p.5 #1What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
About the best at least I think so is Zeiss glass cleaner works very well and I also use their packet lens cleaner. Get a good micro cloth and that should clean nicely. Dust means nothing but those grimy grandkids fingerprints you should clean off. Filters are a personal thing but one caveat is your putting a 40 dollar piece of not so great glass over a 1000 dollar lens. Not the best use of your lens quality. Unless your in real element type stuff than I don’t worry but it’s your call. No one else matters but you. All we can do us older dogs here is give a opinion
p.5 #2What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I usually am for multi coated filters for protection. They won't have any effect on the image. I prefer filters mostly just because they are easier to clean.
My favorite lens cleaner is ROR, then Zeiss, then just plain 91% Isopropyl alcohol.
p.5 #3What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
GMPhotography wrote:
About the best at least I think so is Zeiss glass cleaner works very well and I also use their packet lens cleaner. Get a good micro cloth and that should clean nicely. Dust means nothing but those grimy grandkids fingerprints you should clean off. Filters are a personal thing but one caveat is your putting a 40 dollar piece of not so great glass over a 1000 dollar lens. Not the best use of your lens quality. Unless your in real element type stuff than I don’t worry but it’s your call. No one else matters but you. All we can do us older dogs here is give a opinion...Show more →
A $1000 dollar lens typically has several $40 pieces of glass already built into it. So adding a $40 piece of glass doesn't create any sort of price mismatch. I agree that IQ may be slightly diminished in some situations. But the price argument only goes so far as one can easily buy an expensive filter that's several times more expensive than the cheapest element in the light path.
p.5 #5What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Highly personal in terms of shooting environment and other factors like lens turnover or retention. The more you buy/sell lenses to fussy buyers the more you might consider losing one percent of IQ (Erwin Puts) using a high quality filter. You lose much more with technique, shutter shock, wrong settings etc.
You can never fully remove (or even see in many cases) damaging material in the field, particularly in mountain enviros with high Mohs Scale volcanic dust. This stuff sticks with any humidity and it won't blower off. Wipe it and you are scratching the coatings. Sea spray, what are you going to do - hose it off?
Repeat enough and lose hundreds of dollars and lose sales, even though slight damage does not degrade IQ. People don't want to see your coating damage and will suspect other misuse, what a surprise. Pros won't care on the job but don't ever buy used from them. I'd also say many older classic lenses are finished off by this carelessness. Imagine buying an Otus or Leica M-APO with a scratched front element. Price quote a replacement!
"Zeiss 55mm f/1.4 APO-Distagon T* ZF.2 Otus: {WARNING: HANDLE OTUS LENSES GENTLY as the mechanical internals are subject to catastrophic impact damage.} - {CAREFUL: - A Zeiss Otus lens front element replacement will cost $900 to $1,500.}"
"I sent my scratched (front element) 50mm APO Summicron-M to Leica NJ for repair on February 8th (2-day delivery) .. I received an estimate for the cost of repair: Labor $316.25 Shipping $35 Lens 1, finished $113 Total $429.25."
FM guy Ron Scheffler offers this:
"That's ($2000) apparently the 'typical' cost to repair Zeiss Otus lenses. There are some threads on the WWW about this. Your estimate is considerably better than I expected and half what I paid to replace the 21 SEM front element last year.."
p.5 #6What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
GMPhotography wrote:
Seriously I never scratched a front element in 47 years. I’m careful but not anal
Since I started shooting with slrs in 2006 I've put a permanent mark on one lens front element and I've somewhat been out and about with an array of lenses since (though never in some sort of sand or dust storm). That lone time was in winter on a slippery road in the dark and I was tired and a tripod fell over. I honestly don't know what a uv filter may have done. I might wish I'd been using a hood but I mostly don't bother with hoods either, unless aiming for something that may be a flare problem. I do use caps when storing upside down.
Anyways I have no regrets. Front elements are quite tough to make permanent marks in, in my experience.
I have a colleague who uses filters or hoods always, he says it's "what if I accidently bump into something sharp" and I don't know really know what to say to that. I've never bumped into something with a front element. I respect him for his skill with the camera though and we don't really argue about filters or hoods. To each their own : )
p.5 #7What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Look at your filter at an angle. He's covered in small scratches. I definitely do not want to have such scratches on the glass of my lens.
I always put a B+W filter.
When I shoot in conditions where the filter can affect the photo (which is rare), I just remove the filter for the duration of the shot.
Sorry for my bad english.
p.5 #8What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
smpetty wrote: Younjulius wroteruthenium wroteThis thread illustrates, in small ways, how people can be driven by fears, guided by beliefs, and end up divided, sometimes bitterly, by what they chose to believe in.Peoples are just stating their opinions here. If you can’t stand it, you don’t need to come to read this. You and imagemaster are only two bitter on this subject for some reason.I think that @ruthenium@ was just recognizing a broader trend on social media and in American society. We are very divided by so many issues, even ones as trivial as whether or not to use protective filters. It is a sad state of affairs. I did not read his comment as being critical in any way of your original question.
Thank you for your understanding - this is very kind of you!
p.5 #9What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
I always try to put a clear filter on my lenses. I have scratched the front element on two lenses; they were in my camera bag, but the lens caps popped off.
p.5 #10What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Zeiss has UV filters that include the *T coatings. Does using one of these on a non-Zeiss lens impart any real additional benefit apart from UV filters of otherwise similar build and glass quality?
p.5 #11What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Zeiss UV filters have a hard cut at 410nm, which is unusual for UV filters. For many CV lenses, this helps address some issues with UV light interacting with the lens and causing magenta shading.
Basically it filters UV starting at a higher frequency.
In terms of coatings, I doubt it "adds" much because light is still traversing through the coatings of the lens itself. It's more a function of whether it reflects more visible light and interacts at all with the lens/sensor stack causing reflections. Also, if it's not perfectly flat or if there were any imperfections, it could cause some degradations. But I'm not sure it could really improve things. (Again, unless filtering UV light in front of the lens provides some benefit.)
So Zeiss (and Kenko L41) does provide other benefits to me compared to other UV filters...specifically for my CV lenses.
padrelar wrote:
Zeiss has UV filters that include the *T coatings. Does using one of these on a non-Zeiss lens impart any real additional benefit apart from UV filters of otherwise similar build and glass quality?
p.5 #12What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Editorrr wrote:
Look at your filter at an angle. He's covered in small scratches. I definitely do not want to have such scratches on the glass of my lens.
I always put a B+W filter.
When I shoot in conditions where the filter can affect the photo (which is rare), I just remove the filter for the duration of the shot.
Sorry for my bad english.
I had a look at some of my modern lenses front elements (I usually only inspect when selling and sometimes when cleaning) and didn't see any scratches, minor or elsewise. Shone a led light on the polarizer and ND filters I use expecting to see small scratches on them and concluding that front elements are usually more scratch-proof* than filters but I didn't see any scratches on them either. Some smudges at an angle.
*Generally. The Jupiter 8's front element for instance is pretty easy to scratch
None of this will make anyone change their mind though, that's the nature of a controversial topic.
I'm very happy that as far as controversial topics go this one has no law attached anywhere and everyone is free to follow their own thoughts on the matter and what everyone else thinks doesn't need to matter (well beside a purely marketwise perspective; if everyone were like me there would be less UV filters).
p.5 #13What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
padrelar wrote:
Zeiss has UV filters that include the *T coatings. Does using one of these on a non-Zeiss lens impart any real additional benefit apart from UV filters of otherwise similar build and glass quality?
The main purpose of lens coatings is to avoid reflections. This reduces light loss and improves contrast and sharpness. Hence the best possible coating is like having no surface at all. Hence using no filter is better than the best practically possible coating.
That said, if you have to use a UV filter, a Zeiss coating should be of very good quality. It will be noticeably better than a poor coating (or none), but not noticeably better than other very good coatings.
p.5 #14What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
snegron7 wrote:
I always try to put a clear filter on my lenses. I have scratched the front element on two lenses; they were in my camera bag, but the lens caps popped off.
Sure, that can happen, in particular if you have some stray sand in your bag. On the other hand filters break rather easily and while breaking have a better chance of scratching the front element than most other stuff that tends to come in contact.
p.5 #15What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Arguably if a filter is hit hard enough to break, if there were no filter, there still would probably be damage to either the lens filter threads or the front element of the lens. Obviously some filters tout their resistance to breakage. But even those that don't, if they are quality filters, generally don't break if you sneeze on them. There usually needs to be some force involved.
Now if the edge of a filter is hit, causing the glass to break, and that glass scratches the front element. It's possible that the threads on the lens were saved, but the front element was scratched. (If the hit was hard enough, it could damage the lens threads too.) If there were no filter, you might get away with some damage to the filter threads on the lens, with no damage to the front element. But it's possible it would have been damaged anyway.
There are permutations that depend on severity of impact, angle of impact, filter ring material, filter glass material, etc.
Abrasion though is an obvious scenario where replacing a filter that has had abrasion seems easier then getting a front element replaced that has an abrasion. There will be some that say the abrasion on the front element will not have a tangible impact to image quality, again we all big boys (and girls) here, we can make decisions weighing our own priorities.
In the end it depends. And there is no "wrong" answer. Not using a filter isn't absolutely best, and using a filter isn't absolutely best. Things are seldom black and white, there are always pros and cons and in the end you just balance them. Nobody can make that decision for you. You do what makes sense to you, based on your value system.
Daran wrote: snegron7 wroteI always try to put a clear filter on my lenses. I have scratched the front element on two lenses; they were in my camera bag, but the lens caps popped off.Sure, that can happen, in particular if you have some stray sand in your bag. On the other hand filters break rather easily and while breaking have a better chance of scratching the front element than most other stuff that tends to come in contact.
p.5 #19What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
Daran wrote: snegron7 wroteI always try to put a clear filter on my lenses. I have scratched the front element on two lenses; they were in my camera bag, but the lens caps popped off.Sure, that can happen, in particular if you have some stray sand in your bag. On the other hand filters break rather easily and while breaking have a better chance of scratching the front element than most other stuff that tends to come in contact.
There was no sand in my bag. On both ocasiones the unfiltered front element rubbed against a camera causing a gash, not a scratch, on the front element. The lenses were unusable after this.
As for the protective aspect of filters, I remember shooting a couple of weddings where either a drunk guest or an out of control kid wacked into my lens, touched it with hands full of cake frosting, splattered it with beer, sand blowing while at the beach, etc., and no damage occurred.
My suggestion is for everyone who does not like filters to simply not use them. I shared my personal experiences regarding filters with the sole intention of providing info; I really couldn't care less if anyone here decides to buy or not buy filters. As a matter of fact, if there is a sudden drop in filter sales maybe the prices will drop as well. I would love to buy a few more for some new lenses I recently purchased, hopefully at bargain prices!
p.5 #20What’s the latest opinions on protective lens filters?
snegron7 wrote: Daran wrotesnegron7 wroteI always try to put a clear filter on my lenses. I have scratched the front element on two lenses; they were in my camera bag, but the lens caps popped off.Sure, that can happen, in particular if you have some stray sand in your bag. On the other hand filters break rather easily and while breaking have a better chance of scratching the front element than most other stuff that tends to come in contact.There was no sand in my bag. On both ocasiones the unfiltered front element rubbed against a camera causing a gash, not a scratch, on the front element. The lenses were unusable after this.
As for the protective aspect of filters, I remember shooting a couple of weddings where either a drunk guest or an out of control kid wacked into my lens, touched it with hands full of cake frosting, splattered it with beer, sand blowing while at the beach, etc., and no damage occurred.
My suggestion is for everyone who does not like filters to simply not use them. I shared my personal experiences regarding filters with the sole intention of providing info; I really couldn't care less if anyone here decides to buy or not buy filters. As a matter of fact, if there is a sudden drop in filter sales maybe the prices will drop as well. I would love to buy a few more for some new lenses I recently purchased, hopefully at bargain prices!...Show more →
A lens hood does wonders in preventing grimy hands from touching the glass. In fact a lens hood provides more protection against accidentally bumping the lens against the wall, rock, table or whatever.
Another problem ( at least issue ) is that you would need a filter for every lens which adds up if you have a lot of lenses. Good quality filters can be over $100 each. I have 12 lenses and I would think I’d have to shell out somewhere close to $1,000 to equip them all with filters.