fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications

  
 
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #1Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
docusync wrote:
ArizonaImage wrote
lsquare wrote
Jman13 wrote
lighthound wrote
Hairy Heron wroteWell we don't actually know how inflation impacted Canon here. But the R5 has a a couple of worthy competitors and they are both about $1K less. I'm locked into Canon at this point and have a R5II on order, but whether it's $1K better than it's competition, we'll see. (Not being negative -- excited to get my hands on the R5 II, just being honest -- it's no bargain).
How is this not competitive?
A1 $6500
Z9 $5500
R5II $4300
The R5II is not competing with the Z9. It's competing with the Z8 (which also just happens to be 99% of a Z9 in a smaller body). And the Z8 retails for $3,500 right now (though may go back up to $3,999 eventually, though Nikon's 'sales' tend to be for most of the year.)

The R5 II does have some advantages over the Z8 (the AF is probably a little better, but the Z8's is outstanding), 30fps RAW vs 20fps RAW, for those who need that extra burst rate. Z8, however, has a much faster reading sensor, so at those fast burst rates, the Z8 will have a rolling shutter advantage that may be minimal (birds in flight) or fairly significant (fast ball sports).
How much faster is the Z8's sensor? Isn't the R5 II superior for video, at least on paper?
Superior in which way? Both shoot 8K/60 RAW, oversampled 4K, etc but the Z8 has ProRES which may appeal to some. I do like Canon's LOG better. Nikon needs an NLOG 2.
It looks like both raw and ProRes are 12bit on the Z8/9. The original R5 was also 12 bit I believe. 14 bit is basically a normal raw photo. If that's true - we're getting to the point when still grabs have the same quality as regular raw photos.


Not exactly true. Your shutter speed/angle in video will likely be quite different than what it would be for a still photo in the same conditions, meaning that if there's any panning or subject movement a grab wouldn't do the same trick as a dedicated still.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:14 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
lsquare wrote:
I also wonder how the R5 II's slower sensor impact me as a travel and portrait shooter in practice


Ha ha your portraits of running fans and helicopters will be likely ruined!
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:15 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.8 #3Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
goalerjones wrote:
Earlier quoteGame changing feature. Every time I use a Nikon or Canon I miss it a lot.
Lighting rules are still the same regardless of the zebra feature. I shoot in brightly backlit, and underexposed shadows during horse races as the day comes to an end. For me, non-video zebras aren't helpful, I know I will need to expose for shadows regardless of the blown out backgrounds for proper exposure.



Well with ISO-invariant sensors there is not much benefit of blowing those highlights as the noise seen in the shadow areas once adjusted for brightness will be the same regardless of the ISO selected. Although, some cameras may AF better if the subject is properly exposed at the time of shooting.

I have a custom key set to toggle on/off the zebras and I do toggle them off occasionally if I'm shooting against a boring white sky and don't care if it blows out as the zebras are distracting. But otherwise I find them to be a killer feature in nailing exposure every time.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:17 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
RoamingScott wrote:
docusync wrote
ArizonaImage wrote
lsquare wrote
Jman13 wrote
lighthound wroteHow is this not competitive?
A1 $6500
Z9 $5500
R5II $4300
The R5II is not competing with the Z9. It's competing with the Z8 (which also just happens to be 99% of a Z9 in a smaller body). And the Z8 retails for $3,500 right now (though may go back up to $3,999 eventually, though Nikon's 'sales' tend to be for most of the year.)

The R5 II does have some advantages over the Z8 (the AF is probably a little better, but the Z8's is outstanding), 30fps RAW vs 20fps RAW, for those who need that extra burst rate. Z8, however, has a much faster reading sensor, so at those fast burst rates, the Z8 will have a rolling shutter advantage that may be minimal (birds in flight) or fairly significant (fast ball sports).
How much faster is the Z8's sensor? Isn't the R5 II superior for video, at least on paper?
Superior in which way? Both shoot 8K/60 RAW, oversampled 4K, etc but the Z8 has ProRES which may appeal to some. I do like Canon's LOG better. Nikon needs an NLOG 2.
It looks like both raw and ProRes are 12bit on the Z8/9. The original R5 was also 12 bit I believe. 14 bit is basically a normal raw photo. If that's true - we're getting to the point when still grabs have the same quality as regular raw photos.
Not exactly true. Your shutter speed/angle in video will likely be quite different than what it would be for a still photo in the same conditions, meaning that if there's any panning or subject movement a grab wouldn't do the same trick as a dedicated still.


Correct, but you can get pretty much any shutter speed (below 1/8000) in video too, so it would be the same. I read somewhere that the R7 pre-shooting blob is actually a raw video clip.
The only concern is AF motor speed, which is slower in video (to create a smooth transition).
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:18 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Spot on...don't see why people think stills from video is a useful thing. Settings don't mesh.

Edited on Jul 17, 2024 at 03:19 PM · View previous versions
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:19 PM
lsquare
Offline
Details
p.8 #6Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications


arbitrage wrote:
lsquare wrote
arbitrage wrote
lsquare wrote
molson wroteWins:

- stacked sensor
- useable electronic shutter
- RAW pre-capture
- improved AF (to be confirmed?)
- on/off switch moved to right side of camera
- full-size HDMI port

Fails:

- no dual cards slots - still two mis-matched slots
- no tilting LCD - same old selfie screen
- requires new batteries
- no exposure zebras in stills mode (to be confirmed?)
Which other camera supports zebras for stills?
All Sony cameras for a good while now. Game changing feature. Every time I use a Nikon or Canon I miss it a lot.
A good while as in since when? Does the A6700 or even the RX100 VII support zebras in stills?
I'm not sure when they started. I had it in my 2017 A9 and ever since in every Sony I've owned like A9II, A7RIV, A7RV, A1, A9III.

I did a quick google back to the original A7/A7R and they had it so I think it has been there since the beginning of FF E-mount.
I also did a quick search of the A6700 help guide and it has them also.
And yes the RX100VII has it.
I'm pretty sure every Sony MILC has had it.


Do you also have the RX100 VII?

Don't get me wrong, it would be great if Canon took all this time and made the R5 II definitively better than any other camera out there. It seems like the Panasonic GH7 may be slightly better for video if you don't care about 8K. I suspect whenever Sony releases the A1 II, it'll be the greatest thing to come out since sliced bread.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:19 PM
HicHic
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Does the R5ii have the dreaded low pass filter like the first R5? That was the only thing holding me back from getting it.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:19 PM
PixiPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #8Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
lsquare wrote:
ArizonaImage wrote
lsquare wrote
Jman13 wrote
lighthound wrote
Hairy Heron wroteWell we don't actually know how inflation impacted Canon here. But the R5 has a a couple of worthy competitors and they are both about $1K less. I'm locked into Canon at this point and have a R5II on order, but whether it's $1K better than it's competition, we'll see. (Not being negative -- excited to get my hands on the R5 II, just being honest -- it's no bargain).
How is this not competitive?
A1 $6500
Z9 $5500
R5II $4300
The R5II is not competing with the Z9. It's competing with the Z8 (which also just happens to be 99% of a Z9 in a smaller body). And the Z8 retails for $3,500 right now (though may go back up to $3,999 eventually, though Nikon's 'sales' tend to be for most of the year.)

The R5 II does have some advantages over the Z8 (the AF is probably a little better, but the Z8's is outstanding), 30fps RAW vs 20fps RAW, for those who need that extra burst rate. Z8, however, has a much faster reading sensor, so at those fast burst rates, the Z8 will have a rolling shutter advantage that may be minimal (birds in flight) or fairly significant (fast ball sports).
How much faster is the Z8's sensor? Isn't the R5 II superior for video, at least on paper?
Superior in which way? Both shoot 8K/60 RAW, oversampled 4K, etc but the Z8 has ProRES which may appeal to some. I do like Canon's LOG better. Nikon needs an NLOG 2.
The Z8 can't shoot 8K in ProRes. Does it support Zebras?

Supposedly, C-LOG2 is very good and can capture a good deal of DR. The Z8 can only shoot at best 12-bit videos.


It's not that the Z8 "cant" it's that I don't think ProRES supports 8K RAW. I don't know of a camera in this class that shoots 14-bit RAW internally, perhaps you can fill me in. Not even a FX6 does that internally. The best any competitive mirrorless Canon or Sony thus far shot was 12-bit, and not internal in most instances, not the A7S III, FX3, etc....

Edited on Jul 17, 2024 at 03:51 PM · View previous versions
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:19 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.8 #9Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
lsquare wrote:
arbitrage wrote
lsquare wrote
arbitrage wrote
lsquare wrote
molson wroteWins:

- stacked sensor
- useable electronic shutter
- RAW pre-capture
- improved AF (to be confirmed?)
- on/off switch moved to right side of camera
- full-size HDMI port

Fails:

- no dual cards slots - still two mis-matched slots
- no tilting LCD - same old selfie screen
- requires new batteries
- no exposure zebras in stills mode (to be confirmed?)
Which other camera supports zebras for stills?
All Sony cameras for a good while now. Game changing feature. Every time I use a Nikon or Canon I miss it a lot.
A good while as in since when? Does the A6700 or even the RX100 VII support zebras in stills?
I'm not sure when they started. I had it in my 2017 A9 and ever since in every Sony I've owned like A9II, A7RIV, A7RV, A1, A9III.

I did a quick google back to the original A7/A7R and they had it so I think it has been there since the beginning of FF E-mount.
I also did a quick search of the A6700 help guide and it has them also.
And yes the RX100VII has it.
I'm pretty sure every Sony MILC has had it.
Do you also have the RX100 VII?

Don't get me wrong, it would be great if Canon took all this time and made the R5 II definitively better than any other camera out there. It seems like the Panasonic GH7 may be slightly better for video if you don't care about 8K. I suspect whenever Sony releases the A1 II, it'll be the greatest thing to come out since sliced bread.


No I don't have an RX100. I just did a Quick Look into the online help guide to check if it had zebra feature.

Yes the A1II will likely be a great camera. Probably out Feb 2025.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:20 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
RoamingScott wrote:
docusync wrote
ArizonaImage wrote
lsquare wrote
Jman13 wrote
lighthound wroteHow is this not competitive?
A1 $6500
Z9 $5500
R5II $4300
The R5II is not competing with the Z9. It's competing with the Z8 (which also just happens to be 99% of a Z9 in a smaller body). And the Z8 retails for $3,500 right now (though may go back up to $3,999 eventually, though Nikon's 'sales' tend to be for most of the year.)

The R5 II does have some advantages over the Z8 (the AF is probably a little better, but the Z8's is outstanding), 30fps RAW vs 20fps RAW, for those who need that extra burst rate. Z8, however, has a much faster reading sensor, so at those fast burst rates, the Z8 will have a rolling shutter advantage that may be minimal (birds in flight) or fairly significant (fast ball sports).
How much faster is the Z8's sensor? Isn't the R5 II superior for video, at least on paper?
Superior in which way? Both shoot 8K/60 RAW, oversampled 4K, etc but the Z8 has ProRES which may appeal to some. I do like Canon's LOG better. Nikon needs an NLOG 2.
It looks like both raw and ProRes are 12bit on the Z8/9. The original R5 was also 12 bit I believe. 14 bit is basically a normal raw photo. If that's true - we're getting to the point when still grabs have the same quality as regular raw photos.
Not exactly true. Your shutter speed/angle in video will likely be quite different than what it would be for a still photo in the same conditions, meaning that if there's any panning or subject movement a grab wouldn't do the same trick as a dedicated still.


If someone is shooting video for the intent purpose of extracting stills then they would use the same shutter speed for video as they would for stills.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:27 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
HicHic wrote:
Does the R5ii have the dreaded low pass filter like the first R5? That was the only thing holding me back from getting it.


https://www.canon-europe.com/cameras/eos-r5-mark-ii/specifications/
"Low-Pass Filter - Built-in/Fixed"

I was also hoping Canon will get rid of it but no

I noticed the LR AI denoise feature restores some pixel-level "crispness" though...
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:30 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #12Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
snapsy wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
docusync wrote
ArizonaImage wrote
lsquare wrote
Jman13 wroteThe R5II is not competing with the Z9. It's competing with the Z8 (which also just happens to be 99% of a Z9 in a smaller body). And the Z8 retails for $3,500 right now (though may go back up to $3,999 eventually, though Nikon's 'sales' tend to be for most of the year.)

The R5 II does have some advantages over the Z8 (the AF is probably a little better, but the Z8's is outstanding), 30fps RAW vs 20fps RAW, for those who need that extra burst rate. Z8, however, has a much faster reading sensor, so at those fast burst rates, the Z8 will have a rolling shutter advantage that may be minimal (birds in flight) or fairly significant (fast ball sports).
How much faster is the Z8's sensor? Isn't the R5 II superior for video, at least on paper?
Superior in which way? Both shoot 8K/60 RAW, oversampled 4K, etc but the Z8 has ProRES which may appeal to some. I do like Canon's LOG better. Nikon needs an NLOG 2.
It looks like both raw and ProRes are 12bit on the Z8/9. The original R5 was also 12 bit I believe. 14 bit is basically a normal raw photo. If that's true - we're getting to the point when still grabs have the same quality as regular raw photos.
Not exactly true. Your shutter speed/angle in video will likely be quite different than what it would be for a still photo in the same conditions, meaning that if there's any panning or subject movement a grab wouldn't do the same trick as a dedicated still.
If someone is shooting video for the intent purpose of extracting stills then they would use the same shutter speed for video as they would for stills.


You don't seem to have a solid grasp of how non-bench, real world shooting works
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:30 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
Extracting stills from video works if the video settings are set to still shutter speed but video codecs manage to reduce bandwidth by doing time compression, which means that the image quality is compromised. There is no magic.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:34 PM
HicHic
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
docusync wrote:
HicHic wroteDoes the R5ii have the dreaded low pass filter like the first R5? That was the only thing holding me back from getting it.
https://www.canon-europe.com/cameras/eos-r5-mark-ii/specifications/
"Low-Pass Filter - Built-in/Fixed"

I was also hoping Canon will get rid of it but no

I noticed the LR AI denoise feature restores some pixel-level "crispness" though...


What a shame. Was hoping this would be the one to finally replace my 5DSR. Z8 intrigues me, but the dynamic range is quite bad for a modern FF sensor. Can't deal with Sony ergonomics. Guess I'll stick with my OM-1 until we get a good FF offering. The R5ii was so close.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:37 PM
wind30
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
lighthound wrote:
Hairy Heron wrote
lighthound wroteI'd say Canon did great considering inflation and adding a stacked sensor with all the AF goodies.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53863095734_9dd584bb55_z.jpg
Well we don't actually know how inflation impacted Canon here. But the R5 has a a couple of worthy competitors and they are both about $1K less. I'm locked into Canon at this point and have a R5II on order, but whether it's $1K better than it's competition, we'll see. (Not being negative -- excited to get my hands on the R5 II, just being honest -- it's no bargain).
How is this not competitive?
A1 $6500
Z9 $5500
R5II $4300


Errr isn’t r5ii competing with z8 rather than z9. Look at the body shape. For Sony, i think Sony is stupid with the a9iii and did not have something to compete in this space
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:40 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
arbitrage wrote:
molson wrote
docusync wroteThere is a word "intro" between the "$4299" and "price". Wondering if it makes any difference? Of course Nikon had to drop the price so the camera would remain competitive.
Nikon must have gotten wind of the R5 II into price, because they raised the price of the Z8 by about $1000 here in Canada last week.
They did? Shows $5399 at CC. Wasn't that always the price? Was it way lower recently?


It was around $4600 until last week - or $4200 if you did the trade-in promo.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:43 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
JaimitoFrog wrote:
Z8 is made in Thailand. Canon R5, R1 are made in Japan. Labor cost is always higher in Japan.



Build quality seems to be better from Japan, too. That's one of the first things I noticed when I traded my Z8 for an R5.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:48 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.8 #18Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
RoamingScott wrote:
snapsy wrote
RoamingScott wrote
docusync wrote
ArizonaImage wrote
lsquare wroteHow much faster is the Z8's sensor? Isn't the R5 II superior for video, at least on paper?
Superior in which way? Both shoot 8K/60 RAW, oversampled 4K, etc but the Z8 has ProRES which may appeal to some. I do like Canon's LOG better. Nikon needs an NLOG 2.
It looks like both raw and ProRes are 12bit on the Z8/9. The original R5 was also 12 bit I believe. 14 bit is basically a normal raw photo. If that's true - we're getting to the point when still grabs have the same quality as regular raw photos.
Not exactly true. Your shutter speed/angle in video will likely be quite different than what it would be for a still photo in the same conditions, meaning that if there's any panning or subject movement a grab wouldn't do the same trick as a dedicated still.
If someone is shooting video for the intent purpose of extracting stills then they would use the same shutter speed for video as they would for stills.
You don't seem to have a solid grasp of how non-bench, real world shooting works


If someone is shooting video for the expressed purpose of extracting stills then why would using a video shutter speed equivalent to stills have any relation or dependency on my grasp of non-bench, real-world shooting?
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:52 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
HicHic wrote:
docusync wrote
HicHic wroteDoes the R5ii have the dreaded low pass filter like the first R5? That was the only thing holding me back from getting it.
https://www.canon-europe.com/cameras/eos-r5-mark-ii/specifications/
"Low-Pass Filter - Built-in/Fixed"

I was also hoping Canon will get rid of it but no

I noticed the LR AI denoise feature restores some pixel-level "crispness" though...
What a shame. Was hoping this would be the one to finally replace my 5DSR. Z8 intrigues me, but the dynamic range is quite bad for a modern FF sensor. Can't deal with Sony ergonomics. Guess I'll stick with my OM-1 until we get a good FF offering. The R5ii was so close.


You are aware that the DR numbers of all recent Canon bodies is not representative of the actual sensor DR, right? Canon applies noise reduction to the shadows of their raw files to boast artificially the DR number while depriving the photographer from optimizing image quality by using the best NR available software instead of having to trust in camera NR.

The actual DR of the Z8 is most probably higher than anything Canon has on offer. We just don’t know by how much. Besides the gap btwn Z8 and Z7II is around 1/3 of a stop, completely irrelevant to actual photography.

Edited on Jul 17, 2024 at 03:58 PM · View previous versions
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:53 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Official Canon EOS R5 Mark II Images & Specifications
lsquare wrote:
I like that it's lighter than the Z8! As long as the DR is competitive with the Z8 at base ISO, then I'll be satisfied.



The R5 has about a 1-stop advantage over the Z8 at base ISO; hopefully going to the stacked sensor won't decrease the DR like it did on the Nikon cameras.
Jul 17, 2024 at 03:53 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister