p.3 #1Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote: swldstn wroteAs a multiple system shooter who currently only really just trying to break into BIF I’Ve owned the Z9 + 500PF but still own my Sony A1’s with 100-400 GM and 200-600 G and Canon R5 with a RF 100-500. This has been a really interesting thread and will continue to follow and look for direction.
I gave up on the Z9 because it was heavy and there was no Z8 or lighter body to pair it with. Wasn’t patient enough for them to fill out the system. Owned first the 500 PF with F mount and then the 400/4.5 Z with 1.4X TC. While I tried the Z9 I already had the A1 (x2) + 200-600 G and decided to return to it since I also used Sony for the 61 Mpixel cameras for landscape and general photography which started with Canon, which I still own as well. Lack of a higher Mpixel stacked sensor has kept my Canon stale for BIF and wondering if I should just sell it all even though it takes great pictures for everything below 400mm.
Need you guys to help me out. Thank you.
Now looking to “focus” more and commit to a BIF kit. Should I just go get a 600 GMPersonally I prefer single system photography. It takes a lot of practice to develop "muscle memory" and learn a single system well, much less three different systems.
I see Sony as the leader in photography since the release of the A9, while Canon and Nikon have been several years behind in terms of releasing lenses, bodies etc. that equal Sony's offerings. Who knows when Canon and Nikon will release anything competitive with the A9III?
I think picking one system and learning it well is likely more productive.
I totally agree with you and the Nikon is now gone. Really trying get the time, and energy to divest the Canon system but admit I’ve been hedging to see the R5II announcement later this month I think. Admit, I use multiple Sony bodies for different things where the small compact C full frame bodies have no real equivalent I think and like those for travel so Canon’s bodies and RF lenses can’t satisfy my full use needs.
p.3 #2Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Laslo Varadi wrote: freaklikeme wrotetelyt wrotedo you really want to start a pissing match?Yes, but I'm a little dehydrated right now. Also, I agree with you. The 300GM and its excellent performance with the extenders checked all the boxes for me. I would love for them to release an updated 100-400GM with their smaller/lighter/better engineering applied, but the current model lives on my 6700 when I'm hiking, and the combo hasn't disappointed me in the least.The 100-400 is not a 600mm. The 300gm with 2x tc is about $6300. The 600pf is now on sale for $4300. And I can shoot it at 840mm. Can you do that with the 300gm?
Technically yes...I have a short extension tube that allows me to stack the Sony 1.4TC and 2.0TC so I could get to 840 f/8 with the 300GM if I wanted to. Would it be any good? I don't know....yet. So far I've only shot my friends 300GM so I hadn't had the time to test stacked TCs. Once I own the 300GM (my plan as soon as my 400GM sells) I will certainly try 840 f/8 and see what happens. On past lenses I haven't been impressed but then again I'm hardly impressed by the 2.0TC on its own...that is until I used the 2xTC on the 300GM. That was so much better than on the other lenses...so maybe given how good it does with the 2xTC it may have a chance to work really well with the stacked TCs also??
Granted, all have posted their anecdotal evidences - but looks like I am in a tough spot in deciding which brand to commit to. For example, the 200-600 GM from Sony is something many photographers swear by (Karolina Noree), while many others say the z equivalents are much better.
All this is coming to a head because I have an upcoming safari to the Masai Mara in Dec, where I should take 2 bodies and 2 lenses at a minimum. While this may not be a once-in-a-lifetime trip, it certainly is expensive in terms of time and money. Big 5 and birds are going to be my key subjects. People, astro, macro are not interest areas at least for this trip.
Z9 + 600mm TC, Z8+400mm f2.8 plus a 70-200 2.8 zoom is what I was planning. Alternatively, the Sony A1with 600mm f4, A9III with either the 400 2.8 or the 200-600 is my choice.
With rentals, I know both combinations could work, but given that I am not a pro by any means (advanced beginner would be the best description), I don't want to be struggling with AF/IQ/FPS things during the safari.
I shoot uncompressed RAW all the time, so that I can correct minor mistakes in post
With this info, any specific recommendations you would make?
Granted, all have posted their anecdotal evidences - but looks like I am in a tough spot in deciding which brand to commit to. For example, the 200-600 GM from Sony is something many photographers swear by (Karolina Noree), while many others say the z equivalents are much better.
All this is coming to a head because I have an upcoming safari to the Masai Mara in Dec, where I should take 2 bodies and 2 lenses at a minimum. While this may not be a once-in-a-lifetime trip, it certainly is expensive in terms of time and money. Big 5 and birds are going to be my key subjects. People, astro, macro are not interest areas at least for this trip.
Z9 + 600mm TC, Z8+400mm f2.8 plus a 70-200 2.8 zoom is what I was planning. Alternatively, the Sony A1with 600mm f4, A9III with either the 400 2.8 or the 200-600 is my choice.
With rentals, I know both combinations could work, but given that I am not a pro by any means (advanced beginner would be the best description), I don't want to be struggling with AF/IQ/FPS things during the safari.
I shoot uncompressed RAW all the time, so that I can correct minor mistakes in post
With this info, any specific recommendations you would make?
not to worry about gear as much ,sony the 400mm f2.8 i would take the sony 300mm f2.8 instead it will be lighter and more enjoyable and covers 400mm also ,as well as a wider view ,Nikons well the lenses for the big primes have a advantage built in t/c ,but that will be one heavy bag to carry . Difficult guess it depends on how long it will take to get accustomed to the systems the A1 is the easiest af system to understand it just works ,not a lot of set up time needed from my experience
Granted, all have posted their anecdotal evidences - but looks like I am in a tough spot in deciding which brand to commit to. For example, the 200-600 GM from Sony is something many photographers swear by (Karolina Noree), while many others say the z equivalents are much better.
All this is coming to a head because I have an upcoming safari to the Masai Mara in Dec, where I should take 2 bodies and 2 lenses at a minimum. While this may not be a once-in-a-lifetime trip, it certainly is expensive in terms of time and money. Big 5 and birds are going to be my key subjects. People, astro, macro are not interest areas at least for this trip.
Z9 + 600mm TC, Z8+400mm f2.8 plus a 70-200 2.8 zoom is what I was planning. Alternatively, the Sony A1with 600mm f4, A9III with either the 400 2.8 or the 200-600 is my choice.
With rentals, I know both combinations could work, but given that I am not a pro by any means (advanced beginner would be the best description), I don't want to be struggling with AF/IQ/FPS things during the safari.
I shoot uncompressed RAW all the time, so that I can correct minor mistakes in post
With this info, any specific recommendations you would make?
p.3 #6Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
speedmaster20d wrote:
please note the most important factor in getting great shots with any camera is skill of the photographer. A highly skilled photographer can get great shots with any camera. Beginners typically can get much better ROI by spending their $$$ on workshops, classes and resources first and upgrading gear second.
Now if we want to compare camera systems once one has mastered the skills there are some differences
I switched away from Canon in 2018, back then the Canon 1DXII AF really lacked compared to the Nikon D5. You will find that many top bird photographers switched away from Canon around that timeframe... When I switched to mirrorless both Canon and Nikon were out of the game, Nikon has caught up since then, especially with many attractive premium and specialized ZF lenses, but Canon still are way behind the game if you want the best in bird photography.
They are lagging behind in both bodies and lenses. Their top camera is still only 24 mega pixels (about same as my old 1DXII from 2015) which isn't enough for someone like me and the AF is still behind Sony or Nikon when it comes to BIF.... they just glued an adaptor to their old super tele's while their brand new RF lenses are cheap slow f/8 and f/11 zoom's mainly, I'd personally pass on such lenses. If you don't have the budget to buy faster or super telephoto lenses I would look at second had market, Sony has the 200-600 and Nikon has many "lower cost" great lenses, I would chose between these lenses. again you will see a skilled photographer make excellent photos with the three systems but having said that Canon would no be a choice for me personally for bird photography in 2024. It was by far the best choice when I first started in 2002
I would agree with your statement that a highly-skilled photographer can get great shots with any camera if this thread wasn’t about bird and wildlife photography. The camera makes an enormous difference and thus it makes sense to only consider the top models.
On Canon, let’s see what they roll out this month.
p.3 #7Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote: swldstn wroteAs a multiple system shooter who currently only really just trying to break into BIF I’Ve owned the Z9 + 500PF but still own my Sony A1’s with 100-400 GM and 200-600 G and Canon R5 with a RF 100-500. This has been a really interesting thread and will continue to follow and look for direction.
I gave up on the Z9 because it was heavy and there was no Z8 or lighter body to pair it with. Wasn’t patient enough for them to fill out the system. Owned first the 500 PF with F mount and then the 400/4.5 Z with 1.4X TC. While I tried the Z9 I already had the A1 (x2) + 200-600 G and decided to return to it since I also used Sony for the 61 Mpixel cameras for landscape and general photography which started with Canon, which I still own as well. Lack of a higher Mpixel stacked sensor has kept my Canon stale for BIF and wondering if I should just sell it all even though it takes great pictures for everything below 400mm.
Need you guys to help me out. Thank you.
Now looking to “focus” more and commit to a BIF kit. Should I just go get a 600 GMPersonally I prefer single system photography. It takes a lot of practice to develop "muscle memory" and learn a single system well, much less three different systems.
I see Sony as the leader in photography since the release of the A9, while Canon and Nikon have been several years behind in terms of releasing lenses, bodies etc. that equal Sony's offerings. Who knows when Canon and Nikon will release anything competitive with the A9III?
I think picking one system and learning it well is likely more productive.
I don’t think there is a leader anymore. For example, the FF brands are playing catchup with MFT brands in computational features. Each brand has its strengths and they’re all good.
p.3 #8Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
johnvanr wrote:
I don’t think there is a leader anymore. For example, the FF brands are playing catchup with MFT brands in computational features. Each brand has its strengths and they’re all good.
I don't think MFT is really competitive as a photography platform. I also don't think JPEG is competitive as a photography medium.
So when we look at FF platforms, Sony has 120 FPS, Nikon has 20 FPS, Canon 30 FPS. Nikon doesn't even have RAW precapture!
I just don't see Canon and Nikon being remotely competitive in the action photography segment of the market (sports or wildlife action). Maybe CaNikon are about to release 120FPS cameras in a week or two and can catch back up, but right now their offerings are completely dominated by Sony's A9III.
p.3 #9Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
johnvanr wrote:
Personally, I don’t see the point of the A9III for us mere mortals. If I were to go with Sony, I’d prefer two A1s.
Capturing the decisive moment in wildlife photography. Especially relevant with BIF. Which means:
1) maximum FPS
2) top of the line AF
3) precapture
4) no shutter distortions of the subject
The A9III does all these things.
The Nikon Z8/Z9 is totally uncompetitive with 1 and 3 (doesn't have them in RAW) and lags in 2 and 4.
The Canon R3 is totally uncompetitive in 1, lags in 2,3,4.
Maybe Canon and Nikon release something competitive this year? If so, I'll retract my statement about "years behind", but that has been their position to date.
I hope they do. Sony needs to release better firmware updates. They need to remove their anti-competitive 15FPS and no teleconverter support for third party glass. Pushing Sony with competitive cameras will make Sony release better products, it's a win-win-win all around.
p.3 #10Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
Like I said, maybe Nikon and Canon release 120 FPS global bodies this year. But to date, they have been many years behind Sony for mirrorless capabilities.
Sony A9: 2017
Nikon Z9 (first Nikon mirrorless to match A9 performance): 2021
Canon R3 (first Canon mirrorless to match A9 performance): 2021
People will gaslight you all day long and tell you the systems are equivalent.
No, they are not. Canon and Nikon are stuck at 17-25% of the frame rate of the Sony system for RAW imaging. And Nikon doesn't even offer RAW precapture. That's a fact, and it makes a huge difference in whether you capture the decisive moment or not when the action gets hot.
Granted, all have posted their anecdotal evidences - but looks like I am in a tough spot in deciding which brand to commit to. For example, the 200-600 GM from Sony is something many photographers swear by (Karolina Noree), while many others say the z equivalents are much better.
All this is coming to a head because I have an upcoming safari to the Masai Mara in Dec, where I should take 2 bodies and 2 lenses at a minimum. While this may not be a once-in-a-lifetime trip, it certainly is expensive in terms of time and money. Big 5 and birds are going to be my key subjects. People, astro, macro are not interest areas at least for this trip.
Z9 + 600mm TC, Z8+400mm f2.8 plus a 70-200 2.8 zoom is what I was planning. Alternatively, the Sony A1with 600mm f4, A9III with either the 400 2.8 or the 200-600 is my choice.
With rentals, I know both combinations could work, but given that I am not a pro by any means (advanced beginner would be the best description), I don't want to be struggling with AF/IQ/FPS things during the safari.
I shoot uncompressed RAW all the time, so that I can correct minor mistakes in post
With this info, any specific recommendations you would make?
All systems have good cameras. If you can't make a good image with their modern bodies and lenses, you are a pretty bad photographer, considering they all hold your hand across the finish line. Every so often you get an OP like the one linked that can't get out of their own way and blame the camera instead.
Buy into the ecosystem that has the lenses you want while minimizing the amount of teleconverting you have to do to get your desired reach. That's it. That's the decision. People love to make it way harder than it is.
p.3 #12Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote: johnvanr wrotePersonally, I don’t see the point of the A9III for us mere mortals. If I were to go with Sony, I’d prefer two A1s.Capturing the decisive moment in wildlife photography. Especially relevant with BIF. Which means:
1) maximum FPS
2) top of the line AF
3) precapture
4) no shutter distortions of the subject
The A9III does all these things.
The Nikon Z8/Z9 is totally uncompetitive with 1 and 3 (doesn't have them in RAW) and lags in 2 and 4.
The Canon R3 is totally uncompetitive in 1, lags in 2,3,4.
Maybe Canon and Nikon release something competitive this year? If so, I'll retract my statement about "years behind", but that has been their position to date.
I hope they do. Sony needs to release better firmware updates. They need to remove their anti-competitive 15FPS and no teleconverter support for third party glass. Pushing Sony with competitive cameras will make Sony release better products, it's a win-win-win all around....Show more →
Reading your answer makes you wonder how any great wildlife shots were taken before the arrival of the A9III.
You don’t need a Ferrari to get somewhere fast in the real world…
p.3 #13Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote:
Like I said, maybe Nikon and Canon release 120 FPS global bodies this year. But to date, they have been many years behind Sony for mirrorless capabilities.
p.3 #14Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote: johnvanr wroteI don’t think there is a leader anymore. For example, the FF brands are playing catchup with MFT brands in computational features. Each brand has its strengths and they’re all good.I don't think MFT is really competitive as a photography platform. I also don't think JPEG is competitive as a photography medium.
So when we look at FF platforms, Sony has 120 FPS, Nikon has 20 FPS, Canon 30 FPS. Nikon doesn't even have RAW precapture!
I just don't see Canon and Nikon being remotely competitive in the action photography segment of the market (sports or wildlife action). Maybe CaNikon are about to release 120FPS cameras in a week or two and can catch back up, but right now their offerings are completely dominated by Sony's A9III.
I completely disagree that MFT isn’t competitive. What is that even based on?
And who needs a 120fps camera?
And, btw, RAW pre-capture existed in MFT long before it existed in FF.
p.3 #15Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
johnvanr wrote:
Reading your answer makes you wonder how any great wildlife shots were taken before the arrival of the A9III.
That sounds very much like "Reading your answer makes you wonder how any great wildlife shots were taken before the invention of autofocus."
I didn't say you can't get amazing images with cameras with 1FPS, 5FPS, 20FPS. Of course you can. The question is what is the best tool for action photography.
The A9III is a far superior tool for action photography, including wildlife action, versus cameras with 17-25% of the frame rate, particularly those lacking precapture.
p.3 #16Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
I completely disagree that MFT isn’t competitive. What is that even based on?
The laws of physics.
And who needs a 120fps camera?
People who always want to get the wings in a nice position for BIF
People who always want to capture the exact best moment when two eagles are fighting midair
People who want the exact moment the foot dents the ball at the most pleasing angle
People who want the best image of a momentary expression on the face of a primate expressing an emotion
etc.
And, btw, RAW pre-capture existed in MFT long before it existed in FF.
Yes. But MFT isn't competitive for IQ, resolution and bokeh with FF. That's why it has very little presence in the professional still photography world. It's much more competitive for video and drone use though.
p.3 #17Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
tctmp wrote: swldstn wroteAs a multiple system shooter who currently only really just trying to break into BIF I’Ve owned the Z9 + 500PF but still own my Sony A1’s with 100-400 GM and 200-600 G and Canon R5 with a RF 100-500. This has been a really interesting thread and will continue to follow and look for direction.
I gave up on the Z9 because it was heavy and there was no Z8 or lighter body to pair it with. Wasn’t patient enough for them to fill out the system. Owned first the 500 PF with F mount and then the 400/4.5 Z with 1.4X TC. While I tried the Z9 I already had the A1 (x2) + 200-600 G and decided to return to it since I also used Sony for the 61 Mpixel cameras for landscape and general photography which started with Canon, which I still own as well. Lack of a higher Mpixel stacked sensor has kept my Canon stale for BIF and wondering if I should just sell it all even though it takes great pictures for everything below 400mm.
Need you guys to help me out. Thank you.
Now looking to “focus” more and commit to a BIF kit. Should I just go get a 600 GMZ8 always represents a temptation. If I remember correctly, both Geoff and Douglas tried Z8 recently. @arbitrage@, @Douglas L@, care to elaborate for us what lens you tested with Z8, and what's the conclusion on AF, etc, compared to A1. Thanks.
I tested the Z8 with latest FW with the 400/4.5 with and without the 1.4TC.
I previously owned the Z9 on earlier FW versions and my first time used the 500PF and my second time owned the 400/4.5
The latest Nikon FW Z8 2.0 and I assume Z9 4.1 made a big improvement to being able to use Auto Area AF (essentially like Sony's Wide AF) which to me was a big deal as I shoot my Sonys in Wide most of the time and I used to shoot my Nikon DSLRs in Auto Area most of the time. On the earlier Z9 FW Auto wasn't great and I missed having it.
I still find the A1 AF to be better than the latest Nikon AF. Still mostly for picking up subjects at a distance and for not dropping the subject as it flies towards you.
Granted, all have posted their anecdotal evidences - but looks like I am in a tough spot in deciding which brand to commit to. For example, the 200-600 GM from Sony is something many photographers swear by (Karolina Noree), while many others say the z equivalents are much better.
All this is coming to a head because I have an upcoming safari to the Masai Mara in Dec, where I should take 2 bodies and 2 lenses at a minimum. While this may not be a once-in-a-lifetime trip, it certainly is expensive in terms of time and money. Big 5 and birds are going to be my key subjects. People, astro, macro are not interest areas at least for this trip.
Z9 + 600mm TC, Z8+400mm f2.8 plus a 70-200 2.8 zoom is what I was planning. Alternatively, the Sony A1with 600mm f4, A9III with either the 400 2.8 or the 200-600 is my choice.
With rentals, I know both combinations could work, but given that I am not a pro by any means (advanced beginner would be the best description), I don't want to be struggling with AF/IQ/FPS things during the safari.
I shoot uncompressed RAW all the time, so that I can correct minor mistakes in post
With this info, any specific recommendations you would make?
Being that you are a Canon shooter I probably wouldn't make the switch until you see what the R5II brings this month. The R5II will be more than enough for a safari considering the existing R5 is already more than enough for a safari. It's possible the R5II will surpass the Z8 in a smaller/lighter package with ergos you are used to.
You have several months to figure it out and I believe you will be happier with Canon's ergos considering you are already a Canon shooter. Lenses for a Safari can vary depending on the individual's shooting style and wildlife preferences. For me, the ultimate setup for my last Safari was the RF 100-300 on one R5 and the RF400 on another R5 with a couple TC's to mix it up. If you don't have the 100-300, a 70-200 will work. I do not feel the need to bring my 600 to Africa, but if you are primarily a bird shooter you will want it. If you are staying in the conservancies you can drive right up and get very close to the animals, so there's no need for a 600. But if you are staying in an NP, you will likely want the 600. There are many factors to consider when deciding on which gear to bring, so take a look at the questions I noted at the bottom of page 18 of the Safari thread below.
p.3 #19Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
lightskyland wrote: Earlier quoteI completely disagree that MFT isn’t competitive. What is that even based on?The laws of physics.
Earlier quoteAnd who needs a 120fps camera?People who always want to get the wings in a nice position for BIF
People who always want to capture the exact best moment when two eagles are fighting midair
People who want the exact moment the foot dents the ball at the most pleasing angle
People who want the best image of a momentary expression on the face of a primate expressing an emotion
etc.
Earlier quoteAnd, btw, RAW pre-capture existed in MFT long before it existed in FF.Yes. But MFT isn't competitive for IQ, resolution and bokeh with FF. That's why it has very little presence in the professional still photography world. It's much more competitive for video and drone use though.
This isn’t the place to argue MFT vs FF in detail but I think you’re wrong, esp. when it comes to wildlife photography.
I simply cannot imagine that anyone wants that special shot so badly that he/she would regularly look through multiple 120fps bursts. Maybe I lack imagination…
May 06, 2024 at 02:27 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.3 #20Wildlife & Bird Photography - Move to Sony or stay with Canon?
I just have to laugh when photographers act like they can't get a photo they are happy with without using precapture.