I mean, the R5 II almost seems like an afterthought. 45mp stacked sensor, faster than the R3, and it seems like an afterthought and you can have it by July.
Definitely curious the R1, given they seem to have put a lot more effort into it. Definitely skeptical it's 30mp, for one thing.
middlerockies wrote: Sy Sez wroteThere’s a reason that the camera bodies behind the “big white” lenses, at pro games were 20.1 MP 1DX-3’s as opposed to 30.4 MP 5D-4's, or 24 MP R-3’s rather than 45MP R-5's.stanj wroteYes. Because there was no 45MP version of a rugged, fast body.Sy Sez wrotePrecisely, as they lacked the ability to produce a "45MP version of a rugged, fast body" to their ultimate satisfaction, and apparently, that's still the case.This little exchange right here gets at the essence of this discussion for me. In reality, Canon is just not there yet with their sensor tech. They will use a bunch of marketing and dance around this issue, and Canon users will echo that for them, but at the end of the day they're just not there yet. Sony is, that's their problem. And Nikon is largely because of the Sony sensor tech. It seems to me that Canon was delaying this thing for so long because they were trying to get there, but couldn't. That's just my personal opinion.
I would agree. I made the comment before that Canon isn't able to (hopefully that will change) deliver a high mp + fast readout speed sensor.
Watching football (American,) it mostly looks like DSLR's. Nikon's pro sports DSLR isn't high mp, either, D series..
The pro photographer photographing his son playing in March Madness, looked like he used a decade old D4
If it says Canon on it, it gets complaints on FM. Either people complain about the teles, even though Canon has more than other brands, or something. Never ends
We know the Adorama "specs" were just a word for word, copy and paste from the January Weibo leak that CR reported on.
So we know that Adorama doesn't have any actual information from Canon.
What we DON'T KNOW is if that January Weibo leak is actually legit. So even though the Adorama specs were BS, the specs could still be true.
middlerockies wrote:
Not sure why you're taking it so personally, AmbientMike. Just imagine not having any loyalty to any of these brands and trying to see it from that POV. You don't have to defend any of these companies and have no reason to feel insecure or defensive of your camera choices. It's just stating the obvious—if Canon could do it, they would make the R3 the high-end sports camera, which is what they did, and they'd make the R1 their high-end "jack-of-all-trades" camera like their competitors have evolved to. It would be 50MP and fast as lightning, and they would brag thoroughly about it like they did when they were first to 8K.
Or, if you prefer to keep the history of the R1 as the sports camera, then they could have made the R3 the "jack-of-all-trades" with 50MP and fast as lightning to compete with the A1 and Z9.
The simple truth is that the R1 was delayed for eons and there are many reports of them going back to the drawing board, and now they're coming out with an R1 that looks incredibly similar to the R3, with a small bump in MP to 30. Be honest, if you could design the system from scratch, you would not put your two top of the line cameras as close to each other like that—they're basically identical. They're just objectively not able to compete right now on this one....Show more →
A better question might be: why am I expected to be brand neutral and allow fanboys of other brands to be really negative on Canon? On the Canon board, even!
In the past it's gotten so bad that you start to wonder if you can even get any good photos (of course, you definitely could,) so I quit tolerating this garbage. Honestly the critiques often tend to be pretty stupid, and need to be countered.
The funny thing is that we've had a lot of rumors in the last years with nothing relevant and now we only have another rumor, but this time it's official
AmbientMike wrote:
A better question might be: why am I expected to be brand neutral and allow fanboys of other brands to be really negative on Canon? On the Canon board, even!
These threads always bring out the most insecure fanboys, because it makes them worry the the got the wrong brand name tattooed on their butts.
RobAmy wrote:
Personally the R3 is awesome for my needs, no issue with 24MP over the years I have used them. So to improve on it plus a bump to 30MP I am good with. I never looked back selling my R5's.
Same here Rob. My only problem is I didn't sell R5 "on time" and now the value of R5 on used market has dropped significantly...
arbitrage wrote:
We know the Adorama "specs" were just a word for word, copy and paste from the January Weibo leak that CR reported on.
So we know that Adorama doesn't have any actual information from Canon.
What we DON'T KNOW is if that January Weibo leak is actually legit. So even though the Adorama specs were BS, the specs could still be true.
Yeah, 30Mpx actually sounds in line with what I would expect from Canon in the next 1-series body. I personally believe Canon will keep this camera laser-focused on the highest possible speed for sports and action. So I am inclined to believe this "BS".
I think people who want the "all-rounder" with good resolution and performance are going to want to look at the R5 Mark II, which I suspect will be competitive with other "flagship" models regardless of whether it has a "1" in its name.
big country wrote:
Here what I’ve been told by my reliable sources:
R1 was originally slated to be announced w/specs late first quarter 2024.
The specs leaked and canon got a lot of blow back from everyone over a 30
Megapixel sensor. Canons original feeling was you don’t need all those megapixels.
However need vs want is a delicate line and the market is demanding high resolution like a1, z9.
After much blowback from everyone including their explorers of light, canon went back to the drawing
Board and started reworking and revamping everything, especially the sensor.
This is why it kept getting pushed back. The next announcement was going to q2, with working cameras in pros hands in time for the Olympics, and now the target is by the end of the year.
No. They couldn't do a major shift like change the sensor resolution and have cameras, even beta cameras, out this year. Your reliable sources are making things up.
robert_in_ca wrote: MintMar wroteSy Sez wrotemiddlerockies wrote“Sports sports sports.” I was under the impression they were going to go with a jack-of-all-trades based on 1) the R3 was the pro sports camera this time around, and 2) both Sony and Nikon have a jack-of-all-trades, high MP, high speed camera as their flagship. So Canon will have two sports cameras as their flagships and nothing to compete with the A1 and Z9 on MP and speed?Canon's "1" series has always been their professional sports-oriented body where high MP is not a major priority.Don't forget for quite some time there was the 1Ds hi-rez camera accompanyning the 1D low-rez sport camera...True but that was over 20 years ago and Canon's moved away from doing that sort of product model releasing. Clearly anything is possible, but I seriously doubt Canon will offer variants of the R1.
The 1Ds mark III was announced in 2007, and shipped in the US in 2008. That's not OVER 20 years ago. They didn't drop the split lines until the 1DX in 2011.
AmbientMike wrote:
Watching football (American,) it mostly looks like DSLR's. Nikon's pro sports DSLR isn't high mp, either, D series..
The pro photographer photographing his son playing in March Madness, looked like he used a decade old D4
If it says Canon on it, it gets complaints on FM. Either people complain about the teles, even though Canon has more than other brands, or something. Never ends
I shoot pro sports and a lot of friends who are also Pro sports shooters shooting with Nikon no longer shoot the D series..
Have no idea where you got that info. All the ones I know are shooting Z9s including myself.
Creative Edge wrote: AmbientMike wroteWatching football (American,) it mostly looks like DSLR's. Nikon's pro sports DSLR isn't high mp, either, D series..
The pro photographer photographing his son playing in March Madness, looked like he used a decade old D4
If it says Canon on it, it gets complaints on FM. Either people complain about the teles, even though Canon has more than other brands, or something. Never endsI shoot pro sports and a lot of friends who are also Pro sports shooters shooting with Nikon no longer shoot the D series..
Have no idea where you got that info. All the ones I know are shooting Z9s including myself.
I agree, that argument about Canon dominating everything is getting old and worn out.
gkinard1952 wrote: Creative Edge wroteAmbientMike wroteWatching football (American,) it mostly looks like DSLR's. Nikon's pro sports DSLR isn't high mp, either, D series..
The pro photographer photographing his son playing in March Madness, looked like he used a decade old D4
If it says Canon on it, it gets complaints on FM. Either people complain about the teles, even though Canon has more than other brands, or something. Never endsI shoot pro sports and a lot of friends who are also Pro sports shooters shooting with Nikon no longer shoot the D series..
Have no idea where you got that info. All the ones I know are shooting Z9s including myself.I agree, that argument about Canon dominating everything is getting old and worn out.
Very true. The only thing Canon dominates nowadays is the global camera market, selling more than Nikon and Sony combined.
Market share of leading digital camera manufacturers worldwide as of December 2023, by sales volume
That market share is all cameras, and Canon still sells quite a lot of DSLRs, but those are going to taper off rather dramatically. In the mirrorless world, things are nowhere near dominant for Canon. And the mirrorless world is where things are all going. No one except Pentax is making new DSLRs, so this early fight is important.
Sony saw the writing on the wall and built a huge lead in FF mirrorless, and Canon has done well so far overall, but that is declining as Nikon has been releasing huge hits and Sony continues to roll out amazing lenses and cameras. Forecasting 10 years in the future is difficult in this space, and a lot of the decisions made over the next couple of years are going to have a big impact on future market share.
Creative Edge wrote: AmbientMike wroteWatching football (American,) it mostly looks like DSLR's. Nikon's pro sports DSLR isn't high mp, either, D series..
The pro photographer photographing his son playing in March Madness, looked like he used a decade old D4
If it says Canon on it, it gets complaints on FM. Either people complain about the teles, even though Canon has more than other brands, or something. Never endsI shoot pro sports and a lot of friends who are also Pro sports shooters shooting with Nikon no longer shoot the D series..
Have no idea where you got that info. All the ones I know are shooting Z9s including myself.
Like I said, I watch the games, being a photographer I notice the photographers. Not sure how much eye af helps in football since the eye is buried in the helmet
Jman13 wrote:
That market share is all cameras, and Canon still sells quite a lot of DSLRs, but those are going to taper off rather dramatically. In the mirrorless world, things are nowhere near dominant for Canon. And the mirrorless world is where things are all going. No one except Pentax is making new DSLRs, so this early fight is important.
Sony saw the writing on the wall and built a huge lead in FF mirrorless, and Canon has done well so far overall, but that is declining as Nikon has been releasing huge hits and Sony continues to roll out amazing lenses and cameras. Forecasting 10 years in the future is difficult in this space, and a lot of the decisions made over the next couple of years are going to have a big impact on future market share.
The small number of vocal Nikon and Sony supporters on these internet forums obviously don't make up a very big portion of the overall camera market - if they did, Nikon's market share wouldn't still be declining, and Canon's market share would surely be almost non-existent by now.