Lassep wrote:
Its not that they look out of focus, it simply looks to me as if there is some kind of digital processing done to them. They are not pixel level sharp, none of them.
My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.
One of the Flickr galleries linked by Zenon were images with the new RF 800mm. If you look at the EXIF, the photographer was shooting in the ISO 3200 range. There is certainly NR happening, whether they were in-camera Jpegs, or output RAW through a converter.
As was discussed earlier or in another thread, IMO, Canon's in-camera Jpegs have never been as sharp as the same images shot in RAW and carefully processed. Looking through the DP Review R5 sample gallery, even ISO 100 SOOC Jpegs clearly show signs of NR smoothing. If you compare their studio scene using RAW as source, IMO, R5 image sharpness is comparable to every other 45mp-ish sensor.
I think most agree and understand that with the increase in resolution, minor imaging defects that were otherwise hidden at lower resolutions will become more noticeable. Things like slight subject motion blur, camera shake, mis-focus. A lot of these undesired qualities, including some degree of in-camera image corrections, such as NR, will become effectively invisible in the majority of common viewing scenarios because the images will never be viewed at full resolution. Of course there are exceptions...
Dragonfire wrote:
I'm sorry BUT Rob's 1D XIII appear sharper and have more POP, IMO.
Have you resized his R5 images to the 1DXIII's pixel dimensions and based your conclusion on such observations?
There are so many variables at play. Consider a fair number of his images have pushed the 'reach' envelope of the system to a degree the 1DXIII could never match unless you stacked another tele-converter and thus added further optically induced image deterioration. I.e. R5 APS-C crop 600mm and 2x tele-converter.