fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024ED elements , lens design and 3D pop

  
 
mudlake
Offline
Details
p.3 #1ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
I’ve used a ton of lenses over several decades. Whether they are top-of-the-line Canon or Sony or legacy or whatever, I’ve always found that a little post processing makes every lens look better. Full stop. Of course, the better my image is to start with (lighting, subject, composition, etc.), the better the final image.

3D pop or not, a good image is a good image. Too much thinking about lens elements is a complete waste of time if you can’t take a good photograph to begin with.
Nov 09, 2024 at 10:50 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #2ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
tsdevine wrote:
So here is a shot from today. Does this have any 3D pop? If it does.....is it the lens, the lighting, the leading lines, the contrast, the color, the focal length, the aperture.....some combination of the above. (That's assuming people even see 3D pop.)

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54128855635_c3aa4ea850_h.jpg

As Dan is sort of implying, if it was solely the lens, you'd see it in every shot from that lens.


FWIW, here is the SooC JPEG.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54128527367_5905e25867_h.jpg

And the processed version I posted before.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54128855635_9368975dc4_h.jpg

For the record, I do think that lenses can have an impact on this, but aren't the sole cause of seeing image that we perceive depth.

Edited on Nov 11, 2024 at 06:45 AM · View previous versions
Nov 10, 2024 at 06:16 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.3 #3ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
I found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.


what is the name of this astrologer?
Nov 10, 2024 at 07:18 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.3 #4ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
tsdevine wrote:
So here is a shot from today. Does this have any 3D pop? If it does.....is it the lens, the lighting, the leading lines, the contrast, the color, the focal length, the aperture.....some combination of the above. (That's assuming people even see 3D pop.)

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54128855635_c3aa4ea850_h.jpg
[...]



To my eyes, no.
Perhaps because of the leading lines? Everything looks very natural and familiar. By that I don't mean to say there must bee some kind of surprise in the image for it to "pop". I also think there may be some pop and I may very well be the only one not seeing it.

It's complicated and to make it even harder I don't think there is any consensus on the definition of "pop" but I'm sure that every time we see pop it is a combination of several factors. The poppiest image I ever seen was taken with a Pentax aps-c camera with the 43mm limited lens. Flowers on a rock against some nature background. Then I learned it had a lot to do with light and colors (and complimentary colors).

Here is an image, a mundane thing, from 2009 and a flower I found in our living room. The Panasonic G1 had arrived, the world´s first "MILC" camera. I was an early adopter. The lack of lenses sparked a hunt for adapters and all sorts of good lenses. I remember trying a Kinoptik APO 25mm and some old Swiss made Switar lenses before settling with a native 20/1.7 lens. I tried at least four different macro lenses. The Zuiko OM 50/2 became a favourite and later I used it a lot together with an Canon 5D classic.

Anyway:
https://photos.imageevent.com/jonas_b/fotoforum2022andfw/452_clivia_webM.jpg
Pop? No, not really. Or perhaps. You decide!

It was fun taking some close-ups with the mirrorless camera as there no longer was any problems with misaligned mirror boxes.

Nov 10, 2024 at 08:25 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.3 #5ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Saul from the bible , pronounce as Shaul in hebrew.


Ripolini wrote:
Garmadon wroteI found this video , he has a method to tell if a lens has 3d pop.
what is the name of this astrologer?

Nov 10, 2024 at 08:27 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #6ED elements , lens design and 3D pop


Jonas B wrote:
tsdevine wroteSo here is a shot from today. Does this have any 3D pop? If it does.....is it the lens, the lighting, the leading lines, the contrast, the color, the focal length, the aperture.....some combination of the above. (That's assuming people even see 3D pop.)

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54128855635_c3aa4ea850_h.jpg
[...]
To my eyes, no.
Perhaps because of the leading lines? Everything looks very natural and familiar. By that I don't mean to say there must bee some kind of surprise in the image for it to "pop". I also think there may be some pop and I may very well be the only one not seeing it.

It's complicated and to make it even harder I don't think there is any consensus on the definition of "pop" but I'm sure that every time we see pop it is a combination of several factors. The poppiest image I ever seen was taken
...Show more →

I wasn’t surprised, given that not everyone even can agree when a photo meets the criteria…

And no, I really don't see what I, in my mind, think of when I think of 3D pop in your shot either. It just looks like a shallow depth of field shot of a flower to me.

Historically in threads like this, I often don't jive with others, hence not surprised. So I'm not saying it doesn't have it, just that I don't see it.

Edited on Nov 10, 2024 at 11:19 AM · View previous versions
Nov 10, 2024 at 08:54 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.3 #7ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
tsdevine wrote:
I wasn’t surprised, given that not everyone even can agree when a photo meets the criteria…

And no, I really don't see what I, in my mind, think of when I think of 3D pop in your shot either. It just looks like a shallow depth of field shot of a flower to me.


Exactly - a flower and shallow DOF. We can agree about that. But, it still is an images people often say "pop". I have other images which I do think has some pop but they aren't commented the same way. They get the more usual "nice image" comments (or no comments at all).

These discussions are sometimes fun,
I don't believe in a formula counting glass elements, Depth in a 2D image has much more to do with light, colors and composition. I can make the world's most esotheric, sharp and expensive lens look pretty dull.
Nov 10, 2024 at 09:21 AM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.3 #8ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Any lens that is well corrected for aberrations can give "3D pop", IMO. It doesn't matter at all how this is done, with a zillion elements, ashperical surfaces or fancy glass types. I haven't found anything that connects great lenses in general either. That is because the same optical results can be reached with completely different designs. And lenses with virtually the same design (double Gauss for example) can perform extremely different too.
Nov 10, 2024 at 09:31 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.3 #9ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
I was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).
Nov 10, 2024 at 09:52 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.3 #10ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Yes , I ment photos with deep focus .
You can see the link I posted earlier to the ZA thread , the forest shot by Jim Harris.

j4nu wrote:
I was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).

Nov 10, 2024 at 10:49 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.3 #11ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Garmadon wrote:
Yes , I ment photos with deep focus .
You can see the link I posted earlier to the ZA thread , the forest shot by Jim Harris.

j4nu wroteI was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).


This one?
https://live.staticflickr.com/4221/34803433471_4c484de88c_o.jpg
Nov 10, 2024 at 11:01 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #12ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
j4nu wrote:
Garmadon wroteYes , I ment photos with deep focus .
You can see the link I posted earlier to the ZA thread , the forest shot by Jim Harris.

j4nu wroteI was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).
This one?
https://live.staticflickr.com/4221/34803433471_4c484de88c_o.jpg


I assume he meant this one...which having us try to figure out which one is a little funny in of itself.

Gunzorro wrote:
I recently bought the Zony 35/2.8 ZA on the B&S here. First time I've had a ZA since the Zony 24-70/4 some time ago. Even these inexpensive lenses have the "Zeiss look".

Quinault Rain Forest, Olympic Nat'l Park, Washington State

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/87/2575787.jpg

a7R2, Zony 35/2.8, LRc


Nov 10, 2024 at 11:17 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.3 #13ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Yes .

tsdevine wrote:
j4nu wrote
Garmadon wroteYes , I ment photos with deep focus .
You can see the link I posted earlier to the ZA thread , the forest shot by Jim Harris.

j4nu wroteI was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).
This one?
https://live.staticflickr.com/4221/34803433471_4c484de88c_o.jpg
I assume he meant this one...which having us try to figure out which one is a little funny in of itself.

Gunzorro wroteI recently bought the Zony 35/2.8 ZA on the B&S here. First time I've had a ZA since the Zony 24-70/4 some time ago. Even these inexpensive lenses have the "Zeiss look".

Quinault Rain Forest, Olympic Nat'l Park, Washington State

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/87/2575787.jpg

a7R2, Zony 35/2.8, LRc

Nov 10, 2024 at 11:34 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #14ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Less, lighting yesterday was really hot, I probably should have tried to tone it down in post.

Here's one where I see depth, maybe not 3D pop. But I'm not saying it's like Jim's shot in terms of having it. This shot is at f/11.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54124648105_a07540d4fd_h.jpg

I'm guessing my string of what my eyes see not jiving with others will continue.

j4nu wrote:
I was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).


Nov 10, 2024 at 11:38 AM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.3 #15ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
I see many good examples in your loxia 25mm album.

tsdevine wrote:
Less, lighting yesterday was really hot, I probably should have tried to tone it down in post.

Here's one where I see depth, maybe not 3D pop. But I'm not saying it's like Jim's shot in terms of having it. This shot is at f/11.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54124648105_a07540d4fd_h.jpg

I'm guessing my string of what my eyes see not jiving with others will continue.

j4nu wroteI was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).

Nov 10, 2024 at 12:21 PM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.3 #16ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
tsdevine wrote:
j4nu wrote
Garmadon wroteYes , I ment photos with deep focus .
You can see the link I posted earlier to the ZA thread , the forest shot by Jim Harris.

j4nu wroteI was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).
This one?
https://live.staticflickr.com/4221/34803433471_4c484de88c_o.jpg
I assume he meant this one...which having us try to figure out which one is a little funny in of itself.

Gunzorro wroteI recently bought the Zony 35/2.8 ZA on the B&S here. First time I've had a ZA since the Zony 24-70/4 some time ago. Even these inexpensive lenses have the "Zeiss look".

Quinault Rain Forest, Olympic Nat'l Park, Washington State

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/87/2575787.jpg

a7R2, Zony 35/2.8, LRc


Thanks and yes - that is actually quite funny.
After posting the link to the first image, I had second thoughs that it was maybe about the second one:
https://live.staticflickr.com/932/43814762801_82e1cf80fe_o.jpg
but it turns out it's a different Jim .

Getting back to the point, I can definitely see depth in those images but I don't think it's what I would label obvious "3d pop".
But this did open my eyes a bit, as I can see now that skilful use of light and shadows can replace the blur to some extent .
Nov 10, 2024 at 12:23 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.3 #17ED elements , lens design and 3D pop


Garmadon wrote:
I see many good examples in your loxia 25mm album.

tsdevine wroteLess, lighting yesterday was really hot, I probably should have tried to tone it down in post.

Here's one where I see depth, maybe not 3D pop. But I'm not saying it's like Jim's shot in terms of having it. This shot is at f/11.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54124648105_a07540d4fd_h.jpg

I'm guessing my string of what my eyes see not jiving with others will continue.

j4nu wroteI was under the impression that you need some degree of blur to have any "3d pop" or whatever you call it...
Is there really any picture where everything is tack sharp and it exhibits this effect?

I think in the bonsai shot, the light is a bit too harsh, as something milder is needed to show the transition (at least to my eyes ).


I love my Loxia 25.
Nov 10, 2024 at 12:25 PM
darrellc
Offline
Details
p.3 #18ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
?20240616121703">
Flucht vor der Kritik, Pere Borrell del Caso - 9626
Pere Borrell del Caso
, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

———-

I wonder what lens was used to take a picture of that painting?

I’m sure we could learn much from painters on how to make our photos appear 3d. Some techniques might have a correlation with lens attributes but I doubt that would contribute much in most pics to the illusion of depth/pop

Totally subjective, but I do feel like some of my lenses had more 3d-ism. Jonasb’s Zuiko OM 50/2 macro, Loxia 35 stopped down to around f3.2 or so, CY 35-70 even stopped down - these lenses I’ve owned come to mind as the pics kind of jump in or out / seem 3d when flipping thru my pics. But sometimes I’ll get that effect from a lens like the 24-105/4.

Edited on Nov 10, 2024 at 01:11 PM · View previous versions
Nov 10, 2024 at 01:00 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.3 #19ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
j4nu wrote:
[...]
Getting back to the point, I can definitely see depth in those images but I don't think it's what I would label obvious "3d pop".
But this did open my eyes a bit, as I can see now that skilful use of light and shadows can replace the blur to some extent .


At page 1 of this thread, post 20, tschopp, linked to a Youtube video by somebody calling himself Camera Mystique.
I had a look at it and right in the beginning he defines "pop" and also shows a couple of examples. I/you/anyone may agree or not with what Camera Mystique says. It is however clear that there are different thoughts about what pop is out there.
Nov 10, 2024 at 01:07 PM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.3 #20ED elements , lens design and 3D pop
Jonas B wrote:
j4nu wrote[...]
Getting back to the point, I can definitely see depth in those images but I don't think it's what I would label obvious "3d pop".
But this did open my eyes a bit, as I can see now that skilful use of light and shadows can replace the blur to some extent .
At page 1 of this thread, post 20, tschopp, linked to a Youtube video by somebody calling himself Camera Mystique.
I had a look at it and right in the beginning he defines "pop" and also shows a couple of examples. I/you/anyone may agree or not with what Camera Mystique says. It is however clear that there are different thoughts about what pop is out there.


Yes, these examples are something I visualize when I hear "3d pop".
I guess the other category is "dimensionality", which matches some of the photos posted here in my eyes.
Your photo fits into the former IMHO, though I believe there's a thin line between the amount of transition/blur that makes or brakes such shots in terms of "3d pop" (i.e. too abrubt / no transition makes the effect lesser, not stronger) ...
Nov 10, 2024 at 01:45 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister