fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Post your R5 Images Here

  
 
jtford9
Offline
Details
p.7 #1Post your R5 Images Here
arbitrage wrote:
RobAmy wroteA couple with the 400mm DO II crop mode

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50175710131_8c13f4133a_h.jpgRed Belly looking back (Canon R5) by A & R Photography, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50175975367_4b71d3aa5f_h.jpgRiley (Canon R5) by A & R Photography, on Flickr

600mm + 1.4x in crop mode

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50175970367_a859794906_h.jpgRuby Throated Hummingbird (Canon R5) by A & R Photography, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50175744391_c52e2909d6_h.jpgHummingbird posing (Canon R5) by A & R Photography, on Flickr
Thanks Rob...please share some 400DOII/2xTCIII shots when you have the time. I'd be using that combo at least 75% of the time if I splurge on the R5. My R5 purchase is basically hinging on finding a local used 400DOII to buy right now.


You're the reason I bought a minty used 400DO II a few weeks ago. I started following several of you guys on Flickr and when you started talking about the potential of the 400DO II on the R5 I started looking out for one. Thanks!!
Aug 01, 2020 at 07:56 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.7 #2Post your R5 Images Here
Lassep wrote:
Zenon Char wrote
Lassep wroteGreat images.

I have a question and try not kill me for asking, it is a real concern to me. When pixel peeping (yes, sorry i am that type of person) the R5 images does not seem razor sharp, all images i have seen so far all look a little soft (when peeping). Is this caused by the fact your all still shooting Jpg (or the equivalent) and the camera does all the processing or is this due to the AA filter or simply website compression FM, Flickr. etc.

Have you noticed this yourself?

Thank you so much.
What is your opinion of this set?

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1656877/1#15300273
They look tack sharp, as does all images so far when i am not able to enlarge them

"I found these from a random search

https://www.flickr.com/photos/46506981@N03/albums/72157715304050133"

These look tack sharp too, until you enlarge them. Then they look like a mess. Looks to me like some sort of digital compression, they do not look soft when enlarged. But just a mess of pixels.



Yes, certainly crunchy sharpening in that album.
Aug 01, 2020 at 08:04 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #3Post your R5 Images Here
Pius Sullivan wrote:
arbitrage wrote
Lassep wrote
NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wrote
arbitrage wroteFM is notoriously bad for softening images if you are using some kind of 4K or 5K display. Some of the posters are linking from Flickr. I'd recommend clicking through to their Flickr site to see better quality.
I realize that this is the case with FM but i also see the same "issue" on flickr and even on some direct weblinks. Hopefully this is just a compression thing or the JPG (Heif? Hefie?... you know what i mean) in camera crushing the images. No matter the reason I just want to underline that everyones photos looks amazing, and i am not trying to bash anyones work. I am just trying to figure out if this camera might potentially be for me, being the pixel peeping bastard that i am
Also Sony and Nikon people posting tac-sharp images.
Sorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me.

The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement Hence the questions. I am not trying to stir up any feelings here, at all.
---------------------------------------------

NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wrote
NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wroteI realize that this is the case with FM but i also see the same "issue" on flickr and even on some direct weblinks. Hopefully this is just a compression thing or the JPG (Heif? Hefie?... you know what i mean) in camera crushing the images. No matter the reason I just want to underline that everyones photos looks amazing, and i am not trying to bash anyones work. I am just trying to figure out if this camera might potentially be for me, being the pixel peeping bastard that i am
Also Sony and Nikon people posting tac-sharp images.
Sorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me. The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement
I also have no brand loyalty. I was asking my self why I never seen sharp R5 photos so far.

I thought maybe the way FM present photos cause the original image to lose quality, but then even in the Nikon and Sony forum people post images directly into FM including myself and it can remain quite sharp.

I nevet said or concluded that R5 is not a good camera simply because I never owned one and I am not in a position to judge something I never experemented with.

The only thing I can judge is the image I examine on my screen.
If you guys go to RobAmy's Flickr do you really not think the recent red-bellied WP and dog shots aren't tack sharp? You can view them up to 4K if you click View All Sizes or click into the image on normal view to get a larger view that way. I felt Rob's very first three shots were slightly off focus from the eye (rabbit, tanager and catbird) but the recent ones in better light look as good as anything else out there.
There is no argument about the dog shot, its tac sharp...



I have a 5K screen and I agree.
Aug 01, 2020 at 08:13 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #4Post your R5 Images Here
Dragonfire wrote:
Pius Sullivan wroteThere is no argument about the dog shot, its tac sharp...
If you review Rob's previous Riley photos on Flickr you will see he is not as sharp as when shot with the 1D XIII.

Maybe the lens needs MA for the R5 body.

My question for the future "is the R5 a replacement for the 1D XIII for sports and wildlife?"



There is no MA on mirrorless bodies.
Aug 01, 2020 at 08:17 AM
Dragonfire
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.7 #5Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Dragonfire wrote
Pius Sullivan wroteThere is no argument about the dog shot, its tac sharp...
If you review Rob's previous Riley photos on Flickr you will see he is not as sharp as when shot with the 1D XIII.

Maybe the lens needs MA for the R5 body.

My question for the future "is the R5 a replacement for the 1D XIII for sports and wildlife?"
There is no MA on mirrorless bodies.


I know that, so, the lens must be returned to Canon so they can install the appropriate mounting flange.

Good luck with that...

Aug 01, 2020 at 08:20 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #6Post your R5 Images Here
Dragonfire wrote:
Zenon Char wrote
Dragonfire wrote
Pius Sullivan wroteThere is no argument about the dog shot, its tac sharp...
If you review Rob's previous Riley photos on Flickr you will see he is not as sharp as when shot with the 1D XIII.

Maybe the lens needs MA for the R5 body.

My question for the future "is the R5 a replacement for the 1D XIII for sports and wildlife?"
There is no MA on mirrorless bodies.
I know that, so, the lens must be returned to Canon so they can install the appropriate mounting flange.

Good luck with that...



If that was possible what does the flange have to do with it?
Aug 01, 2020 at 08:29 AM
Dragonfire
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.7 #7Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Dragonfire wrote
Zenon Char wrote
Dragonfire wrote
Pius Sullivan wroteThere is no argument about the dog shot, its tac sharp...
If you review Rob's previous Riley photos on Flickr you will see he is not as sharp as when shot with the 1D XIII.

Maybe the lens needs MA for the R5 body.

My question for the future "is the R5 a replacement for the 1D XIII for sports and wildlife?"
There is no MA on mirrorless bodies.
I know that, so, the lens must be returned to Canon so they can install the appropriate mounting flange.

Good luck with that...
If that was possible what does the flange have to do with it?


When I dropped my 1D IV and 400L 5.6 the mounting flange on the lens snapped and I called Toshio and asked if he could replace the flange.

Toshio said "If I have the correct flange" then he explained that Canon makes a series of flanges and that is how they adjust a lens.

So, now you know.
Aug 01, 2020 at 08:39 AM
Hathaway
Offline
Details
p.7 #8Post your R5 Images Here


JaimitoFrog wrote:
Don't see any RF 600 or RF 800 images. Guess most FM users passed on it. More curious about the RF TCs.

Check out this guy's setup with EF 100mm macro, 12mm extension tube, EF 2x TC, and variND EF/RF adaptor.

https://twitter.com/photopositive/status/1289258308726120453?s=19


I don’t have an extension tube but will be testing this setup when mine arrives. Pieces are dribbling. Got the grip and 1.4x. Now awaiting the camera! Going to be a long wait I am afraid. I can’t wait to test that focus stack in camera option for macro and ultra wide landscape. Should be a lot more fun that doing it manually. Dunes would be another awesome subject with auto focus stacking. Would love it if someone could test out that feature to see how well it works.
Aug 01, 2020 at 08:58 AM
aae991
Offline
Details
p.7 #9Post your R5 Images Here
Lassep wrote:
arbitrage wrote
Lassep wrote
NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wrote
arbitrage wroteFM is notoriously bad for softening images if you are using some kind of 4K or 5K display. Some of the posters are linking from Flickr. I'd recommend clicking through to their Flickr site to see better quality.
I realize that this is the case with FM but i also see the same "issue" on flickr and even on some direct weblinks. Hopefully this is just a compression thing or the JPG (Heif? Hefie?... you know what i mean) in camera crushing the images. No matter the reason I just want to underline that everyones photos looks amazing, and i am not trying to bash anyones work. I am just trying to figure out if this camera might potentially be for me, being the pixel peeping bastard that i am
Also Sony and Nikon people posting tac-sharp images.
Sorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me.

The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement Hence the questions. I am not trying to stir up any feelings here, at all.
---------------------------------------------

NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wrote
NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wroteI realize that this is the case with FM but i also see the same "issue" on flickr and even on some direct weblinks. Hopefully this is just a compression thing or the JPG (Heif? Hefie?... you know what i mean) in camera crushing the images. No matter the reason I just want to underline that everyones photos looks amazing, and i am not trying to bash anyones work. I am just trying to figure out if this camera might potentially be for me, being the pixel peeping bastard that i am
Also Sony and Nikon people posting tac-sharp images.
Sorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me. The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement
I also have no brand loyalty. I was asking my self why I never seen sharp R5 photos so far.

I thought maybe the way FM present photos cause the original image to lose quality, but then even in the Nikon and Sony forum people post images directly into FM including myself and it can remain quite sharp.

I nevet said or concluded that R5 is not a good camera simply because I never owned one and I am not in a position to judge something I never experemented with.

The only thing I can judge is the image I examine on my screen.
If you guys go to RobAmy's Flickr do you really not think the recent red-bellied WP and dog shots aren't tack sharp? You can view them up to 4K if you click View All Sizes or click into the image on normal view to get a larger view that way. I felt Rob's very first three shots were slightly off focus from the eye (rabbit, tanager and catbird) but the recent ones in better light look as good as anything else out there.
Its not that they look out of focus, it simply looks to me as if there is some kind of digital processing done to them. They are not pixel level sharp, none of them.

Here is an example. I know its not the same system or lens, but this to me is pixel level sharp.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/125363288@N06/49912939166/in/photolist-2j3CRSE-2ivEVN7-2is9rL3-2isA8ho-2huwXRq-2iQJyim-2hUb5Ag-2hQzTgE-2iyoR7Y-2iwpgqz-2iwSYot-2iGjrq1-2iGjrBo-2j6zcjL-2iAxHUd-2jjMyNL-2hSa29E-2cwQ7ot-2jq6pgi-2jjKhX2-2iNwkxT-2iozcm1-2eWq7fX-2inoWhU-2iBvRGo-2hM367o-2j6fYVq-2jhceBj-2iLLpPU-265316b-2jd98Va-2jfANyo-2jntZrn-2jnHKFZ-2jmUKLS-2igkmCs-24QvMiK-2iyhbM3-2ixDwbZ-2iJgVV6-2iNe36T-2hyvato-2iFfeGz-2haCSNY-2gUiX5B-2i5hkQg-2iMmJgX-2isRSc7-2hhQ2G6-2gLVLEj

My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.


My R5 arrives Tuesday. I'm really looking forward to the chance to test this with various L glass plus the "kit" 24-105RF that's coming with it. Looking at the various Flickr albums and "pixel peeping," there's really no firm RAW processing being done yet (correct me if I'm wrong). For example, I'm a big fan of DxO and I'm sure I'll need to convert to dng files before working on my first images. Hopefully they'll add the R5 profiles soon. I'm guessing once a reliable workflow with raw files comes to fruition, images like the one shot on the D850 will be possible with really good glass. The D850 also has no AA filter which might help enhance detail, but with proper settings and post processing, the R5 images should be comparable. I'll also test my A7R4 and A7R3 with comparable glass (and no AA filter) against the R5 and see how they compare. Aside from the pixel peeping attempts, I think much of what we're seeing is people learning how to use this tool. As more information becomes available, I expect we'll see plenty of tack sharp images AND beautifully composed ones too! Dialing in the best settings takes time and practice. The R5 will be no different. And for the record, that shot done with the D850 and 400mm f2.8 is stunning in its detail.

Aug 01, 2020 at 09:15 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #10Post your R5 Images Here
Dragonfire wrote:
Zenon Char wrote
Dragonfire wrote
Zenon Char wrote
Dragonfire wrote
Pius Sullivan wroteThere is no argument about the dog shot, its tac sharp...
If you review Rob's previous Riley photos on Flickr you will see he is not as sharp as when shot with the 1D XIII.

Maybe the lens needs MA for the R5 body.

My question for the future "is the R5 a replacement for the 1D XIII for sports and wildlife?"
There is no MA on mirrorless bodies.
I know that, so, the lens must be returned to Canon so they can install the appropriate mounting flange.

Good luck with that...
If that was possible what does the flange have to do with it?
When I dropped my 1D IV and 400L 5.6 the mounting flange on the lens snapped and I called Toshio and asked if he could replace the flange.

Toshio said "If I have the correct flange" then he explained that Canon makes a series of flanges and that is how they adjust a lens.

So, now you know.


My guess is that is for phase detect AF because for contrast detect you don't need any adjustments.
Aug 01, 2020 at 09:22 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #11Post your R5 Images Here
aae991 wrote:
Lassep wrote
arbitrage wrote
Lassep wrote
NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wroteI realize that this is the case with FM but i also see the same "issue" on flickr and even on some direct weblinks. Hopefully this is just a compression thing or the JPG (Heif? Hefie?... you know what i mean) in camera crushing the images. No matter the reason I just want to underline that everyones photos looks amazing, and i am not trying to bash anyones work. I am just trying to figure out if this camera might potentially be for me, being the pixel peeping bastard that i am
Also Sony and Nikon people posting tac-sharp images.
Sorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me.

The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement Hence the questions. I am not trying to stir up any feelings here, at all.
---------------------------------------------

NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wrote
NissanPatrol wroteAlso Sony and Nikon people posting tac-sharp images.
Sorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me. The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement
I also have no brand loyalty. I was asking my self why I never seen sharp R5 photos so far.

I thought maybe the way FM present photos cause the original image to lose quality, but then even in the Nikon and Sony forum people post images directly into FM including myself and it can remain quite sharp.

I nevet said or concluded that R5 is not a good camera simply because I never owned one and I am not in a position to judge something I never experemented with.

The only thing I can judge is the image I examine on my screen.
If you guys go to RobAmy's Flickr do you really not think the recent red-bellied WP and dog shots aren't tack sharp? You can view them up to 4K if you click View All Sizes or click into the image on normal view to get a larger view that way. I felt Rob's very first three shots were slightly off focus from the eye (rabbit, tanager and catbird) but the recent ones in better light look as good as anything else out there.
Its not that they look out of focus, it simply looks to me as if there is some kind of digital processing done to them. They are not pixel level sharp, none of them.

Here is an example. I know its not the same system or lens, but this to me is pixel level sharp.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/125363288@N06/49912939166/in/photolist-2j3CRSE-2ivEVN7-2is9rL3-2isA8ho-2huwXRq-2iQJyim-2hUb5Ag-2hQzTgE-2iyoR7Y-2iwpgqz-2iwSYot-2iGjrq1-2iGjrBo-2j6zcjL-2iAxHUd-2jjMyNL-2hSa29E-2cwQ7ot-2jq6pgi-2jjKhX2-2iNwkxT-2iozcm1-2eWq7fX-2inoWhU-2iBvRGo-2hM367o-2j6fYVq-2jhceBj-2iLLpPU-265316b-2jd98Va-2jfANyo-2jntZrn-2jnHKFZ-2jmUKLS-2igkmCs-24QvMiK-2iyhbM3-2ixDwbZ-2iJgVV6-2iNe36T-2hyvato-2iFfeGz-2haCSNY-2gUiX5B-2i5hkQg-2iMmJgX-2isRSc7-2hhQ2G6-2gLVLEj

My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.
My R5 arrives Tuesday. I'm really looking forward to the chance to test this with various L glass plus the "kit" 24-105RF that's coming with it. Looking at the various Flickr albums and "pixel peeping," there's really no firm RAW processing being done yet (correct me if I'm wrong). For example, I'm a big fan of DxO and I'm sure I'll need to convert to dng files before working on my first images. Hopefully they'll add the R5 profiles soon. I'm guessing once a reliable workflow with raw files comes to fruition, images like the one shot on the D850
...Show more →

I hope you like your lens. Much better than the EF version 1. Mine will be glued to my R for many years.
Aug 01, 2020 at 09:23 AM
aae991
Offline
Details
p.7 #12Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
aae991 wrote
Lassep wrote
arbitrage wrote
Lassep wrote
NissanPatrol wroteAlso Sony and Nikon people posting tac-sharp images.
Sorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me.

The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement Hence the questions. I am not trying to stir up any feelings here, at all.
---------------------------------------------

NissanPatrol wrote
Lassep wroteSorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me. The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement
I also have no brand loyalty. I was asking my self why I never seen sharp R5 photos so far.

I thought maybe the way FM present photos cause the original image to lose quality, but then even in the Nikon and Sony forum people post images directly into FM including myself and it can remain quite sharp.

I nevet said or concluded that R5 is not a good camera simply because I never owned one and I am not in a position to judge something I never experemented with.

The only thing I can judge is the image I examine on my screen.
If you guys go to RobAmy's Flickr do you really not think the recent red-bellied WP and dog shots aren't tack sharp? You can view them up to 4K if you click View All Sizes or click into the image on normal view to get a larger view that way. I felt Rob's very first three shots were slightly off focus from the eye (rabbit, tanager and catbird) but the recent ones in better light look as good as anything else out there.
Its not that they look out of focus, it simply looks to me as if there is some kind of digital processing done to them. They are not pixel level sharp, none of them.

Here is an example. I know its not the same system or lens, but this to me is pixel level sharp.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/125363288@N06/49912939166/in/photolist-2j3CRSE-2ivEVN7-2is9rL3-2isA8ho-2huwXRq-2iQJyim-2hUb5Ag-2hQzTgE-2iyoR7Y-2iwpgqz-2iwSYot-2iGjrq1-2iGjrBo-2j6zcjL-2iAxHUd-2jjMyNL-2hSa29E-2cwQ7ot-2jq6pgi-2jjKhX2-2iNwkxT-2iozcm1-2eWq7fX-2inoWhU-2iBvRGo-2hM367o-2j6fYVq-2jhceBj-2iLLpPU-265316b-2jd98Va-2jfANyo-2jntZrn-2jnHKFZ-2jmUKLS-2igkmCs-24QvMiK-2iyhbM3-2ixDwbZ-2iJgVV6-2iNe36T-2hyvato-2iFfeGz-2haCSNY-2gUiX5B-2i5hkQg-2iMmJgX-2isRSc7-2hhQ2G6-2gLVLEj

My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.
My R5 arrives Tuesday. I'm really looking forward to the chance to test this with various L glass plus the "kit" 24-105RF that's coming with it. Looking at the various Flickr albums and "pixel peeping," there's really no firm RAW processing being done yet (correct me if I'm wrong). For example, I'm a big fan of DxO and I'm sure I'll need to convert to dng files before working on my first images. Hopefully they'll add the R5 profiles soon. I'm guessing once a reliable workflow with raw files comes to fruition, images like the one shot on the D850 will be possible with really good glass. The D850 also has no AA filter which might help enhance detail, but with proper settings and post processing, the R5 images should be comparable. I'll also test my A7R4 and A7R3 with comparable glass (and no AA filter) against the R5 and see how they compare. Aside from the pixel peeping attempts, I think much of what we're seeing is people learning how to use this tool. As more information becomes available, I expect we'll see plenty of tack sharp images AND beautifully composed ones too! Dialing in the best settings takes time and practice. The R5 will be no different. And for the record, that shot done with the D850 and 400mm f2.8 is stunning in its detail.
I hope you like your lens. Much better than the EF version 1. Mine will be glued to my R for many years.


I gave my original EF v1 to my daughter and son-in-law last year to go with the 80D is gifted them. I had a really sharp copy, but this new RF version does sound intriguing. I agree - it will probably be my main walk around lens. On my Sony bodies, the 24-105 G is on 80% of the time.
Aug 01, 2020 at 09:30 AM
hatch1921
Online
Details
p.7 #13Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Lassep wroteGreat images.

I have a question and try not kill me for asking, it is a real concern to me. When pixel peeping (yes, sorry i am that type of person) the R5 images does not seem razor sharp, all images i have seen so far all look a little soft (when peeping). Is this caused by the fact your all still shooting Jpg (or the equivalent) and the camera does all the processing or is this due to the AA filter or simply website compression FM, Flickr. etc.

Have you noticed this yourself?

Thank you so much.
What is your opinion of this set?

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1656877/1#15300273




My opinion.... the 50mm 1.2 is killer If I were in the Canon space... this lens would be in my bag. The R5 delivered here...
Hatch
Aug 01, 2020 at 09:36 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #14Post your R5 Images Here
aae991 wrote:
Zenon Char wrote
aae991 wrote
Lassep wrote
arbitrage wrote
Lassep wroteSorry mate i am not sure i understand what you mean here. I will put this right out there, i think the Canon R5 looks like an amazing camera and i have 0% brand loyalty. A camera is a tool and i have used all brands, thats the end of it for me.

The best camera i have used so far is the D850 and i am hoping this could be its mirror-less replacement Hence the questions. I am not trying to stir up any feelings here, at all.
---------------------------------------------

NissanPatrol wroteI also have no brand loyalty. I was asking my self why I never seen sharp R5 photos so far.

I thought maybe the way FM present photos cause the original image to lose quality, but then even in the Nikon and Sony forum people post images directly into FM including myself and it can remain quite sharp.

I nevet said or concluded that R5 is not a good camera simply because I never owned one and I am not in a position to judge something I never experemented with.

The only thing I can judge is the image I examine on my screen.
If you guys go to RobAmy's Flickr do you really not think the recent red-bellied WP and dog shots aren't tack sharp? You can view them up to 4K if you click View All Sizes or click into the image on normal view to get a larger view that way. I felt Rob's very first three shots were slightly off focus from the eye (rabbit, tanager and catbird) but the recent ones in better light look as good as anything else out there.
Its not that they look out of focus, it simply looks to me as if there is some kind of digital processing done to them. They are not pixel level sharp, none of them.

Here is an example. I know its not the same system or lens, but this to me is pixel level sharp.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/125363288@N06/49912939166/in/photolist-2j3CRSE-2ivEVN7-2is9rL3-2isA8ho-2huwXRq-2iQJyim-2hUb5Ag-2hQzTgE-2iyoR7Y-2iwpgqz-2iwSYot-2iGjrq1-2iGjrBo-2j6zcjL-2iAxHUd-2jjMyNL-2hSa29E-2cwQ7ot-2jq6pgi-2jjKhX2-2iNwkxT-2iozcm1-2eWq7fX-2inoWhU-2iBvRGo-2hM367o-2j6fYVq-2jhceBj-2iLLpPU-265316b-2jd98Va-2jfANyo-2jntZrn-2jnHKFZ-2jmUKLS-2igkmCs-24QvMiK-2iyhbM3-2ixDwbZ-2iJgVV6-2iNe36T-2hyvato-2iFfeGz-2haCSNY-2gUiX5B-2i5hkQg-2iMmJgX-2isRSc7-2hhQ2G6-2gLVLEj

My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.
My R5 arrives Tuesday. I'm really looking forward to the chance to test this with various L glass plus the "kit" 24-105RF that's coming with it. Looking at the various Flickr albums and "pixel peeping," there's really no firm RAW processing being done yet (correct me if I'm wrong). For example, I'm a big fan of DxO and I'm sure I'll need to convert to dng files before working on my first images. Hopefully they'll add the R5 profiles soon. I'm guessing once a reliable workflow with raw files comes to fruition, images like the one shot on the D850 will be possible with really good glass. The D850 also has no AA filter which might help enhance detail, but with proper settings and post processing, the R5 images should be comparable. I'll also test my A7R4 and A7R3 with comparable glass (and no AA filter) against the R5 and see how they compare. Aside from the pixel peeping attempts, I think much of what we're seeing is people learning how to use this tool. As more information becomes available, I expect we'll see plenty of tack sharp images AND beautifully composed ones too! Dialing in the best settings takes time and practice. The R5 will be no different. And for the record, that shot done with the D850 and 400mm f2.8 is stunning in its detail.
I hope you like your lens. Much better than the EF version 1. Mine will be glued to my R for many years.
I gave my original EF v1 to my daughter and son-in-law last year to go with the 80D is gifted them. I had a really sharp copy, but this new RF version does sound intriguing. I agree - it will probably be my main walk around lens. On my Sony bodies, the 24-105 G is on 80% of the time.


My EV v1 was sharp but was pretty bad at 24mm on a FF IMO. I never liked it for that. Here's the RF on my R.







Aug 01, 2020 at 09:37 AM
aae991
Offline
Details
p.7 #15Post your R5 Images Here
Very nice... I hope my copy is as sharp!
Aug 01, 2020 at 09:44 AM
ted1000
Offline
Details
p.7 #16Post your R5 Images Here
Lassep wrote:
Here is an example. I know its not the same system or lens, but this to me is pixel level sharp.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/125363288@N06/49912939166/in/photolist-2j3CRSE-2ivEVN7-2is9rL3-2isA8ho-2huwXRq-2iQJyim-2hUb5Ag-2hQzTgE-2iyoR7Y-2iwpgqz-2iwSYot-2iGjrq1-2iGjrBo-2j6zcjL-2iAxHUd-2jjMyNL-2hSa29E-2cwQ7ot-2jq6pgi-2jjKhX2-2iNwkxT-2iozcm1-2eWq7fX-2inoWhU-2iBvRGo-2hM367o-2j6fYVq-2jhceBj-2iLLpPU-265316b-2jd98Va-2jfANyo-2jntZrn-2jnHKFZ-2jmUKLS-2igkmCs-24QvMiK-2iyhbM3-2ixDwbZ-2iJgVV6-2iNe36T-2hyvato-2iFfeGz-2haCSNY-2gUiX5B-2i5hkQg-2iMmJgX-2isRSc7-2hhQ2G6-2gLVLEj

My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.


It might just be my personal taste but that image looks a tad oversharpened to me.

Ted

Aug 01, 2020 at 09:53 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #17Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Dragonfire wrote
Zenon Char wrote
Dragonfire wrote
Zenon Char wrote
Dragonfire wroteIf you review Rob's previous Riley photos on Flickr you will see he is not as sharp as when shot with the 1D XIII.

Maybe the lens needs MA for the R5 body.

My question for the future "is the R5 a replacement for the 1D XIII for sports and wildlife?"
There is no MA on mirrorless bodies.
I know that, so, the lens must be returned to Canon so they can install the appropriate mounting flange.

Good luck with that...
If that was possible what does the flange have to do with it?
When I dropped my 1D IV and 400L 5.6 the mounting flange on the lens snapped and I called Toshio and asked if he could replace the flange.

Toshio said "If I have the correct flange" then he explained that Canon makes a series of flanges and that is how they adjust a lens.

So, now you know.
My guess is that is for phase detect AF because for contrast detect you don't need any adjustments.


I did forget to say I didn't know about the flange thingy. That is interesting.I always thought they did a mechanical or electric adjustment. One of my lenses needed too much MFA for my liking and Canon found an mis-calibrated board. That was a modern lens. I guess with older gear that makes sense. Interesting.

I would have purchased that lens if it had IS. I opted for the 300L F4 IS which reluctantly sold last week. It was my first telephoto and I loved it. Got a lot of good years out of it but I hardly used it after getting my 100-400 II. If Canon had released a 400 prime with IS I would have taken that over the zoom.
Aug 01, 2020 at 09:55 AM
rscheffler
Online
Details
p.7 #18Post your R5 Images Here
Lassep wrote:
Its not that they look out of focus, it simply looks to me as if there is some kind of digital processing done to them. They are not pixel level sharp, none of them.

My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.


One of the Flickr galleries linked by Zenon were images with the new RF 800mm. If you look at the EXIF, the photographer was shooting in the ISO 3200 range. There is certainly NR happening, whether they were in-camera Jpegs, or output RAW through a converter.

As was discussed earlier or in another thread, IMO, Canon's in-camera Jpegs have never been as sharp as the same images shot in RAW and carefully processed. Looking through the DP Review R5 sample gallery, even ISO 100 SOOC Jpegs clearly show signs of NR smoothing. If you compare their studio scene using RAW as source, IMO, R5 image sharpness is comparable to every other 45mp-ish sensor.

I think most agree and understand that with the increase in resolution, minor imaging defects that were otherwise hidden at lower resolutions will become more noticeable. Things like slight subject motion blur, camera shake, mis-focus. A lot of these undesired qualities, including some degree of in-camera image corrections, such as NR, will become effectively invisible in the majority of common viewing scenarios because the images will never be viewed at full resolution. Of course there are exceptions...

Dragonfire wrote:
I'm sorry BUT Rob's 1D XIII appear sharper and have more POP, IMO.


Have you resized his R5 images to the 1DXIII's pixel dimensions and based your conclusion on such observations?

There are so many variables at play. Consider a fair number of his images have pushed the 'reach' envelope of the system to a degree the 1DXIII could never match unless you stacked another tele-converter and thus added further optically induced image deterioration. I.e. R5 APS-C crop 600mm and 2x tele-converter.
Aug 01, 2020 at 10:13 AM
jkochuni
Offline
Details
p.7 #19Post your R5 Images Here
Here are a few images I took yesterday evening when I was testing the camera...You can view them on Google Drive. I wasn't sure how to post them. All cropped. Put two larger files in there.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1a9rmpmUK95hMsKTZfaJaokQb0PKP45Yt?usp=sharing
Aug 01, 2020 at 10:33 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.7 #20Post your R5 Images Here
rscheffler wrote:
Lassep wroteIts not that they look out of focus, it simply looks to me as if there is some kind of digital processing done to them. They are not pixel level sharp, none of them.

My guesstimate is the fact that none of the posters are using RAW yet. Its likely the inbody JPG engine causing this.
One of the Flickr galleries linked by Zenon were images with the new RF 800mm. If you look at the EXIF, the photographer was shooting in the ISO 3200 range. There is certainly NR happening, whether they were in-camera Jpegs, or output RAW through a converter.

As was discussed earlier or in another thread, IMO, Canon's in-camera Jpegs have never been as sharp as the same images shot in RAW and carefully processed. Looking through the DP Review R5 sample gallery, even ISO 100 SOOC Jpegs clearly show signs of NR smoothing. If you compare their studio scene using RAW as
...Show more →
Dragonfire wroteI'm sorry BUT Rob's 1D XIII appear sharper and have more POP, IMO.


With 45mp I'm a little concerned about motion blur. I'm not the steadiest person and I it gets worse when I start to get tired. I need to stop drinking a Tim Hortons extra large coffee before I shoot. Did that shooting a wedding once. That was the last time I did that.
Aug 01, 2020 at 10:50 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister