fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2018 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2018FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender

  
 
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.7 #1FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
If Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.


interesting observation, Fred.
Feb 21, 2019 at 01:37 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.7 #2FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
If Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.


What would you consider older?
Feb 21, 2019 at 03:18 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #3FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteIf Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.
What would you consider older?


John's is 18154xx
Mine is 18039xx

Mine has much bigger vignetting so I call it "old". He has a "new" version. I don't know the exact range which makes it hard to know when "new" started. Perhaps Sony knows.
Feb 21, 2019 at 04:04 PM
davev
Offline
Details
p.7 #4FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteIf Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.
What would you consider older?


That's what I'm trying to figure out, how old is my tc?
Serial Number - 1811073. Bought from B&H in late Aug, or early Sept. of 2018.

My raw shots show some vignetting, but I normally shoot jpgs, so it doesn't show as much.

Feb 21, 2019 at 04:08 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #5FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
davev wrote:
bluloo wrote
Fred Miranda wroteIf Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.
What would you consider older?
That's what I'm trying to figure out, how old is my tc?
Serial Number - 1811073. Bought from B&H in late Aug, or early Sept. of 2018.

My raw shots show some vignetting, but I normally shoot jpgs, so it doesn't show as much.



It's newer than mine but older than John's (who's copy has very light vignetting). If you shoot a clear sky at f/8 (with the teleconverter) you will find out. Set lens to infinity, RAW and turn off all corrections (in-camera and in Lightroom). See how strong the vignetting is.
Feb 21, 2019 at 04:15 PM
davev
Offline
Details
p.7 #6FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
This is what I have.
The sun is about 70 degrees (kind of low in the sky) to the right of the camera.
I'm pointing a bit away from the sun.

https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Tests/i-mjqjBGV/0/3fd89116/X3/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-21%20at%204.40.59%20PM-X3.jpg


And for the hell of it, 100-400 with a 2x tc.

https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Tests/i-6jFFkFm/0/985347f9/X3/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-21%20at%204.53.19%20PM%202x-X3.jpg


Just to complete this, the 100-400 without a tc.

https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Tests/i-qmTgLCK/0/7eb49f1c/X3/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-21%20at%205.03.21%20PM%20100-400-X3.jpg



Looks like it's more of a lens issue than a tc issue.

Edited on Feb 21, 2019 at 05:06 PM · View previous versions
Feb 21, 2019 at 04:45 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.7 #7FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Fred Miranda wrote:
bluloo wrote
Fred Miranda wroteIf Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.
What would you consider older?
John's is 18154xx
Mine is 18039xx

Mine has much bigger vignetting so I call it "old". He has a "new" version. I don't know the exact range which makes it hard to know when "new" started. Perhaps Sony knows.


Mine is 18126xx, so in between.
Feb 21, 2019 at 04:51 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.7 #8FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
bluloo wrote
Fred Miranda wroteIf Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.
What would you consider older?
John's is 18154xx
Mine is 18039xx

Mine has much bigger vignetting so I call it "old". He has a "new" version. I don't know the exact range which makes it hard to know when "new" started. Perhaps Sony knows.
Mine is 18126xx, so in between.


Mine is 18042xx

Rich

Feb 21, 2019 at 04:58 PM
AZSteve
Offline
Details
p.7 #9FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Boy, do I not understand all this. I could get "stripes" in my pics of blue sky with heavy processing adjustments, but now pics of a uniform wall, focus set at infinity manually, I get a bit of vignetting with lens comp on, but cannot get the stripes no matter how hard I try. The vignetting is impossible to remove perfectly, even with manual adjustments on top of the lens profile, although it is possible to get close. With the blue sky, I couldn't see any vignetting at all, definitely better than the wall. Duh.
Feb 21, 2019 at 05:43 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #10FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
naturephoto1 wrote:
bluloo wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
bluloo wrote
Fred Miranda wroteIf Sony had to make a small adjustment (to fix the heavy vignetting), I think it would be easier to do on the teleconverter instead of the lens.
Still, if (and only if) something was modified on newer teleconverters (higher serial numbers) and they perform better vignetting-wise, Sony should have done a recall and offer replacements.

From my experience examining RAW files from 4 members, newer teleconverters may perform like John's and all of us with older serial numbers will see heavier vignetting.
What would you consider older?
John's is 18154xx
Mine is 18039xx

Mine has much bigger vignetting so I call it "old". He has a "new" version. I don't know the exact range which makes it hard to know when "new" started. Perhaps Sony knows.
Mine is 18126xx, so in between.
Mine is 18042xx

Rich



And performs just like mine.
Feb 21, 2019 at 05:48 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #11FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
davev wrote:
This is what I have.
The sun is about 70 degrees (kind of low in the sky) to the right of the camera.
I'm pointing a bit away from the sun.

https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Tests/i-mjqjBGV/0/3fd89116/X3/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-21%20at%204.40.59%20PM-X3.jpg

And for the hell of it, 100-400 with a 2x tc.

https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Tests/i-6jFFkFm/0/985347f9/X3/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-21%20at%204.53.19%20PM%202x-X3.jpg

Just to complete this, the 100-400 without a tc.

https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Tests/i-qmTgLCK/0/7eb49f1c/X3/Screen%20Shot%202019-02-21%20at%205.03.21%20PM%20100-400-X3.jpg

Looks like it's more of a lens issue than a tc issue.


Your vignetting looks more like mine. John's RAW files had way less vignetting at f/8. His serial number is higher for the teleconverter.

Nothing is for sure here and I am not sure what's causing the discrepancy. My guess is that newer teleconverters have less vignetting. I will purchase a new one and try it against mine. I also contacted Precision Camera about this.
Feb 21, 2019 at 05:51 PM
Douglas L
Online
Details
p.7 #12FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
Mine is 18X0663.

Maybe it's really that the one above 5000 up are good ones and the ones under 5000 are bad ones as the Sony rep hinted to me?
Feb 21, 2019 at 06:15 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.7 #13FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
We don't seem to know for certain its not a lens issue, that is exacerbated by the TC, given that some photos w/o the TC show vignetting.

Too bad Roger at Lens Rentals couldn’t run some tests, holding more variables constant.
Feb 21, 2019 at 06:31 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #14FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote:
We don't seem to know for certain its not a lens issue, that is exacerbated by the TC, given that some photos w/o the TC show vignetting.

Too bad Roger at Lens Rentals couldn’t run some tests, holding more variables constant.


If I buy a new one (with latest serial number) and it has vignetting similar to John's, I will know for sure if the teleconverter is the culprit.
Feb 21, 2019 at 06:51 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.7 #15FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I also noticed that the rear baffle on my 1.4X is much closer to the rear TC element than on my 2X.

Difficult to tell from John's TC pic if his is close like mine, or if there's even any variation.

Here's two iphone pics illustrating the difference in the distance between the rear elements and baffle that I’m referring to.

I haven't checked for similar vignetting using the 2x, so it may not even matter.

(I have no idea what that odd reflection is on the 1.4X either, must have been on my iPhone lens)





14.X TC







2.0X TC

Feb 21, 2019 at 07:29 PM
71sbeetle
Offline
Details
p.7 #16FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote:
We don't seem to know for certain its not a lens issue, that is exacerbated by the TC, given that some photos w/o the TC show vignetting.

Too bad Roger at Lens Rentals couldn’t run some tests, holding more variables constant.


I spoke to them since the rental I had from Sony Pro support came from there, they said they would let him know about the issue. I have tried 3 different A7III, an A9 and 3 different 100-400 and I can replicate the issue on all of them.
Feb 21, 2019 at 08:36 PM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.7 #17FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
I decided to run an additional test using my tripod mounted Leica R 280mm f4 Apo-Telyt with my Leica R 1.4X Apo Extender, Novoflex Leica R to NEX adapter with my Sony 1.4X Teleconverter with my A7rIII. The result of this is 548.8mm instead of 560mm using the 100-400mm GM set to 400mm with the 1.4X teleconverter.

For these images the lens correction was left on Auto, but I do not believe that that would have any affect since the Leica 280mm f4 Apo-Telyt lens is a MF lens not supporting the Sony corrections. The first of the 2 images is straight of my camera using the LR6.14 defaults. The second image is corrected for exposure by 1.91 Stops. Both images ISO 100, f8 at 1/640 second.

Looking at the results, I would certainly say that based upon my and other reports in this thread that the Sony 1.4X Teleconverter is contributing to the vignetting that we are seeing. I can not say in this case whether the Novoflex adapter or the Leica 1.4X Apo Extender also are contributing to what is observed.

Rich



© naturephoto1 2019


Leica 280mm f4 Apo-Telyt with Leica 1.4X Apo with Novoflex Adapter with Sony 1.4X right out of camera





© naturephoto1 2019


Leica 280mm f4 Apo-Telyt with Leica 1.4X Apo with Novoflex Adapter with Sony 1.4X with + 1.91 Stops

Feb 22, 2019 at 09:51 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.7 #18FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
bluloo wrote:
I also noticed that the rear baffle on my 1.4X is much closer to the rear TC element than on my 2X.

Difficult to tell from John's TC pic if his is close like mine, or if there's even any variation.

Here's two iphone pics illustrating the difference in the distance between the rear elements and baffle that I’m referring to.

I haven't checked for similar vignetting using the 2x, so it may not even matter.

(I have no idea what that odd reflection is on the 1.4X either, must have been on my iPhone lens)


Yes, the stripes in my corners look like they are reflections from those in the corners of the rear baffles, but I think I've convinced myself that these are not the culprit (I'd really like to remove the rear baffle but am reluctant to do so in case I need to return the TC).

Really I need to try a different TC/100-400GM combo and will attempt to get to the rental place later today for a 1 day rental.
Feb 22, 2019 at 10:58 AM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.7 #19FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
jhinkey wrote:
bluloo wroteI also noticed that the rear baffle on my 1.4X is much closer to the rear TC element than on my 2X.

Difficult to tell from John's TC pic if his is close like mine, or if there's even any variation.

Here's two iphone pics illustrating the difference in the distance between the rear elements and baffle that I’m referring to.

I haven't checked for similar vignetting using the 2x, so it may not even matter.

(I have no idea what that odd reflection is on the 1.4X either, must have been on my iPhone lens)
Yes, the stripes in my corners look like they are reflections from those in the corners of the rear baffles, but I think I've convinced myself that these are not the culprit (I'd really like to remove the rear baffle but am reluctant to do so in case I need to return the TC).

Really I need to try a different TC/100-400GM combo and will attempt to get to the rental place later today for a 1 day rental.



Is your baffle very close (~1mm) to the rear lens element as in my pic, or is it further away as in the 2X TC pic?

Shot in the dark, but want to know if all the 1.4 TCs are constructed the same way.
Feb 22, 2019 at 12:36 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.7 #20FE 100-400 issues with and without 1.4 extender
So, just finishing up with Sony support. They're supposed to be processing an exchange for another 1.4 TC. They say that some TCs have an issue that can cause the vignetting with e-mount lenses - but not all TCs in the same serial number range have this issue.

The tech didn't know the source.

FYI, YMMV etc.
Feb 22, 2019 at 12:56 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister