fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?

  
 
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.6 #1What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
schlotz wrote:
Oh my, over 5 pages just on filters Hmm...


And we haven't touched yet the microcontrast and 3D pop of Zeiss filters vs. the smooth rendering of B+W.....


Jul 20, 2022 at 04:44 PM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.6 #2What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?


chez wrote:
snegron7 wrote
Daran wrote
snegron7 wroteI always try to put a clear filter on my lenses. I have scratched the front element on two lenses; they were in my camera bag, but the lens caps popped off.
Sure, that can happen, in particular if you have some stray sand in your bag. On the other hand filters break rather easily and while breaking have a better chance of scratching the front element than most other stuff that tends to come in contact.
There was no sand in my bag. On both ocasiones the unfiltered front element rubbed against a camera causing a gash, not a scratch, on the front element. The lenses were unusable after this.

As for the protective aspect of filters, I remember shooting a couple of weddings where either a drunk guest or an out of control kid wacked into my lens, touched it with hands full of cake frosting, splattered it with beer, sand blowing while at the beach, etc., and no damage occurred.

My suggestion is for everyone who does not like filters to simply not use them. I shared my personal experiences regarding filters with the sole intention of providing info; I really couldn't care less if anyone here decides to buy or not buy filters. As a matter of fact, if there is a sudden drop in filter sales maybe the prices will drop as well. I would love to buy a few more for some new lenses I recently purchased, hopefully at bargain prices!
A lens hood does wonders in preventing grimy hands from touching the glass. In fact a lens hood provides more protection against accidentally bumping the lens against the wall, rock, table or whatever.

Another problem ( at least issue ) is that you would need a filter for every lens which adds up if you have a lot of lenses. Good quality filters can be over $100 each. I have 12 lenses and I would think I’d have to shell out somewhere close to $1,000 to equip them all with filters.



Look up Canon EW-83E (the lens hood for the Canon 17-40mm f4.0L). There are other similar lens hoods for wide angle zooms that won't protect the front element at all.

Yes, good filters are expensive. But, for me at least, it's still cheaper to pay $100 for a filter than shell out $200+ to have a lens repaired.

On some of my less expensive lenses (like kit lenses, or my new Tamron 24mm f2.8), I won't bother with a filter because the cost isn't worth it. However, with my better lenses (especially my Canon L series lenses), I make it a point to have a filter on them. There is no noticeable image degradation at all with filters I use, so it's a no-brainer for me. Again, this is just a me thing.

Jul 20, 2022 at 05:43 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.6 #3What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Intelligent makers are aware of the need for standardising filter thread dimensions which is why so many of Cosina's and Leica lenses share filter sizes - all the SL primes are 67mm so you can swap them around if the lenses have emptied your bank balance.

But the big issue for many enthusiasts is to look for lenses with small filter threads. 49mm and 52mm covers a lot of ground for CV, and many are smaller still, e.g. at 46mm and 39mm. 58mm and smaller are half the asking price of a 77mm filter or even less, at around $40-50. About 8-10 cups of coffee. Sell and and buy lenses with the same size, it often happens. CZ used 55mm as a standard for many early lenses, Leica too.

The first thing a potential buyer of your used lens will do is to take a steely look at your front element in good light. Blemishes means no sale for many of these sensible people, and you end up having to reduce the asking price.
Jul 20, 2022 at 06:46 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.6 #4What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
philip_pj wrote:
Intelligent makers are aware of the need for standardising filter thread dimensions which is why so many of Cosina's and Leica lenses share filter sizes - all the SL primes are 67mm so you can swap them around if the lenses have emptied your bank balance.

But the big issue for many enthusiasts is to look for lenses with small filter threads. 49mm and 52mm covers a lot of ground for CV, and many are smaller still, e.g. at 46mm and 39mm. 58mm and smaller are half the asking price of a 77mm filter or even less, at around $40-50.
...Show more →

But having a standardize filter size does little when you are carrying all your lenses in your bag and they get banged up in the bag as was noted by a member. Each lens would still require a filter…there is no sharing a filter.

A bigger issue for me is a filter might prevent but one cause of damage…there are many more reasons a camera and / or lens can get damaged…or even stolen. I’ve dropped lenses, cameras, even entire bags of equipment…have been lucky no serious damage.

Insurance covers the vast majority of problems that can arise using your equipment and I know for sure insurance does not affect image quality.
Jul 20, 2022 at 07:01 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.6 #5What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
snegron7 wrote:
chez wrote
snegron7 wrote
Daran wrote
snegron7 wroteI always try to put a clear filter on my lenses. I have scratched the front element on two lenses; they were in my camera bag, but the lens caps popped off.
Sure, that can happen, in particular if you have some stray sand in your bag. On the other hand filters break rather easily and while breaking have a better chance of scratching the front element than most other stuff that tends to come in contact.
There was no sand in my bag. On both ocasiones the unfiltered front element rubbed against a camera causing a gash, not a scratch, on the front element. The lenses were unusable after this.

As for the protective aspect of filters, I remember shooting a couple of weddings where either a drunk guest or an out of control kid wacked into my lens, touched it with hands full of cake frosting, splattered it with beer, sand blowing while at the beach, etc., and no damage occurred.

My suggestion is for everyone who does not like filters to simply not use them. I shared my personal experiences regarding filters with the sole intention of providing info; I really couldn't care less if anyone here decides to buy or not buy filters. As a matter of fact, if there is a sudden drop in filter sales maybe the prices will drop as well. I would love to buy a few more for some new lenses I recently purchased, hopefully at bargain prices!
A lens hood does wonders in preventing grimy hands from touching the glass. In fact a lens hood provides more protection against accidentally bumping the lens against the wall, rock, table or whatever.

Another problem ( at least issue ) is that you would need a filter for every lens which adds up if you have a lot of lenses. Good quality filters can be over $100 each. I have 12 lenses and I would think I’d have to shell out somewhere close to $1,000 to equip them all with filters.
Look up Canon EW-83E (the lens hood for the Canon 17-40mm f4.0L). There are other similar lens hoods for wide angle zooms that won't protect the front element at all.

Yes, good filters are expensive. But, for me at least, it's still cheaper to pay $100 for a filter than shell out $200+ to have a lens repaired.

On some of my less expensive lenses (like kit lenses, or my new Tamron 24mm f2.8), I won't bother with a filter because the cost isn't worth it. However, with my better lenses (especially my Canon L series lenses), I make it a
...Show more →

I’ve actually used the 17-40 quite extensively when shooting landscapes and have on multiple occasions banged the front of the lens ( hood ) when scrambling over rocks to reach a certain composition. I really wonder what the outcome would have been if I did not use a lens hood but just had a simple UV filter. I’m pretty sure the filter would have shattered…but no idea if the front element would have been damaged.

Jul 20, 2022 at 07:07 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.6 #6What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Hey, if you are extra-clumsy you should be using a protective filter, a lens hood, a lenscoat, and have lens insurance.
Jul 20, 2022 at 08:51 PM
aCuria
Offline
Details
p.6 #7What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
When shooting anything to do with sand, metal working, factories and so on, a clear filter keeps allot of crap out of your front element.

Children also have some kind of attraction to poking your lens element, and it’s much easier to clean a flat removable filter which can be run under the sink with a drop of dishwashing fluid.

Yes there’s some amount of image quality loss but this is greatly minimized by buying multi coated filters

One trap is buying uv filters, a artifact from the film days, which has zero benefit for digital cameras and produces a slight yellow cast

In recent years there have been improvements in this space, with filters that are made of impact resistant glass that can stop a 100g ball bearing falling from 1.2m, which is probably enough to crush your toe

Sigma makes a “WR Ceramic” filter and Marumi makes the Exus Solid” in this category

Overall there’s a time and place for filters and you should have one for each lens
Jul 22, 2022 at 08:56 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.6 #8What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Certain lenses, like the Tamron 35/2.8, CV 35/2 APO, CV 50/2 APO (and possibly more CV lenses) do benefit from hard cut L41 (410nm) UV filters (Like Zeiss UV and Kenko L41 UV filters.) It resolves most of an issue where shooting where ambient UV causes magenta shading with these lenses.

aCuria wrote:
When shooting anything to do with sand, metal working, factories and so on, a clear filter keeps allot of crap out of your front element.

Children also have some kind of attraction to poking your lens element, and it’s much easier to clean a flat removable filter which can be run under the sink with a drop of dishwashing fluid.

Yes there’s some amount of image quality loss but this is greatly minimized by buying multi coated filters

One trap is buying uv filters, a artifact from the film days, which has zero benefit for digital cameras and produces a slight yellow
...Show more →



Edited on Jul 22, 2022 at 10:00 AM · View previous versions
Jul 22, 2022 at 09:01 AM
jeffbuzz
Offline
Details
p.6 #9What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
This video is from a few years back but obviously still relevant. I think it was well done and shows just how little "impact" protection a typical filter provides compared to the front lens element. I don't really have any expectation of impact protection from a filter. I use them for convenience of cleaning and protection from grit and gravel.

Jul 22, 2022 at 09:55 AM
aCuria
Offline
Details
p.6 #10What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Oh, this is something I don’t know about

Why is there a cast in the presence of UV? Without a filter is there still a cast out of the sun where UV isn’t a problem?

tsdevine wrote:
Certain lenses, like the Tamron 35/2.8, CV 35/2 APO, CV 50/2 APO (and possibly more CV lenses) do benefit from hard cut L41 (410nm) UV filters (Like Zeiss UV and Kenko L41 UV filters.) It resolves most of an issue where shooting where ambient UV causes magenta shading with these lenses.

aCuria wroteWhen shooting anything to do with sand, metal working, factories and so on, a clear filter keeps allot of crap out of your front element.

Children also have some kind of attraction to poking your lens element, and it’s much easier to clean a flat removable filter which can be run under the sink with a drop of dishwashing fluid.

Yes there’s some amount of image quality loss but this is greatly minimized by buying multi coated filters

One trap is buying uv filters, a artifact from the film days, which has zero benefit for digital cameras and produces a slight yellow cast

In recent years there have been improvements in this space, with filters that are made of impact resistant glass that can stop a 100g ball bearing falling from 1.2m, which is probably enough to crush your toe

Sigma makes a “WR Ceramic” filter and Marumi makes the Exus Solid” in this category

Overall there’s a time and place for filters and you should have one for each lens

Jul 22, 2022 at 10:04 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.6 #11What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?

No, the level of magenta shading is a function of how much ambient UV there is. Indoors you're not going to see it. Outdoors, you'll see it, but the level depends on how strong UV is.

And you have to filter the light going in the lens, not what is coming out and hitting the sensor. Many people aren't bothered by this, so I don't want to make a mountain out of a molehill (except for people who see it as a mountain, it's good to know how to solve for it.)

To discuss more, it may make sense to do it in this thread. It's a little tricky because some people get hung up on the "magenta ring" problem, which is more of an issue with some Sony cameras applying some form of alteration even when shading correction is turned off. It leads to some concentric magenta rings for some lenses on some cameras. But I'm 100% confident on the lenses I note above that there is something unique happening related to UV spectrum.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1683319/4#15549041

aCuria wrote:
Oh, this is something I don’t know about

Why is there a cast in the presence of UV? Without a filter is there still a cast out of the sun where UV isn’t a problem?

tsdevine wroteCertain lenses, like the Tamron 35/2.8, CV 35/2 APO, CV 50/2 APO (and possibly more CV lenses) do benefit from hard cut L41 (410nm) UV filters (Like Zeiss UV and Kenko L41 UV filters.) It resolves most of an issue where shooting where ambient UV causes magenta shading with these lenses.

aCuria wroteWhen shooting anything to do with sand, metal working, factories and so on, a clear filter keeps allot of crap out of your front element.

Children also have some kind of attraction to poking your lens element, and it’s much easier to clean a flat removable filter which can be run under the sink with a drop of dishwashing fluid.

Yes there’s some amount of image quality loss but this is greatly minimized by buying multi coated filters

One trap is buying uv filters, a artifact from the film days, which has zero benefit for digital cameras and produces a slight yellow cast

In recent years there have been improvements in this space, with filters that are made of impact resistant glass that can stop a 100g ball bearing falling from 1.2m, which is probably enough to crush your toe

Sigma makes a “WR Ceramic” filter and Marumi makes the Exus Solid” in this category

Overall there’s a time and place for filters and you should have one for each lens


Jul 22, 2022 at 01:11 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.6 #12What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
When we shot transparency film AKA Kodachrome any and all corrections had to be at time of shoot since there is no post. Today we are all in post to fix or correct any IV contamination. Life is far easier now as so is any exposure being off or white balance issues. Not to mention not getting any immediate feedback. We had none of that . Any flash work with multiple units on set was a nightmare. Sometimes we do a test run with E6 film than go back with adjustments and shoot it for real. We are so spoiled now. But a guy like me making the transition to digital was a cake walk. It was all built in from the film days
Jul 22, 2022 at 02:54 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.6 #13What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?

I agree, it's so nice to be able to address many things in post with digital....compared to slides, or even C41 if you are not doing the printing yourself.

Unfortunately this specific issue with certain lenses is a royal PITA to try to fix in post. So back to the old school solution which addresses the issue at shooting time. You do what you gotta do...

GMPhotography wrote:
When we shot transparency film AKA Kodachrome any and all corrections had to be at time of shoot since there is no post. Today we are all in post to fix or correct any IV contamination. Life is far easier now as so is any exposure being off or white balance issues. Not to mention not getting any immediate feedback. We had none of that . Any flash work with multiple units on set was a nightmare. Sometimes we do a test run with E6 film than go back with adjustments and shoot it for real. We are so spoiled
...Show more →

Jul 22, 2022 at 03:07 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.6 #14What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
GMPhotography wrote:
When we shot transparency film AKA Kodachrome any and all corrections had to be at time of shoot since there is no post. Today we are all in post to fix or correct any IV contamination. Life is far easier now as so is any exposure being off or white balance issues. Not to mention not getting any immediate feedback. We had none of that . Any flash work with multiple units on set was a nightmare. Sometimes we do a test run with E6 film than go back with adjustments and shoot it for real. We are so spoiled
...Show more →

All my color film-era pics were taken with Kodachrome.

It was expensive to get it wrong (especially as a student) so we learned to get it right.

Mostly by paying attention.

That experience has served me well with digital.

Jul 22, 2022 at 03:21 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.6 #15What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Geez, the old geezers are coming out of the closets.

The cost of using 35mm Kodachrome was peanuts compared to 4"x5" Kodachrome.

My minimal post-processing was done in the darkroom.
Jul 22, 2022 at 04:52 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.6 #16What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
tsdevine wrote:
Certain lenses, like the Tamron 35/2.8, CV 35/2 APO, CV 50/2 APO (and possibly more CV lenses) do benefit from hard cut L41 (410nm) UV filters (Like Zeiss UV and Kenko L41 UV filters.) It resolves most of an issue where shooting where ambient UV causes magenta shading with these lenses.

aCuria wroteWhen shooting anything to do with sand, metal working, factories and so on, a clear filter keeps allot of crap out of your front element.

Children also have some kind of attraction to poking your lens element, and it’s much easier to clean a flat removable filter which can be run under the sink with a drop of dishwashing fluid.

Yes there’s some amount of image quality loss but this is greatly minimized by buying multi coated filters

One trap is buying uv filters, a artifact from the film days, which has zero benefit for digital cameras and produces a slight yellow cast

In recent years there have been improvements in this space, with filters that are made of impact resistant glass that can stop a 100g ball bearing falling from 1.2m, which is probably enough to crush your toe

Sigma makes a “WR Ceramic” filter and Marumi makes the Exus Solid” in this category

Overall there’s a time and place for filters and you should have one for each lens


Very interesting that the UV/magenta problem is lens specific. Is it a function of the coatings used by Cosnia and on the one Tamron lens? Or glass forumlation?
Jul 22, 2022 at 05:45 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.6 #17What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?

In the end it doesn't matter. Many don't notice when shooting these lenses, and even if you point it out, most people won't care. But for anyone who might, it's good to share the workaround.

The CVs are excellent lenses, and the Tamron 35 is an amazing bargain.

chiron wrote:
tsdevine wroteCertain lenses, like the Tamron 35/2.8, CV 35/2 APO, CV 50/2 APO (and possibly more CV lenses) do benefit from hard cut L41 (410nm) UV filters (Like Zeiss UV and Kenko L41 UV filters.) It resolves most of an issue where shooting where ambient UV causes magenta shading with these lenses.

aCuria wroteWhen shooting anything to do with sand, metal working, factories and so on, a clear filter keeps allot of crap out of your front element.

Children also have some kind of attraction to poking your lens element, and it’s much easier to clean a flat removable filter which can be run under the sink with a drop of dishwashing fluid.

Yes there’s some amount of image quality loss but this is greatly minimized by buying multi coated filters

One trap is buying uv filters, a artifact from the film days, which has zero benefit for digital cameras and produces a slight yellow cast

In recent years there have been improvements in this space, with filters that are made of impact resistant glass that can stop a 100g ball bearing falling from 1.2m, which is probably enough to crush your toe

Sigma makes a “WR Ceramic” filter and Marumi makes the Exus Solid” in this category

Overall there’s a time and place for filters and you should have one for each lens
Very interesting that the UV/magenta problem is lens specific. Is it a function of the coatings used by Cosnia and on the one Tamron lens? Or glass forumlation?


Jul 22, 2022 at 05:59 PM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.6 #18What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
tsdevine wrote:
In the end it depends. And there is no "wrong" answer. Not using a filter isn't absolutely best, and using a filter isn't absolutely best. Things are seldom black and white, there are always pros and cons and in the end you just balance them. Nobody can make that decision for you. You do what makes sense to you, based on your value system.



Agreed, and IMHO if the decision results in taking more photos so much the better.
Jul 22, 2022 at 06:31 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.6 #19What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
tsdevine wrote:
In the end it doesn't matter. Many don't notice when shooting these lenses, and even if you point it out, most people won't care. But for anyone who might, it's good to share the workaround.

The CVs are excellent lenses, and the Tamron 35 is an amazing bargain.

chiron wrote
tsdevine wroteCertain lenses, like the Tamron 35/2.8, CV 35/2 APO, CV 50/2 APO (and possibly more CV lenses) do benefit from hard cut L41 (410nm) UV filters (Like Zeiss UV and Kenko L41 UV filters.) It resolves most of an issue where shooting where ambient UV causes magenta shading with these lenses.

aCuria wroteWhen shooting anything to do with sand, metal working, factories and so on, a clear filter keeps allot of crap out of your front element.

Children also have some kind of attraction to poking your lens element, and it’s much easier to clean a flat removable filter which can be run under the sink with a drop of dishwashing fluid.

Yes there’s some amount of image quality loss but this is greatly minimized by buying multi coated filters

One trap is buying uv filters, a artifact from the film days, which has zero benefit for digital cameras and produces a slight yellow cast

In recent years there have been improvements in this space, with filters that are made of impact resistant glass that can stop a 100g ball bearing falling from 1.2m, which is probably enough to crush your toe

Sigma makes a “WR Ceramic” filter and Marumi makes the Exus Solid” in this category

Overall there’s a time and place for filters and you should have one for each lens
Very interesting that the UV/magenta problem is lens specific. Is it a function of the coatings used by Cosnia and on the one Tamron lens? Or glass forumlation?


Yes, I agree with you about the lenses and that the problem doesn't really mean much, but I am curious about the source of the problem.
Jul 22, 2022 at 06:32 PM
fffatkid65
Offline
Details
p.6 #20What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I use the Zeiss t* because of the be coatings and the data shows it's correct.

InFocus2014 wrote:
Roger Cicala at Lens Rentals performed tests on filters some time ago:

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2017/06/the-comprehensive-ranking-of-the-major-uv-filters-on-the-market/

One of the charts from his article (I would avoid Tiffen filters):



Jul 22, 2022 at 07:45 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister