fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024ED elements , lens design and 3D pop

  
 
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.5 #1ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
philip_pj wrote:
We can disagree amicably, and we do.


Of course we do.
I have now re-read my poorly written reply, the last one, above. My English isn't good enough and I'll refrain from these discussions in the future.
I'm sorry to see you edited out your replies above. We are maybe not in agreement about everything but I found them valuable.
All the best!
/Jonas
Nov 14, 2024 at 12:49 AM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.5 #2ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Jonas B wrote:
My English isn't good enough and I'll refrain from these discussions in the future.
/Jonas


Your English is good enough, don't be discouraged from joining discussions.
Nov 14, 2024 at 10:51 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #3ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
evanhanded wrote:
I see some pop in the picture of the girl. But, it most likely is due to the subject separation as opposed to any special characteristics of the lens used. Again, i said "pop" and not "3D pop". If 3D pop was obvious, it would be easy to point it out. Since it's not so obvious to the point of questioning its existence, I have to ask why it's of any interest, much less importance.

I did my own test using one of the favored 3D pop lenses, the 55mm f/1.8 Sony Zeiss vs the kit zoom, 28-70mm Sony. Side by
...Show more →

"lens pop," "3D effect," "rendering," and most of that stuff constitute the emperor's new clothes of photography. One of them anyway.

In any endeavor in which good equipment is important (cars, cameras/lenses, sound equipment, computers, and more) too many people look for "magic" in the supposedly best or perfect gear, not realizing that the marginal differences in performance at the good-to-excellent end of the spectrum have virtually nothing to do with the final quality of the thing.

I know. Disappointing, right?

Here's the good news. Rather than lusting after magical lenses, one can direct that same energy into learning how to see photographically, how to effectively use the tools, and then practice, practice, practice. That WILL make a difference in the quality of your work… and occasionally produce true photographic magic.

Edited on Nov 15, 2024 at 04:17 PM · View previous versions
Nov 14, 2024 at 11:37 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.5 #4ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
What are your favorite lenses ? for sony and adapted?

philip_pj wrote:
It's a necessary development, control of language is a hidden key to understanding. Before we have a description, the concept does not officially exist. The Arri guy did a great service to his readers.

I worked in the wine industry for several years and witnessed numerous blind tastings. They can fool the best judges, even winemakers.

Nov 15, 2024 at 11:56 AM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.5 #5ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
@gdanmitchell:

Are you implying that there’s no 3D pop? When images with 3D pop are presented, I tend to be one of those people who don’t recognize it. However, with some images, the subject sometimes stands out so much that even I can see it. Several explanations that make sense to me have been mentioned here in the discussion: quickly or slowly falling off areas of sharpness, colors, micro-contrast, post-processing, composition, light fall-off... Here’s a picture I took a few years ago with the FE 50mm F1.4 ZA at an aperture of f/1.4. When I look at this image on a 65-inch OLED screen, I feel like the bus is about to jump out of the screen and into my living room. I believe it has to do with the transition of sharpness with the 50/1.4 ZA. I’ve had this lens for many years, and I keep noticing that the sharpness gradually and smoothly falls off. Often, when I view the images, I can’t tell at all where sharpness transitions into blur

FE 50mm F1.4 ZA; f1.4
DSC08214 by stm geist, auf Flickr
Nov 16, 2024 at 03:46 PM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.5 #6ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Here’s another example. The images were taken with the Batis 40/2 lens. I used apertures of f2, f2.2, and f4. At f4, a large portion of the image is sharp, and I find that the effect is most pronounced here. So, it has nothing to do with sharpness. While I was taking the pictures, I noticed during the image review in the viewfinder that the subject looks very three-dimensional. The effect is therefore not related to post-processing. It’s so strong that it’s almost uncomfortable for me to view the images on a large screen. I think "the emperor's new clothes" looks different.

Batis 2/40

f2
DSC06430 by stm geist, auf Flickr

f2.2
DSC06421 by stm geist, auf Flickr

f4
DSC06419 by stm geist, auf Flickr
Nov 16, 2024 at 03:59 PM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.5 #7ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Schwarzlicht wrote:
Here’s another example. The images were taken with the Batis 40/2 lens. I used apertures of f2, f2.2, and f4. At f4, a large portion of the image is sharp, and I find that the effect is most pronounced here. So, it has nothing to do with sharpness. While I was taking the pictures, I noticed during the image review in the viewfinder that the subject looks very three-dimensional. The effect is therefore not related to post-processing. It’s so strong that it’s almost uncomfortable for me to view the images on a large screen. I think "the emperor's new clothes"
...Show more →

The issue with "3d pop" is that it's such an elusive term different people experience it differently. For example, to my eyes the faster shots of the above are more "poppy" than the f/4 one (but then I'm not sure if I'm viewing it correctly at 1600x1067 px).
So, I think that the question whether sharpness across the frame affects "3d pop" in one way or another remains open...
I liked the linked video which differentiates between "3d pop" and "dimensionality", where the latter describes shots where many things are in focus creating this kinda "layered" effect. That's me though ...
Nov 16, 2024 at 05:16 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #8ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Schwarzlicht wrote:
@gdanmitchell@:

Are you implying that there’s no 3D pop? When images with 3D pop are presented, I tend to be one of those people who don’t recognize it. However, with some images, the subject sometimes stands out so much that even I can see it. Several explanations that make sense to me have been mentioned here in the discussion: quickly or slowly falling off areas of sharpness, colors, micro-contrast, post-processing, composition, light fall-off... Here’s a picture I took a few years ago with the FE 50mm F1.4 ZA at an aperture of f/1.4. When I look at this image on a
...Show more →

I am sayuing that the thing (things, actually) that people describe with the unfortunate term "3D pop," are not the result of what lens you use.

Images that have the range of characteristics that get described this way get that from a range of other things: composition, lighting, handling of color, and to a great extent how the images are worked during the post processing phase.

If you want whatever this effect is, don't spend time trying to decide what lens to buy. Spend time on mastering these other things.
Nov 16, 2024 at 08:30 PM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.5 #9ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Schwarzlicht wrote:
Here’s another example. The images were taken with the Batis 40/2 lens. I used apertures of f2, f2.2, and f4. At f4, a large portion of the image is sharp, and I find that the effect is most pronounced here. So, it has nothing to do with sharpness.

Sharpness is only one of the factors, as I hope we can all agree on by now. But in your images a jump in sharpness from the dog to the background only happens for your f4 shot. The faster two shots have too little DOF for your subject. Most of the dog is soft in those two, particularly the outline is soft. Hence instead of a sharp subject in front of a soft background these have a sharp face surrounded by a soft dog. So reducing the visual contrast of the dog to the background, rather than supporting it.
Nov 16, 2024 at 11:55 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.5 #10ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Daran wrote:
Schwarzlicht wroteHere’s another example. The images were taken with the Batis 40/2 lens. I used apertures of f2, f2.2, and f4. At f4, a large portion of the image is sharp, and I find that the effect is most pronounced here. So, it has nothing to do with sharpness.
Sharpness is only one of the factors, as I hope we can all agree on by now. But in your images a jump in sharpness from the dog to the background only happens for your f4 shot. The faster two shots have too little DOF for your subject. Most of the dog is soft in those two, particularly the outline is soft. Hence instead of a sharp subject in front of a soft background these have a sharp face surrounded by a soft dog. So reducing the visual contrast of the dog to the background, rather than supporting it.


All I see is a very patient woman.
@Schwarzlicht: I like the blue bus though. I have never seen the model in real life. What size is it compared to a VW Kleinbus?
Nov 17, 2024 at 05:15 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.5 #11ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Lets analyze that one because it really has the 3d feel.
First , the regular things , it is sharp and contrasty ,the light highlight it more then the background and the angle also helps.
What else ? are there other things that help? the CA maybe ? maybe those reflactions?

Schwarzlicht wrote:
@gdanmitchell@:

Are you implying that there’s no 3D pop? When images with 3D pop are presented, I tend to be one of those people who don’t recognize it. However, with some images, the subject sometimes stands out so much that even I can see it. Several explanations that make sense to me have been mentioned here in the discussion: quickly or slowly falling off areas of sharpness, colors, micro-contrast, post-processing, composition, light fall-off... Here’s a picture I took a few years ago with the FE 50mm F1.4 ZA at an aperture of f/1.4. When I look at this image on a
...Show more →
Nov 17, 2024 at 06:13 AM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.5 #12ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Jonas B wrote:
Daran wrote
Schwarzlicht wroteHere’s another example. The images were taken with the Batis 40/2 lens. I used apertures of f2, f2.2, and f4. At f4, a large portion of the image is sharp, and I find that the effect is most pronounced here. So, it has nothing to do with sharpness.
Sharpness is only one of the factors, as I hope we can all agree on by now. But in your images a jump in sharpness from the dog to the background only happens for your f4 shot. The faster two shots have too little DOF for your subject. Most of the dog is soft in those two, particularly the outline is soft. Hence instead of a sharp subject in front of a soft background these have a sharp face surrounded by a soft dog. So reducing the visual contrast of the dog to the background, rather than supporting it.
All I see is a very patient woman.
@Schwarzlicht@: I like the blue bus though. I have never seen the model in real life. What size is it compared to a VW Kleinbus?




I just asked myself the exact same question yesterday. I noticed that the distant background in the photo with the blue bus is still relatively sharp, even though the picture was taken at f1.4. The photo with the VW bus was taken at 40mm focal length and f2. The distant background appears almost blurrier here. The blue bus isn’t particularly large; I would say it’s about 1.5 times bigger than the VW bus. I think this is because the sharpness of the 50/1.4 ZA lens decreases very slowly and evenly, while with the Batis, the sharpness falls off relatively quickly. In my opinion, this is why some images taken with the 50 Planar have a wow effect on me. I haven’t used the 50/1.4 ZA much in the last two years. A few days ago, I took the lens with me for the first time in a long while during my morning walk with the dog. I only took a few snapshots and thought, “Wow, what a beautiful image impression.” Moving forward, I want to use the Planar more often.
Nov 17, 2024 at 06:37 AM
evanhanded
Offline
Details
p.5 #13ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
The Blue Bus photo does have some "pop" because it's sharp...and the perspective where it fills much of the frame makes it stand out even more. Put it on a big screen and yeah, it will look impressive. That's not what I would call 3D. If you want actual 3D you need special processing to meld the images and 3D glasses to view.

I have a legacy Contax 50mm f/1.4 lens. Sharp in the center, but soft in the corners at f/1.4. Does that lens produce 3D pop compared to a lens that is sharp across the frame at f/1.4? I don't see it. The dog in the images stands out because it's centered in the photo's...more so when the background is soft. That's not 3D.

I will also note that many, if not most, car ads place the vehicle at an angle to give it the depth perception. Converging lines indicate distance. Common place and nothing to do with lens quality.
Nov 17, 2024 at 09:28 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.5 #14ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Let’s look at the reasons that this photograph works for us.

1. The composition puts the central focus on the front of the vehicle (centered on the grill) just right of the center of the frame.

2. The image flows from left to right toward that point for a range of reasons including the direction the vehicle faces.

3. The use of a wide angle lens exaggerates the convergence of perspective lines and makes this central area at the front of the vehicle larger than it actually is, so that central focus takes up a bit more of the image.

4. The colors of the vehicle are quite intense/saturated, in contrast to the less saturated and softer colors in the distance. (I’ll mention an exception or two at the end of this post.)

5. The reflection on the vehicle surface also emphasize its “hardness” by comparison to the background that has no such hard, reflective quality.

6. A subtle effect amplifying the effect of depth is that the front of the vehicle crosses that strong horizontal line on the plane just beneath it, thus “pushing” into the space of the viewer.

7. The contrast (via curves, and other manipulations) has been increased in post, both locally and more broadly, to the point that its brightest tones approach or reach pure white (beyond which the image would blow out) and the darkest tones are at or close to pure black.

8. A large aperture was used to blur the far background elements, which creates an even stronger sense of “subjective sharpness” of the vehicle.

9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)

10. A fair degree of vignetting is used in the image, too — enough that either a strongly vignetting lens was used or, more likely, the vignetting was introduced in post. (Vignetting serves to deemphasize peripheral elements and draw our attention toward the center of the frame.) To see how significant the vignetting adjustment is here, compare how bright the center of the main background building is above the vehicle to how much darker it is at the left edge of the image. (I’ll say that the vignetting was handled well, but it has a very big impact here.)

There are a few compositional weaknesses in the image, though they may have been hard to avoid. For example, the bright scaffolding and sign in the distance seem to emerge from the rack on the roof of the vehicle, drawing our attention away from the vehicle a bit and creating a confusing division between rack and distant sign. The odd little white, pointed kiosk at the far left is a distraction point. (I might have tried to reposition to block it, or else darkened it in post… or even considered eliminating it.) There are some similar issues to the right of the vehicle in the distance. Especially, I would consider desaturating that bright red element, and perhaps lightening the strong vertical of the very dark pole and its base.

Against all of that, just about any lens with this focal length and decent quality would have given us the effect seen here after the image was completed.



Schwarzlicht wrote:
@gdanmitchell@:

Are you implying that there’s no 3D pop? When images with 3D pop are presented, I tend to be one of those people who don’t recognize it. However, with some images, the subject sometimes stands out so much that even I can see it. Several explanations that make sense to me have been mentioned here in the discussion: quickly or slowly falling off areas of sharpness, colors, micro-contrast, post-processing, composition, light fall-off... Here’s a picture I took a few years ago with the FE 50mm F1.4 ZA at an aperture of f/1.4. When I look at this image on a
...Show more →

FE 50mm F1.4 ZA; f1.4
DSC08214 by stm geist, auf Flickr

Nov 17, 2024 at 10:37 AM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.5 #15ED elements , lens design and 3D pop


gdanmitchell wrote:
9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)

In my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.
Nov 17, 2024 at 12:58 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.5 #16ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Nifty Fifty wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)
In my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.


Exactly…if one looks carefully, one can see this. Of course if one is looking to disprove something…their eyes see what they want to disprove.
Nov 17, 2024 at 01:07 PM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.5 #17ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
gdanmitchell wrote:
Let’s look at the reasons that this photograph works for us.

1. The composition puts the central focus on the front of the vehicle (centered on the grill) just right of the center of the frame.

2. The image flows from left to right toward that point for a range of reasons including the direction the vehicle faces.

3. The use of a wide angle lens exaggerates the convergence of perspective lines and makes this central area at the front of the vehicle larger than it actually is, so that central focus takes up a bit more of the image.

4. The colors of
...Show more →
Schwarzlicht wrote@gdanmitchell@@@:

Are you implying that there’s no 3D pop? When images with 3D pop are presented, I tend to be one of those people who don’t recognize it. However, with some images, the subject sometimes stands out so much that even I can see it. Several explanations that make sense to me have been mentioned here in the discussion: quickly or slowly falling off areas of sharpness, colors, micro-contrast, post-processing, composition, light fall-off... Here’s a picture I took a few years ago with the FE 50mm F1.4 ZA at an aperture of f/1.4. When I look at this image on a 65-inch OLED screen, I feel like the bus is about to jump out of the screen and into my living room. I believe it has to do with the transition of sharpness with the 50/1.4 ZA. I’ve had this lens for many years, and I keep noticing that the sharpness gradually and smoothly falls off. Often, when I view the images, I can’t tell at all where sharpness transitions into blur


It is 50mm , not a wide angle.
what would you say about this one last photo)
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1451678/64/

Same photographer ,different lens , also shiny and saturated with reflections - but less dimensional .
Nov 17, 2024 at 01:31 PM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.5 #18ED elements , lens design and 3D pop


Is there actually 3D pop without high sharpness,without high contrast and without high color saturation?
[url=https://flic.kr/p/2quMFYP]
[/url]DSC02217 by Werner Wurst, on Flickr

Edited on Nov 17, 2024 at 02:17 PM · View previous versions
Nov 17, 2024 at 02:01 PM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.5 #19ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
2D? 3D? Pop? Or maybe rock? 😄
DSC01468 (2) (1) (1) (1) by Werner Wurst, on Flickr
Nov 17, 2024 at 02:07 PM
foto16
Offline
[X]
Details
p.5 #20ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
gdanmitchell wrote:
evanhanded wroteI see some pop in the picture of the girl. But, it most likely is due to the subject separation as opposed to any special characteristics of the lens used. Again, i said "pop" and not "3D pop". If 3D pop was obvious, it would be easy to point it out. Since it's not so obvious to the point of questioning its existence, I have to ask why it's of any interest, much less importance.

I did my own test using one of the favored 3D pop lenses, the 55mm f/1.8 Sony Zeiss vs the kit zoom, 28-70mm Sony. Side by side they look the same. Sorry. No pop in the images I took, 3D or otherwise.
"lens pop," "3D effect," "rendering," and most of that stuff constitute the emperor's new clothes of photography. One of them anyway.

In any endeavor in which good equipment is important (cars, cameras/lenses, sound equipment, computers, and more) too many people look for "magic" in the supposedly best or perfect gear, not realizing that the marginal differences in performance at the good-to-excellent end of the spectrum have virtually nothing to do with the final quality of the thing.

I know. Disappointing, right?

Here's the good news. Rather than lusting after magical lenses, one can direct that same energy into learning how to see photographically,
...Show more →

The need for awe and for a mythical power beyond us satisfies the deepest psychological yearning in humans, from the cave dwellers who used charcoal to draw things on the wall of the cave to modern day photo hobbyists who wield precision optics.
Nov 17, 2024 at 02:08 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister