fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?

  
 
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
johnvanr wrote:
Who cares when they introduced things.


People who don't want to wait 3,4,5 years for a 120 FPS camera from Canon and Nikon and are using the A9III since February.

Edited on May 06, 2024 at 07:10 PM · View previous versions
May 06, 2024 at 02:41 PM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
I simply cannot imagine that anyone wants that special shot so badly that he/she would regularly look through multiple 120fps bursts. Maybe I lack imagination…

There are actually special tools for doing this to make it quick and efficient.
May 06, 2024 at 02:43 PM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
RoamingScott wrote:
I just have to laugh when photographers act like they can't get a photo they are happy with without using precapture.

How tragic and embarrassing.




I just have to laugh when photographers act like they can't get a photo they are happy with without using [autofocus] [digital capture] [motor drive] [high iso] etc.
May 06, 2024 at 02:44 PM
AZHeaven
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote:
AZHeaven wroteSteve Perry from Backcountry Gallery seems to have switched back to Nikon even though he still uses his A1 from time to time.
A few days ago he said he's taking the new 300 GM, TCs and the 600 GM to Botswana.



I missed that! He goes back and forth I guess!
May 06, 2024 at 03:16 PM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote:
Earlier quoteI simply cannot imagine that anyone wants that special shot so badly that he/she would regularly look through multiple 120fps bursts. Maybe I lack imagination…
There are actually special tools for doing this to make it quick and efficient.


Which ones?
May 06, 2024 at 03:35 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #6Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
AZHeaven wrote:
telyt wrote
AZHeaven wroteSteve Perry from Backcountry Gallery seems to have switched back to Nikon even though he still uses his A1 from time to time.
A few days ago he said he's taking the new 300 GM, TCs and the 600 GM to Botswana.
I missed that! He goes back and forth I guess!


It's almost like gear is an afterthought to those with talent.
May 06, 2024 at 03:42 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote:
johnvanr wroteWho cares when they introduced things.
People who don't want to wait 3,4,5 years for a 120 FPS camera


While they wait, others are taking amazing images at amateur rates of 20 fps. Have you been sitting on your laurels awaiting 120fps before going out to take photos?
May 06, 2024 at 03:50 PM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.4 #8Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Laslo Varadi wrote
freaklikeme wrote
telyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?
Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.
The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?
On the 6700, the 100-400GM looks very much like a 150-600, and I can add TCs to extend that range. I'm limited to 11fps and 26mp, but, you know, everything that's supposed to be in focus is in focus. The rest is just timing. Can Nikon promise me all that in as small and capable a package?

Yep, the GM's more expensive and worth every penny to me. On my rV with the 2x, I can still get 26mp at a 900 equivalent. I'd love to say that comes in more handy, but I rarely have the atmospherics necessary to make anything over 600 pay off. Having the 300/2.8's more likely to pay off for me in the end. If I do have the atmospherics for it, then I'll borrow a 600GM.
There is no comparison between the Z8 and the A6700. I prefer the size of the Z8. And with a 1.4Tc, on a 600 pf and z8 in crop mode you are still out gunned. And does the Sony 600 GM come with a built in teleconverter like the Nikon 600 f4? And let’s no forget the Nikon 800 pf . Take a look at the photos on the Nikon forum. I see some pretty good results with it.



I know. One of them has a fully mechanical shutter available, can successfully track a butterfly in flight, and only sets you back $1400. I wouldn't want it to be my only camera, but it's a brilliant little hiking buddy.

The built-in TCs on Nikon's 400 and 600 are cool and handy, no doubt, but I'd actually be frustrated if Sony wanted me to pay $2000-2500 more for the convenience. The lenses are expensive enough. I'll work on anticipating my needs and deal with the accessory TCs instead. And I'm glad the Z8 and 800 PF are out there. If I run into a situation where an 800mm prime that's as small and light as a 500/4 is perfect and I know the lack of a mechanical shutter won't be an issue, that's top of the list to rent. For everything else, Sony has me well-covered.
May 06, 2024 at 06:34 PM
Laslo Varadi
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
freaklikeme wrote:
Laslo Varadi wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Laslo Varadi wrote
freaklikeme wrote
telyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?
Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.
The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?
On the 6700, the 100-400GM looks very much like a 150-600, and I can add TCs to extend that range. I'm limited to 11fps and 26mp, but, you know, everything that's supposed to be in focus is in focus. The rest is just timing. Can Nikon promise me all that in as small and capable a package?

Yep, the GM's more expensive and worth every penny to me. On my rV with the 2x, I can still get 26mp at a 900 equivalent. I'd love to say that comes in more handy, but I rarely have the atmospherics necessary to make anything over 600 pay off. Having the 300/2.8's more likely to pay off for me in the end. If I do have the atmospherics for it, then I'll borrow a 600GM.
There is no comparison between the Z8 and the A6700. I prefer the size of the Z8. And with a 1.4Tc, on a 600 pf and z8 in crop mode you are still out gunned. And does the Sony 600 GM come with a built in teleconverter like the Nikon 600 f4? And let’s no forget the Nikon 800 pf . Take a look at the photos on the Nikon forum. I see some pretty good results with it.
I know. One of them has a fully mechanical shutter available, can successfully track a butterfly in flight, and only sets you back $1400. I wouldn't want it to be my only camera, but it's a brilliant little hiking buddy.

The built-in TCs on Nikon's 400 and 600 are cool and handy, no doubt, but I'd actually be frustrated if Sony wanted me to pay $2000-2500 more for the convenience. The lenses are expensive enough. I'll work on anticipating my needs and deal with the accessory TCs instead. And I'm glad the Z8 and 800 PF are out there. If I
...Show more →
I prefer the A1 and the Z8 that shoot at 20-30 fps and never need to shoot with mechanical shutter. Nikon is now the leader with the exotic lenses. Although I won’t spend $15000 on one, if I would go for a lens like that the $2500 would not matter. I like the convenience of flipping a switch and activate the 1.4tc. It’s a nice feature to avoid fumbling with a big lens to add or remove a tc, especially in an adverse situation.
I do enjoy our bantering back and forth and actually enjoy both the A1 and Z8 and the lens options available. Both systems have certain advantages over the other. If Sony had a 600 Pf equivalent I probably would not have added the Z8.

May 06, 2024 at 07:32 PM
Laslo Varadi
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
chez wrote:
lightskyland wrote
johnvanr wroteWho cares when they introduced things.
People who don't want to wait 3,4,5 years for a 120 FPS camera
While they wait, others are taking amazing images at amateur rates of 20 fps. Have you been sitting on your laurels awaiting 120fps before going out to take photos?


Agree. As a hobbyist I don’t enjoy sorting through a thousand nearly identical photos. Imagine if I shot at 120fps.
May 06, 2024 at 07:36 PM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
arbitrage wrote:
tctmp wrote
swldstn wroteAs a multiple system shooter who currently only really just trying to break into BIF I’Ve owned the Z9 + 500PF but still own my Sony A1’s with 100-400 GM and 200-600 G and Canon R5 with a RF 100-500. This has been a really interesting thread and will continue to follow and look for direction.

I gave up on the Z9 because it was heavy and there was no Z8 or lighter body to pair it with. Wasn’t patient enough for them to fill out the system. Owned first the 500 PF with F mount and then the 400/4.5 Z with 1.4X TC. While I tried the Z9 I already had the A1 (x2) + 200-600 G and decided to return to it since I also used Sony for the 61 Mpixel cameras for landscape and general photography which started with Canon, which I still own as well. Lack of a higher Mpixel stacked sensor has kept my Canon stale for BIF and wondering if I should just sell it all even though it takes great pictures for everything below 400mm.

Need you guys to help me out. Thank you.

Now looking to “focus” more and commit to a BIF kit. Should I just go get a 600 GM
Z8 always represents a temptation. If I remember correctly, both Geoff and Douglas tried Z8 recently. @arbitrage@@, @Douglas L@@, care to elaborate for us what lens you tested with Z8, and what's the conclusion on AF, etc, compared to A1. Thanks.
I tested the Z8 with latest FW with the 400/4.5 with and without the 1.4TC.
I previously owned the Z9 on earlier FW versions and my first time used the 500PF and my second time owned the 400/4.5

The latest Nikon FW Z8 2.0 and I assume Z9 4.1 made a big improvement to being able to use Auto Area AF (essentially like Sony's Wide AF) which to me was a big deal as I shoot my Sonys in Wide most of the time and I used to shoot my Nikon DSLRs in Auto Area most of the time. On the earlier
...Show more →

I recently tried the Z8 on the 800 PF, a couple hours total, just didn't have time. My impression is the Z8 picks out the birds' eyes quicker than the A1, but the A1 picks out birds with busy background quicker than the Z9 (in Dec 2023) and the Z8. I sold the Z8 and is selling the 800 PF. I tried running two systems (Z9+600 TC in Dec 2023, Z8+800 PF) twice. It just didn't work out for me. I MUCH prefer how the A1 operates and its customization, maybe because I have shot them since 2021. I hadn't taken the Z8 out for some time because I didn't have time, few weeks ago I took it out for a walk, when I took it out of the bag, I was lost, I didn't know what other buttons do besides the shutter button, took me 10 minutes to "wake up". I think that was the moment I told myself: "stop fooling around with 2 systems". I had enough trouble with the A1 and the A7RV during the recent air to air shoot. That's why I just bought another A1 back!

But as I mentioned a couple posts back, I would go with Nikon Z8 and their nice selection of telephoto lenses if I start from scratch.
May 06, 2024 at 07:39 PM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
I found the debate about the dependence on using new technology to get "THE" shot very interesting. I can see both sides' points. I am in the camp that believe newer technology will no doubt increases the odds of getting "THE" shot, all things equal. I am obsessed with getting a 100% perfect head-on opposing passes of the Blue Angels or the Thunderbirds, the A1 is pretty good at that at 30 FPS and I was close (say 98% perfect) getting the perfect shot twice, but still not 100% perfect. I just ordered an A9III to try for this particular purpose, call me crazy.

I know some will say 10 FPS is more than enough if you know what you are doing. I think that has a lot to do with luck sometimes. An airshow buddy of mine who goes to 20 airshows a year got a perfect head-on opposing pass shot last year with his Z9, he said he may never be able to get the same shot in the next 15 years. Statistically, 120 FPS is 5 times more likely in getting "THE" shot than 20 FPS, in the same photographer's hand, as least that's how I see it.
May 06, 2024 at 08:27 PM
speedmaster20d
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
johnvanr wrote:
speedmaster20d wroteplease note the most important factor in getting great shots with any camera is skill of the photographer. A highly skilled photographer can get great shots with any camera. Beginners typically can get much better ROI by spending their $$$ on workshops, classes and resources first and upgrading gear second.

Now if we want to compare camera systems once one has mastered the skills there are some differences

I switched away from Canon in 2018, back then the Canon 1DXII AF really lacked compared to the Nikon D5. You will find that many top bird photographers switched away from Canon around that timeframe... When I switched to mirrorless both Canon and Nikon were out of the game, Nikon has caught up since then, especially with many attractive premium and specialized ZF lenses, but Canon still are way behind the game if you want the best in bird photography.
They are lagging behind in both bodies and lenses. Their top camera is still only 24 mega pixels (about same as my old 1DXII from 2015) which isn't enough for someone like me and the AF is still behind Sony or Nikon when it comes to BIF.... they just glued an adaptor to their old super tele's while their brand new RF lenses are cheap slow f/8 and f/11 zoom's mainly, I'd personally pass on such lenses. If you don't have the budget to buy faster or super telephoto lenses I would look at second had market, Sony has the 200-600 and Nikon has many "lower cost" great lenses, I would chose between these lenses. again you will see a skilled photographer make excellent photos with the three systems but having said that Canon would no be a choice for me personally for bird photography in 2024. It was by far the best choice when I first started in 2002
I would agree with your statement that a highly-skilled photographer can get great shots with any camera if this thread wasn’t about bird and wildlife photography. The camera makes an enormous difference and thus it makes sense to only consider the top models.

On Canon, let’s see what they roll out this month.


using the right tool for the job makes a difference I do agree, but having the best gear does not equal great photographs. At the end of the day a hammer does not build a house. I see quite a few photographers with the latest 20K+ gear only to produce the same shots they did before, soft, noisy, wrong angle, bird flying away etc. yet I see many award winning photos excellent both technically and aesthetically produced by the older (obsolete) gear and printed for display at museums around the world. While I wouldn't want to go back to the Canon days, I did produce many great shots with it. I had to work much harder, but it was possible.

I myself do happen to get the latest and greatest now, but I have worked on my skills for a while. IMO learning the art and the skill for a beginner comes before getting in the race to buy the latest and the greatest. Now the OP may already be experienced so in that case the best makes sense, and by all means get the best if you can....just pointing out some general observation...
May 06, 2024 at 10:09 PM
tctmp
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Douglas L wrote:
I found the debate about the dependence on using new technology to get "THE" shot very interesting. I can see both sides' points. I am in the camp that believe newer technology will no doubt increases the odds of getting "THE" shot, all things equal. I am obsessed with getting a 100% perfect head-on opposing passes of the Blue Angels or the Thunderbirds, the A1 is pretty good at that at 30 FPS and I was close (say 98% perfect) getting the perfect shot twice, but still not 100% perfect. I just ordered an A9III to try for this
...Show more →

The chance of what you are after can be estimated. It's said that they have a combined speed of 1000 mph during crosses. That's about 440 meters per second. If you shoot 20fps, the average error will be 11 meters. If you shoot 120fps, the average error will be about 1.8 meters. F18 has a length of 17 meters. 99% perfect means error of 0.17 meters. That will take about 10 crosses at 120fps on average assuming no other deficiencies.

Having said that, many times the crosses are never lined up to begin with. In that case, it's entirely out of the photographer's control, regardless how good the skill is or the equipment used.
May 06, 2024 at 10:49 PM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
tctmp wrote:
Douglas L wroteI found the debate about the dependence on using new technology to get "THE" shot very interesting. I can see both sides' points. I am in the camp that believe newer technology will no doubt increases the odds of getting "THE" shot, all things equal. I am obsessed with getting a 100% perfect head-on opposing passes of the Blue Angels or the Thunderbirds, the A1 is pretty good at that at 30 FPS and I was close (say 98% perfect) getting the perfect shot twice, but still not 100% perfect. I just ordered an A9III to try for this particular purpose, call me crazy.

I know some will say 10 FPS is more than enough if you know what you are doing. I think that has a lot to do with luck sometimes. An airshow buddy of mine who goes to 20 airshows a year got a perfect head-on opposing pass shot last year with his Z9, he said he may never be able to get the same shot in the next 15 years. Statistically, 120 FPS is 5 times more likely in getting "THE" shot than 20 FPS, in the same photographer's hand, as least that's how I see it.
The chance of what you are after can be estimated. It's said that they have a combined speed of 1000 mph during crosses. That's about 440 meters per second. If you shoot 20fps, the average error will be 11 meters. If you shoot 120fps, the average error will be about 1.8 meters. F18 has a length of 17 meters. 99% perfect means error of 0.17 meters. That will take about 10 crosses at 120fps on average assuming no other deficiencies.

Having said that, many times the crosses are never lined up to begin with. In that case, it's entirely out of
...Show more →

Thanks for doing the math! No question 120 FPS will increase the odds of getting the shot tremendously. I may try 120 FPS precapture for 0.5 second. A lot also depends on my skill in keeping the jet I am following in the frame. I can also increase the shutter speed even further to increase the odds.

I got these 4 shots in 2022, almost there but no cigar. It may mean nothing to 99.9999999% of the people but I have been trying to get a 100% perfect shot for 14 years. It is not going to get me anything other than some self satisfaction and bragging rights. The A1 got me closer to that goal than any camera I owned before that, I have no doubt the A9III will get me even closer under the same conditions. It's just a matter of statistics.

Both the second shot of the Thunderbirds and the Blue Angels, respectfully, was the very next shot after the first one, it shows how far they traveled in between shots (30 FPS) at 1/4000 second (the T birds) and 1/5000 second (the Blue Angels). Again, better tools help, all other things being equal.





  ILCE-1    FE 200-600mm F5.6-6.3 G OSS lens    376mm    f/6.3    1/4000s    200 ISO    -1.0 EV  






  ILCE-1    FE 200-600mm F5.6-6.3 G OSS lens    376mm    f/6.3    1/4000s    200 ISO    -1.0 EV  






  ILCE-1    FE 200-600mm F5.6-6.3 G OSS lens    489mm    f/6.3    1/5000s    500 ISO    -0.3 EV  






  ILCE-1    FE 200-600mm F5.6-6.3 G OSS lens    489mm    f/6.3    1/5000s    500 ISO    -0.3 EV  

May 07, 2024 at 04:06 AM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote:
As a hobbyist I don’t enjoy sorting through a thousand nearly identical photos. Imagine if I shot at 120fps.


Imagine not understanding that the A9III has a completely different workflow available than "sorting through a thousand nearly identical photos".



Watch and learn something...
May 07, 2024 at 01:25 PM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
johnvanr wrote:
lightskyland wrote
Earlier quoteI simply cannot imagine that anyone wants that special shot so badly that he/she would regularly look through multiple 120fps bursts. Maybe I lack imagination…
There are actually special tools for doing this to make it quick and efficient.
Which ones?


This is built right into the camera to make it easy to treat a burst of images like a single image, delete an entire burst, view it as a video, then mark and download only the images you want:


May 07, 2024 at 01:31 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #18Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Who is culling in the field?
May 07, 2024 at 01:43 PM
Laslo Varadi
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote:
Laslo Varadi wroteAs a hobbyist I don’t enjoy sorting through a thousand nearly identical photos. Imagine if I shot at 120fps.
Imagine not understanding that the A9III has a completely different workflow available than "sorting through a thousand nearly identical photos".



Watch and learn something...


I have the A1 and not interested in the A9iii until it has at least a 50-60mp sensor. I did look at the video and while it was short, can we also use a similar approach on the A1. I use Adobe Bridge and large monitor to do the culling. I wonder how that would work if I group the photos in camera. I think both Nikon and Sony can do that.
May 07, 2024 at 01:57 PM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
RoamingScott wrote:
Who is culling in the field?


The same methodology can and will eventually be implemented in bridge, LR, C1 etc. But they can use this approach right now to avoid "sorting through thousands of images" at 120 FPS.
May 07, 2024 at 02:24 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister