fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Canon r1 official announcement.

  
 
docusync
Offline
Details
p.16 #1Canon r1 official announcement.
big country wrote:
I didn't ask about DR or FPS, so i have no idea.

This is an assumption on my part: Canon is keeping this project pretty tight lipped and they are in control of the leaks. And i think bad info is getting leaked on purpose and some of the "info" being leaked is just made up...but who knows!

CelesteForza wrote
big country wroteJust got some hot info on the R1, unfortunately I cannot publicly post it, i have shared it with some that also participate in this forum, we will see if it's correct or not.
Thanks for the info! To confirm, the R1 has 80MP, 200FPS, and 16-stops of dynamic range throughout the ISO range


Yeah, we understand. It's more than just an NDA, it is Omerta. Canon is in close collaboration with Yakuza, and the latter are "taking care" of the "leaking" individuals...
May 29, 2024 at 09:00 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.16 #2Canon r1 official announcement.


arbitrage wrote:
AmbientMike wroteThe Canon R5 is a fast, 45mp camera. Even today. They already have a fast 24mp camera, the R3 has been out since 2021, the R5 came out in 2020.

So on top of the normal development, they took an extra year to improve speeds. Just not seeing this as a 24mp camera. I've already mentioned other reasons I dont think it's 24mp, Canon rumors is a rumor site.

The A1 has inferior DR, as well. I'm not necessarily interested in the latest greatest, either, and still use DSLR
If you are going to keep bringing up the A1's "inferior" DR, please use the qualifier of "at ISO 100 only" and "only after the R5 applies NR to the RAW files". At every other ISO value they are practically identical or within a 1/4 stop. The only outlier is the dual gain point where the R5 jumps 1/3 stop sooner so of course at that single ISO value (400) it is a stop higher than the A1.


Nobody used any qualifiers on DSLR'S, and I'm not doing it here.

Sony has 8-9+% distortion on their 20-70 and 16-35/4, basically requiring lens corrections. And you assume they aren't using software to correct their sensors? Doesn't make much sense, does it?

At least Canon didn't have the star eater issue


May 29, 2024 at 10:40 PM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.16 #3Canon r1 official announcement.
Minority Report
May 30, 2024 at 01:54 AM
randomguy
Offline
Details
p.16 #4Canon r1 official announcement.
arbitrage wrote:
This will be a 96MP camera....

QPRAW files will be 96MP.....and no one will use them just like nobody uses the DPRAW files.

You heard it here first


I guess you are joking, but actually my drone has quad pixel sensor already offering a 48MP mode instead of the regular 12MP. And it definitely gives more detail than the regular files but it can sometimes look a bit weird compared to the regular files. I use it most of the time on my drone, main drawback is it is damn slow and the files 100MB in size. I believe also many cell phones also use utilize quad pixel sensors like this..
May 30, 2024 at 02:05 AM
randomguy
Offline
Details
p.16 #5Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteThe Canon R5 is a fast, 45mp camera. Even today. They already have a fast 24mp camera, the R3 has been out since 2021, the R5 came out in 2020.

So on top of the normal development, they took an extra year to improve speeds. Just not seeing this as a 24mp camera. I've already mentioned other reasons I dont think it's 24mp, Canon rumors is a rumor site.

The A1 has inferior DR, as well. I'm not necessarily interested in the latest greatest, either, and still use DSLR
If you are going to keep bringing up the A1's "inferior" DR, please use the qualifier of "at ISO 100 only" and "only after the R5 applies NR to the RAW files". At every other ISO value they are practically identical or within a 1/4 stop. The only outlier is the dual gain point where the R5 jumps 1/3 stop sooner so of course at that single ISO value (400) it is a stop higher than the A1.
Nobody used any qualifiers on DSLR'S, and I'm not doing it here.

Sony has 8-9+% distortion on their 20-70 and 16-35/4, basically requiring lens corrections. And you assume they aren't using software to correct their sensors? Doesn't make much sense, does it?

At least Canon didn't have the star eater issue



Well we have people like Bill Claff who tests sensors for noise reduction scientifically and got great credibility, and we got fanboys on the internet who make up fake news and got zero credibility.
May 30, 2024 at 02:51 AM
Uarctos
Offline
Details
p.16 #6Canon r1 official announcement.
So, still no news on the R1?
May 30, 2024 at 04:36 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.16 #7Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteThe Canon R5 is a fast, 45mp camera. Even today. They already have a fast 24mp camera, the R3 has been out since 2021, the R5 came out in 2020.

So on top of the normal development, they took an extra year to improve speeds. Just not seeing this as a 24mp camera. I've already mentioned other reasons I dont think it's 24mp, Canon rumors is a rumor site.

The A1 has inferior DR, as well. I'm not necessarily interested in the latest greatest, either, and still use DSLR
If you are going to keep bringing up the A1's "inferior" DR, please use the qualifier of "at ISO 100 only" and "only after the R5 applies NR to the RAW files". At every other ISO value they are practically identical or within a 1/4 stop. The only outlier is the dual gain point where the R5 jumps 1/3 stop sooner so of course at that single ISO value (400) it is a stop higher than the A1.
Nobody used any qualifiers on DSLR'S, and I'm not doing it here.

Sony has 8-9+% distortion on their 20-70 and 16-35/4, basically requiring lens corrections. And you assume they aren't using software to correct their sensors? Doesn't make much sense, does it?

At least Canon didn't have the star eater issue



You must have a very short memory. For years, I consistently defended Canon's DSLR DR for wildlife/bird photographers by pointing out that all the competitors advantage came at low ISO values that wildlife/bird photogs rarely use. I always granted the critics that Canon was behind at lower ISO at the time but I always made sure to clarify that high ISO was mostly on par with the competition.

Here is one example I would show people who raved that D850 was ahead of 5DIV....by 1250 the 5DIV was actually slightly ahead. So because I defended Canon in those days, I will argue against your generalized and therefore misleading attack on the A1's DR.




May 30, 2024 at 06:12 AM
Sy Sez
Offline
Details
p.16 #8Canon r1 official announcement.
For those that are:

(1) Obsessed with Canon.
(2) Obsessed with owning “the” Flagship body.
(3) Obsessed with 45MP minimal sensor resolution.

What will they do, if the EOS R1 has only a 24MP sensor?

(1) Shamefully switch to NIKON, but camouflage all their gear, with LensCoat camo covers, so no one will notice, and attach a Canon strap to their Z9?

(2) Skip the upgrade, hang on to their current Canon body, and descend into sulk mode for the next 5 years in hope that the R1 Mark 2 will finally meet their desired mega-mega pixel expectations?

(3) Give up on photography altogether, and seek another more gratifying hobby?
May 30, 2024 at 07:35 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.16 #9Canon r1 official announcement.
Sy Sez wrote:
For those that are:

(1) Obsessed with Canon.
(2) Obsessed with owning “the” Flagship body.
(3) Obsessed with 45MP minimal sensor resolution.

What will they do, if the EOS R1 has only a 24MP sensor?

(1) Shamefully switch to NIKON, but camouflage all their gear, with LensCoat camo covers, so no one will notice, and attach a Canon strap to their Z9?

(2) Skip the upgrade, hang on to their current Canon body, and descend into sulk mode for the next 5 years in hope that the R1 Mark 2 will finally meet their desired mega-mega pixel expectations?

(3) Give up on photography altogether, and seek
...Show more →

If I planned on acquiring the R1 (which I'm not) my answers would be...

#1 Would never happen as I prefer my image in focus. Especially the eyes of my subjects.

#2 This option is viable as my R5 already meets my desired mega-mega pixel expectations.

#3 All the way baby!
My needlepoint is coming along quite nicely.
I'd post up some pics of my progress but my R5's rolling shutter and pathetic DR renders the images un-post worthy.
May 30, 2024 at 08:26 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.16 #10Canon r1 official announcement.

randomguy wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteThe Canon R5 is a fast, 45mp camera. Even today. They already have a fast 24mp camera, the R3 has been out since 2021, the R5 came out in 2020.

So on top of the normal development, they took an extra year to improve speeds. Just not seeing this as a 24mp camera. I've already mentioned other reasons I dont think it's 24mp, Canon rumors is a rumor site.

The A1 has inferior DR, as well. I'm not necessarily interested in the latest greatest, either, and still use DSLR
If you are going to keep bringing up the A1's "inferior" DR, please use the qualifier of "at ISO 100 only" and "only after the R5 applies NR to the RAW files". At every other ISO value they are practically identical or within a 1/4 stop. The only outlier is the dual gain point where the R5 jumps 1/3 stop sooner so of course at that single ISO value (400) it is a stop higher than the A1.
Nobody used any qualifiers on DSLR'S, and I'm not doing it here.

Sony has 8-9+% distortion on their 20-70 and 16-35/4, basically requiring lens corrections. And you assume they aren't using software to correct their sensors? Doesn't make much sense, does it?

At least Canon didn't have the star eater issue
Well we have people like Bill Claff who tests sensors for noise reduction scientifically and got great credibility, and we got fanboys on the internet who make up fake news and got zero credibility.


Sony star-eater: not fake news

Just look at opticallimits on the distortion on those lenses.

Unless you are referring to yourself as the fake news fanboy


Edited on May 30, 2024 at 11:15 AM · View previous versions
May 30, 2024 at 11:06 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.16 #11Canon r1 official announcement.


arbitrage wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteThe Canon R5 is a fast, 45mp camera. Even today. They already have a fast 24mp camera, the R3 has been out since 2021, the R5 came out in 2020.

So on top of the normal development, they took an extra year to improve speeds. Just not seeing this as a 24mp camera. I've already mentioned other reasons I dont think it's 24mp, Canon rumors is a rumor site.

The A1 has inferior DR, as well. I'm not necessarily interested in the latest greatest, either, and still use DSLR
If you are going to keep bringing up the A1's "inferior" DR, please use the qualifier of "at ISO 100 only" and "only after the R5 applies NR to the RAW files". At every other ISO value they are practically identical or within a 1/4 stop. The only outlier is the dual gain point where the R5 jumps 1/3 stop sooner so of course at that single ISO value (400) it is a stop higher than the A1.
Nobody used any qualifiers on DSLR'S, and I'm not doing it here.

Sony has 8-9+% distortion on their 20-70 and 16-35/4, basically requiring lens corrections. And you assume they aren't using software to correct their sensors? Doesn't make much sense, does it?

At least Canon didn't have the star eater issue
You must have a very short memory. For years, I consistently defended Canon's DSLR DR for wildlife/bird photographers by pointing out that all the competitors advantage came at low ISO values that wildlife/bird photogs rarely use. I always granted the critics that Canon was behind at lower ISO at the time but I always made sure to clarify that high ISO was mostly on par with the competition.

Here is one example I would show people who raved that D850 was ahead of 5DIV....by 1250 the 5DIV was actually slightly ahead. So because I defended Canon in those days, I will
...Show more →

OK, maybe you did, but there didn't seem to be a lot of that going on.

Funny you'd bring up the D850 (granted it is one of the more popular bodies.) Bill Claff's site said one of the Fuji aps bodies better DR, he apparently showed up on here himself to tell me that wasn't actually correct, even though I'd apparently read the graph correctly

But, no, I don't believe Sony and others do major lens corrections, then completely leave the raw files alone. I dont think you could even turn the star eater off, on raw, even.
May 30, 2024 at 11:14 AM
juststeve
Offline
Details
p.16 #12Canon r1 official announcement.
I realize Arbitrage's QPAF was largely meant jokingly, but...

If QPAF is arranged as four square sub pixels per main single RGBG pixel, would it not be possible to measure its luminance value and compile it separately to boost resolution to 96 MP while averaging the four to give the color value for the pixel?

This might make for some interesting work for the RAW converter engineers, and require some very considerable computer power, both in the camera and in the digital darkroom. Maybe too much to be practical.

This is an idea which has been bouncing around inside my head for a few days now. I am trying to remember if Canon has patented an idea similar to this. I have a vague memory they have done so.
May 30, 2024 at 11:24 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.16 #13Canon r1 official announcement.
I'm reading stuff like crop mode button, NR mentioned in the development announcement, etc and looking up 8k requirements and the thing that doesn't make sense is the statement apparently by CR of 24mp and 6k. So I'm throwing that out.

The specs haven't been released yet, few know how many pixels it actually has. I don't really know if the guy is right, I'm using my own judgement, as opposed to following the CR site.

CR reported it has QPAF I am pretty sure. So if we have to believe everything they say it's a fact.
May 30, 2024 at 11:58 AM
ilkka_nissila
Offline
Details
p.16 #14Canon r1 official announcement.
Since the different subpixels for QPAF would be sensitive to different directions of incoming light, I don't think it would be possible to use it to improve spatial resolution in the image plane but it might give some depth information like in the Lytro camera.
May 30, 2024 at 12:10 PM
robert_in_ca
Offline
Details
p.16 #15Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
I'm reading stuff like crop mode button, NR mentioned in the development announcement, etc and looking up 8k requirements and the thing that doesn't make sense is the statement apparently by CR of 24mp and 6k. So I'm throwing that out.

The specs haven't been released yet, few know how many pixels it actually has. I don't really know if the guy is right, I'm using my own judgement, as opposed to following the CR site.

CR reported it has QPAF I am pretty sure. So if we have to believe everything they say it's a fact.


To your point it's a lot of speculation but I wouldn't be surprised if the R1 is 30mp or less--which would be consistent with the 1 series not being the highest resolution cameras in the Canon lineup.

Edited on May 30, 2024 at 01:06 PM · View previous versions
May 30, 2024 at 12:11 PM
Dragonfire
Offline
Details
p.16 #16Canon r1 official announcement.
arbitrage wrote:
This will be a 96MP camera....

QPRAW files will be 96MP.....and no one will use them just like nobody uses the DPRAW files.

You heard it here first


Geoff, I asked you not to tell anyone
May 30, 2024 at 12:58 PM
armd
Offline
Details
p.16 #17Canon r1 official announcement.
Apart from perhaps some better DR, maybe some better video capabilities, and better form/ergonomics how do people envision this camera eclipsing the A9III?
May 30, 2024 at 01:05 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.16 #18Canon r1 official announcement.
arbitrage wrote:
This will be a 96MP camera....

QPRAW files will be 96MP.....and no one will use them just like nobody uses the DPRAW files.

You heard it here first


Methinks you're confusing DPRAW (which no one uses) with DPAF (which everyone loves and uses).

If the new camera has QPAF, it will give it an even bigger lead over Nikon cameras, which still struggle at times with anything not having vertical lines.
May 30, 2024 at 01:11 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.16 #19Canon r1 official announcement.
armd wrote:
Apart from perhaps some better DR, maybe some better video capabilities, and better form/ergonomics how do people envision this camera eclipsing the A9III?


Given that it does get QPAF, and that the resolution is 30 MP, it will not Eclipse the A9III. Except for better resolution, better DR, better AF, better video, better form/ergonomics, better viewfinder, better all round capabilities.

(Remember the "What have the Romans ever done for us" scene from Life of Brian ? )


Edited on May 31, 2024 at 03:05 PM · View previous versions
May 30, 2024 at 01:20 PM
rscheffler
Online
Details
p.16 #20Canon r1 official announcement.
armd wrote:
Apart from perhaps some better DR, maybe some better video capabilities, and better form/ergonomics how do people envision this camera eclipsing the A9III?


It works with lenses exclusive to the RF mount? Like the 100-300, 28-70, 24-105Z and hopefully eventually a 200-500/4.

Everyone seems to feel it's Nikon and Sony with all the good lenses, but there are some good ones only available from Canon, too. If those are important for your work, it's just another reason to use Canon.

Oh, and CPS support, too.
May 30, 2024 at 02:16 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister