p.2 #1Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Great viewpoints and thanks to all of you who took the time to reply!
I am going to wait for the R5II, as suggested by arbitrage and others. Nikon is a surprise entry here as I never considered it. Multiple reasons for that:
1. None of the pro photographers I have gone on tours with have used Nikon
2. Top wildlife photographers I follow on youtube/instagram show images with Nikon
3. In the early days of my photography journey, my opinion was Nikon's overall Image Quality was slightly less than Canon's.
I am still leaning towards Sony, assuming I can afford an A9III or A1 with some planning. With a decent 200-600 lens and great glass available for rent, it seems a decent compromise. I feel Nikon lags behind in innovation and while great on paper, on-field performance does not reflect the specs. PLease feel free to disabuse me of this notion (or point me towards great images!)
p.2 #2Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
The Sigma 500mm f5.6 is also available on emout for a very reasonable price but it does come with a max 15fps in AF-C mode on the A1/A9 bodies and isn’t compatible with TCs.
Even though this is the Sony forum for wildlife/birding in particular Nikon’s super tele lens range is easily the best on the market at the moment. Paired with a Z9 or Z8 that would be a very powerful setup. But so would an A1 with the GM super teles.
p.2 #3Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote: telyt wroteAmbientMike wroteSony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.
Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts300mm f/2.8 GM
400mm f/2.8 GM
600mm f/4 GM
100-400 GM
200-600 G
No supertele lenses?300 GM is $6000 and you need to play with TCs to get to 600mm which is minimum for birding . The 400 and 600 are $10000 or more and heavy. The 100-400 is too short for birding. The 200-600 is an excellent at good price lens but heavy and I usually have to shoot it at 600mm. I’m in both the Sony and Nikon systems and there is nothing now unfortunately in the Sony system that compares with the compact and lightweight Nikon 600 PF or the larger but still handhold able 800PF both of which are less expensive than the Sony alternatives that take you to that range. The 200-600 is not as good as the 600pf.
p.2 #4Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote:
do you really want to start a pissing match?
Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.
p.2 #5Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
freaklikeme wrote: telyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.
The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?
p.2 #6Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote: freaklikeme wrotetelyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?
On the 6700, the 100-400GM looks very much like a 150-600, and I can add TCs to extend that range. I'm limited to 11fps and 26mp, but, you know, everything that's supposed to be in focus is in focus. The rest is just timing. Can Nikon promise me all that in as small and capable a package?
Yep, the GM's more expensive and worth every penny to me. On my rV with the 2x, I can still get 26mp at a 900 equivalent. I'd love to say that comes in more handy, but I rarely have the atmospherics necessary to make anything over 600 pay off. Having the 300/2.8's more likely to pay off for me in the end. If I do have the atmospherics for it, then I'll borrow a 600GM.
p.2 #7Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote: freaklikeme wrotetelyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?
p.2 #8Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
freaklikeme wrote: Laslo Varadi wrotefreaklikeme wrotetelyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?On the 6700, the 100-400GM looks very much like a 150-600, and I can add TCs to extend that range. I'm limited to 11fps and 26mp, but, you know, everything that's supposed to be in focus is in focus. The rest is just timing. Can Nikon promise me all that in as small and capable a package?
Yep, the GM's more expensive and worth every penny to me. On my rV with the 2x, I can still get 26mp at a 900 equivalent. I'd love to say that comes in more handy, but I rarely have the atmospherics necessary to make anything over 600 pay off. Having the 300/2.8's more likely to pay off for me in the end. If I do have the atmospherics for it, then I'll borrow a 600GM....Show more →
There is no comparison between the Z8 and the A6700. I prefer the size of the Z8. And with a 1.4Tc, on a 600 pf and z8 in crop mode you are still out gunned. And does the Sony 600 GM come with a built in teleconverter like the Nikon 600 f4? And let’s no forget the Nikon 800 pf . Take a look at the photos on the Nikon forum. I see some pretty good results with it.
p.2 #9Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote: freaklikeme wroteLaslo Varadi wrotefreaklikeme wrotetelyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?On the 6700, the 100-400GM looks very much like a 150-600, and I can add TCs to extend that range. I'm limited to 11fps and 26mp, but, you know, everything that's supposed to be in focus is in focus. The rest is just timing. Can Nikon promise me all that in as small and capable a package?
Yep, the GM's more expensive and worth every penny to me. On my rV with the 2x, I can still get 26mp at a 900 equivalent. I'd love to say that comes in more handy, but I rarely have the atmospherics necessary to make anything over 600 pay off. Having the 300/2.8's more likely to pay off for me in the end. If I do have the atmospherics for it, then I'll borrow a 600GM.There is no comparison between the Z8 and the A6700. I prefer the size of the Z8. And with a 1.4Tc, on a 600 pf and z8 in crop mode you are still out gunned. And does the Sony 600 GM come with a built in teleconverter like the Nikon 600 f4? And let’s no forget the Nikon 800 pf . Take a look at the photos on the Nikon forum. I see some pretty good results with it.
I have nothing against the Nikon system, in fact the z8 + 600 PF was on my short list for a hiking camera before the 300 GM's specs were known. The a1+ 300 GM + TCs meets my needs better for a hiking camera. No need to be defensive about your favorite brand.
May 05, 2024 at 10:22 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.2 #10Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
arbitrage wrote: telyt wroteAmbientMike wroteSony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.
Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts300mm f/2.8 GM
400mm f/2.8 GM
600mm f/4 GM
100-400 GM
200-600 G
No supertele lenses?Just ignore him....he is the biggest Canon apologist on these forums....and he shoots a Rebel yet speaks as if he has a clue about flagship cameras and flagship glass.
I'm so ignorant, you had to attack me more personally, ad opposed to the substance of my post
You are going to have to ignore me, and reality, if you want to believe Sony has a lot of teles, vs Canon and Nikon
Funny, read one of your annoying Sony apologist posts on the Nikon board recently. Rebels don't have a known issue of parts cracking
May 05, 2024 at 10:55 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.2 #11Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote: AmbientMike wroteSony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.
Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts300mm f/2.8 GM
400mm f/2.8 GM
600mm f/4 GM
100-400 GM
200-600 G
No supertele lenses?
Canon has multiple versions 9f most of these; 200/2, 300/2.8, 400/4, 400/2.8, 200-400/4, 500/4, 600/4, 800/5.6, 1200/8 (and a few 5.6's)
The 200-600 is 50% heavier than the 100-500, Canon has 200-800, 1.5 lb Rf 100-400, sub-3lb 600/11 & 800/11. And I haven't mentioned them all, and could easily be forgetting some
p.2 #12Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote: Laslo Varadi wrotefreaklikeme wroteLaslo Varadi wrotefreaklikeme wrotetelyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?On the 6700, the 100-400GM looks very much like a 150-600, and I can add TCs to extend that range. I'm limited to 11fps and 26mp, but, you know, everything that's supposed to be in focus is in focus. The rest is just timing. Can Nikon promise me all that in as small and capable a package?
Yep, the GM's more expensive and worth every penny to me. On my rV with the 2x, I can still get 26mp at a 900 equivalent. I'd love to say that comes in more handy, but I rarely have the atmospherics necessary to make anything over 600 pay off. Having the 300/2.8's more likely to pay off for me in the end. If I do have the atmospherics for it, then I'll borrow a 600GM.There is no comparison between the Z8 and the A6700. I prefer the size of the Z8. And with a 1.4Tc, on a 600 pf and z8 in crop mode you are still out gunned. And does the Sony 600 GM come with a built in teleconverter like the Nikon 600 f4? And let’s no forget the Nikon 800 pf . Take a look at the photos on the Nikon forum. I see some pretty good results with it.I have nothing against the Nikon system, in fact the z8 + 600 PF was on my short list for a hiking camera before the 300 GM's specs were known. The a1+ 300 GM + TCs meets my needs better for a hiking camera. No need to be defensive about your favorite brand.
I shoot with a Z9/Z8 + 400mm TC and 600mm TC and I was looking at the 300mm 2.8 as it does look like an impressive lens. I was able to try out the A9iii the other day and I was really liked it. Not enough to ditch my Nikon kit but enough to consider adding it along with the 300mm for when I hike around.
p.2 #13Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote:
The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?
300gm is f/5.6 at 600. 600pf is f/6.3 at 600, right? Everyone knows the #1 indicator is the aperture value at a given focal length. If you bring up 800pf, maybe. But 600pf, no, it won't be a lens that will interest people to use a different system over 300gm.
AmbientMike wrote:
Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.
Who cares what Canon did in 80s. It's totally irrelevant. What matters is who has the best equipment today. In fact, other than financial companies, very few companies can stay on top for a long time. Look at where Minolta is now. Didn't it have better AF than Canon in 80s. So I consider it a negative on the business if someone has to brag about what happened 30 years ago since it implies they don't have much good to say about current situation.
AmbientMike wrote:
Canon has multiple versions 9f most of these; 200/2, 300/2.8, 400/4, 400/2.8, 200-400/4, 500/4, 600/4, 800/5.6, 1200/8 (and a few 5.6's)
The 200-600 is 50% heavier than the 100-500, Canon has 200-800, 1.5 lb Rf 100-400, sub-3lb 600/11 & 800/11. And I haven't mentioned them all, and could easily be forgetting some
It doesn't matter whether Canon has one or 10 versions of a same lens. The only thing matters is how the latest version compares to other companies'. We could care even less on how many of those f/8, f/11 lens Canon puts out. If you are the type who cares about that, we are certainly on different wavelengths and have different interests.
p.2 #14Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
To me, much of this is talking about marginal differences. As I said, all the top-tier cameras will be perfectly fine. And unless you are a weightlifter and have tons of money, it doesn’t matter how many lenses a brand offers, but whether it offers the lens(es) you want and can afford.
I’ve seen stunning images taken with all brands. Morten Hilmer just released a video where he talks about his gear and while he has two of the new Nikon superteles, he often uses the 180-600mm instead.
p.2 #15Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
please note the most important factor in getting great shots with any camera is skill of the photographer. A highly skilled photographer can get great shots with any camera. Beginners typically can get much better ROI by spending their $$$ on workshops, classes and resources first and upgrading gear second.
Now if we want to compare camera systems once one has mastered the skills there are some differences
I switched away from Canon in 2018, back then the Canon 1DXII AF really lacked compared to the Nikon D5. You will find that many top bird photographers switched away from Canon around that timeframe... When I switched to mirrorless both Canon and Nikon were out of the game, Nikon has caught up since then, especially with many attractive premium and specialized ZF lenses, but Canon still are way behind the game if you want the best in bird photography.
They are lagging behind in both bodies and lenses. Their top camera is still only 24 mega pixels (about same as my old 1DXII from 2015) which isn't enough for someone like me and the AF is still behind Sony or Nikon when it comes to BIF.... they just glued an adaptor to their old super tele's while their brand new RF lenses are cheap slow f/8 and f/11 zoom's mainly, I'd personally pass on such lenses. If you don't have the budget to buy faster or super telephoto lenses I would look at second had market, Sony has the 200-600 and Nikon has many "lower cost" great lenses, I would chose between these lenses. again you will see a skilled photographer make excellent photos with the three systems but having said that Canon would no be a choice for me personally for bird photography in 2024. It was by far the best choice when I first started in 2002
p.2 #16Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
sony for portrait ,studio and event ,canon for documentry and sports ,nikon for wildlife ,but all will have cross overs and all will get the job done, but i would say that sony could do better for users firmware has been slack and 3rd party limitations ,Nikon love there users with firmware and unique lenses but also try and trick them with overpriced rebadged lenses ,Canon is the odd one ,but once the 3rd party lens restriction gets dropped ,they will be a obvious choice for many canon make very enjoyable products that work well and there lower tier gear is very comparable to the high end gear .choices?
p.2 #17Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
As a multiple system shooter who currently only really just trying to break into BIF I’Ve owned the Z9 + 500PF but still own my Sony A1’s with 100-400 GM and 200-600 G and Canon R5 with a RF 100-500. This has been a really interesting thread and will continue to follow and look for direction.
I gave up on the Z9 because it was heavy and there was no Z8 or lighter body to pair it with. Wasn’t patient enough for them to fill out the system. Owned first the 500 PF with F mount and then the 400/4.5 Z with 1.4X TC. While I tried the Z9 I already had the A1 (x2) + 200-600 G and decided to return to it since I also used Sony for the 61 Mpixel cameras for landscape and general photography which started with Canon, which I still own as well. Lack of a higher Mpixel stacked sensor has kept my Canon stale for BIF and wondering if I should just sell it all even though it takes great pictures for everything below 400mm.
Need you guys to help me out. Thank you.
Now looking to “focus” more and commit to a BIF kit. Should I just go get a 600 GM
p.2 #18Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
swldstn wrote:
As a multiple system shooter who currently only really just trying to break into BIF I’Ve owned the Z9 + 500PF but still own my Sony A1’s with 100-400 GM and 200-600 G and Canon R5 with a RF 100-500. This has been a really interesting thread and will continue to follow and look for direction.
I gave up on the Z9 because it was heavy and there was no Z8 or lighter body to pair it with. Wasn’t patient enough for them to fill out the system. Owned first the 500 PF with F mount and then the 400/4.5 Z with 1.4X TC. While I tried the Z9 I already had the A1 (x2) + 200-600 G and decided to return to it since I also used Sony for the 61 Mpixel cameras for landscape and general photography which started with Canon, which I still own as well. Lack of a higher Mpixel stacked sensor has kept my Canon stale for BIF and wondering if I should just sell it all even though it takes great pictures for everything below 400mm.
Need you guys to help me out. Thank you.
Now looking to “focus” more and commit to a BIF kit. Should I just go get a 600 GM...Show more →
Personally I prefer single system photography. It takes a lot of practice to develop "muscle memory" and learn a single system well, much less three different systems.
I see Sony as the leader in photography since the release of the A9, while Canon and Nikon have been several years behind in terms of releasing lenses, bodies etc. that equal Sony's offerings. Who knows when Canon and Nikon will release anything competitive with the A9III?
I think picking one system and learning it well is likely more productive.
p.2 #20Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
swldstn wrote:
As a multiple system shooter who currently only really just trying to break into BIF I’Ve owned the Z9 + 500PF but still own my Sony A1’s with 100-400 GM and 200-600 G and Canon R5 with a RF 100-500. This has been a really interesting thread and will continue to follow and look for direction.
I gave up on the Z9 because it was heavy and there was no Z8 or lighter body to pair it with. Wasn’t patient enough for them to fill out the system. Owned first the 500 PF with F mount and then the 400/4.5 Z with 1.4X TC. While I tried the Z9 I already had the A1 (x2) + 200-600 G and decided to return to it since I also used Sony for the 61 Mpixel cameras for landscape and general photography which started with Canon, which I still own as well. Lack of a higher Mpixel stacked sensor has kept my Canon stale for BIF and wondering if I should just sell it all even though it takes great pictures for everything below 400mm.
Need you guys to help me out. Thank you.
Now looking to “focus” more and commit to a BIF kit. Should I just go get a 600 GM...Show more →
Z8 always represents a temptation. If I remember correctly, both Geoff and Douglas tried Z8 recently. @arbitrage, @Douglas L, care to elaborate for us what lens you tested with Z8, and what's the conclusion on AF, etc, compared to A1. Thanks.