fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Canon r1 official announcement.

  
 
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.18 #1Canon r1 official announcement.
molson wrote:
AmbientMike wroteIs Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?
Hard to say, but I see lots of used ones for sale already, and dealers are complaining no one is buying any new ones. I suspect that the press agency pools are the only customers for that camera.


If it gets down to A9II price of $4500 I'd have another look. Otherwise my $6K is better saved and put towards the A1II.
Jun 02, 2024 at 12:23 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.18 #2Canon r1 official announcement.
middlerockies wrote:
I can't remember a time when Canon gave us more than we wanted or what the rumors were expecting. Usually there's wild speculation and delusional thinking, like all the discussion of 120-200MP sensors that are occurring right now over on the rumor site, and have been for five years or so now. People get their hopes up that Canon will compete and one-up the competition on all fronts, flexing their muscles and showing Sony and Nikon who's boss. And then when the camera is finally released, there's one hyped up marketing feature that stands out like 8K or QPAF and
...Show more →

IMO you could insert any camera brand in place of Canon above and it would also be true. Perhaps the reality is that no one brand is dominant in every technology that is combined to produce current mirrorless systems. Therefore no one brand is running away from the others.

I can't help but think of Roger Cicala's Law of New Product Introduction

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/media/2013/01/PERCEIVEDWORTH1.jpg

And I think this is what is and will happen with the R1, R5II, etc. As was the case with other cameras too, even 'groundbreaking' ones like the recent aIII.

There will be some good new features in all of these releases and they will prove to be useful. But they will not prove to make the given camera quantum leaps better than those from the competition, or even the previous generation(s). This will also be somewhat dependent on each photographer's needs, as some will find certain new features extremely valuable for their work, while the same features make no difference for the work of others.

It reminds me of the R6>R6II. I own both and actually bought the R6 after the R6II. On paper it doesn't seem like much difference. Only an additional 4MP, pretty much the same body with a sprinkling of new features. I can however say that the R6II is a clear improvement over the R6 and some of its 'minor' new features actually provide significant value in specific situations that matter to me. Off the top of my head: better battery life, better experience switching between stills and video, 40fps without AF or file type compromises, smoother EVF experience photographing action (same EVF panel but more powerful processor), better rolling shutter, high speed flicker compensation. However, I still use the R6 regularly alongside the R6II because the practical differences between the two in ~85-90% of my work does not affect the results.

R1 and R5II will probably be similarly true relative to the R3 and R5 respectively, though given more years between those products and the new releases than the R6 and R6II, some of the improvements likely will be more noticeable in use. I really don't believe Canon is behind Sony and Nikon. Rather, each system has certain strengths and weaknesses, some of which are difficult to tease out simply from the specs sheet. Where across the range of features those strengths and weaknesses lie may be relevant for your work and you may therefore prefer one system over the others for these reasons. But I suspect for the majority, any of the systems will work. It's a matter of picking one that suits your needs, learning its specific strengths and weakness and knowing how to use them to your advantage, or work around them, in the photographic situations you are most often working. The bottom line is probably that currently there really is no 'bad' system (unless you want Pentax and mirrorless ).



Jun 02, 2024 at 12:33 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.18 #3Canon r1 official announcement.
arbitrage wrote:
molson wrote
AmbientMike wroteIs Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?
Hard to say, but I see lots of used ones for sale already, and dealers are complaining no one is buying any new ones. I suspect that the press agency pools are the only customers for that camera.
If it gets down to A9II price of $4500 I'd have another look. Otherwise my $6K is better saved and put towards the A1II.



Maybe the $2500 price range of an OM-1 II or X-H2S is the right snack bracket...
Jun 02, 2024 at 01:06 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.18 #4Canon r1 official announcement.
middlerockies wrote:
I can't remember a time when Canon gave us more than we wanted or what the rumors were expecting. Usually there's wild speculation and delusional thinking, like all the discussion of 120-200MP sensors that are occurring right now over on the rumor site, and have been for five years or so now. People get their hopes up that Canon will compete and one-up the competition on all fronts, flexing their muscles and showing Sony and Nikon who's boss. And then when the camera is finally released, there's one hyped up marketing feature that stands out like 8K or QPAF and
...Show more →

So what? Don't like what Canon is doing, go buy another brand.
Jun 02, 2024 at 01:07 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #5Canon r1 official announcement.

middlerockies wrote:
alundeb wroteSoon there won't be anyone left to want a high MP camera from Canon. With high, I mean above 80 MP.
With the launch of the Fuji GFX 100s II, there is a clearance discount on the 100s. I can get it new for just pennies more than the current Canon R5 price. I'm in for that. 100 MP mini-MF for less than the Sony A7rV so-called high resolution landscape oriented camera. So it is not only about Canon either. There is simply no point trying to compete with medium format anymore.
If you're talking about MP alone, then "there is simply no point trying to compete with medium format anymore" holds true, sure. But what about speed? Reach? Video? Size and weight? Lens options? I mean, come on, this is a ridiculous statement unless you're a very specific genre of shooting and prioritize only MP.

It is so ridiculous that even all camera manufacturers believe it.

You forgot dynamic range. MP and DR.

Even how desperately people are going to want it, a camera with both high speed and high resolution does not exist. A 100 MP Canon camera would probably not be any faster than the newer GFX cameras. Lens selection can be solved in many ways. The GFX 100s is size and weight wise like the praised Z8. Fuji GF has just announced the "best" lightweight tele prime yet, the 500/5.6. Check it out.
Jun 02, 2024 at 01:23 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #6Canon r1 official announcement.


middlerockies wrote:
alundeb wroteIt is so ridiculous that even all camera manufacturers believe it.
Huh? All camera manufacturers believe it? Sony? Canon? Nikon? None of them have medium format systems. You're either high on your own supply or drinking on a Sunday.


Or maybe something with your comprehension? Why is no camera maker making a 100 MP camera that is NOT medium format?
Jun 02, 2024 at 01:29 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.18 #7Canon r1 official announcement.
Imagemaster wrote:
middlerockies wroteI can't remember a time when Canon gave us more than we wanted or what the rumors were expecting. Usually there's wild speculation and delusional thinking, like all the discussion of 120-200MP sensors that are occurring right now over on the rumor site, and have been for five years or so now. People get their hopes up that Canon will compete and one-up the competition on all fronts, flexing their muscles and showing Sony and Nikon who's boss. And then when the camera is finally released, there's one hyped up marketing feature that stands out like 8K or QPAF and yet they're behind or just catching up with most other features, and inevitably there's a lot of disappointment. I don't see this cycle being any different somehow. Canon is notorious for giving its users just enough and no more. The R1 will be the same.
So what? Don't like what Canon is doing, go buy another brand.


Ignore him... he's only here for the attention.
Jun 02, 2024 at 01:30 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #8Canon r1 official announcement.


middlerockies wrote:
alundeb wroteOr maybe something with your comprehension? Why is no camera maker making a 100 MP camera that is NOT medium format?
Processing speeds and video. The only companies making medium format products are niche manufacturers because the larger market demands speed and video. Canon, Sony, and Nikon are appealing to the masses, whereas Fujifilm, Hasselblad, and Phase One are catering to a more stills-oriented, niche user, that doesn't need speed or video.

With medium format, you've got a bottleneck with processing speeds. You can't push that much data through the camera fast enough. Canon, Nikon, and Sony could all make medium format cameras if they wanted to, and they'd have the same challenges everyone else does. Will we get there eventually?
...Show more →

Nobody ever said medium format is superior on all fronts. It was pretty obvious that what I was talking about was that there seems to be little interest for SoNiCa to make a camera that competes with medium format in resolution.
Jun 02, 2024 at 01:51 PM
ilkka_nissila
Online
Details
p.18 #9Canon r1 official announcement.
alundeb wrote:
middlerockies wrote
alundeb wroteOr maybe something with your comprehension? Why is no camera maker making a 100 MP camera that is NOT medium format?
Processing speeds and video. The only companies making medium format products are niche manufacturers because the larger market demands speed and video. Canon, Sony, and Nikon are appealing to the masses, whereas Fujifilm, Hasselblad, and Phase One are catering to a more stills-oriented, niche user, that doesn't need speed or video.

With medium format, you've got a bottleneck with processing speeds. You can't push that much data through the camera fast enough. Canon, Nikon, and Sony could all make medium format cameras if they wanted to, and they'd have the same challenges everyone else does. Will we get there eventually? I'm sure. But going back to your initial comment, it's hyperbole at best to insinuate there's no point trying to compete with medium format anymore as if it's superior on all fronts.
Nobody ever said medium format is superior on all fronts. It was pretty obvious that what I was talking about was that there seems to be little interest for SoNiCa to make a camera that competes with medium format in resolution.


It's not that there isn't any interest but the manufacturers want to sell as many generations of cameras as possible and so they make minimal improvements that will still result in sales in each generation. Eventually there will be 100 MP and higher resolutions in 35 mm format digital cameras.
Jun 02, 2024 at 02:05 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #10Canon r1 official announcement.


middlerockies wrote:
alundeb wroteThere is simply no point trying to compete with medium format anymore.
You literally said that. And then when I said that's ridiculous you followed it up with:

alundeb wroteIt is so ridiculous that even all camera manufacturers believe it.
Regardless, nobody is here to speculate on medium format as we know its limitations right now. We're shooting full frame and talking about the R1, which is only apparently going to have 24MP, far from the 80MP ceiling you mentioned with Canon.

Now I understand why you thought it was ridiculous. You took one sentence from my post out of context and thought is was meant generally. I don't think that was my fault.
Jun 02, 2024 at 02:07 PM
Sy Sez
Offline
Details
p.18 #11Canon r1 official announcement.
The apparent reason that Medium Format has been mentioned, is that there seems to be many who have a rather irrational belief that pixel count on a 24mm X 36mm sensor, without compromise, is limitless.
Jun 02, 2024 at 02:18 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.18 #12Canon r1 official announcement.


arbitrage wrote:
AmbientMike wroteCanon 120mp sensors are older than dirt, been around forever. Found 2018 video I think one article 2011. For some reason they never put them in consumer cameras. Not hard to see why.

Nikon hasn't quite caught the 2015 5DsR yet (not that I consider 45 vs 50 or even 60 that big) and it took Sony 4 years to pass it. So it's hard to take this Canon isn't innovative stuff too seriously, kind of ridiculous if you ask me

Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?
Other than the headline 51MPs, the 5DSR sensor was nothing to get excited about.
Nikon may not have made up those 6MPs but the D850's 45MP sensor is better in every other way.
The Sony A1 50MP is just light years ahead in tech and performance over the 5DSR sensor.
Yes the 5DSR was cool when it arrived and I owned one for a short while but other than the 80D it was the shortest time I kept a camera for. It was just not a great camera for any type of action and the pixel detail was always lost because of the
...Show more →

Oh come on.

So you think it's amazing a 5-6 year newer Sony has some advantages ? Sony had no fast super teles, 0, when the 5DsR came out, none anywhere near release. No fast af bodies either , and the D850 still a couple years off

I'd probably take 5DsR af over the 2nd gen Sonys for sports.




Jun 02, 2024 at 10:00 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #13Canon r1 official announcement.

middlerockies wrote:
alundeb wrote
middlerockies wrote
alundeb wroteThere is simply no point trying to compete with medium format anymore.
You literally said that. And then when I said that's ridiculous you followed it up with:

alundeb wroteIt is so ridiculous that even all camera manufacturers believe it.
Regardless, nobody is here to speculate on medium format as we know its limitations right now. We're shooting full frame and talking about the R1, which is only apparently going to have 24MP, far from the 80MP ceiling you mentioned with Canon.
Now I understand why you thought it was ridiculous. You took one sentence from my post out of context and thought is was meant generally. I don't think that was my fault.
If that is the case, then I apologize. It was unclear to me what you were referring to there.

Back to the discussion, though, I'm a wildlife photographer and would love as many MPs as possible for multiple reasons, primary just having more data to manipulate and crop with. Sony does this well with their A1 and even the A7RV, which are 50MP and 61MP respectively. But they are pretty much at the ceiling with present tech it seems, so if I were to jump up to medium format, my options are really only with Fujifilm at the moment since I
...Show more →

Apologies accepted! I could also have been clearer about my statement referring to competing about offerings in the highest resolution segment where there will always be compromises.
Jun 02, 2024 at 10:53 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #14Canon r1 official announcement.


middlerockies wrote:
alundeb wrote
middlerockies wrote
alundeb wroteThere is simply no point trying to compete with medium format anymore.
You literally said that. And then when I said that's ridiculous you followed it up with:

alundeb wroteIt is so ridiculous that even all camera manufacturers believe it.
Regardless, nobody is here to speculate on medium format as we know its limitations right now. We're shooting full frame and talking about the R1, which is only apparently going to have 24MP, far from the 80MP ceiling you mentioned with Canon.
Now I understand why you thought it was ridiculous. You took one sentence from my post out of context and thought is was meant generally. I don't think that was my fault.
Back to the discussion, though, I'm a wildlife photographer and would love as many MPs as possible for multiple reasons, primary just having more data to manipulate and crop with. Sony does this well with their A1 and even the A7RV, which are 50MP and 61MP respectively. But they are pretty much at the ceiling with present tech it seems, so if I were to jump up to medium format, my options are really only with Fujifilm at the moment since I need longer glass. The 500mm they just put out is just under 400mm equivalent, which is not nearly
...Show more →

I disagree about the lens, it is the equivalent of the praised Nikon 400 4.5 and cropped to 45 MP the 600 6.3 in one lens. Also in equivalent speed. It combines the two lenses and at a reasonable cost too.

The camera functions of the sII are better than the 5DSR for wildlife, so it is doable but far from competitive of course.
Jun 02, 2024 at 11:12 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.18 #15Canon r1 official announcement.


ilkka_nissila wrote:
alundeb wrote
middlerockies wrote
alundeb wroteOr maybe something with your comprehension? Why is no camera maker making a 100 MP camera that is NOT medium format?
Processing speeds and video. The only companies making medium format products are niche manufacturers because the larger market demands speed and video. Canon, Sony, and Nikon are appealing to the masses, whereas Fujifilm, Hasselblad, and Phase One are catering to a more stills-oriented, niche user, that doesn't need speed or video.

With medium format, you've got a bottleneck with processing speeds. You can't push that much data through the camera fast enough. Canon, Nikon, and Sony could all make medium format cameras if they wanted to, and they'd have the same challenges everyone else does. Will we get there eventually? I'm sure. But going back to your initial comment, it's hyperbole at best to insinuate there's no point trying to compete with medium format anymore as if it's superior on all fronts.
Nobody ever said medium format is superior on all fronts. It was pretty obvious that what I was talking about was that there seems to be little interest for SoNiCa to make a camera that competes with medium format in resolution.
It's not that there isn't any interest but the manufacturers want to sell as many generations of cameras as possible and so they make minimal improvements that will still result in sales in each generation. Eventually there will be 100 MP and higher resolutions in 35 mm format digital cameras.

Maybe, i don't disagree with your reasoning. It is just that at this point in time, even with the increasing doubling times, we should have had a doubling from 50 by now. There has been nothing for the last five years, not even chatter about small improvements above 60. It seems what happens nowadays are discussions about 24 being enough.
Jun 03, 2024 at 04:45 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.18 #16Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteCanon 120mp sensors are older than dirt, been around forever. Found 2018 video I think one article 2011. For some reason they never put them in consumer cameras. Not hard to see why.

Nikon hasn't quite caught the 2015 5DsR yet (not that I consider 45 vs 50 or even 60 that big) and it took Sony 4 years to pass it. So it's hard to take this Canon isn't innovative stuff too seriously, kind of ridiculous if you ask me

Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?
Other than the headline 51MPs, the 5DSR sensor was nothing to get excited about.
Nikon may not have made up those 6MPs but the D850's 45MP sensor is better in every other way.
The Sony A1 50MP is just light years ahead in tech and performance over the 5DSR sensor.
Yes the 5DSR was cool when it arrived and I owned one for a short while but other than the 80D it was the shortest time I kept a camera for. It was just not a great camera for any type of action and the pixel detail was always lost because of the sub-par AF system.

Sony' A9III 24MP sensor is not idiotic. It is innovative and will push the market forward to better GS sensors. I don't really benefit from GS in my photography so I don't really care. I'd rather just keep the DR of a stacked sensor over the GS. But for some it will be a big benefit to solve banding under certain light sources.
Oh come on.

So you think it's amazing a 5-6 year newer Sony has some advantages ? Sony had no fast super teles, 0, when the 5DsR came out, none anywhere near release. No fast af bodies either , and the D850 still a couple years off

I'd probably take 5DsR af over the 2nd gen Sonys for sports.




I had no interest in Sony during the 1st, 2nd and 3rd generations of the A7/A7R lineup. And yes there was no lens selection with the 100-400GM only coming out in 2017. Another reason I had no interest.

You are correct in that I would have taken a 5DSR over them and guess what?....I did....I bought one....but there were still better cameras out there for wildlife and sports which is why I didn't keep the 5DSR for very long. I much preferred my 1DX and even the 7DII at the time. One year later we had the 1DXII and 5DIV...both of which I also preferred to the 5DSR.

But the big shakeup for wildlife photography came at that same time in the form of the D500. That is what started my gradual move away from Canon.
Jun 03, 2024 at 07:26 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.18 #17Canon r1 official announcement.


arbitrage wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteCanon 120mp sensors are older than dirt, been around forever. Found 2018 video I think one article 2011. For some reason they never put them in consumer cameras. Not hard to see why.

Nikon hasn't quite caught the 2015 5DsR yet (not that I consider 45 vs 50 or even 60 that big) and it took Sony 4 years to pass it. So it's hard to take this Canon isn't innovative stuff too seriously, kind of ridiculous if you ask me

Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?
Other than the headline 51MPs, the 5DSR sensor was nothing to get excited about.
Nikon may not have made up those 6MPs but the D850's 45MP sensor is better in every other way.
The Sony A1 50MP is just light years ahead in tech and performance over the 5DSR sensor.
Yes the 5DSR was cool when it arrived and I owned one for a short while but other than the 80D it was the shortest time I kept a camera for. It was just not a great camera for any type of action and the pixel detail was always lost because of the sub-par AF system.

Sony' A9III 24MP sensor is not idiotic. It is innovative and will push the market forward to better GS sensors. I don't really benefit from GS in my photography so I don't really care. I'd rather just keep the DR of a stacked sensor over the GS. But for some it will be a big benefit to solve banding under certain light sources.
Oh come on.

So you think it's amazing a 5-6 year newer Sony has some advantages ? Sony had no fast super teles, 0, when the 5DsR came out, none anywhere near release. No fast af bodies either , and the D850 still a couple years off

I'd probably take 5DsR af over the 2nd gen Sonys for sports.
I had no interest in Sony during the 1st, 2nd and 3rd generations of the A7/A7R lineup. And yes there was no lens selection with the 100-400GM only coming out in 2017. Another reason I had no interest.

You are correct in that I would have taken a 5DSR over them and guess what?....I did....I bought one....but there were still better cameras out there for wildlife and sports which is why I didn't keep the 5DSR for very long. I much preferred my 1DX and even the 7DII at the time. One year later we had the 1DXII and 5DIV...both of
...Show more →

Yes, the 5DsR was pretty amazing at the time, I remember seeing the high resolution images posted on here. But it really didn't seem to be aimed at the action market.

And comparing it to cameras years into the future isn't exactly a fair comparison, The D500 had less mp than the d7200 that already existed, comparing a reduced mp body built to shoot action vs a very high mp body isn't exactly the fairest comparison, either. Although personally I don't use the DR much, 5fps usually enough for me, sometimes debatably even too much, so I'd definitely consider the 5DsR today

Jun 03, 2024 at 09:21 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.18 #18Canon r1 official announcement.
AmbientMike wrote:
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteCanon 120mp sensors are older than dirt, been around forever. Found 2018 video I think one article 2011. For some reason they never put them in consumer cameras. Not hard to see why.

Nikon hasn't quite caught the 2015 5DsR yet (not that I consider 45 vs 50 or even 60 that big) and it took Sony 4 years to pass it. So it's hard to take this Canon isn't innovative stuff too seriously, kind of ridiculous if you ask me

Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?
Other than the headline 51MPs, the 5DSR sensor was nothing to get excited about.
Nikon may not have made up those 6MPs but the D850's 45MP sensor is better in every other way.
The Sony A1 50MP is just light years ahead in tech and performance over the 5DSR sensor.
Yes the 5DSR was cool when it arrived and I owned one for a short while but other than the 80D it was the shortest time I kept a camera for. It was just not a great camera for any type of action and the pixel detail was always lost because of the sub-par AF system.

Sony' A9III 24MP sensor is not idiotic. It is innovative and will push the market forward to better GS sensors. I don't really benefit from GS in my photography so I don't really care. I'd rather just keep the DR of a stacked sensor over the GS. But for some it will be a big benefit to solve banding under certain light sources.
Oh come on.

So you think it's amazing a 5-6 year newer Sony has some advantages ? Sony had no fast super teles, 0, when the 5DsR came out, none anywhere near release. No fast af bodies either , and the D850 still a couple years off

I'd probably take 5DsR af over the 2nd gen Sonys for sports.
I had no interest in Sony during the 1st, 2nd and 3rd generations of the A7/A7R lineup. And yes there was no lens selection with the 100-400GM only coming out in 2017. Another reason I had no interest.

You are correct in that I would have taken a 5DSR over them and guess what?....I did....I bought one....but there were still better cameras out there for wildlife and sports which is why I didn't keep the 5DSR for very long. I much preferred my 1DX and even the 7DII at the time. One year later we had the 1DXII and 5DIV...both of which I also preferred to the 5DSR.

But the big shakeup for wildlife photography came at that same time in the form of the D500. That is what started my gradual move away from Canon.
Yes, the 5DsR was pretty amazing at the time, I remember seeing the high resolution images posted on here. But it really didn't seem to be aimed at the action market.

And comparing it to cameras years into the future isn't exactly a fair comparison, The D500 had less mp than the d7200 that already existed, comparing a reduced mp body built to shoot action vs a very high mp body isn't exactly the fairest comparison, either. Although personally I don't use the DR much, 5fps usually enough for me, sometimes debatably even too much, so I'd definitely consider the
...Show more →

5DSR might be a great camera for your use and they go for under a thousand in good used condition.

And hey, if you buy one, you can waste another $40 on this reprinted user manual

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1846618/
Jun 03, 2024 at 09:25 AM
Dragonfire
Offline
Details
p.18 #19Canon r1 official announcement.
arbitrage wrote:
Yes, the 5DsR was pretty amazing at the time

And hey, if you buy one, you can waste another $40 on this reprinted user manual

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1846618/


I heard about that camera and I understand that the gentleman selling the manual gives all the proceeds to charity.
Jun 03, 2024 at 10:30 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.18 #20Canon r1 official announcement.

arbitrage wrote:
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wrote
arbitrage wrote
AmbientMike wroteCanon 120mp sensors are older than dirt, been around forever. Found 2018 video I think one article 2011. For some reason they never put them in consumer cameras. Not hard to see why.

Nikon hasn't quite caught the 2015 5DsR yet (not that I consider 45 vs 50 or even 60 that big) and it took Sony 4 years to pass it. So it's hard to take this Canon isn't innovative stuff too seriously, kind of ridiculous if you ask me

Is Sony's $6k 24mp idiotic or innovative?
Other than the headline 51MPs, the 5DSR sensor was nothing to get excited about.
Nikon may not have made up those 6MPs but the D850's 45MP sensor is better in every other way.
The Sony A1 50MP is just light years ahead in tech and performance over the 5DSR sensor.
Yes the 5DSR was cool when it arrived and I owned one for a short while but other than the 80D it was the shortest time I kept a camera for. It was just not a great camera for any type of action and the pixel detail was always lost because of the sub-par AF system.

Sony' A9III 24MP sensor is not idiotic. It is innovative and will push the market forward to better GS sensors. I don't really benefit from GS in my photography so I don't really care. I'd rather just keep the DR of a stacked sensor over the GS. But for some it will be a big benefit to solve banding under certain light sources.
Oh come on.

So you think it's amazing a 5-6 year newer Sony has some advantages ? Sony had no fast super teles, 0, when the 5DsR came out, none anywhere near release. No fast af bodies either , and the D850 still a couple years off

I'd probably take 5DsR af over the 2nd gen Sonys for sports.
I had no interest in Sony during the 1st, 2nd and 3rd generations of the A7/A7R lineup. And yes there was no lens selection with the 100-400GM only coming out in 2017. Another reason I had no interest.

You are correct in that I would have taken a 5DSR over them and guess what?....I did....I bought one....but there were still better cameras out there for wildlife and sports which is why I didn't keep the 5DSR for very long. I much preferred my 1DX and even the 7DII at the time. One year later we had the 1DXII and 5DIV...both of which I also preferred to the 5DSR.

But the big shakeup for wildlife photography came at that same time in the form of the D500. That is what started my gradual move away from Canon.
Yes, the 5DsR was pretty amazing at the time, I remember seeing the high resolution images posted on here. But it really didn't seem to be aimed at the action market.

And comparing it to cameras years into the future isn't exactly a fair comparison, The D500 had less mp than the d7200 that already existed, comparing a reduced mp body built to shoot action vs a very high mp body isn't exactly the fairest comparison, either. Although personally I don't use the DR much, 5fps usually enough for me, sometimes debatably even too much, so I'd definitely consider the 5DsR today
5DSR might be a great camera for your use and they go for under a thousand in good used condition.

And hey, if you buy one, you can waste another $40 on this reprinted user manual

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1846618/


Congrats on finding something new amd innovative to criticize Canon on, criticizing the instruction manual, people pick on Canon on any and every little thing they can find. Drives me nuts. Can't you get a free pdf on the Canon site?

Doesn't Sony charge for firmware updates or something?
Jun 03, 2024 at 11:41 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister