p.6 #3FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
jhinkey wrote: bluloo wrotejhinkey wroteThis is what the back end of my 1.4x TC looks like - I just bought it off of Amazon last week.
What does your all TC back ends look like?
- JohnNot exactly sure what you want compared, but mine looks the same - same baffles and construction. I don't' expect others would be different.Looking for differences in the light baffle at the back. Sometime manufacturers change stuff along the way and it's nice to know if they did.
Makes sense.
My TC SN is 1812621, if that might be useful at some point.
I've seen some vignetting, which I don't really like, but so far I don't recall seeing what you're seeing. I will try to get a few sky shots @560mm tomorrow & F11.
I did have some hard "vignetting" once, but I also forgot to take the hood off when I used the 1.4TC.
p.6 #4FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote: jhinkey wrotebluloo wrotejhinkey wroteThis is what the back end of my 1.4x TC looks like - I just bought it off of Amazon last week.
What does your all TC back ends look like?
- JohnNot exactly sure what you want compared, but mine looks the same - same baffles and construction. I don't' expect others would be different.Looking for differences in the light baffle at the back. Sometime manufacturers change stuff along the way and it's nice to know if they did.Makes sense.
My TC SN is 1812621, if that might be useful at some point.
I've seen some vignetting, which I don't really like, but so far I don't recall seeing what you're seeing. I will try to get a few sky shots @560mm tomorrow & F11.
I did have some hard "vignetting" once, but I also forgot to take the hood off when I used the 1.4TC.
I leave my Sony hood on my 100-400mm GM when using my 1.4X and 2X teleconverters. I am not sure if that has had any input on the vignetting that I have experienced.
p.6 #5FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote: bluloo wrotejhinkey wrotebluloo wrotejhinkey wroteThis is what the back end of my 1.4x TC looks like - I just bought it off of Amazon last week.
What does your all TC back ends look like?
- JohnNot exactly sure what you want compared, but mine looks the same - same baffles and construction. I don't' expect others would be different.Looking for differences in the light baffle at the back. Sometime manufacturers change stuff along the way and it's nice to know if they did.Makes sense.
My TC SN is 1812621, if that might be useful at some point.
I've seen some vignetting, which I don't really like, but so far I don't recall seeing what you're seeing. I will try to get a few sky shots @560mm tomorrow & F11.
I did have some hard "vignetting" once, but I also forgot to take the hood off when I used the 1.4TC.
I leave my Sony hood on my 100-400mm GM when using my 1.4X and 2X teleconverters. I am not sure if that has had any input on the vignetting that I have experienced.
Rich
Actually, I think it was the 2XTC, FWIW. Check it out w/o the hood, for sure.
p.6 #6FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
the plot thickens...
After examining RAW files from a couple members, I was convinced that the vignetting would happen with all 1.4x teleconverters....since they performed just like my copy.
However, after checking John's raws @jhinkey, I changed my mind. I see minimal vignetting with the 100-400GM + 1.4x @f/8 RAW files he share with me. Apparently he also just bought the teleconverter...Perhaps there was a silent upgrade?
p.6 #8FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
My vignetting is not as much as others, but now I have what appears to be reflections off the rear light baffles of the TC (see my previous post of the TC rear baffle).
So tonight I put it at 400mm, focused to infinity and set the lens+A7RIII down on my lit slide sorting light table (remember what those are) which has a very uniform light distribution.
First one is straight out of RAW in ACR with no corrections, second has "EnableProfile" active, and the last is a highly stretched version of "EnableProfile" to highlight the stripes in the corners that I get with my lens & 1.4xTC combo.
I want to remove the 3 or 4 screws that appear to hold the rear baffle in place and take comparison photos with and without it, but I don't have enough nerve. Anyone else care to do this with their TC to show me the way? I do have the correct JIS screwdrivers.
p.6 #10FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
If this is like other's I've disassembled, there's a tiny screw that sits perpendicular to the mount, securing the plastic contact assembly. Remove that, and then carefully remove the mount screws. You should be able to slide the contact assembly out as you remove the mount itself, and then remove the baffle from the mount.
I'm guessing the baffle also secures the contact assembly, so I’m not sure it would be a good idea to use it without, unless you don't mind the potential breakage in the name of science.
I'd test the TC to make sure the contacts are secure, without the baffle, before attempting to mount it.
p.6 #11FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Well, since I was a chicken about removing the rear baffle, I instead taped off one of the corners in the baffle with a small piece of gaffers tape (black) and nothing changed at all. I.e., the reflections that I'm seeing appear to not be related to the ridges on the rear baffle in the corners.
So it appears the this is an internal reflection inside the TC.
I'm going to rent a 1.4xTC tomorrow and take side-by-side images. If they give me the same pattern I'll rent a 100-400GM and see if a different lens has a different pattern.
p.6 #14FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
jhinkey wrote:
Also, my 1.4xTC SN is 18154xx.
My 100-400 is also brand new.
- J
PS -
In my A7RIII settings under "Lens Comp" I have "Shading" set to AUTO.
Any other settings I should be reporting?
John, in my experiment, with the camera's lens comp shading at "on", it really helps, further applying the LR profile correction, the vignetting is pretty much gone. So from now on I will go against the grain and leave the camera's lens comp. shading on.
p.6 #15FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Here's two more, with in-camera lens adjustments set to auto. LR basic tone auto adjustments and LR lens profile applied.
I think they're both worse (in terms of the "stripes"), with the sky shot showing some of the pronounced "stripes" seen in jhinkey's pics, but not seen w/o the in camera settings active.
I'd really like to know what's going on, and if the consensus is that Sony needs to issue a fix - whether that's firmware or hardware.
p.6 #17FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I recently bought the 100-400 GM and more recently the SEL 14TC, SN 18127XX (maybe Adorama is not rotating its stock like fresh eggs). Having just made a bunch of beyond-satisfactory test images I wondered, What is this about vignetting? None on the pics I have.
So I got back into the current LR and set the contrast to +100 and made the tone curve as steep as it would go for the blue-sky tones, putting fully half the tonal range of the entire image absolutely black. Ah, yes, now we see three faint arcs in each corner with blue sky. Ah, yes, also some dust.
The three faint arcs are visible whether or not Enable Profile Corrections is checked, although it takes different processing settings to disclose them. (Because vignetting corrections raise the tones in the corners.) They are not visible on images made with the lens with no converter, just a smooth fall off of illumination into the corners, something seen with almost all lenses.
These arcs would be (and were) utterly invisible without really malicious, gross LR settings that could never be used for any operational image. I'm pretty neurotic about this stuff (ask my wife!), and this phenomenon doesn't bother me at all.
If people are experiencing vignetting in practical photography, there is some problem other than what I've described above. We need to be sure we're talking about the same thing.
p.6 #19FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
AZSteve wrote:
These arcs would be (and were) utterly invisible without really malicious, gross LR settings that could never be used for any operational image. I'm pretty neurotic about this stuff (ask my wife!), and this phenomenon doesn't bother me at all.
If people are experiencing vignetting in practical photography, there is some problem other than what I've described above. We need to be sure we're talking about the same thing.
Nope, already seen this in one of my standard landscape images with my standard high contrast ETTR kind of exposure. It's subtle, but there. Especially if you have to raise the shadows and increase contrast and these appear in some featureless part of the iamge, which is pretty much a standard thing on many landscape type images.
p.6 #20FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
If Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.
From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.