This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.
Archive 2024Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.5 #1Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote: RoamingScott wroteWho is culling in the field? The same methodology can and will eventually be implemented in bridge, LR, C1 etc. But they can use this approach right now to avoid "sorting through thousands of images" at 120 FPS.
blah blah blah
so you HAVE to cull in the field today. no one is doing that
p.5 #2Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote: johnvanr wroteWho cares when they introduced things.People who don't want to wait 3,4,5 years for a 120 FPS camera from Canon and Nikon and are using the A9III since February.
My verb was the past tense. As in the stock market, past performance does not predict future performance.
p.5 #3Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
speedmaster20d wrote: johnvanr wrotespeedmaster20d wroteplease note the most important factor in getting great shots with any camera is skill of the photographer. A highly skilled photographer can get great shots with any camera. Beginners typically can get much better ROI by spending their $$$ on workshops, classes and resources first and upgrading gear second.
Now if we want to compare camera systems once one has mastered the skills there are some differences
I switched away from Canon in 2018, back then the Canon 1DXII AF really lacked compared to the Nikon D5. You will find that many top bird photographers switched away from Canon around that timeframe... When I switched to mirrorless both Canon and Nikon were out of the game, Nikon has caught up since then, especially with many attractive premium and specialized ZF lenses, but Canon still are way behind the game if you want the best in bird photography.
They are lagging behind in both bodies and lenses. Their top camera is still only 24 mega pixels (about same as my old 1DXII from 2015) which isn't enough for someone like me and the AF is still behind Sony or Nikon when it comes to BIF.... they just glued an adaptor to their old super tele's while their brand new RF lenses are cheap slow f/8 and f/11 zoom's mainly, I'd personally pass on such lenses. If you don't have the budget to buy faster or super telephoto lenses I would look at second had market, Sony has the 200-600 and Nikon has many "lower cost" great lenses, I would chose between these lenses. again you will see a skilled photographer make excellent photos with the three systems but having said that Canon would no be a choice for me personally for bird photography in 2024. It was by far the best choice when I first started in 2002 I would agree with your statement that a highly-skilled photographer can get great shots with any camera if this thread wasn’t about bird and wildlife photography. The camera makes an enormous difference and thus it makes sense to only consider the top models.
On Canon, let’s see what they roll out this month.using the right tool for the job makes a difference I do agree, but having the best gear does not equal great photographs. At the end of the day a hammer does not build a house. I see quite a few photographers with the latest 20K+ gear only to produce the same shots they did before, soft, noisy, wrong angle, bird flying away etc. yet I see many award winning photos excellent both technically and aesthetically produced by the older (obsolete) gear and printed for display at museums around the world. While I wouldn't want to go back to the Canon days, I did produce many great shots with it. I had to work much harder, but it was possible.
I myself do happen to get the latest and greatest now, but I have worked on my skills for a while. IMO learning the art and the skill for a beginner comes before getting in the race to buy the latest and the greatest. Now the OP may already be experienced so in that case the best makes sense, and by all means get the best if you can....just pointing out some general observation... ...Show more →
Agree overall, but another element of great shots is the knowledge and ability to travel to the best locations at the best of times. That’s where a lot of amateurs lose out to the pros.
p.5 #4Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
RoamingScott wrote:
Who is culling in the field?
Unfortunately a few people I know and who therefore miss shots all the time while they chimp and cull during the down times.
But you could use the A9III's in camera features back at home before doing the download to the computer I guess.
What I found with the A9III is that even though I had 8000+ images on a card I got through them in very short order because you can just hold down the right arrow in a good culling program like PhotoMechanic or Winnow and it basically plays the 60 or 120 as a movie and you only want one or two ideal frames in every 100 or 200 shots so it is very quick to go through that many shots.
p.5 #7Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
I don't think you can go wrong with any of the systems. I shot Canon for a long time. When it was obvious they were't keeping up I switched to Sony thru the A9. Then when the R5 came out I switched back to Canon. Now I alternate shooting between the Canon and OM systems. Looking back on my photos I couldn't tell which camera I used. Get something that fits your price point and skill level and don't look back. Most importantly know your camera and its capabilities up and down.
Correction - there are shots I can get with my OM system Pro capture that would be very difficult to get in the Sony or Canon systems.
p.5 #8Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
call me crazy.
Ok. You're crazy . Can you stop down the lens so the distant plane is in (better) focus? It looks like the more distant plane has movement blur, which is some kind of optical illusion. Don't know if stopping down will work given the distance between the planes.
p.5 #9Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Robin Smith wrote: Earlier quotecall me crazy.Ok. You're crazy . Can you stop down the lens so the distant plane is in (better) focus? It looks like the more distant plane has movement blur, which is some kind of optical illusion. Don't know if stopping down will work given the distance between the planes.
Actually it is motion blur. At a crossing speed of 1000mph, that's a movement of 0.1 meters or 4 inches at a shutter speed of 1/5000. And the reason there is no blur on the other plane is because he's panning based on that one.
p.5 #10Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
tctmp wrote: Robin Smith wroteEarlier quotecall me crazy.Ok. You're crazy . Can you stop down the lens so the distant plane is in (better) focus? It looks like the more distant plane has movement blur, which is some kind of optical illusion. Don't know if stopping down will work given the distance between the planes.Actually it is motion blur. At a crossing speed of 1000mph, that's a movement of 0.1 meters or 4 inches at a shutter speed of 1/5000. And the reason there is no blur on the other plane is because he's panning based on that one.
I think the A9III is the only tool that could possibly prevent that at the moment, correct?
p.5 #11Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
tctmp wrote: Robin Smith wroteEarlier quotecall me crazy.Ok. You're crazy . Can you stop down the lens so the distant plane is in (better) focus? It looks like the more distant plane has movement blur, which is some kind of optical illusion. Don't know if stopping down will work given the distance between the planes.Actually it is motion blur. At a crossing speed of 1000mph, that's a movement of 0.1 meters or 4 inches at a shutter speed of 1/5000. And the reason there is no blur on the other plane is because he's panning based on that one.
Panning was certainly a factor that contributed to the blurriness of the jet in the back. In IMHO, the depth of field may have even more to do with it. In reality the jets are not as close they appear in pictures in those opposing passes, due to safety reasons obviously. I think the combination of the compression effect of telephoto lenses and certain shooting angles make them appear to be really close. I don’t think I can make the jet in the back look sharp unless I shoot at f13 or even narrower. I can give it a try.
p.5 #12Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
artsupreme wrote: tctmp wroteRobin Smith wroteEarlier quotecall me crazy.Ok. You're crazy . Can you stop down the lens so the distant plane is in (better) focus? It looks like the more distant plane has movement blur, which is some kind of optical illusion. Don't know if stopping down will work given the distance between the planes.Actually it is motion blur. At a crossing speed of 1000mph, that's a movement of 0.1 meters or 4 inches at a shutter speed of 1/5000. And the reason there is no blur on the other plane is because he's panning based on that one.I think the A9III is the only tool that could possibly prevent that at the moment, correct?
I highly doubt it. I don’t think the blurriness of the jet in the back had anything to do with fast or slow FPS. I think the blurriness was caused by panning, and even more so by the depth of field issued because the real distance between the two jets were far greater than it appeared.
Sorry for getting way of topic from the OP’s question.
p.5 #13Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Douglas L wrote:
Panning was certainly a factor that contributed to the blurriness of the jet in the back. In IMHO, the depth of field may have even more to do with it. In reality the jets are not as close they appear in pictures in those opposing passes, due to safety reasons obviously. I think the combination of the compression effect of telephoto lenses and certain shooting angles make them appear to be really close. I don’t think I can make the jet in the back look sharp unless I shoot at f13 or even narrower. I can give it a try....Show more →
I'm not sure even f/13 will work. Looking at the letters and other markings on the back plane, the blur is pretty much in the horizontal direction. I think we most likely will just have to live with it.
artsupreme wrote:
I think the A9III is the only tool that could possibly prevent that at the moment, correct?
Unfortunately not. Motion blur is pretty much only a function of movement relative to the shutter speed. What A9iii solves completely is the rolling shutter effect which is distortion of moving vertical objects, but not blur.
p.5 #14Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
tctmp wrote: Douglas L wrotePanning was certainly a factor that contributed to the blurriness of the jet in the back. In IMHO, the depth of field may have even more to do with it. In reality the jets are not as close they appear in pictures in those opposing passes, due to safety reasons obviously. I think the combination of the compression effect of telephoto lenses and certain shooting angles make them appear to be really close. I don’t think I can make the jet in the back look sharp unless I shoot at f13 or even narrower. I can give it a try.I'm not sure even f/13 will work. Looking at the letters and other markings on the back plane, the blur is pretty much in the horizontal direction. I think we most likely will just have to live with it.
artsupreme wroteI think the A9III is the only tool that could possibly prevent that at the moment, correct?Unfortunately not. Motion blur is pretty much only a function of movement relative to the shutter speed. What A9iii solves completely is the rolling shutter effect which is distortion of moving vertical objects, but not blur.
Yes, but doesn't the A9III have a very high max shutter speed? Wouldn't 5x the SS mean a lot less motion blur?
p.5 #15Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
I've been shooting with Sony A1 and have been using the Nikon Z9 since it came out. I very much enjoy the fact that all my Sony lenses work just fine on the Z9 with the ETZ21 adapter. I may go back to Canon some day but the one lens that keeps me in the Sony camp is the Sony 200-600 lens. For birds/wildlife it's perfect for me.
I also shoot astro and I prefer the Z9 for astro work. It's easier to manual focus, has illuminated buttons and with the larger battery, lasts a lot longer in cold conditions.
Here are a few comparisons A1 vs Z9/Z8:
Ergonomics / Menus: Prefer the A1 (I much prefer memory settings via a dial than vs banks. I also don't have to futz with buttons as much to get autofocus to work on birds.)
Autofocus: A1 tends not to grab the background (and get stuck on the background) as much as the Z9/Z8. Nikon has closed the gap on this with firmware changes, but still prefer the A1's autofocus system.
Video: Hands down the Z9/Z8. (Not sure your interest in video, but I do a lot of wildlife videos. At present the Z9/Z8 is much better with video options, although the A1 has a bit more dynamic range with SLOG3.) I love the fact that I can punch in (DX/FX) 4k slow motion with the press of a button. Very handy. Also, no bird eye detect on the A1 for video.
Would I ever go back to Canon? Video options on the R5 and R3 have held me back. Canon needs to stop dumbing-down their stills/hybrid cameras to differentiate themselves from their cinema cameras. Hard to use codecs, lack of SLOG2 and "overheating" that's not real are a few of my irritants.
The bottom line however is that all three (Sony, Nikon and Canon) have cameras and lenses that create fantastic images at this stage. It really boils down to ergonomics and what camera you feel comfortable using. I suggest borrowing a camera/lens from a friend if you can or renting a system to try out for at least a week if not more. The learning curves are somewhat steep on all of these cameras and it doesn't matter what I think or anyone else. It's whatever system you feel most comfortable using. That's the bottom line in my opinion.
p.5 #16Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
I'm not sure even f/13 will work.
It depends how much panning movement is expected to impact the image when using a very high shutter speed 1/8000+ or so. Stop down to f16, up the ISO, and give it a try. He might as well see.