fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #1What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
NJPhotographer wrote:
If you look at used lenses, you can usually tell which have been protected by a filter and which have not.


But can you tell from the images which lens took which image. There are conditions where degradation ( lens flare ) will show up on images shot with a filter.
Jul 18, 2022 at 09:16 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #2What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
A.Y. wrote:
Always test your lenses with and without an UV filter to see for yourself. I tested all of my lenses and not one showed image degradation with an UV filter; therefore, I always use them! YMMV of course because no two lenses are the same!


Shooting conditions which are prone to inducing flare should be tested if one shoots under these conditions. This is where I find filters in general have the most detrimental affects.
Jul 18, 2022 at 09:22 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.2 #3What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
chez wrote:
NJPhotographer wroteIf you look at used lenses, you can usually tell which have been protected by a filter and which have not.
But can you tell from the images which lens took which image. There are conditions where degradation ( lens flare ) will show up on images shot with a filter.


Lens flare is an obvious problem, as is the reflection of white lettering around the front of some lenses. I stopped using UV filters when I discovered they caused a subtle focus shift in longer lenses, and my prized B+W filters were the worst offenders.
Jul 18, 2022 at 09:31 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #4What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I have to laugh at the notion of putting them on your MOST expensive lenses...you know, the lenses you paid that much for because of their superior IQ...and then slap a cheap piece of glass in front of it.

A novel idea: spend that money on insuring your gear instead and enjoy your lens as it's meant to be used.
Jul 18, 2022 at 09:48 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.2 #5What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
RoamingScott wrote:
I have to laugh at the notion of putting them on your MOST expensive lenses...you know, the lenses you paid that much for because of their superior IQ...and then slap a cheap piece of glass in front of it.

A novel idea: spend that money on insuring your gear instead and enjoy your lens as it's meant to be used.


Ditto. It is mostly the OCD crowd. The sky is falling, the sky is falling
Jul 18, 2022 at 09:52 AM
Bsmooth
Offline
Details
p.2 #6What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
It all depends on how careful you are with your equipment. If you have lenses without filters, and they never get scratched or dirty, then you don't need one. If however you may get a scratch or two, and you would rather clean a filter than your original lens element, then I would get one.
If you drop a lens on the front element, I don't think even a filter will help, but for everything else it probably will.
I literally can't afford to replace an expensive lens, but I can afford a really good filter, one that doesn't affect the image quality.
In the end its really up to you, which is a pretty good thing, don't you think ?
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:01 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #7What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Bsmooth wrote:
It all depends on how careful you are with your equipment. If you have lenses without filters, and they never get scratched or dirty, then you don't need one. If however you may get a scratch or two, and you would rather clean a filter than your original lens element, then I would get one.
If you drop a lens on the front element, I don't think even a filter will help, but for everything else it probably will.
I literally can't afford to replace an expensive lens, but I can afford a really good filter, one that doesn't affect
...Show more →

If you can't afford to replace an expensive lens, you NEED insurance. If you can afford good filters, you can afford insurance.

I swear, it's like these people that wring their hands over buying name brand camera batteries. You spend $7000 on a camera body but cry a river about a $70 battery.
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:02 AM
wordfool
Offline
Details
p.2 #8What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Oh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I definitely wouldn't use a filter is if there's a strong chance of flare (low sun or a lot of reflections etc.) because I've noticed over the years that filters can make it worse.

My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:08 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.2 #9What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
wordfool wrote:
Oh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I
...Show more →

Agree 100%.

I am unlikely to use the front of my shirt to clean dirt/salt water/sweat/finger smudges/dog slobber/whale gravy/cobra venom/alpaca spit/etc. off of the front of my lens when hiking/climbing/biking, but I won't hesitate to do the same if a good quality clear or UV filter is in place. It really is a decision best made on your own experiences. Those that go without must be a good bit more fastidious than me.
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:25 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.2 #10What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?

Agree, I have my reasons to use them, other people have reasons to not use them. News at 11.

Until we have perfected mind control and there is no free will...different people will have different preferences.

I think that's ok, actually preferable.

wordfool wrote:
Oh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I
...Show more →

Jul 18, 2022 at 10:31 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.2 #11What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
There is no free will, but that's another matter......

tsdevine wrote:
Agree, I have my reasons to use them, other people have reasons to not use them. News at 11.

Until we have perfected mind control and there is no free will...different people will have different preferences.

I think that's ok, actually preferable.

wordfool wroteOh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I definitely wouldn't use a filter is if there's a strong chance of flare (low sun or a lot of reflections etc.) because I've noticed over the years that filters can make it worse.

My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".


Jul 18, 2022 at 10:33 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #12What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
smpetty wrote:
wordfool wroteOh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I definitely wouldn't use a filter is if there's a strong chance of flare (low sun or a lot of reflections etc.) because I've noticed over the years that filters can make it worse.

My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".
Agree 100%.

I am unlikely to use the front of my shirt to clean dirt/salt water/sweat/finger smudges/dog slobber/whale gravy/cobra venom/alpaca spit/etc. off of the front of my lens when hiking/climbing/biking, but I won't hesitate to do the same if a good quality clear or UV filter is in place. It really is a decision best made on your own experiences. Those that go without must be a good bit more fastidious than me.


I quite often clean my lenses when out in the field with my breath and tee shirt. Never had an issue with this. Now in environments that have blowing sand or salt, I'll put a filter on...but most of the time it's a polarizer for the effects.
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:42 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #13What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
wordfool wrote:
My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".


Just to be clear...if you are implying that dust or even scratches on the front element are visible in photos, you need to watch a few youtubes where they absolutely destroy front elements to see how much damage is required before it becomes visible in photos.
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:45 AM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.2 #14What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
RoamingScott wrote:
wordfool wroteMy opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".
Just to be clear...if you are implying that dust or even scratches on the front element are visible in photos, you need to watch a few youtubes where they absolutely destroy front elements to see how much damage is required before it becomes visible in photos.


http://kurtmunger.com/dirty_lens_articleid35.html
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:47 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.2 #15What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
chez wrote:
smpetty wrote
wordfool wroteOh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I definitely wouldn't use a filter is if there's a strong chance of flare (low sun or a lot of reflections etc.) because I've noticed over the years that filters can make it worse.

My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".
Agree 100%.

I am unlikely to use the front of my shirt to clean dirt/salt water/sweat/finger smudges/dog slobber/whale gravy/cobra venom/alpaca spit/etc. off of the front of my lens when hiking/climbing/biking, but I won't hesitate to do the same if a good quality clear or UV filter is in place. It really is a decision best made on your own experiences. Those that go without must be a good bit more fastidious than me.
I quite often clean my lenses when out in the field with my breath and tee shirt. Never had an issue with this. Now in environments that have blowing sand or salt, I'll put a filter on...but most of the time it's a polarizer for the effects.


I agree, mostly, but I have had two lens injuries (front element) when not using filters that likely would have been less severe or prevented had a filter been in place. One was bumping the front element of my Canon 16-35/2.8 L on rock during a climb in Canyonlands, the other was scraping the front element of a 35mm lens on pit wall at the Charlotte Motor Speedway.

So my experiences have led to me often using protection filters. I have never had a front element nick, scratch, or fracture while using the protection filters, so my success rate, so far, is 100%

YMMV

Edited on Jul 18, 2022 at 10:51 AM · View previous versions
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:50 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.2 #16What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I sometimes get the impression that people defend UV "protection" filters because they're too embarrassed to admit they got sucked into wasting money on them...
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:51 AM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.2 #17What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
molson wrote:
I sometimes get the impression that people defend UV "protection" filters because they're too embarrassed to admit they got sucked into wasting money on them...


You must believe we're all idiots, at least those of us that use $40 filters to protect $2000 lenses.
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:53 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.2 #18What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I'd consider not using them if CV could figure out how to handle UV spectrum properly.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1683319/4#15549041

But since I use them on my CV lenses, I also use them on many of my other lenses. But everyone should make the decision for themselves, and it's okay either way.

I will say this thread really shows off the darker side of people when it comes to differences in opinion.
Jul 18, 2022 at 10:57 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #19What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
smpetty wrote:
chez wrote
smpetty wrote
wordfool wroteOh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I definitely wouldn't use a filter is if there's a strong chance of flare (low sun or a lot of reflections etc.) because I've noticed over the years that filters can make it worse.

My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".
Agree 100%.

I am unlikely to use the front of my shirt to clean dirt/salt water/sweat/finger smudges/dog slobber/whale gravy/cobra venom/alpaca spit/etc. off of the front of my lens when hiking/climbing/biking, but I won't hesitate to do the same if a good quality clear or UV filter is in place. It really is a decision best made on your own experiences. Those that go without must be a good bit more fastidious than me.
I quite often clean my lenses when out in the field with my breath and tee shirt. Never had an issue with this. Now in environments that have blowing sand or salt, I'll put a filter on...but most of the time it's a polarizer for the effects.
I agree, mostly, but I have had two lens injuries (front element) when not using filters that likely would have been less severe or prevented had a filter been in place. One was bumping the front element of my Canon 16-35/2.8 L on rock during a climb in Canyonlands, the other was scraping the front element of a 35mm lens on pit wall at the Charlotte Motor Speedway.

So my experiences have led to me often using protection filters. I have never had a front element nick, scratch, or fracture while using the protection filters, so my success rate, so
...Show more →

Lens hoods would have prevented both of those situations. I find a lens hood provides much more protection against bumps or scrapes of the front element.
Jul 18, 2022 at 11:03 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #20What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
chez wrote:
smpetty wrote
chez wrote
smpetty wrote
wordfool wroteOh no, not this debate again. I look forward to trenchant opinions masquerading as objective facts As you say, there is no right or wrong answer and I doubt anyone could tell the IQ difference between no filter, a UV filter and a clear filter (as long as the filters are high quality of course). I use either UV or clear filters on some lenses, not on others, depending on lens, use case scenario, weather, and a host of other factors. And UV vs clear depending on what was cheapest at the time of purchase. The only time I definitely wouldn't use a filter is if there's a strong chance of flare (low sun or a lot of reflections etc.) because I've noticed over the years that filters can make it worse.

My opinion is that filters are much cheaper than replacing a front element and do little or nothing to degrade an image (especially when you factor in how much dust can accumulation on a nekkid front element during a day of shooting anyway). So why not use them for a bit of insurance to avoid having to clean crud off the front element all the time and risk scratches? And on those hood-not-required days they certainly make life easier than dealing with a big clumsy hood as "protection".
Agree 100%.

I am unlikely to use the front of my shirt to clean dirt/salt water/sweat/finger smudges/dog slobber/whale gravy/cobra venom/alpaca spit/etc. off of the front of my lens when hiking/climbing/biking, but I won't hesitate to do the same if a good quality clear or UV filter is in place. It really is a decision best made on your own experiences. Those that go without must be a good bit more fastidious than me.
I quite often clean my lenses when out in the field with my breath and tee shirt. Never had an issue with this. Now in environments that have blowing sand or salt, I'll put a filter on...but most of the time it's a polarizer for the effects.
I agree, mostly, but I have had two lens injuries (front element) when not using filters that likely would have been less severe or prevented had a filter been in place. One was bumping the front element of my Canon 16-35/2.8 L on rock during a climb in Canyonlands, the other was scraping the front element of a 35mm lens on pit wall at the Charlotte Motor Speedway.

So my experiences have led to me often using protection filters. I have never had a front element nick, scratch, or fracture while using the protection filters, so my success rate, so far, is 100%

YMMV
Lens hoods would have prevented both of those situations. I find a lens hood provides much more protection against bumps or scrapes of the front element.


Depends on the hood. Plenty of "petal" style hoods that offer very little projection from sharp objects.
Jul 18, 2022 at 11:05 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister