fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Canon r1 official announcement.

  
 
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.17 #1Canon r1 official announcement.
Methinks he was talking about what he was talking about. I think he was saying with DPRAW it's twice the information, with QPRAW he's extrapolating that it would be 4 times the information...and 24 & 4 is 96. And he literally said that no one uses DPRAW, which you agree with.

I don't think he was talking about DPAF vs QPAF. He was joking that they'd call a 24 MP camera a 96 MP camera by implementing QPRAW. He was specifically honing in on the whole 24 MP vs 30 MP vs 45 MP vs ?? MP discussion. Not advancements in AF.

molson wrote:
arbitrage wroteThis will be a 96MP camera....

QPRAW files will be 96MP.....and no one will use them just like nobody uses the DPRAW files.

You heard it here first
Methinks you're confusing DPRAW (which no one uses) with DPAF (which everyone loves and uses).

If the new camera has QPAF, it will give it an even bigger lead over Nikon cameras, which still struggle at times with anything not having vertical lines.


May 30, 2024 at 03:34 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.17 #2Canon r1 official announcement.
tsdevine wrote:
I don't think he was talking about DPAF vs QPAF. He was joking that they'd call a 24 MP camera a 96 MP camera by implementing QPRAW. He was specifically honing in on the whole 24 MP vs 30 MP vs 45 MP vs ?? MP discussion. Not advancements in AF.



Thanks for the clarification, Geoff.
May 30, 2024 at 03:46 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.17 #3Canon r1 official announcement.
what happened to the last two posts?
May 30, 2024 at 08:27 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.17 #4Canon r1 official announcement.
It looks like the R1 is already out. Gordon Laing has reviewed it a month ago: https://bit.ly/3KopHXH
The biggest surprise - it got a SONY sensor!
May 30, 2024 at 09:14 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.17 #5Canon r1 official announcement.
rscheffler wrote:
what happened to the last two posts?


What did we miss?
May 30, 2024 at 09:32 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #6Canon r1 official announcement.


docusync wrote:
It looks like the R1 is already out. Gordon Laing has reviewed it a month ago: https://bit.ly/3KopHXH
The biggest surprise - it got a SONY sensor!

Can't wait to see the R1 being praised in the Sony forum

The naming confusion is already there. When they talk about the 'R5', they mean the A7rV
May 30, 2024 at 11:52 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.17 #7Canon r1 official announcement.
rscheffler wrote:
what happened to the last two posts?

artsupreme wrote:
What did we miss?


A humorous post that mashed together Canon's R1 plight and politics, and a witty reply that both apparently transgressed the moderator's boundaries. I thought it was well done but perhaps those more sensitive about the riff on certain political leanings might not have agreed.
May 31, 2024 at 01:14 AM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.17 #8Canon r1 official announcement.
The thread might as well have moved to politics.
It certainly was not providing any useful discussion on the R1.
More like training material for 1st year Psych students.

May 31, 2024 at 05:30 AM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.17 #9Canon r1 official announcement.


rscheffler wrote:
rscheffler wrotewhat happened to the last two posts?
artsupreme wroteWhat did we miss?
A humorous post that mashed together Canon's R1 plight and politics, and a witty reply that both apparently transgressed the moderator's boundaries. I thought it was well done but perhaps those more sensitive about the riff on certain political leanings might not have agreed.


I thought there was something in the witty reply for both sides, haha, but I guess Fred knows best.
May 31, 2024 at 05:49 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.17 #10Canon r1 official announcement.
garyvot wrote:
I thought there was something in the witty reply for both sides, haha, but I guess Fred knows best.


Probably because Fred knows that witty comments about politics or religion can be demeaning and offensive to some members.

So keep those type of comments out of photo discussions on this site.
May 31, 2024 at 08:29 AM
juststeve
Offline
Details
p.17 #11Canon r1 official announcement.
Yesterday on FM I posted the possibility of the R1 being able to take the data of the four quad pixels for auto focus and calculate the luminosity for each and coming up with 96 MP. I believe the luminosity value has for more value in determining resolution than does the color value of the pixel. Now I realize this is not technically perfect engineer talk but the concept may be sound. Since the Bayer RGBG matrix is already determining pixel color by smoke and mirrors and who knows what else getting good, smooth, accurate color may be possible even with these four subpixels under one primary color pixels.

I am not an engineer or physicist so a sprinkle of salt may be in order.

Here is a quote of what I posted on FM:

"If QPAF is arranged as four square sub pixels per main single RGBG pixel, would it not be possible to measure its luminance value and compile it separately to boost resolution to 96 MP while averaging the four to give the color value for the pixel?

This might make for some interesting work for the RAW converter engineers, and require some very considerable computer power, both in the camera and in the digital darkroom. Maybe too much to be practical.

This is an idea which has been bouncing around inside my head for a few days now. I am trying to remember if Canon has patented an idea similar to this. I have a vague memory they have done so."
May 31, 2024 at 08:42 PM
vbnut
Offline
Details
p.17 #12Canon r1 official announcement.
rscheffler wrote:
armd wroteApart from perhaps some better DR, maybe some better video capabilities, and better form/ergonomics how do people envision this camera eclipsing the A9III?
It works with lenses exclusive to the RF mount? Like the 100-300, 28-70, 24-105Z and hopefully eventually a 200-500/4.

Everyone seems to feel it's Nikon and Sony with all the good lenses, but there are some good ones only available from Canon, too. If those are important for your work, it's just another reason to use Canon.

Oh, and CPS support, too.


... and if the rumored "variable" teleconverter (see here) ever materializes, it could be a huge benefit.
May 31, 2024 at 09:15 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #13Canon r1 official announcement.
juststeve wrote:
Yesterday on FM I posted the possibility of the R1 being able to take the data of the four quad pixels for auto focus and calculate the luminosity for each and coming up with 96 MP. I believe the luminosity value has for more value in determining resolution than does the color value of the pixel. Now I realize this is not technically perfect engineer talk but the concept may be sound. Since the Bayer RGBG matrix is already determining pixel color by smoke and mirrors and who knows what else getting good, smooth, accurate color may be possible even
...Show more →

There has been some talk about this in the past, but nothing substantial.

Even if they could try to do this, and even successfully squeeze out a bit of detail from QPRAW files, it will not replace normal resolution.

Regarding detail in the files, the difference in luminousity between sub-pixels is supposed to be depth information and not information about detail. How to suddenly make that the other way around is going to look more like AI powered uprezzing of normal low resolution files.

The other aspect is that the frame rate is going to be much lower. You can't have the speed and the resolution at the same time, although you could have it in the same camera. Just imagine how that will be received here.

When I have talked about this in the past, it was more a fear that Canon will try to cheat us by saying this is the high resolution camera, than expectation of something great.

Jun 01, 2024 at 02:02 AM
juststeve
Offline
Details
p.17 #14Canon r1 official announcement.
One of those 1/4 size sub pixels would or could be just another pixel except they would be under the same color filter. The luminosity of each sub pixel would give much the same info as the full pixel except at four times the detail. I am not sure what the depth information is about. Each sub pixel is going to have the same color information, whether red, green or blue, but each sub pixel can have luminosity value dependent on the amount of light hitting that sub pixel. Sounds like detail to me.

It would take some doing to make a 96 MP file, but it seems possible with a super fast stacked sensor and a third sensor layer dedicated to performing the processing. Of course, there is to be expected a speed hit, but if the camera is capable of 30-40 FPS at 24 MP then 7 to 10 might be possible at 96 MP. I certainly would be quite happy with 7 to 10 FPS at that resolution.
Jun 01, 2024 at 11:47 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #15Canon r1 official announcement.
Don't confuse QPRAW from a QPAF sensor with regular quad pixel sensors as seen in drones and other small sensor devices. QPAF has additional directional filters for the sub-pixels, designed to give different luminousity for light from different incident angles of the sensor.
Jun 01, 2024 at 12:20 PM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.17 #16Canon r1 official announcement.
alundeb wrote:
When I have talked about this in the past, it was more a fear that Canon will try to cheat us by saying this is the high resolution camera, than expectation of something great.


If this did materialize, I imagine it would be positioned as a special mode, sort of like a pixel-shift "hi-res" capture on other bodies, or the "custom high framerate" 195fps mode on the R3, and not as a core capability of the camera. But of course, who knows what Canon marketing will do.

Even if possible though, this seems rather out of scope for a 1-series body. Canon tends to introduce "experimental" features (like DPRAW or eye control focusing) in lesser bodies first, to prove the technology and gain user feedback.

I think this could be cool but is likely wishful thinking.
Jun 02, 2024 at 08:00 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.17 #17Canon r1 official announcement.
Canon 120mp sensors are older than dirt, been around forever. Found 2018 video I think one article 2011. For some reason they never put them in consumer cameras. Not hard to see why.

Nikon hasn't quite caught the 2015 5DsR yet (not that I consider 45 vs 50 or even 60 that big) and it took Sony 4 years to pass it. So it's hard to take this Canon isn't innovative stuff too seriously, kind of ridiculous if you ask me

Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?

Jun 02, 2024 at 11:34 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #18Canon r1 official announcement.
Soon there won't be anyone left to want a high MP camera from Canon. With high, I mean above 80 MP.
With the launch of the Fuji GFX 100s II, there is a clearance discount on the 100s. I can get it new for just pennies more than the current Canon R5 price. I'm in for that. 100 MP mini-MF for less than the Sony A7rV so-called high resolution landscape oriented camera. So it is not only about Canon either. There is simply no point trying to compete with medium format anymore.
Jun 02, 2024 at 11:52 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.17 #19Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?




Hard to say, but I see lots of used ones for sale already, and dealers are complaining no one is buying any new ones. I suspect that the press agency pools are the only customers for that camera.
Jun 02, 2024 at 12:00 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.17 #20Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
Canon 120mp sensors are older than dirt, been around forever. Found 2018 video I think one article 2011. For some reason they never put them in consumer cameras. Not hard to see why.

Nikon hasn't quite caught the 2015 5DsR yet (not that I consider 45 vs 50 or even 60 that big) and it took Sony 4 years to pass it. So it's hard to take this Canon isn't innovative stuff too seriously, kind of ridiculous if you ask me

Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?



Other than the headline 51MPs, the 5DSR sensor was nothing to get excited about.
Nikon may not have made up those 6MPs but the D850's 45MP sensor is better in every other way.
The Sony A1 50MP is just light years ahead in tech and performance over the 5DSR sensor.
Yes the 5DSR was cool when it arrived and I owned one for a short while but other than the 80D it was the shortest time I kept a camera for. It was just not a great camera for any type of action and the pixel detail was always lost because of the sub-par AF system.

Sony' A9III 24MP sensor is not idiotic. It is innovative and will push the market forward to better GS sensors. I don't really benefit from GS in my photography so I don't really care. I'd rather just keep the DR of a stacked sensor over the GS. But for some it will be a big benefit to solve banding under certain light sources.
Jun 02, 2024 at 12:22 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister