steve Spencer wrote
Garmadon wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
DWOfPaul wroteI don't know enough about optics to prove it, but I have theory lenses with more 3D pop are less corrected and those aberrations, such as field curvature give some of that pop effect.

For example, the sigma 45mm f2.8 is known for having smooth bokeh but has fringing. I have heard some people say the bokeh would not be as smooth if they corrected the design for fringing.
I think it depends on the aberration. Under corrected spherical aberrations certainly can make the bokeh softer. That is what I believe gives the Sigma 45 f/2.8 its signature bokeh, but fringing I think isn't that related. Under corrected spherical aberrations can also mask fringing, but fringing itself I don't think makes the bokeh softer or harsher.

I think what generally happens is that when a lens tries to reduce aberrations it tends to go for all of them reduced chromatic aberrations, reduced spherical aberrations, reduced field curvature, etc., and that very corrected look doesn't lend itself to rendering that some people like.

I think 3D pop, however, is very complex. Perceptual psychologists have studied 3D perception in 2D objects for over 100 years. There are many factors involved and it isn't simple, but I don't think control of fringing is one of the factors that matters much if at all, and this hypothesis in the video posted by the OP is really about whether controlling fringing reduces 3D pop and I doubt that it does, but really that is just speculation on my part.
I dont think there is a connection between 3d pop and Bokeh , I think the 3D 'feel' can be achieved even when the whole frame is in focus.
As I alluded to above, perceptual psychologists have studies 3D perception of 2D objects for over 100 years. I think it is an interesting and complex topic. To summarize, there are many factors involved in whether people report seeing 3D dimensionality in a 2D object. Some of those factors (and in fact most) have nothing to do with blur in the image, but that doesn't mean that blur plays no role. I think all the things Dan mentioned are likely to play a role. If you hold all those things constant, however, do some lenses lead to people seeing more 3D perception in an image than other lenses? I don't know, but it wouldn't surprise me if that were true, but even if it is true the lens would just be one factor among many affecting 3D perception. If your goal was creating 3D perception, which I don't think it hardly ever is for me, the lens would just be one thing among many that you would have to consider and I doubt it would be that important of a factor.
I really like that shot by Jim, but my own view is that it is the composition that creates the look you are describing way more than the lens. If you want to begin to study what perceptual psychologists describe about this phenomena you can begin by looking up a texture gradient and then think about how that can be used in composition. My own take is whether Jim did that intentionally or not that is what he took advantage of in that photo and it works really well.

Nov 07, 2024 at 02:56 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.1 #19ED elements , lens design and 3D pop

This is going to sound intensely dumb. But I find perusing shots on Flickr is a good way to see if there really is "magic" with shots from a given lens. Put a lens in the hands of the masses......if you actually see a meaningful number of shots that exhibit this.....then maybe you'll get the same results with the lens.

I don't know the right answer. But any depth or dimensionality we see in shots, which again others may not see, is a sum of many parts....IMHO. It's not just the lens, it's not just the lighting, it's not just the perspective, it's not just the aperture....etc.

For example, I see a lot of dimensionality in the shots from the Tamron 35/1.4 (doesn't mean others will)...and I suspect that lens is in the video guy's flat list.
Nov 07, 2024 at 03:12 PM
tschopp
Offline
Details
p.1 #20ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
The guy in the first video has a bunch of videos on pop. I tried watching a second one, but he just didn't seem to be saying anything.

The guy below has a small channel, but I like his videos. Seems a bit of a different take on many things photography based. His voice is also nearly identical to a guy I know that is the smartest person I know with an IQ easily 160+. I think this tends to make me take what he says much more seriously.

Nov 07, 2024 at 06:07 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister