Forgive my ignorance. I have the file that you posted and it was opened. Could you walk me through how to install/import this into my LR6.14.
Thanks for your assistance. I can not find how and where this is:
Username > Library > Application Support > Adobe > CameraRaw > Settings > User Presets.
Do I just use the + in LR for Presets to add this?
Rich
Alternatively you can open Lightroom in Develop mode, and click on the Presets "+" sign. (see image)
Than just click on Import Presets... (and find the one you downloaded from here. Unzip it first)
It should appear in your "User Presets" list as "100-400+1.4x-vignetting-fix".
p.5 #2FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Hi Fred,
Thank you. I was able to use your "Fix" and to import it into LR.
Below are Images were shot with my tripod mounted 100-400mm GM plus the mentioned 1.4X teleconverter. Lens with teleconverter set at ISO 100, f8 at 1/500 sec.
First Image Lens Compensation on, Fred's "Fix" + LR Profille.
Second Image Lens Compensation on, LR Profile applied plus Manual Vignetting applied that I originally had prepared. This is shown for comparison with Fred's "Fix". They are close, but I believe Fred's version is slightly better.
p.5 #3FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Personally I leave all in-camera compensation corrections turned OFF. I think they cause more harm than good and I never shoot jpeg so, I don't lose anything when editing RAW files in Lightroom. I find that with most images I tried, just the preset fix should be enough compensation. (For the 100-400@400+1.4x vignetting)
p.5 #4FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
Personally I leave all in-camera compensation corrections turned OFF. I think they cause more harm than good and I never shoot jpeg so, I don't lose anything when editing RAW files in Lightroom. I find that with most images I tried, just the preset fix should be enough compensation. (For the 100-400@400+1.4x vignetting)
Hi Fred,
When I tried the image with the lens compensation turned off, I got much poorer results.
p.5 #5FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote: Fred Miranda wrotePersonally I leave all in-camera compensation corrections turned OFF. I think they cause more harm than good and I never shoot jpeg so, I don't lose anything when editing RAW files in Lightroom. I find that with most images I tried, just the preset fix should be enough compensation. (For the 100-400@400+1.4x vignetting)Hi Fred,
When I tried the image with the lens compensation turned off, I got much poorer results.
Rich
I think there is a small variance in the amount of vignetting we are getting. So, perhaps the preset is not one-fits-all.
p.5 #6FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote: naturephoto1 wroteFred Miranda wrotePersonally I leave all in-camera compensation corrections turned OFF. I think they cause more harm than good and I never shoot jpeg so, I don't lose anything when editing RAW files in Lightroom. I find that with most images I tried, just the preset fix should be enough compensation. (For the 100-400@400+1.4x vignetting)Hi Fred,
When I tried the image with the lens compensation turned off, I got much poorer results.
RichI think there is a small variance in the amount of vignetting we are getting. So, perhaps the preset is not one-fits-all.
Hi Fred,
I am in the processes of running a backup on my computer. I will post my results with your "Fix" with what I had posted earlier as well as adding additional vignetting adjustment after the back-up is complete.
p.5 #7FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Below are Images that were shot with my tripod mounted 100-400mm GM plus the mentioned 1.4X teleconverter. Lens with teleconverter set at ISO 100, f8 at 1/500 sec.
First Image Lens Compensation off, Fred's "Fix" + LR Profille.
Second Image Lens Compensation off, LR Profile applied plus Manual Vignetting applied.
Third Image as presented previously, Lens Compensation off, LR Profile applied, plus Manual Vignetting applied.
p.5 #8FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote:
Below are Images that were shot with my tripod mounted 100-400mm GM plus the mentioned 1.4X teleconverter. Lens with teleconverter set at ISO 100, f8 at 1/500 sec.
First Image Lens Compensation off, Fred's "Fix" + LR Profille.
Second Image Lens Compensation off, LR Profile applied plus Manual Vignetting applied.
Third Image as presented previously, Lens Compensation off, LR Profile applied, plus Manual Vignetting applied.
p.5 #10FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Well, here's two shots with the 1.4xTC (brand new) + 100-400GM set at 400mm.
Highly stretched in post.
Note that I have a B+W MRC clear filter on this - I don't only get vignetting, but a pattern that I suspect is due to the addition of the filter. This is weird. I'll try for the same kind of shots with and without the filter.
It was not a perfectly gray day this morning, so I pointed it at the largest cloud with the most uniform gray center as I could, thus the illumination across the field is not perfect.
p.5 #11FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
And here's a typical shot that I would use this combo for (took it a bit earlier this morning), the corner issues are not apparent in the RAW image, but with typical contrast enhancement, stretching, etc. for a landscape shot you can just start to see hints of the pattern in the lower left corner in the water (and barely in the lower right corner). The upper corners appear to be just fine.
p.5 #12FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
jhinkey wrote:
And here's a typical shot that I would use this combo for (took it a bit earlier this morning), the corner issues are not apparent in the RAW image, but with typical contrast enhancement, stretching, etc. for a landscape shot you can just start to see hints of the pattern in the lower left corner in the water (and barely in the lower right corner). The upper corners appear to be just fine.
Looks like no filter for this lens + TC combo.
Can you take a picture of a solid sky with the extender at f/8?
p.5 #13FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote: jhinkey wroteAnd here's a typical shot that I would use this combo for (took it a bit earlier this morning), the corner issues are not apparent in the RAW image, but with typical contrast enhancement, stretching, etc. for a landscape shot you can just start to see hints of the pattern in the lower left corner in the water (and barely in the lower right corner). The upper corners appear to be just fine.
Looks like no filter for this lens + TC combo.Can you take a picture of a solid sky with the extender at f/8?
That's what the first one was supposed to be, though I couldn't get a good solid grey sky. I'll try this afternoon if the weather cooperates (? I want a totally overcast gray sky?? that's kind of funny).
p.5 #14FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Parariss wrote:
Page 38 in the a7riii manual. Little grren boxes for small objects, big green boxes for larger stuff.
Lock on focus mode is not good for scenes like the one shown and could yield poor focus because there is not a clear object to lock on. Also, AF-C in general is not good for static landscapes because the camera is trying to focus even when it's already in focus. That means it moves the lens away from good focus, perhaps right when you shoot. You could also try to move shutter release to focus emphasis. I think the default is balanced emphasis. Mode 1 steady shot for handheld.
I don't see hard vignetting like that. That could mean a problem not soluble by the above. Ideas: make sure your software is up to date. I think there have been some updates. Also using a fat filter maybe?
p.5 #15FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Had good enough gray sky this morning.
First shot with the B+W F-Pro 77mm MRC clear filter and the second without - seems there is no difference.
These have been stretched a bit to enhance the issue, but as I showed previously these corner things show up in normal images when you apply some typical post processing.
p.5 #16FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Looking at the rear light baffle of the teleconverter it appears to me to be a reflection from the serrated surface in the corners. It looks like you can take the rear baffle out with a couple of screws . . .
p.5 #17FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
jhinkey wrote:
Looking at the rear light babble of the teleconverter it appears to me to be a reflection from the serrated surface in the corners. It looks like you can take the rear baffle out with a couple of screws . . .
I took two shots today with the camera's lens compensation on and off, and tried the following processing: SOOC, Lightroom correction, Fred's secret sauce correction. Fred's fix seems to over correct a bit.
To my eyes, the best result is with lens comp. on in the camera, + LR profile correction.
Lens Comp. on SOOC
Lens Comp. on and correct by LR profile
Lens Comp. on and corrected in LR with Fred Sauce
Lens Comp. off SOOC
Lens Comp. off and correct by LR profile
Lens Comp. off and corrected in LR with Fred Sauce
p.5 #19FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
FYI, this pattern appears without the TC also, Sony Pro support has had my lens a few times and Sony engineers in Japan looked into it. They came back saying it is normal behavior and nothing can be done about it. I take a lot of aviation pictures, planes on blue skies, and have been having a hard time getting pictures accepted/sold because of the weird pattern that happens mostly above 220mm, to the point I am considering buying another Canon 100-400 and adapt it as I was getting better results with that than the 100-400 G Master. I mean, even my friend's $700 sigma adapted yielded better results than this $2500 lens
It appears the pattern visible in the pictures is in fact a reflection of a baffle inside the lens (around the diaphragm), and at just the right FL and ambient light angle you get a nice "flower" pattern.
Oh just a trick, if you really want to see how bad it is, in photoshop just use the "Equalize" function, you can't miss it then!