fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Lightroom Classic AI Denoise (12.3)

  
 
lsquare
Offline
Details
p.20 #1Lightroom Classic AI Denoise (12.3)


mcbroomf wrote:
Are you asking about old vs new LRC? If so the more recent version was slower last time I checked.


I meant 3090 vs 4090 with the latest LRC.
Aug 28, 2024 at 10:07 AM
mcbroomf
Offline
Details
p.20 #2Lightroom Classic AI Denoise (12.3)
No data
Aug 28, 2024 at 12:05 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.20 #3Lightroom Classic AI Denoise (12.3)
mcbroomf wrote:
gus6464 wroteI just built a new system with a core i9 13900k and an Intel arc a770 16gb and to be honest this card is a steal for what I paid ($200 open box). If someone wants to send me the 60mp test file I can do the denoise timed test in LR to add to the spreadsheet.

I will add that the GPU is very optimized in topaz as that is one of Intel's partners. I was going to buy a refurb 3090 for the 24gb of vram but not really finding a need.
Here's the link to download the raw file for testing.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/15UAKmx9IA1k2Zt877ShHeUewCcHquyhu/view

I have not been updating the table as it was made using LRC 12.4 and there were changes to times when Adobe release 13.* It would be good to see what an Intel GPU does though, maybe add it as a footnote. Thanks ...



I was curious to test this file. I have LR 14.0 release candidate. I'm using M1 Max 16" MBP with 32GB RAM and 24GPU.

Just wanted to know what your procedure is for the test? Are you running at the default setting of 50? Are you stopping the timer when the progress bar disappears.

Thanks.

I did just run it at a setting of 50 and stopped the timer when the progress bar disappeared and got ~26s.
Aug 29, 2024 at 11:00 AM
pr4photos
Offline
Details
p.20 #4Lightroom Classic AI Denoise (12.3)
arbitrage wrote:
mcbroomf wrote
gus6464 wroteI just built a new system with a core i9 13900k and an Intel arc a770 16gb and to be honest this card is a steal for what I paid ($200 open box). If someone wants to send me the 60mp test file I can do the denoise timed test in LR to add to the spreadsheet.

I will add that the GPU is very optimized in topaz as that is one of Intel's partners. I was going to buy a refurb 3090 for the 24gb of vram but not really finding a need.
Here's the link to download the raw file for testing.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/15UAKmx9IA1k2Zt877ShHeUewCcHquyhu/view

I have not been updating the table as it was made using LRC 12.4 and there were changes to times when Adobe release 13.* It would be good to see what an Intel GPU does though, maybe add it as a footnote. Thanks ...
I was curious to test this file. I have LR 14.0 release candidate. I'm using M1 Max 16" MBP with 32GB RAM and 24GPU.

Just wanted to know what your procedure is for the test? Are you running at the default setting of 50? Are you stopping the timer when the progress bar disappears.

Thanks.

I did just run it at a setting of 50 and stopped the timer when the progress bar disappeared and got ~26s.


How did you get LR 14.0? I'm on 13.5
Aug 29, 2024 at 12:22 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.20 #5Lightroom Classic AI Denoise (12.3)
pr4photos wrote:
arbitrage wrote
mcbroomf wrote
gus6464 wroteI just built a new system with a core i9 13900k and an Intel arc a770 16gb and to be honest this card is a steal for what I paid ($200 open box). If someone wants to send me the 60mp test file I can do the denoise timed test in LR to add to the spreadsheet.

I will add that the GPU is very optimized in topaz as that is one of Intel's partners. I was going to buy a refurb 3090 for the 24gb of vram but not really finding a need.
Here's the link to download the raw file for testing.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/15UAKmx9IA1k2Zt877ShHeUewCcHquyhu/view

I have not been updating the table as it was made using LRC 12.4 and there were changes to times when Adobe release 13.* It would be good to see what an Intel GPU does though, maybe add it as a footnote. Thanks ...
I was curious to test this file. I have LR 14.0 release candidate. I'm using M1 Max 16" MBP with 32GB RAM and 24GPU.

Just wanted to know what your procedure is for the test? Are you running at the default setting of 50? Are you stopping the timer when the progress bar disappears.

Thanks.

I did just run it at a setting of 50 and stopped the timer when the progress bar disappeared and got ~26s.
How did you get LR 14.0? I'm on 13.5


A few years ago I was complaining about things on the Adobe forums and the admin gave me access to the LR Pre-release program to test potential fixes they were working on and I've had access ever since. So I will typically get many dot versions of a main version before the next main version goes out to everyone.
Aug 29, 2024 at 02:12 PM
mcbroomf
Offline
Details
p.20 #6Lightroom Classic AI Denoise (12.3)
arbitrage wrote:
mcbroomf wrote
gus6464 wroteI just built a new system with a core i9 13900k and an Intel arc a770 16gb and to be honest this card is a steal for what I paid ($200 open box). If someone wants to send me the 60mp test file I can do the denoise timed test in LR to add to the spreadsheet.

I will add that the GPU is very optimized in topaz as that is one of Intel's partners. I was going to buy a refurb 3090 for the 24gb of vram but not really finding a need.
Here's the link to download the raw file for testing.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/15UAKmx9IA1k2Zt877ShHeUewCcHquyhu/view

I have not been updating the table as it was made using LRC 12.4 and there were changes to times when Adobe release 13.* It would be good to see what an Intel GPU does though, maybe add it as a footnote. Thanks ...
I was curious to test this file. I have LR 14.0 release candidate. I'm using M1 Max 16" MBP with 32GB RAM and 24GPU.

Just wanted to know what your procedure is for the test? Are you running at the default setting of 50? Are you stopping the timer when the progress bar disappears.

Thanks.

I did just run it at a setting of 50 and stopped the timer when the progress bar disappeared and got ~26s.


Yikes! ... it's been a while.

Pretty sure we stopped the timer when the image showed up, but that's probably only about a second after the task bar completes. Pretty sure we used default settings but I also used a new catalog (no files other than the test file). And also if you want/need to run it again either clear the cache or reboot LRC.

EDIT : Sorry, I had to edit the post (deleted last para) as I commented on times for Denoise in the GPU vs Time graph I'd posted. That was using Art's data for his 36MP Nikon file, not the 60MP Sony file we use

PS. If 26 secs is right then that's a good improvement over LRC 12.3. As you see from the table the same configuration of M1 Max and GPU cores, but with 64GB ram came in at 37 secs (data from my own 14" MBP).

Aug 29, 2024 at 03:11 PM
FM ForumsPost-processing & PrintingJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister