fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

  
 
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

For the magenta ring, you could probably use Flat Field in Lightroom Classic, it's not available in the CC version.

-Tim

Teo Rey wrote:
olalafoto wroteExample: [email protected] ,a7Riii

The color shift of edge and corners is easy to correct, but the ring color shift of central area is very difficult to correct. I use LCC to solve the problem

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/202103/4739/473947/473947_1615610380.jpg
What tool in Lightroom do you use to correct this?


Mar 13, 2021 at 06:35 AM
olalafoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
For LCC, Lightroom Classic is simpler and can output DNG format, work better with Photoshop, while Capture One has controllable parameters, but can only output PSD or TIFF format,each has its own merits.
Mar 13, 2021 at 10:00 AM
inksandpaper
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
@tsdevine, perhaps I should add a comment to this thread rather than in the Cosina Voigtlander 35mm F2 one. I'll leave this link to my post there for posterity's sake.

Kindly take a look at this: https://www.image-engineering.de/library/image-quality/factors/1073-shading#section-5-2

I've been wondering for a time why would off-axis magenta shading be affected by UV. Magenta btw is a weird in-between colour, between blue and red, which are on opposite sides of the spectrum. For a while, I was thinking that it was the IR blocking filter on the sensor (which has interference-based filtering) that resulted in off-axis magenta shading, and not UV, because a transmission shift to shorter wavelengths would explain the red colour cast. If it were UV, a transmission shift to shorter wavelengths would lead to more UV transmission indeed, which would not register as a magenta cast.

I still don't understand then why adding a UV-filtering filter would cut so much IR radiation. Optical glass is transparent to IR.
Mar 14, 2021 at 04:22 PM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
Inksandpaper; couple of the assumptions that you make are wrong.

1. IR blocking filter: both absorptive and interference (dichroic) type filters are in a Sony filter stack. FWIW, Nikon, Canon, Panasonic Sigma and others have a similar (if not identical) arrangement. Leica M is different.

2. An UV filter (such as a Kenko L41) does NOT block any IR (see the spectrum I posted). I can shoot in IR with an added Kenko L41 filter.

One of these days, time permitting, I will make a separate post on filters. I have my optical bench set up, partially now.
Mar 14, 2021 at 05:07 PM
Slingers
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
I have a suspicion around this that I cannot prove, that Sony is baking corner fixes into raws for all lenses with some basic AI. Only way I know how to reproduce is to take a correct exposure then compare to an underexposed image with gain added. The gain though adds too many problems of its own to be reliable so is just another assumption. Will continue to follow these threads though for what the final issue is. Thanks to everyone contributing as I’ve been silently reading along.
Mar 14, 2021 at 05:50 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

I think we're mixing two different things here. The concentric ring issue is something that was been pretty well shown to exist, and there are some examples of that in this thread. That does seem to be on Sony.

The magenta shading which I show in my shots, and can be reduced with the filters I show above, seems to be something different. This seems to be more an issue with the lens.

Slingers wrote:
I have a suspicion around this that I cannot prove, that Sony is baking corner fixes into raws for all lenses with some basic AI. Only way I know how to reproduce is to take a correct exposure then compare to an underexposed image with gain added. The gain though adds too many problems of its own to be reliable so is just another assumption. Will continue to follow these threads though for what the final issue is. Thanks to everyone contributing as I’ve been silently reading along.


Mar 14, 2021 at 07:10 PM
inksandpaper
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
realVivek wrote:
Inksandpaper; couple of the assumptions that you make are wrong.

1. IR blocking filter: both absorptive and interference (dichroic) type filters are in a Sony filter stack. FWIW, Nikon, Canon, Panasonic Sigma and others have a similar (if not identical) arrangement. Leica M is different.

2. An UV filter (such as a Kenko L41) does NOT block any IR (see the spectrum I posted). I can shoot in IR with an added Kenko L41 filter.

One of these days, time permitting, I will make a separate post on filters. I have my optical bench set up, partially now.


I've only ever said that the IR blocking filter is both absorptive and interference based. So I was not wrong there.

And I also know UV filters do not block IR (I mentioned optical glass, but I also know UV filters don't). So I am not wrong there again.

I'm afraid you have to do better than that to call out my "wrong" assumptions. And I still have not heard of any viable explanation for this off-axis magenta cast, which I am unable to reproduce on my end, even when UV levels are exceptionally high. I look forward to your post on filters, though I'm still finding it hard to see how this is Cosina's fault.

Edited on Mar 14, 2021 at 07:22 PM · View previous versions
Mar 14, 2021 at 07:18 PM
inksandpaper
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
tsdevine wrote:
I think we're mixing two different things here. The concentric ring issue is something that was been pretty well shown to exist, and there are some examples of that in this thread. That does seem to be on Sony.

The magenta shading which I show in my shots, and can be reduced with the filters I show above, seems to be something different. This seems to be more an issue with the lens.

Slingers wroteI have a suspicion around this that I cannot prove, that Sony is baking corner fixes into raws for all lenses with some basic AI. Only way I know how to reproduce is to take a correct exposure then compare to an underexposed image with gain added. The gain though adds too many problems of its own to be reliable so is just another assumption. Will continue to follow these threads though for what the final issue is. Thanks to everyone contributing as I’ve been silently reading along.


That's right, the in-camera applied flat field correction that cannot be turned off fully which causes concentric rings of varying tone and colour is a different issue altogether, and that's only visible (after all in-camera corrections are turned off) with a significant push to the file. Typically only deep sky astrophotographers will be affected by this.
Mar 14, 2021 at 07:20 PM
olalafoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
The weather is so bad today, I can only make an indoor comparison first,very low or no ultraviolet rays.

AL50, a7Riv, with the same exposure and white balance,T&Y has obvious color deviation.

According to the lab data provided by realVivek, T&Y is about 420nm, which maybe due to cutting off part of the visible light in the range of 410~420nm?

Maybe T&Y makes sense only when the ultraviolet rays is extremely strong?when the weather gets better, I'll do the outdoor comparison

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/202103/4739/473947/473947_1615801619.jpg

Mar 15, 2021 at 04:06 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
These lines, inskandpaper, are what my post was based on. If that conveys a very different meaning to you, fine.

inksandpaper wrote:
For a while, I was thinking that it was the IR blocking filter on the sensor (which has interference-based filtering) that resulted in off-axis magenta shading, ...

I still don't understand then why adding a UV-filtering filter would cut so much IR radiation.


Mar 15, 2021 at 04:22 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
T&Y, as I mentioned, is more like a 420 cut filter. Yes, it will affect your white balancing seriously, as you have shown here.

olalafoto wrote:
The weather is so bad today, I can only make an indoor comparison first,very low or no ultraviolet rays.

AL50, a7Riv, with the same exposure and white balance,T&Y has obvious color deviation.

According to the lab data provided by realVivek, T&Y is about 420nm, which maybe due to cutting off part of the visible light in the range of 410~420nm?

Maybe T&Y makes sense only when the ultraviolet rays is extremely strong?when the weather gets better, I'll do the outdoor comparison

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/202103/4739/473947/473947_1615801619.jpg


Mar 15, 2021 at 04:24 AM
Petegh
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
olalafoto wrote:
The weather is so bad today, I can only make an indoor comparison first,very low or no ultraviolet rays.

AL50, a7Riv, with the same exposure and white balance,T&Y has obvious color deviation.

According to the lab data provided by realVivek, T&Y is about 420nm, which maybe due to cutting off part of the visible light in the range of 410~420nm?

Maybe T&Y makes sense only when the ultraviolet rays is extremely strong?when the weather gets better, I'll do the outdoor comparison

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/202103/4739/473947/473947_1615801619.jpg


Are you sure you've got the first two labelled properly? The purple teapot in the image labelled Zeiss UV looks more saturated on my monitor than the no filter shot??
Mar 15, 2021 at 06:01 AM
olalafoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
Petegh wrote:
Are you sure you've got the first two labelled properly? The purple teapot in the image labelled Zeiss UV looks more saturated on my monitor than the no filter shot??


Yes, I'm sure, but it's just a quick comparison. there maybe some interference factors. I made another comparison to try my best to avoid all possible interference, and even turned off the electronic front curtain shutter.

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/202103/4739/473947/473947_1615818862.jpg
Mar 15, 2021 at 08:45 AM
olalafoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
Camera output,same exposure and 5100k.

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/202103/4739/473947/473947_1615867218.jpg


ACR process(same exposure and saturation), white balance matching based on building.

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/202103/4739/473947/473947_1615867234.jpg
Mar 15, 2021 at 10:11 PM
olalafoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
I did some comparisons and tests on T&Y L41 with VE15/4.5, the results were pretty bad

tsdevine's judgment is completely correct, and Zeiss T* UV is the best choice
Mar 16, 2021 at 12:39 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
Here is the CV50 on my a7R II. (My previous tests were on my a7R III.)

Sony a7R II + Voigtlander 50/2 APO-Lanthar - bare
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p2265407524-6.jpg


Sony a7R II + Voigtlander 50/2 APO-Lanthar - Kenko Zeta L41 UV Filter
https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p2265407513-6.jpg


Now here are the same two shots above with the color temperature adjusted to 15000.

https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p2265407516-6.jpg


https://www.devine.photography/img/s/v-10/p2265407512-6.jpg


So it's not just my a7R III, it shows on both my cameras.

-Tim
Mar 29, 2021 at 07:12 PM
sselhtrim
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
I can actually find the kenko zeta l41 uv filter on amazon japan if that helps.
Mar 29, 2021 at 11:43 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

Yes, that's the source I used.

-Tim
Mar 30, 2021 at 04:57 AM
sebbe
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)
olalafoto wrote:
This is an FM member once posted a color shading map of Loxia21(on a7Rii), but I can't find the original post any more. It can be seen that the magenta ring is basically consistent with the sketch map I drew, I'm not sure what caused it, but it's real,and the intensity of color shading,a7Riii and a7Riv is significantly higher than a7iii

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/201911/4739/473947/473947_1573537450.jpg


olalalafoto, it was me, sorry for being late in the discussion:

The very same issue we talked some time ago:
There is some colour shift and an additional pattern depending on the construction with any lens. Both is visible with extreme processing (oversaturation, strong contrast, shadow lifts, etc).

I made a few tests in the other thread:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1579845/2&year=2019#14731151
(you may read the post before and three later for additional infos)

You can easily solve it with an LCC-shot with the very same lens/f-stop-combo in C1.
For LR I don't know, maybe you can try to process the LCC-shot as a negative overlay.
Mar 30, 2021 at 06:21 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Magenta Shading (L41 UV Filter)

And just to be clear for the followers of this thread, this is a different issue than the main one I'm calling out here. The UV induced magenta shading is dependent on ambient UV strength. So I believe the L41 UV filter is a better solution to that issue, as the shots used for LCC wouldn't exhibit the diversity of different lighting situations.

-Tim

sebbe wrote:
olalafoto wroteThis is an FM member once posted a color shading map of Loxia21(on a7Rii), but I can't find the original post any more. It can be seen that the magenta ring is basically consistent with the sketch map I drew, I'm not sure what caused it, but it's real,and the intensity of color shading,a7Riii and a7Riv is significantly higher than a7iii

https://forum.xitek.com/pics/201911/4739/473947/473947_1573537450.jpg
olalalafoto, it was me, sorry for being late in the discussion:

The very same issue we talked some time ago:
There is some colour shift and an additional pattern depending on the construction with any lens. Both is visible with extreme processing (oversaturation, strong contrast, shadow lifts, etc).

I made a few tests in the other thread:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1579845/2&year=2019#14731151
(you may read the post before and three later for additional infos)

You can easily solve it with an LCC-shot with the very same lens/f-stop-combo in C1.
For LR I don't know, maybe you can try to process the LCC-shot as a negative overlay.


Mar 30, 2021 at 06:32 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister