fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?

  
 
theobserver
Offline

p.1 #1Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Hi

I have been shooting Canon for more than 7-8 years now, from the 550D to 1DX Mark III and so have decent experience with the Canons. I will note that I haven't used mirrorless at all till now though from any manufacturer.

After a somewhat long break, I am looking to get back into wildlife and bird photography. I have a Canon 100-400 MKII, so my preference is Canon, but I am open to selling that lens and moving to Sony, if that's a better system.

I can afford the Canon R5, so its equivalent on Sony would be ok (with the 200-600 as the standard lens). I can rent the big primes on either system.

Given the capabilities of these 2 systems in terms of IQ and autofocus seem to be similar (?), I am confused. I see a log of professional photographers have moved to Sony from Canon/Nikon, so not sure if that's because of Sony's marketing (sponsor all gear type) or there is something genuinely better about Sony.

Hit me with questions for info/nuance that I know I am missing.
May 04, 2024 at 06:21 PM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
A relevant fact: Sony A9 was released in 2017. It was the first full frame mirrorless with a stacked sensor.
Sony A9, A93 and A1 have stacked sensor. So do Nikon Z9 and Z8. And Canon R3.
Stacked sensors provide big benefits for action photography.
Check release dates for Canon and Nikon stacked sensors.
There is a big reason for so many moving to Sony.
May 04, 2024 at 06:45 PM
Jeffgraham
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Hoping to see Canon come out with a 45MP+ Stacked Sensor soon. This IMO is the biggest advantage Sony and Nikon have over Canon. The ability to crop for BIF is huge. If you are not shooting birds this is not as big of an advantage.

Mirrorless is the future IMO. I dont think any Mfgr is putting much effort into DSLRs, So now is the time to plan on a system. Nikon is really starting to shine in the mirrorless lens department. But all of them have really nice optics.

Sony IMO leads the way in speed and sensor tech. --- Makes for a tough choice.
I am currently shooting with an Sony A1, A9m2 and A7R3. The A1 does everything so well that I rarely reach for the others. (The A9 at 24MP is just not enough and for me this eliminates the A9III for me)

Would be worth handling each brand to narrow down what feels best. Then Rent one to see if fits the bill.
Wildlife systems are so expensive that you really get committed to a system quickly once you buy a lens or two.

Lastly I suspect A new Sony A1M2 is around the corner and likely a Flagship Canon with 45+MP so you may want to hang on for that.
Good luck on a decision
May 04, 2024 at 08:37 PM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Both Canon and Nikon seem to be committed to large bulky integrated vertical grips for their top-of-the-line cameras. IDK about others but I appreciate the smaller lighter top-of-the-line Sony bodies, especially when I carry a backup body into the field. Might be something to consider.

Something else to consider is the vast array of E-mount lenses available from other lens makers.
May 04, 2024 at 09:16 PM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
First of all, Canon is expected to announce two new cameras this month, so don’t buy Canon now.

If you buy the top tier cameras of any brand nowadays, you are becoming the weakest link in getting the shot. They’re all very good. So then it comes down to ergonomics (I never got used to Sony), lenses (I think Nikon offers the most interesting range) and what you’re willing to carry.

I finally settled on Olympus/OM System for my bird photography. I love it. I did sell my Canon 600mm f/4 and my Canon 100-500mm after the switch (but kept my R5). I also tried the A1 and always loved the Sony 200-600mm (amazing lens for the price).
May 05, 2024 at 01:21 AM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote:
Both Canon and Nikon seem to be committed to large bulky integrated vertical grips for their top-of-the-line cameras. IDK about others but I appreciate the smaller lighter top-of-the-line Sony bodies, especially when I carry a backup body into the field. Might be something to consider.

Something else to consider is the vast array of E-mount lenses available from other lens makers.


The Z8 doesn’t have an integrated grip (though it’s still quite large).
May 05, 2024 at 01:22 AM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
johnvanr wrote:
telyt wroteBoth Canon and Nikon seem to be committed to large bulky integrated vertical grips for their top-of-the-line cameras. IDK about others but I appreciate the smaller lighter top-of-the-line Sony bodies, especially when I carry a backup body into the field. Might be something to consider.

Something else to consider is the vast array of E-mount lenses available from other lens makers.
The Z8 doesn’t have an integrated grip (though it’s still quite large).


Also doesn't have dual fast card slots.
May 05, 2024 at 01:27 AM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
If I were in your shoe I would pick Nikon.
May 05, 2024 at 04:35 AM
AZHeaven
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Steve Perry from Backcountry Gallery seems to have switched back to Nikon even though he still uses his A1 from time to time.

Nikon equals bigger bodies vs Sony. But coming from Nikon (D7200) 6 years ago to Sony (A7III) the size of the grip I just got used to. The positive of Sony and to a lesser extent Nikon is that in Sony's case we have the choice of excellent 3rd party glass from Tamron, Sigma and Viltrox. Yes, Viltrox. I have their 16mm f1.8 and it's excellent.

With the 4 and 5th gen Sony bodies the grips have improved quite a bit.
May 05, 2024 at 08:18 AM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
AZHeaven wrote:
Steve Perry from Backcountry Gallery seems to have switched back to Nikon even though he still uses his A1 from time to time.


A few days ago he said he's taking the new 300 GM, TCs and the 600 GM to Botswana.

May 05, 2024 at 09:35 AM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
middlerockies wrote:
Nikon has proven themselves committed to the genre and want to dominate this space; Sony and Canon seem to be prioritizing the wide genres and sports/journalism on the long end.


Nikon's bodies aren't even competitive with the 3 year old Sony A1 much less remotely competitive with the A9III with global shutter (20 FPS RAW vs 120 FPS RAW). Nor do the Nikon bodies offer pre-capture in RAW.

JPEG-only functionality is a joke, IMO.
May 05, 2024 at 09:51 AM
robert_in_ca
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote:
AZHeaven wroteSteve Perry from Backcountry Gallery seems to have switched back to Nikon even though he still uses his A1 from time to time.
A few days ago he said he's taking the new 300 GM, TCs and the 600 GM to Botswana.



He has both systems but he does lean more towards Nikon... he headed out to Botswana yesterday and he is testing out the A9iii.

Edited on May 05, 2024 at 12:18 PM · View previous versions
May 05, 2024 at 11:13 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #13Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Sony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.

Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts
May 05, 2024 at 11:16 AM
robert_in_ca
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote:
middlerockies wroteNikon has proven themselves committed to the genre and want to dominate this space; Sony and Canon seem to be prioritizing the wide genres and sports/journalism on the long end.
Nikon's bodies aren't even competitive with the 3 year old Sony A1 much less remotely competitive with the A9III with global shutter (20 FPS RAW vs 120 FPS RAW). Nor do the Nikon bodies offer pre-capture in RAW.

JPEG-only functionality is a joke, IMO.


To say the Z9/Z8 doesn't compete with the A1 is simple not true. Also shooting pre-cap at 120 fps vs 20 fps has more to do with file size (ie: 24mp sensor vs 45mp sensor) and quickly needing to clear the buffer then it does with having a global shutter. For example the 2 year old 20mp OM-1 shoots up to 120 fps (maxes out at 50 fps when shooting AF tracking on) in RAW whereas the A1 doesn't even have pre-capture. It will be interesting to see what Sony does with the A1 Mk2 - but it's highly unlikely they will have pre-capture exceeding 20-30 fps in RAW.

May 05, 2024 at 11:30 AM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
AmbientMike wrote:
Sony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.

Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts


300mm f/2.8 GM
400mm f/2.8 GM
600mm f/4 GM
100-400 GM
200-600 G

No supertele lenses?
May 05, 2024 at 12:15 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote:
AmbientMike wroteSony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.

Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts
300mm f/2.8 GM
400mm f/2.8 GM
600mm f/4 GM
100-400 GM
200-600 G

No supertele lenses?


Just ignore him....he is the biggest Canon apologist on these forums....and he shoots a Rebel yet speaks as if he has a clue about flagship cameras and flagship glass.
May 05, 2024 at 01:07 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
robert_in_ca wrote:
lightskyland wrote
middlerockies wroteNikon has proven themselves committed to the genre and want to dominate this space; Sony and Canon seem to be prioritizing the wide genres and sports/journalism on the long end.
Nikon's bodies aren't even competitive with the 3 year old Sony A1 much less remotely competitive with the A9III with global shutter (20 FPS RAW vs 120 FPS RAW). Nor do the Nikon bodies offer pre-capture in RAW.

JPEG-only functionality is a joke, IMO.
To say the Z9/Z8 doesn't compete with the A1 is simple not true. Also shooting pre-cap at 120 fps vs 20 fps has more to do with file size (ie: 24mp sensor vs 45mp sensor) and quickly needing to clear the buffer then it does with having a global shutter. For example the 2 year old 20mp OM-1 shoots up to 120 fps (maxes out at 50 fps when shooting AF tracking on) in RAW whereas the A1 doesn't even have pre-capture. It will be interesting to see what Sony does with the A1 Mk2 - but it's highly unlikely
...Show more →

Unless the A9III's global shutter is needed to achieve the current 120FPS compressed RAW precapture than I don't see why a 50MP A1II won't be able to manage 60FPS compressed RAW precapture as it would be similar data going through the pipeline. Not to mention the A1II should be around a year later in tech advancements and likely support CFe-A Type 4 for double the card speed over the A9III.

The Nikon implenentation of pre-capture is an afterthought and useless in real world shooting. Jpeg only and having to menu dive just to turn it on are not conducive to using it in a workflow out in the field. The A9III's implementation is genius...well pretty much all Sony's customization options are genius. Having precapture be able to be toggled on/off with any custom button and having it work at full compressed RAW up to 120FPS means you can be in and out of precapture as you need it with a single click (I've been using a push of the joystick to toggle in and out). That combined with their new Boost custom button (which unlike what their marketing seemed to imply can be assigned to any button you like) to instantly increase or, if you'd rather, decrease your FPS either via a hold or a toggle is game changing when dealing with such high FPS options that would leave your culling finger exhausted if you ran at max all the time.
May 05, 2024 at 01:16 PM
Laslo Varadi
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
telyt wrote:
AmbientMike wroteSony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.

Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts
300mm f/2.8 GM
400mm f/2.8 GM
600mm f/4 GM
100-400 GM
200-600 G

No supertele lenses?

300 GM is $6000 and you need to play with TCs to get to 600mm which is minimum for birding . The 400 and 600 are $10000 or more and heavy. The 100-400 is too short for birding. The 200-600 is an excellent at good price lens but heavy and I usually have to shoot it at 600mm. I’m in both the Sony and Nikon systems and there is nothing now unfortunately in the Sony system that compares with the compact and lightweight Nikon 600 PF or the larger but still handhold able 800PF both of which are less expensive than the Sony alternatives that take you to that range. The 200-600 is not as good as the 600pf.

May 05, 2024 at 01:21 PM
lightskyland
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
AmbientMike wrote:
Sony has basically no supertele lenses. People gripe about Canon and it's a joke, Canon came out with 400/2.8 on FD in the 80's, Sony in 2018.

Sony has a couple interesting things, vs decades of options from Canon. Canon came out 1st light 600/4 and people have a hard time comprehending the innovation since they offered it in both Ef and Rf. Drives me nuts


Sony has basically no supertele lenses?

Wot?!

Sony has the 100-400GM, 200-600G, 300GM, 400GM, 600GM, 1.4x TC, 2.0 TC. If you don't need more than 15FPS, E-mount also has a boatload of third party supertele lenses, most of which are not available for Canon and Nikon native mounts.

Of course, Sony absolutely does need to remove the stupid limitations on third party glass. But saying "basically no supertele lenses" is bizarre.
May 05, 2024 at 01:25 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
To answer the OP...

I wouldn't make any decision until we see what Canon announces this month. The R5II could leap frog a lot of the others.

Like mentioned above, I really think that going to mirrorless and shooting any type of action/BIF you want to look at a stacked sensor camera. The only camera I'd look at without a stacked sensor right now is an R5.
So considerations would be high MP cameras A1, Z8, Z9, R5 or low Mp cameras A9, A9II, A9III, R3 (I guess maybe an R6II would also be a low-MP option on par with the R5 for sensor speed without being stacked).

Canon is in a bit of a rut. Ignoring the upcoming announcements I'd look at an R5 and RF100-500.

Nikon is hands down leader in wildlife glass. I'd look at Z8 (unless you want a bigger Z9 and/or dual CFe-B slots) paired with any number of their great glass...180-600, 100-400, 400/4.5, 600PF, 800PF or the exotic 400/600TC lenses. Such a range of lenses at all price points, all high quality and can all be paired with the most affordable high MP, stacked sensor available in the Z8.

Sony does IMO having owned all three system's top cameras still have the best AF, the best button layout and the best button/dial customization options...of course that also makes it the most confusing new system to learn but also the most customizable one once you figure it all out.
Sony is okay with lenses and offers a good selection but not as unique or broad as Nikon. You have the 200-600, 100-400, 300/2.8GM, 400/2.8GM and 600f/4GM. All excellent lenses for their price points.

Now I see you say you can afford the R5 and would buy something similar with Sony. The issue there is IMO the only Sony cameras worth buying are the A9 and A1 series and the A9 lacks MPs compared to an R5 (24 vs 45).
If your budget is more around the R5 level than I'd recommend going Nikon with a Z8 and 180-600.

That all said, if the R5II is a stacked sensor, at a similar R5 or Z8 price level, then and only then I'd maybe consider that with a RF100-500 since you are used to Canon and there is something to be said about being comfortable with a system since you are already making a big change going to mirrorless.
May 05, 2024 at 01:28 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister